Pirate Pizza is easily in our top 3 favorite pizza spots ‍--and that's saying something. The pizza is consistently great, with fresh, flavorful ingredients that actually taste like they were chosen with care, not just thrown together. But let's talk about that garlic bread... wow. It's the kind you keep reaching for even when you swear you're full. Perfectly balanced--just the right amount of garlic, butter, and seasoning without being overpowering. If you're craving solid, satisfying pizza with sides that don't feel like an afterthought, Pirate Pizza absolutely delivers. Definitely a spot we'll keep coming back to. read more

See all

We've lived in the WGV area for 2 years now and we finally ordered a pie from Pirate Pizza. Why didn't we try it sooner? The best NY style pizza in the area! We ate 3 slices each for dinner and I usually only eat 1! We had a good old cheese pizza and the girl on the phone was right- we didn't need to order extra cheese. My husband's only comment: Great foldable crust, delicious sauce, quality ingredients but needed olive oil to run down his arm to his elbow- essential oils in his mind! Add to the fact that we had just returned from Huntington NY where we ate at Little Vincent's - a 41 year old cornerstone! read more

Pirate Pizza - Pirate Pizza - you can tell if it's going to be good - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Amazing food, exceeded my Expectations. We went here and dined in, ordered the family special which was a great deal and had a lot of food. We also ordered some mozzarella sticks and jalapeño poppers. It was all delicious. You order at the counter and they bring the food to your table. Everything was delicious and fresh. My only complaint is that they only have bottled drinks, wish they had a fountain for those that dine in. The decor of the restaurant was cute, kept on theme with the name. There's not a lot of seating inside however everyone should give this place a try. I'm excited to go back and try more items! read more

If you're looking for a place that absolutely delivers on flavor, Pirate Pizza is it. The pizza is insanely delicious--perfect crust, rich sauce, and loaded with toppings that actually taste fresh. Every bite hits just right. And the wings? Easily some of the best I've had. Crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, and packed with flavor. You can tell they don't cut corners here. Definitely a spot you have to try--you won't regret it. Wonderful service and amazing local businesses everyone should try!!! read more

First time- friendly staff excellent pizza. We ordered the 10" Scallywag perfectly cooked crust. Plenty of tasty ingredients. Parking lot in front of the restaurant. They also sell pizza by the slice at lunch. Plus have lots of interesting sandwiches. So thanks Yelp it's a 5! read more

Pirate Pizza - 2.29.24 - 10" Scallywag pizza - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Aug.1, 2025. I happened upon Pirates Pizza. My friend and I agreed to get the Veggie Pizza pie. Was not disappointed. The crust was, as it should be, crusty. The flavor was wonderful and the pizza did not get mushy from all the vegetables. Next time I am in the area will definitely stop in and try another pie. The staff were friendly and happy and so was I after I ate the pizza. read more

First time to have tried Pirate Pizza and I enjoyed it. Did a pick-up order for their 14" pizza for two of us and had a couple slices leftover to enjoy the next day. Our toppings were pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and extra cheese. Unfortunately, the pepperoni was left off but we still enjoyed the pizza and would order again. Crust was tasty and overall a good pie. They have subs, salads, and other items we want to try also. If you're in the area definitely give it a try. Young lady who took our order over the phone and helped at pickup was friendly. They do have inside seating, as well. read more

I would have loved to try the pizza after my doctor appointment this morning, however the girl opening the store just looks at me at 11:40 when it says they open at 11:30 the just keeps walking around. I'll just eat Costco pizza like I normally do across the street read more

Pirate Pizza - I was here on Friday October 3rd at 11:40 am - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Ordered the Scalywag pizza. Possibly one of the best pizzas I've ever had! Service was great. Nothing fancy but made the experience even better. read more

Fantastic crust and tasty sauce. Pizza in Florida is still a miss most of the time but this place is hidden gem. If you like thin crust, this is your place. read more

Pirate Pizza - Pizza - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Sooooooo good. Fast delivery to our condo and it was absolutely delicious! Highly recommend the garlic knots! read more

No atmosphere in the restaurant, but the pizza itself is pretty darn good. I think the place is in business to be carry-out.

SO GOOD. We started with the Jack bread. There was suck good flavor. My husband got the scallywag (supreme) and my daughter and I ordered the Swashbuckler (white pizza)...with added sausage on half. Both were very tasty. The staff was very nice and there's 3 tables to choose from if you want to eat there. It was still delicious the next day! read more

Pirate Pizza - Scallywag Pizza - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Friendly and fast service with delicious NY crust pizza to boot! Prices are a bit high but I'm good paying more for quality pizza. I'll have to bring my family in at some point to eat in house. Cute place. read more

Pizza and garlic nots were so good. We ordered 5 pizzas and everyone said we have to eat here again before leaving to go back home. Pizza's are a good size. read more

I had a great experience at Pirate Pizza! The pizza was delicious--perfectly cooked and full of flavor. We also tried the Jack Bread and the mozzarella sticks, and both were fantastic additions to the meal. Definitely a solid spot if you're looking for high-quality food and a great variety of sides. I'll be back for sure! read more

Not great. Lack of toppings on both pizzas: ordered sausage and extra cheese-hardly a dimes worth of sausage and definitely not any extra cheese. The buckaneer while tasty was also lacking ingredients. Overall, skimpy on what was advertised as NY pizza. ordered garlic knots and got garlic bread instead. Mozz sticks and salad were average. read more

We got the Buccaneer pizza and garlic knots, they were both really good! We ordered it Togo and they were pretty quick to get it done. Would definitely go again! read more

Delicious A must eat on your way to South Florida Veggie pizza was a blast Sandwich is excellent read more

Ordered the Scallywag 18'' for a couple of us at the office and I must admit - it was DELICIOUS!! Great flavor for the crust and the amount of sauce and toppings was perfect. My only complaint was the use of canned mushrooms. Great value for the price! read more

Pirate Pizza - All that's left of the 18" Scallywag - a slice and a half. - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Family run, friendly pizzeria with excellent pizzas and salads. Order at counter, and they'll bring out the pizza. Have enjoyed their spicy pizza, and their Swashbuckler white cheese pizza. Prices are great. Located next to Twisted Turtle Creamery. read more

Today was the first day we had a chance to try Pirate Pizza. Since we are from NY/NJ, good pizza is a favorite, and somehow, not super easy to find around here. The restaurant is small and clean, with a pirate theme (as evidenced by the name). There is a large counter for ordering and a few booths and tables for dine-in. The menu has some appetizers, salads, pizzas, and sandwiches. it reminds me of an old-school pizzaria, where you can order pizza by the slice, which is served on super thin white paper plates. And that's exactly what I had. We got meatball app (two huge meatballs in a foil bowl, which my husband loved), and the fried 'shrooms with ranch. There's something about fried mushrooms from a pizza joint, and these were no exception. He ordered the Calypso (basically a chicken parmesan sandwich) with light sauce, and I had a slice of cheese pizza. The crust was thin and crispy, and the sauce had a great tomato flavor (I usually don't like sauce, but this was great). Plenty of cheese, too! This is a great spot for a quick lunch or takeout! We will be ordering some pies from them soon! read more

See all

My family and I just tried their pizza and everyone loved it. I recommend trying it if you are in the WGV area!

Blackbeard sub, one of my favorites! Also love their salads. Friendly staff, and get to the order right away. Definitely will use this when I want to order pizza or subs. Especially Blackbeard! read more

Love love the pizza. New favorite place for pizza. The wings were delicious. Only this is I wish they had real plates and silverware. Other than that my new to go place for pizza. read more

See all

Had pizza from here yesterday and it is hands down the best in the area we've had since moving from NJ! It was thin, crispy, not doughy at all. Definitely our new go to place read more

Pirate Pizza - Plain pie - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

While I don't believe in posting right off the bat as I want to give the establishment time to reply to my concerns, I have sent 2 emails, 1 facebook message and 1 instagram message and after several weeks of no response I feel it is time to let others know my experience. Below is the message I sent to the establishment. "We have ordered a few times but not for a while as we had a so so experience last time but wanted to give it another try. We ordered 2 18" pizzas along with some sides. 1 cheese 1 Bbq chicken. We ordered through Uber eats and I selected to add fried chicken to the order as well(2X chicken) We did not get any grilled chicken just fried chicken even though it shows we selected an additional topping. The lack of toppings was really disappointing and for $32 I was really expecting it loaded up based on some of your pictures on your site. I understand everyone can have an off day but if this is a representation of what you think is acceptable then we will select another establishment for our needs." Please see picture below. read more

Pirate Pizza - Does this look like a $32 dollar pizza to you? It was supposed to be a BBQ pizza and have 2X chicken that we paid EXTRA for! - Salad Near Me - St Augustine, Florida

Amazing pizza but even better calzone. Outstanding our go to take out place. Always friendly and always great food.

Great service and wonderful pizza and bread. Just amazing! We will be back again the next time we visit.

Good food, great amount of food for price, friendly staff. I happened to be in the area and wanted to try something "local". Much to my surprise, this one of the few places in the area that is local. At the quiet end of a shopping mall, this unassuming storefront boasts a lot of flavor. Dining by myself, I over ordered in order to be able to try more things. The salad was bountiful and fresh. My single slice cheese pizza was piping hot and had a perfect for folding thin crust. Very cheesy. The sandwich was the Davey Jones. Hot. So much meat packed with so many fresh vegetables, I couldn't even handle it. I ate the rest of the food and 1/4 of this sandwich. The amount of flavor from the 4 types of hot meat and melted cheese does battle with the fresh vegetables and comes together to form the most mouth watering bites. And for dinner, it was also delicious cold!!! :) If you're in the area, I highly recommend trying out Pirate Pizza. You can thank me later!!! :) read more

See all

Outstanding! Had the QUARTERMASTER which is Spinach, Sun Dried Tomato, Sweet Cherry Pepper, Roasted Red Pepper, Garlic, Feta, Cheddar, Monterey Jack, Mozzarella, & Sweet Pesto Sauce with a Cheddar Edged Crust. It was unique and absolutely delicious. Crust was the perfect combination of crunchy and chewy. Wasn't too thick or too thin. 100% the best delivery pizza I have found in Saint Augustine or Jacksonville. Delivery was pretty fast too. Give them a try! You won't be disappointed! read more

food is great, but customer service is ok. Asked for mozzarella on my pizza and they just put shredded Mozzarella instead of large pieces of mozzarella. Then they told me that I should have asked for a margarita, pizza or fresh mozzarella. Of course I wanted the fresh mozzarella. if I wanted more shredded cheese, I would've just asked for extra cheese. they should have fixed it total disappointment not at all the pizza I wanted although the flavor is good read more

So I can't lie when I say this was a comeback story for me! My husband and I ordered when they first opened(maybe about a month after they opened) and got it to go. It was not great... we were fairly disappointed. But locals talk-and our neighbors have constantly said their favorite pizza in town is Pirate Pizza! So I finally had to give it another go! Went last week and got the lunch special-2 slices and a soda! The pizza was a bit greasy( I did get sausage and pepperoni so it was expected) but nothing a few napkins couldn't handle! But overall really tasty and I would definitely give it another go!! And I loved the crunch on the bottom of the pizza-that was my favorite part! And the slices were huge! After the first slice I really could have stopped but I was enjoying it too much! I'm glad I tried it again! read more

You need to be ONE BITE cheese pizza Crust was on point..... found you guys by accident . Totally worth it....

We were shopping in the area and decided to try Pirate Pizza that day. It is a family owned business and they are just so nice. You order at the counter and there are some tables and booths for dinning in. We did the lunch special of two slices of pizza and a drink. The pizza choices are pepperoni and cheese. I had one of each and my husband had just pepperoni. The other lunch special is one slice of pizza, side salad and a drink. The pizza was very good and when we go back I want to try the Buccaneer. Know that they are closed on Sunday and Monday. read more

Mediocre pizza, unorganized staff. Don't bother calling in an order, they will tell you an hour and still make you wait even longer than that when you get there. read more

Non chain franchise and local is where I always want to explore. This place made good pirate bread, and the Philly steak especially is almost exact the same that I like in north Maryland. Pizza however is the reason I rate it at 4. Taste too much salt in pizza, pizza itself does taste good but salt is in the way. Only if they could reduce the salt, I think it would be my favorite one. However it is favorite for the Philly steak sub! read more

Was a little overdone for me without asking and I like it done. It was close but fell a bit short

Stopped here from our trip back from Disney and this place was amazing. The service was incredible and everyone was so nice! The pizza was down right delicious too! Best pizza I have had so far!! The place was very relaxing, and had great vibes. Literally one of the best places to go for an amazing pizza and a wonderful experience. read more

Hard to find good pizza. This place is great. Generous toppings, delicious crust, and quality cheese. read more

See all