Excellent I get GF and it's amazing Real old school Highly recommend the GF pizzas read more

If you're anywhere near Ponte Vedra Beach and craving pizza, Tony's Pizza is always a solid choice! Their simple cheese pizza is my go-to every time--perfectly crispy crust, great sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. Sometimes you don't need anything fancy, and they absolutely nail the basics. Consistently good, reliable, and hits the spot every time. Definitely one of my favorite pizza spots in the area! read more

See all

New owners and no comparison to original Tony's. It was my goto pizza NY style.. been going there since 2015 and always the best NY pizza. Today my grandaughter wanted a pizza from Tony's. I chose anchovy. What a disappointment, no flavor or charachter. I was told they were Mediterranean anchovies. I am used to traditional salty brown anchovy filet. They did replace but the crust which should be slightly charred. The crust was burnt from center and the flavor was bland with hardend cheese that tore off crust. I am from Philly and I know pizza and Tony's alway ranked tops. The new ownership may call it Tony's. But the flavor and personality of original Tony's was the best in folks and flavors. Sadly I guess I will not be returning as even though they remade pizza, It was uneventful. For those few of us who love the traditional Sally bone in flat filets it is not at Tony's. I will not be returning. FYI do not expect what we enjoyed from the original crew of Tony's and the great flavors we loved. Time to move on. read more

Tony's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

Always fabulous food and the service is always fun when you walk in and get a little bruschetta while waiting for your pie thank you to our neighborhood pizza restaurant read more

Amazing food and service the best pizza around. Food is always on time tasting great and served with love.

Always delicious food!! Anti pasta salad and meatballs are awesome!! Love the pizza and spinach swirl!! Love the bruschetta at pickup, thank you so much!! read more

Got the Stromboli. It was perfect. Service was friendly as well. Second time ordering from here. Both times have been very good.

We love the pizza at Tony's! We make it a point to go as much as possible when we go back for visits.

Their food is delicious. We had pizza one night and it was and it was very good and then the next time we had eggplant Parmesan chicken Alfredo and something else and it was all so good great place to go price point OK read more

You might bristle at the nice lady who answers the phone (she gets to the point) but the pizza is the best!!! Don't forget the number.

Excellent pizza. Really the best that I have had anywhere in the Jax area. This will be my go to.

Can't believe it took as so long to find this amazing pizza. You walk in and immediately get the old school real pizza place vibe. My wife loves pizza and she fell in love with there pizza, we had the mama and an onion and garlic pizza read more

We got takeout and the pizza was delicious! Our order was on time. We will definitely be ordering from there again in the near future.

Excellent pizza and salads. Ask for extra-crispy crust. Have not tried their pasta. Friendly service.

Great pizza and service. Plenty of toppings and Great sauce. There a few small tables inside and you can get a glass of wine.

This is a sad review to write. We love Tony's and have been ordering their pies for years. The pizza is still great but management is now so bad we probably will not be ordering again. We ordered a few pizzas at 5:30p and were told they would be ready at 6:30p. We left with the pizzas around 7:15p after watching the staff panic and bicker for 45 min. Amazing pizza but until they get new management, order elsewhere or order really early. read more

We ordered pizza to be picked up just prior to the Fourth of July holiday weekend. We were fortunately advised to know the preferred process of just what you want to order when you call as the conversation goes much better if you are fully prepared when you call! No names are exchanged in order to place an order, you are just given a number as well as a reasonable timeframe your order will be ready. We ordered one large meat lover's pizza, one large Hawaiian pizza and one medium white pizza; all three were delicious and ready for pick up upon our arrival. We gave them our previously "assigned number" and, in return, we were handed our pizzas! In addition, while paying our bill, we were offered a piece of their non-menu house made bruschetta that was simply a special treat for ordering our meal. Once we settled up our account and finished our very good sample of bruschetta, we left the pizzeria to return home in order to feed the family! Thin crust pizza, New York style, as well as an order of their delightful garlic knots, easily put plenty of smiles on our family's face! read more

Our favorite local pizza joint has changed some ingredients and we needed to find a new "place". We found Tony's (which has been here for many years), and we couldn't be happier. The pizza is generously sized, high quality and tasty. LOVE the margherita. Also tried thier "meat" lovers style pizza, both excellent. Can't wait to try Grandma's pizza. But we have found our new spot! The apps have been a little hit and miss (thus 4 instead of 5 stars from me). But hey, their core product is amazing! read more

Tony's Pizza - Meat pizza - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

See all

Hands down one of the best pizzas in the world. I can't hype this place up enough. Owners and staff are very friendly. For the price you can eat for days off one pie. Used to go to Vs for my pizza, not anymore. Tonys all the way baby. read more

We enjoyed our night out to Tony's imagining that we were in a NY eatery with all of the decor here. When you dine in, they offer a complimentary garlic knots for the table. The service was great and we were excited to see this Baymeadows pizza spot flourishing with a full crowd. read more

Tony's Pizza - Grandma's pie with pepperoni added - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

Ok. Been patronizing Tony's almost every Friday night since we moved here 11 years ago. Last two times crust has been overdone and the pie has been folded up on one side in the box. Can't explain that! Burned crust and cheese is gross, and we will be looking for another pizza place. Too bad because we really liked it when they cared about the product. read more

Got some takeout pizzas for dinner, a Hawaiian and a Chicken Primo. The pickup was quick and easy, and they give you Bruschetta while you wait. Had to call to order, as there was no online ordering. Prices were reasonable, and the 18" Hawaiian was fantastic! The crust is amazing as well. The 2nd pizza was very bland, hence the loss of star. Chicken, artichoke, red pepper, ricotta, and red onion was just a lot of things going on. Probably my fault for ordering it. The service was very friendly, though! read more

The best in the area and having been a regular for years. Don't trust anyone else for pies!

We ordered a pizza for pickup and it was great. We had the meat pizza. When we picked up the pizza they gave us some bruschetta while we waited for the pizza. read more

Really good pizza. Friendly people with very traditional style. This is my pizza place in PV.

Pizza is one of the best NY style close enough for me to have delivered. I live by Mayo. Not DaVinci good, but...

Great pizza. Great flavors. Always the best. Their eggplant Parmesan is excellent. They give you enough for two.

Got two pizzas here the other night. The white pie tasted quite poor and one of the cheeses even seemed a little off. The plain pie was just too much dough and even seemed a tad undercooked. Both were medium, so I wonder if that is partly what impacted why they turned out so poorly? They probably use the same size dough from medium to large. Either way both pizzas were quite poor and we threw out what we didn't eat quickly. read more

I am sad to post this rating. You may notice that I previously rated Tony's 5 star. Once my favorite pizza place, I now realize that it is no longer what it once was. The family suffered a great loss and my heart is with them. The decline in quality was understandable. We've gone back several times to the same result... overly cheesy, thick, doughy pizza. We were hoping the the people who cooked before would maintain the quality, but they've not. I hope they can bring back the flavorful, thin, perfectly balanced NY style pizza they once had. If anyone notices an improvement, let me know. I'd be back in a heartbeat! read more

Tony's Pizza - Cheese slice - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

See all

Pro tip. Get the Grandma's! It's the best. Deep dish is airy with beautiful crust. You can taste the quality ingredients of tomatoes, mozzarella, and basil. The liberal dose of olive oil tops perfection. read more

Great pies. Great sauce, friendly staff, fresh ingredients, killer crust. Best pizza margherita in town. Do yourself a favor & call Tony's. It's ' to go ' only, no dining area. read more

The order taker was rude, she said pick up in 45 min and when my daughter went she'd said another 45 minutes, the pizza was way below expectations read more

This is a tiny restaurant and we are 'pizza snobs' having eaten some really delicious pizza- especially in Italy. But as a small business owner this is a decent, take out restaurant with a consistently decent pizza. Very fair on his prices. read more

Found this pizza place after a day of clean up. Just wanted to not have to worry about dinner. Split a pizza and grabbed one of the few places to sit. Loved the atmosphere, and the pizza was excellent. Order ahead and take out. This is an excellent option for anyone living in PV. read more

Best pizza we have discovered in Florida! My husband is from NJ and it's the best pizza outside of Jersey. read more

Tony's Pizza - two pizzas in boxes - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

I moved to Jax from Jersey in September 2015 and have been on the hunt for a decent pizza since. We recently moved down the road from this joint in PVB and decided to try it out. As soon as I walked in I could smell the dough and it took me back to the corner pizzeria in my Jersey hometown. I immediately had high hopes and they sure as hell delivered. When you walk in they offer you a bruschetta which is a nice touch and it was really good. There are really only two factors in a good pie for me. 1. Crust 2. Flavor and freshness of ingredients. The dough was as close to NJ/NYC pizza I have seen in Florida. You hear the excuse down here about "the water not being the same". They over came this. There is American pizza and there is Italian American pizza. This place delivers legit Italian American pizza. The crust has crunch but is soft on the inside with out being "doughy" or "chewy". When you fold the slice it cracks down the middle along the bottom. There is just a little flop at the narrow end but not enough that the ingredients slide around. THIS IS GOOD DOUGH. 2. Ingredients: no body makes their own cheese for their pizza. But you can buy quality cheese and crappy cheese and they use good mozz for sure. Good texture and taste and not dripping oil. The sauce is legit. The sauce itself has great depth of flavor with real minced garlic and fresh herbs. There are a lot of nice things about living in Ponte Vedra Beach but being a mile away from this God send is among the best of them. As old blue eyes would say, "only the best is good enough for me." This my friends is the best Pizza in Duval/St. John's county by far! read more

Excellent pizza! 10/10 recommend. Go there and order 2. Maybe 3 pizzas. You won't regret it.

My favorite pizza in the area! I've had Tony's Pizza a few times and I always have been impressed. read more

Tony's Pizza - 12" Margarita Pizza - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

I'm originally from Brooklyn, moved to NSB quite a while ago. My daughter lives in Jax. Whenever I visit her I try and get Tony's for their margherita pizza. Absolutely delicious! Sauce is delicious, fresh mozz, great crust cooked to a nice crisp. I love it when there are "bubbles" on my crust. If you're a die hard pizza person, you'll know exactly what I'm talking about. . Also tried the pinwheel spinach roll. I've never had one with ricotta in it. Yum. It's served with a soufflé cup of sauce on the side. Save that for dipping your pizza crust in (I mean, I never heard of using ranch dressing on my crust, that's ridiculous..lol) and eat the pinwheel straight up. It's flavor packed on its own. Nice and garlicky! Next time I'm going to order a cannoli based on the reviews. Here's to my next visit .pinwheel spinach roll with ricitta, mozz, spinach and garlic. Yummmmm read more

Tony's Pizza - a sandwich wrapped in foil - Italian Near Me - Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida

The Jax authentic NY pizza authority. Great pizza without the nonsense. Top notch service with a side of bruschetta. Wish they were in the beach, but well worth the drive to PV as they're the best in the area hands down. Wish they delivered! read more