Cancel

Open app

Search

Paisano's Pizza

3.5 (17 reviews)
ModeratePizza
Open • 11:00 am - 11:00 pm

Paisano's Pizza Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Paisano's Pizza

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

16" (LRG) sausage/onion
Tim T.

1st...Paisano's is CASH ONLY. I was unaware of this and had to visit the ATM 4 blocks away, then pay a $3 service fee to withdraw some money. 2nd...There is only a small gravel area on the south side of the building to park. (plan on getting blocked in) The inside of Paisano's is dirty, but the food prep area looked clean. On my visit, there were a few teenagers hanging out in 1 of 2 booths watching TV and a twenty-something lady with her baby sitting behind the counter. The pizza had a crispy thin crust and good amounts of toppings/cheese. The tomato sauce had a nice kick to it, which I enjoyed. I paid $18 for a 2 topping large (16") which is a fair price. I did find their Facebook page, but it lacked any vital information that would have helped me make a decision on what to order. I would like to see an online menu or website, after-all, it is 2012. If I were to order again, I'd probably opt for their delivery service, simply to save myself from the parking adventure. Pizza places come and go so fast in this area and this is why...If I was so confident my pie topped others, I would definitely spend the extra time/money, invest in my product and build something special. Different is good!!! Change is good!!! Right? Oh...........and watch your step when entering/exiting, there's one tiny stair that may break your neck.

18 inch Pepperoni Pizza

See all

5 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Kay M.
0
29
0

10 months ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Steve C.
1
192
64

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Tim T.
3
28
34

14 years ago

Helpful 5
Thanks 0
Love this 2
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Mark K.
0
33
15

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

This place is NOT closed. It is great! Good classic pizza, plain and simple! You cannot go wrong here!

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

First time going. Got two Italian beef sandwiches. Really good food, nice people all around.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

6 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Paisano's Pizza Reviews in Other Languages

Ask the Community - Paisano's Pizza

Review Highlights - Paisano's Pizza

“Good classic pizza, plain and simple!”

Mentioned in 2 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Pizza 8,602 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

The Original John's Pizzeria

The Original John's Pizzeria

3.9(102 reviews)
1.9 mi
•$$

Absolutely love their sausage and green pepper pizza. I order it every time. Carry out service is…read moreusually good... if ordering party cut to go make sure you double check as they missed a couple cuts which I'm guessing was just due to overall volume of pizzas they were cooking.

I sure was hungry and not too far from me was this joint. It seemed to be the right stop for me…read more There was a sign that stated The Original John's PIZZERIA. It had an arrow pointing straight for Dine In. It stated Immediate Seating Available. My significant other and I entered through the door that stated JOHN'S FAMILY DINING Entrance. We were told we could choose a table to sit at. We chose a spot in the corner. I looked at the menu to see what was offered. I ordered a Glass Diet Pepsi. It was $3.25. From the Cocktails section, we got a Margarita. It was $8.50. The server gave us options for the flavor and we chose lime. The server gave us the options of salt or no salt and we chose salt. From the Pizza section, we got a Small 12" Cheese Pizza ...... 17.00. The Pasta section stated with Garlic Bread. Choose your Pasta and Sauce. Spaghetti * Angel Hair * Rigatoni Penne * Linguine. For the Pasta, we chose Penne. For the Sauce, we chose Phil's Special Meat Sauce. It was Mushrooms & Green Peppers....12.95. The Diet Pepsi was smooth and tasty. Both of the free refills I was given were as well. The Margarita was concocted beautifully. It was pleasant to sip on throughout my visit. The Cheese Pizza was simple, yet delicious. I couldn't stop eating it, but unfortunately I had to after the last slice. The Pasta caught me off guard with the hefty size of it. It looked fantastic and it surely was. The Garlic Bread had a nice crunch with a burst of flavor. I enjoyed it. The service was exceptional. I didn't have any issues. Overall, I had an excellent experience at this joint. I wouldn't hesitate to go again. Date of visit: 5/20/25

Photos
The Original John's Pizzeria - Paper Menu as of 5/10/26

Paper Menu as of 5/10/26

The Original John's Pizzeria - Paper Menu

Paper Menu

The Original John's Pizzeria - Paper Menu as of 5/10/26. Website has menu but no prices.

See all

Paper Menu as of 5/10/26. Website has menu but no prices.

Pudgy's Pizza & Sandwiches - Sausage pizza. Always a classic.

Pudgy's Pizza & Sandwiches

4.3(73 reviews)
4.7 mi•Hegewisch
•$

If there's such a thing as a hidden gem on the cusp of Chicagoland before it morphs into Indiana,…read morethis is it. Someone I know posted this pizza on TWITTER, and they told me it was Pudgy's on the far SE side, so I had to indulge and try it for myself. I called ahead, and the pizza was ready in 25 mins. Upon walking in, it's by far the most wholistic pizzeria spot ever. You get to see all the personalized photos, memorabilia, and decorations that put you directly into the heart and mind of who the owner is! I'm not certain who that is, but if you've been to enough hand-built pizzerias in your life, you know the vibes. The pizza was ready, and of course there's only one catch 22 with a classic spot as such: HAVE YOUR PHYSICAL DOLLARS READY AS THE CURRENCY! As far as I can see, it's cash only, and the use of the rustic cash register is a strong reminder of a time long forgotten. The pizza was INSANELY good! A very dense layering of toppings, great amount of cheese, and it's truly an experience. The medium size with my toppings came out to roughly $24, so a fair value also. I don't like having to commute to the northside or even to the distant southwest parts of Chicago for a quality tavern style, so this spot definitely has my attention. The website is a Wordpress site, so it may not show all the information based on your mobile browser, so you might wanna call or visit to get an idea of all the other food options available. With that being said, I highly recommend the pizzeria that's guarded by a commemorative tank on the corner! A true gem for an authentic Chicago pizza experience!

I live on 133rd buffalo and ordered a medium pepperoni for delivery on Sunday June 1st 2025. That…read moreis a 5 minute walk and a 1 minute drive from pudgys. I ordered the pizza at 737 pm. At 818 I called backed twice and no answer. My son was hungry so we went to Burger King. At 848, 71 minutes later the pizza comes. I told him that I tried calling to see what the status of my pizza was and no one answered so I thought they forgot about me so I send the pizza back. 10 minutes later I get a harassing voicemail from the owner. Will post the voicemail soon. P.S He never told me it would be at least 50 minutes if not I would have just picked it up...

Photos
Pudgy's Pizza & Sandwiches - Medium pizza with mushrooms + black olives! PRIMO!

Medium pizza with mushrooms + black olives! PRIMO!

Pudgy's Pizza & Sandwiches - Firehouse pizza

Firehouse pizza

Pudgy's Pizza & Sandwiches - The Mistake. Delicious

See all

The Mistake. Delicious

Edwardo's Natural Pizza Restaurant

Edwardo's Natural Pizza Restaurant

3.6(169 reviews)
1.3 mi
•$$

Edward's offers the best pizza in North West Indiana. The…read moreservers truly care about your dining experience and anything we can do to make your dining experience more enjoyable. Restaurant has a nice ambiance in the atmosphere, a good choice for a 1st date. Edward's offers you to pre-order your dinner ahead of time for those on a busy schedule. The owner Joe samara is a good owner and enjoys seeing his customers coming back. Very well liked by others. If you haven't treated yourself yet your missing out. Munster just wouldn't be the same without a Edward's. So much more then just a business. Food critic NWI Mandy P Foster

So I grew up eating Edwardo's fairly often, as there used to be a restaurant on 57th street in Hyde…read morePark. Once I discovered there is still a place only 20 minutes away in Indiana, I had to make the trip. Getting there was fairly easy and the lot was large enough for several cars. Upon walking in we were greeted by a host and shown where to sit. Yall the dining area could have used an update and a vacuum. There were napkins and small bits of food all over the floor and the upholstery on the benches and chairs could have used cleaning. My sister was so bothered by how dirty the carpeted floor was she mentioned there was a vacuum near the bathroom, lols. Anyway, our server was really nice and while we were set to order a deep dish pizza, she let us know the restaurant would close in about an hour. Yall I googled the place and made sure it would be open later because, I mean...we crossed state lines. We settled on a salad (it was ok) and thin crust pies. They were good, nothing to drive to another state for, but good. I did enjoy the crispy chip things they gave us, it really took me back to my 57th street days! Overall I would probably order takeout and a deep dish, but maybe skip the dine in until they can get a manual vacuum on that carpet during dining hours.

Photos
Edwardo's Natural Pizza Restaurant - The so-called "stuffed" pizza. Basically a block of mediocre-quality cheese. Did I mention that the "toppings" were $2.50 each?

The so-called "stuffed" pizza. Basically a block of mediocre-quality cheese. Did I mention that the "toppings" were $2.50 each?

Edwardo's Natural Pizza Restaurant
Edwardo's Natural Pizza Restaurant

See all

State Line Pizza - Medium thin crust pizza with sausage. Delicious!

State Line Pizza

3.2(42 reviews)
1.5 mi
•$$

Best Pizza in the area…read more Service and Taste.... AMAZING!! You even get a FREE pizza if you collect 15 of their coupons. Their customer service and delivery is always friendly and fast. Highly Recommended!

I was in the area and craved a pizza, obviously. I walked inside this establishment and I wanted to…read morecheck out their menu. They gave me a magnet with a code to scan through my phone's camera. It directed me to their website to check out the menu. That was a new concept and interesting. I looked it over and made a call to them to place my order. I ordered a Large Thin Crust Pizza with Crumbled Sausage, Pepperoni, and Onion. I was told it would be ready by 9, so I just waited outside in my car. It probably took about 30 minutes. I waited a bit to try it out, since the box was pretty hot. They even put foil in the box. The pizza was, of course, crispy. It was a Thin Crust Pizza after all. I'd say they didn't cheap out on the crumbled sausage or pepperoni, but the onions were difficult to locate. That was a bummer. The cheese layered on the pizza was good enough. I did enjoy their crispy crust for the most part. It was definitely a change of pace from other pizza places. The pizza as a whole, would mostly be on the line of average. I didn't hate it, but I just didn't love it, either. I would also say that they should have gone heavier on the sauce. It was pretty distant. The employees were friendly and easy to communicate with. I didn't have any issues here in terms of service, so that's a big plus. Overall, this place is a tiny bit above average for me, so they deserve three stars. I might return here, but I might not. It's hard to say, but it was worth the try.

Photos
State Line Pizza
State Line Pizza - Cool

Cool

State Line Pizza - Check it out. Their service is AMAZING!

See all

Check it out. Their service is AMAZING!

Paisano's Pizza - pizza - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...