First time here thanks to so many raves about this place. Had to see if it lived up to the reputation. Guess what?!?! It did!!! We ordered and sat in a quaint dining area inside as we watched the traffic go by. There is also seating out front and on a side patio. It was about 30 minutes of smelling the amazing aroma of pizza. Once ours was brought out, we were thrilled to have such a great tasting pizza. The sauce was perfect. The toppings were plentiful. The crust was cooked just right. So good!! Oh and the service was really friendly. read more

Miller Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

See all

This was a fun spot for a dinner out with friends while in Miller Beach. The interior is small but does have a few tables for dine-in. You order at a counter and they bring it to you in to-go boxes. It takes about 20 minutes for a small deep dish but it was worth the wait. We found it delicious and filling and had plenty for two (plus leftovers) in a small! A fun spot to stop in if you are craving pizza. read more

Not sure what the big deal is with this place. It's not worth the hype in my opinion. I've had better thin pizza. I actually placed my order online - but was told the online service wasn't working...although it charged me for the order anyway. I realized this when I went inside to pick it up and they had no record of my order...although they could have been nicer about it - the rudeness of the employees turned me off completely and probably made the pizza taste bad. read more

Miller Pizza Company - Sausage and onion thin crust - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

OMGosh delish! I've been coming to Miller Pizza for years. Always consistent and never disappoints. A true staple of the neighborhood. read more

Miller Pizza Company - Half pepperoni, half Italian beef with mild peppers - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

Some of the best pizza in all of Northwest Indiana! Great spot for lunch to take advantage of their lunch special: 2 slices of deep dish and a can of soda for $8. read more

Miller Pizza Company - menu for miller pizza co - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

See all

Best Pizza in Gary Indiana! It is a Miller Beach staple and been around for years. The crust is baked just right and the cheese is premium. Any preferred toppings will be fresh and perfectly cooked. The pizza is what they are known for but they also have great sandwiches like the Italian Beef and their wings are pretty stellar as well! If you are ever in Gary, consider making the trip to Miller Beach and try the best pizza in town! Parking is limited in the back of establishment but always seems to be an available spot. Enjoy! read more

Miller Pizza Company - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

Great pizza and the staff is even better! We arrived and they were very busy but the staff was right on top of everything.

Great take out pizza!!!! Fast and delicious. Convenient location in Miller. Nice people.

Best pizza in the area! Actually the best pizza outside the area as well! Love their big crust in the pan pizza but even just a regular good old pizzas the best from Miller Pizza read more

Great Food Great Service Great ambiance Great Time Great job = All smiles (5G ratted) read more

Miller Pizza Company - Double cheese Pizza just for me! - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

We were visiting various spots in the Midwest from Vegas. Had spent the day at Indiana Dunes. On our way to Madison afterwards and were seeking some amazing pizza. This place came up on Yelp so we decided to give it a try. The building is cool, love to old train station. The staff were friendly and welcoming and the food was fabulous! We truly enjoyed our pizza! Highly recommend this historical restaurant with amazing food and service! read more

Chicago style pizza and more. Tasty and great ambiance! Next to the train tracks, parking across the street. read more

See all

Top notch Pie in the area, deep dish, extra cheese and Pepperoni hits every time! Service is great, small little spot but does have some seating available and has great Lunch deal for 2 slices and a soda! read more

Always delicious! Tonight my husband and I ordered the deep dish pizza with sausage and mushrooms! YUMMY! They never disappoint. The appetizers are always great! The Italian beef is fantastic! And the staff is always helpful and friendly! I'm very fortunate to live in their delivery area! read more

Good neighborhood stand by! Order thin crust with garlic for full pizza flavor without the bloat. Chicken Parmesan sandwich is excellent. Fries! Good salads too. Good place, good staff, lovely people. read more

Great little spot. Good service and good food. Got two think crust pizza one Greek and one sausage. Loved the Greek pizza.

This was my first visit to Miller Pizza Co. The first thing I noticed was how friendly and professional the staff was. I ordered a large thin sausage, mushroom and jalapeño pizza. The pizza was delicious. I do not know why I was surprised. Maybe because it is hard to find courteous servers and good food now days. Be careful, the jalapeños are hot as h###. I enjoyed them immensely. Definitely give them a try. You won't be disappointed. read more

So as a Chicago native and food snob I'm always comparing the pizza . Millers Pizza is doing something magical in the kitchen, we always order thin crust, extra sauce cuz nobody wants a dry choke pizza, easy cheese, sausage and spinach. We are exceptionally pleased each and every time we eat here. Absolutely the best pizza around!! read more

We get pizza delivered from Miller Pizza at least once a month.. There isn't even a pizza place in Chicago as good as them. We got a pizza tonight & it was the best pizza ever. Thanks Miller Pizza- we r so glad u r in our hood read more

I've driven by this place numerous times on my way to Marquette Park or Miller Woods. The place is always hopping. I told myself I'd try it when it wasn't so busy. I stopped in on a Saturday mid-afternoon and the place was already busy. I opted then to order a medium deep-dish vegetarian pizza to go. I was told it would be 45 minutes. The pizza came out as stated. I was very impressed. For under $20 this pizza is more flavorful and a good ten bucks cheaper than Beggar's Pizza, another regional pizza. It was loaded with toppings. If this place weren't so far from Crown Point on my summer visits, I'd come by here more often. The entire kitchen crew hustled. I will try to try the dine-in next time. The restaurant is right by busy South Shore railroad tracks, and that train sure can blast through at deafening speed. read more

Miller Pizza Company - Our vegetarian deepdish pizza to go - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

Off the road but most definitely worth it. Best pizza I've had in a long time. Cooked to order so if you get a deep dish expect to wait as it cooks. It's nice and clean inside and everyone is friendly. But back to the food. The pizza is amazing. Delicious and you can pick what you want inside it. I highly suggest you stop here for a slice or more. read more

See all

The best pizza I have ever tasted the deep dish with everything is wonderful. They have timely delivery service and I live far from them. The delivery people are always polite, as well as the people you speak to on the phone. read more

I am from Chicago and this pizza is the best pizza hands down it is huge and absolutely delicious

Always excellent food, service, and at a great value! We love that we live near this gem of a restaurant. Whether it's delivery or dine in, lunch or dinner, we're always happy with them. I highly recommend the lunch specials! read more

We stopped off here for some lunch while visiting Indiana Dunes. The pizza was delicious. The crust was a perfect thing crust with crispy dough, but still maintained some chewiness. The sauce and toppings were flavorful. The Italian beef was very good with a nice bread and flavor. You definitely want au jous, otherwise it would have been a bit on the dry side. The building is a very cool former train station. The only reason I didn't give five stars is the service was pretty slow. read more

This pizza was bad the cheese was bad and my little bother got sick and we took him to the doctor for a check up

It's ok pizza. But in Gary, IN it's THEE pizza place ‍ the stuffed pizza is pretty good.

Considering the ratings, I was disappointed. I get it we have all different taste buds. I am true foodie and pizza is one of my favorites. The sauce was bland and it was cold in the sitting area. read more

Love Miller Pizza! One of the only pizza places to deliver in Gary and that stays open late. Pizza is excellent and the sandwiches are good too. read more

My absolute favorite favorite pizza!!! just picked up my superbowl dinner... deep dish .. The Works Every time I've ordered from there the staff has been absolutely amazing!! Friendly... Professional... And the pizza?????? Omgggg!!!! I come from Hammond and am planning on moving to Tinley Park soon and guess what???? I'll still come out here!!!! read more

The area is a bit sketchy but been seeing the billboards had to try it, its a hike for me since I am in Valpo but again them billboards said best pizza ! Ordered sausage pizza fries and cheese sticks for dine in, no servers or waiter just order sit wait and come pick up at the window once complete And find urself a table inside our outside. The pizza was decent nothing to write home i mean it was average the crust was chewy cheese and sausage was ok. If ur in the neighborhood why not but don't go out of ur way like I did. Next time i go pick up crack around the corner will pick up a pie but other than that will stick to Valpo pizza area. read more

Antipasto salad always a hit! The produce is so fresh and they don't skimp on the other ingredients! Very flavorful....keep holding a Good standard read more

Having spent the weekend in the area, I searched for local pizza that offered delivery on a Friday night. I stumbled upon Miller Pizza Company- 4 stars / 95 reviews on yelp. 4.4 stars / 953 reviews on google. Considering these stellar ratings, I was disappointed in both the thin crust and stuffed pizzas. The dough was just not very good. Having worked in a pizza joint as a kid, the taste was consistent with that of old/frozen dough. read more

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE NEVER GET RID OF THE SPICY CHICKEN!!! It is the closest thing to Sausage on a pizza me and my wife have tasted for 2 years. We don't eat pork and we've been to every good pizza place around. I guess we saved the best for last! Best Pizza place from ehre to Valparaiso HANDS DOWN! Thin Crust is Amazing. We also had the Italian beefs, outstanding as well. Gonna go there today for Another Spicy Chicken/ Ground Beef Pizza. TRY IT!!! read more

Paid 24 bucks for a small deep dish and it wasn't fully cooked the crust was extra soggy

I've been going to Miller since they opened about 35 years ago and they have the best pizza in the area hands down. They've never disappointed! And they offer gluten free crust. What I especially like is that all their ingredients are fresh - no canned mushrooms or green peppers at Miller Pizza, you get the real thing and you can taste the difference. They offer a menu of appetizers and some sandwiches as well, and their wings are the best I've ever had! The variety is fantastic with thin crust, deep dish and you should definitely check out the Chicago stuffed pizza. read more

Miller Pizza is an absolute old school gem for the neighborhood! Always consistent and delicious, with prompt delivery and friendly service! read more

Miller Pizza is a classic spot, around here...with great pizza and good service. I remember when they opened...and I'll be a customer, for life. read more

I'm from out of town and was looking for a solid stuffed pizza place near Portage without having to drive all the way to Chicago. This place exceeded my expectations. I know enough about Gary that I was concerned to check it out for a late dinner but the location was no issue and I had a pleasant experience. It was pretty dead inside on a Monday night but their phone was ringing frequently and a steady influx of people were coming to pick up orders...a sign of a good pizza shop. I had a mozzarella stick appetizer and a small stuffed pizza all to myself. So my meal was basically all cheese that night. It was far more food than I needed and I took half the pizza home. They also offered a local beer from a brewery across the street and it was an IPA (my favorite) so I took the opportunity to try it. There is some noise from the trains passing by right outside and the interior of the restaurant was nothing fancy, but the food certainly delivered. read more

Miller Pizza Company - Small stuffed pie with sausage and pepperoni. Enough for 2 people. - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana

See all

Tasty, but the pizza is on the expensive side and the shop gets busy. We ordered some thin crust pizza hoping our order would finish faster than thick crust, but it was still an hour wait at dinner time. There seemed to be many people at the pickup counter waiting a little longer than they expected. But if you are willing to wait, they really do make an excellent pie. I would love to go back and try the thick crust on a day where I am in less of a rush. The beer prices are very reasonable, so if you have the time to wait and relax with a beer, I suggest you give it a try. read more

Miller Pizza Company - I like the looks of these prices! - Pizza Near Me - Gary, Indiana