Again, I understand pizza preferences are VERY personal but now that we tried Amore's Sicilian pizza, this is definitely our favorite in our area. It may simply be that I do not like a lot of red sauce but prefer more cheese. We like the others too, but our experience here, with the owners family and friends serving us, has been fantastic. So glad we gave it another try or two.. I see us being regulars here now for sure! read more

See all

Cute and cozy Italian pizza. A few tables but big on take out. Generous toppings. Fresh and flavorful. Love a thin crisp and airy crust! read more

See all

Ate the buffalo pizza.... It was soooo incredibly salty and oily. It has potential to be good but they need to dial back the salt. I could hardly finish 1 piece. Garlic cheese bread was good. Salad was just ok. Would be better with fresher yellow peppers. Will probably come back one more time to see if it's worth incorporating into my routine. read more

The search for great pizza in Saint Johns continues. I may have to stick with BBQ and sushi. After around 17 years, I'm about to give up. I used the online ordering, which was simple to use. As I approached the door, one of the 2 guys making the pizza opened the door for me and was very friendly. The inside was clean and still looked brand new. I went to the counter and told the girl there my name and what I had ordered. An older woman came over and said they didn't have my order. I again told them I ordered 3 pizzas and a calzone. At that point, they found the order, and I was informed that they had a power outage during the time I placed my order, and because of that, the kitchen never received my order even though it was paid for. I was told I was going to have to wait for them to make it. I was given a large sofa for my trouble. The pizza and calzone came out faster than I expected. The other guy making the pizza carried the pizza to my truck and put them on the passenger seat so I could seat belt them in place for a safe trip home. When I arrived home and we jumped into a pizza feast. I gave my wife the calzone, and she split it with one of my sons. How was it? An underwhelming it's okay, but they've had better. I tried my normal favorite, which is sausage & onions. The pizza had a good amount of onions and sausage. I was thrilled with the thin and crisp crust. The crust was great. However, something was missing with the sauce, cheese, sausage, and onion. What was missing? Sadly, it was flavor. It didn't have much. I went from happy to sad in a couple of chews. The slices are also small, so I arrived at the crust faster than I normally do. The crust tasted burnt, but it looked like it was cooked perfectly. I checked the rest of the slices on that pie, and it wasn't burnt on the bottom. Neither were the other pies. I'm guessing the oven wasn't clean and was giving the pizza a burnt flavor. I also ordered a pizza with extra cheese. The cheese amount on this pizza seemed light even for a pizza without extra cheese. The Margherita pizza was very disappointing. No one wanted the last piece, and that never happens, even with frozen pizza. This rating bothered me because the people working there were very friendly and provided good customer service when my order was misplaced. However, I expected a lot more from a place that states they have 20 years' experience with 3 generations in the restaurant business. The food just doesn't taste good. If it wasn't for the employees, I would have given them 1 star. I doubt we'll try it again. read more

See all

It's unfortunate to write a negative review. Mostly service issues. The lady at the front counter was very mean and negative. Definitely makes it hard to go back again. Pizza was okay at best but service was awful. read more

Tried for the first time last week! Had a delicious pizza that was not skimpy on toppings and great lasagna! Will definitely be going back!

We have ordered from Amore roughly 5-6 times now, and have enjoyed each meal. The pizza is fantastic and I am a snob! Service is always friendly and timely, and the food quality is outstanding and fresh. We will continue to frequent this business. read more

As a vegetarian I loved the fresh and plentiful veggies on my pizza as did my husband (a big fan of NY pizza)

Ordered the large margarita pizza and it's very good . fresh mozzarella cheese ,basil, tomatoes and sauce . you won't be disappointed! read more

We love this restaurant! The food is delicious (no matter what pizza you order - they're all fantastic!). Fresh ingredients. Delicious dough. Yummy cheese and the sauce isn't too sweet, it's just right! read more

AND HERE WE GO AGAIN!!! This time ordered take out PEPPERONI PIZZA to go.. Only problem is that I only got pepperoni on half.  The same (incompetent) server from my previous post said "it's probably underneath the cheese".  I politely explained that there was no pepperoni on that side and it wouldn't make sense that half was on top and half was underneath. Its time to retire her!!! Or just close this joint 2 STRIKES AND YOUR OUT! Not giving 3... WHAT IS WRONG WITH THIS PLACE! read more

Amore Mio Pizzeria - This is a whole pepperoni pizza??!!‍ - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

What a delightful spot! Everything about this was a great experience. Nice decor, very clean, good waitress. And the food!! Italian. To die for!! Our first time there and it won't be the last. The food is made on the spot. All fresh and soooo delish! Varied menu with pizza, Stromboli, calzones, and wraps, plus entrees that are Italian specialties. Can't wait to return and you should go too! It was a wonderful surprise - Rt. 210 construction makes it a bit hard to access but it's worth making the effort. Hopefully, that road will get finished sooner than later so this restaurant can attract many more visitors. Waitress told us it was SRO before construction began and I can believe that. They need to get that road done soon! Meanwhile, they serve indoors plus there's pick-up and free delivery most days. Closed on Mondays. Go. See for yourself - or, taste for yourself! 5 stars in my book! ***** read more

Authentic Italian Food , Awesome Service. Nice Ambiance . Meatballs are perfectly cooked and delicious read more

Just moving into the neighborhood and stopped in for lunch. Hubby and I shared a 14" pepperoni pizza. We're from New York originally and appreciate a good, crispy, thin crust. Amore Mio delivered! The pizza could have used a little more pepperoni, but the sauce was great and the cheese was good quality and the right proportion. We will definitely come back to try the entrees. read more

Amore Mio Pizzeria - 14" Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

HONEST REVIEW - Cheap quality & expect Tips Went here because of convince. I got Ziti with salad which was OKAY not great. Good at best but definitely not a delicious place to eat at. Everything looks and tastes like homemade like boiled wet noodles with cottage cheese spread and sauce dumped on top. It's good, not fantastic including the pizza. Read the other reviews, it's true they spread the crust and toppings so thin to save money and burn the bottom for $19! My issue is with the women at check out. Your customer service is terrible. We come in, make an order, I ask for olives on my salad and get told "there's no way for the system to charge me extra money to add olives, so I can't have that".. then at signing the receipt you ask for a tip? HA. When food is ready 20 minutes later you visibly show anger at me on my way out because I was taking 4 extra napkins yelling from the register you put napkins in my bag. MA'AM. You placed 1 single sorry thin napkin in my bag. Absolutely disgusting cheap place where quality is NOT worth the prices. Go to Olive Garden for $25 with free bread & delicious taste. read more

Amore Mio Pizzeria - Pizza, Ziti w/ salad - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

Placed an online order to be ready at 710pm husband still standing there at 745 with no pizza and kept being told it was in the oven 10 more minutes. Around 725pm he asked for the money back and no one could take care of him. They kept lying and saying 10 minutes... Get your sh.t together before you take orders !! 748 walking out with the pizza and wasn't offered anything after waiting an extra 38 minutes... read more

We are from out of town visiting family. Ordered a large cheese pizza that we requested to be crispy as one of the order options. Pizza was not crispy. Overall a decent crust. The sauce had a very off flavor that was bitter. Not sure if this was a bad batch of sauce or if this is the norm. Regardless, can't see how Amore can remain in business serving such inferior product. read more

We saw the 'Pizza' flags waving each time we passed and decided to give Amore Mio a try. Being from NYC and recently moved to the area, I didn't get my hopes up too much, only because we have been disappointed with several other so-called pizzeria's in the area. I do have to say that the pizza at Amore Mio will not disappoint. You can taste the quality ingredients in the sauce, cheese, etc. We met the owner Dennis while we were there and he was a real gentleman and stand up guy. The interior is very nice and cozy, although the walls are missing a picture or two of Frances Albert Sinatra, but I'm sure those will be displayed sooner or later since his songs and other Italian favorites were playing continuously throughout or meal. We will return to try more pies and the Hot Heros. read more

Amore Mio Pizzeria - 14" Plain Cheese Pizza with Fresh Basil. - Pizza Near Me - St Johns, Florida

Had the pizza on several occasions for lunch. Service great and waitress very polite. Nice little get away for a quite and enjoyable meal. read more

Husband just ordered a 14" pepperoni for take out - ready on his arrival, good flavor, says he will go back!

Best pizza so far in Jacksonville... Best quality of ingredients and taste. I recommend them.

We love this small, family owned Italian restaurant. Our servers are always on it, are friendly and know the menu. We have eaten here multiple times, choosing a variety of options...all have been delicious. The salads are fresh and delicious. Give it a try! read more

We had a dinner party and some friends offered to bring Italian food from Amore Mio Pizzeria on 210 in St John's County. Wow! What incredible pizza! Loved the assortment but mainly loved the really fresh, quality ingredients. It was no ordinary pizza! The pizza was followed by the most delicious Tiramisu and Cannolis that any of us had ever eaten! Both were homemade and again, with quality ingredients. I don't think I have ever actually licked a pan in my life but I did that one! Give Amore Mio Pizza a try! You will be happy you did! read more

This food was just Devine. Stopped in on a whim and was happy to find tasteful light food. The pizza was crispy and not too dense, we had a simple caprese. The Mediterranean salad was fresh and had phenomenal toppings! Would visit again! read more

Absolutely loved their pizza. Ready after 30 minutes as promised. Definitely will be going back for more. Don't let the bad reviews stop you, honestly unfair reviews. This is a new establishment so please be patient. Give the new kids on the block a chance. Thank you Amore Mío! We love you guys! read more

8 of us dined in and ate a variety of food. Everything was great, especially the pizzas!! The place was cozy and service was good. Looks like we found a new favorite place to eat anytime we are in town. Thanks for the great dinner!! read more

Mediocre pizza at best. The owner has the worst customer service. I recommend Miei Amici Pizzeria and Jenk's Pizza.

Pizza is good and delivery is timely. Staff has been attentive when we call. Would recommend.

The dining room was nice t impressive. Menu is a little on the pricey side. Pizza was phenomenal, really fresh.

This is a real shame. The pizza here is awesome, when it's not BURNT! The owner needs to watch more carefully what goes out the door. Since moving into the area in August we have given them so many tries I can't even count. read more

I'm sad to read the reviews bc we want this place to survive based on location convenience. We have ordered here twice. The pizza has been OK. The first time we did to-go & my husband said the place was very smoky inside. They also forgot our salad dressings. Second order was delivery and we appreciated that it was on time, however we paid for extra cheese and there was barely any cheese and barely any crust. We are simple people who usually just order cheese for our toddlers. Please thicken your crust a tad and add extra cheese, so we're eating something! We will give you one last try! Actual rating 2.5-3 stars. read more

Want to say I had a small hiccup with my order today and the owner went above and beyond to make it right even hand delivered my order to my door. Every business has times where things may not meet the customers expectations what matters if if they are willing to acknowledge and rectlify it and this owner truly cares. read more

We ordered take-out, and everyone in the family was thoroughly pleased. The chicken parm is . The pizza tasted fresh and authentic. The cheesy bread was perfectly browned. The service was pleasant and friendly, and the ambiance was quaint and relaxing. We will absolutely be putting Amore Mio into rotation. read more

I am from Jersey so I am extremely picky on what ' good pizza' is. It is hard to find a good slice here in Florida, but Amore Mío Pizzeria did not disappoint! The pizza tasted just like home. It was so so good! We got a pie half mushroom half sausage and pepperoni and it was devoured very quickly. Also very quick service- only took 15 min to make the pie! Will come back for sure read more

We tried 4 different things and every single one was absolutely delicious! This will be our new regular.

First time going in today and let me say my wife and I enjoyed everything about the place. The ambiance is amazing, service was top notch and the food is impeccable. Def worth a 5 star if not higher. Dont trust the low ratings go see for yourself and be impressed read more