I tried piefection years ago and wasn't super impressed, felt it was just mediocre but nothing majorly wrong. I just stopped in this week and was so disappointed after spending a lot of money on a few different slices and a whole pie. The chocolate cream pie was so sweet. The filling was like brownie batter that had not been cooked. The crusts in the pie slices is pretty much non existent. I've had a better chocolate cream pie from Albertsons. read more

We decided to visit the pop up shop in Scottsdale since we live around the corner. They had a ton of different pies for Father's Day weekend. I was very surprised and excited by the selection! We decided on the lime in the coconut pie. I liked it a lot. It was so odd - literally one bite I would feel like I was eating Keylime pie and the second bite I would feel like I was having coconut cream pie! I love both so it was a great fit. The only thing that st knocks it one star is that the pie crust was really hard to get out of the tin. The pie crust was delicious so I was disappointed that it was stuck to the bottom and hard to get out. The pies are expensive... But I am a firm believer that you get what you pay for. I can't wait to go back and try their berry cheesecake that they are featuring this summer. I also saw that there Mesa location has peanut butter pies. I love peanut butter so I want to try that as well! read more

Piefection - Cute box - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Every pie we've had we love! We have tried the chandler and mesa location and they're both great!

Honestly used to love Piefection, but the last two pecan pies I've picked up have been bad and nowhere near worth the cost. A Safeway pecan pie would be better. They need to invest in their quality control as they expand and grow. The last one was burnt and todays just tasted bad. Going to need to find a new spot moving forward. read more

Bought a banana cream pie. Crust is non existent, and filling watery. This isn't the first time like this so unfortunately giving up on them. read more

Can't rave enough about Piefection! Iva head their banana cream pie and blackberry apple crumb pie; both were amazing! The only minor complaint I have is that the space is super small inside the Queen Creek Location so it's a little crammed when busy but not too terrible. read more

Piefection - Banana Cream - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

Definitely will be returning in the future! Amazing pies! Amazing staff! 10/10 would recommend!

It is an unfortunate pattern that businesses get popular through the quality of their products, and then focus on increasing profits at the expense of the product quality that built the business in the first place. I used to love the coconut cream pie, today's fresh piece had a crust that was a 3/10, "whipped cream" was unpleasant so I give it a 2/10. The filling itself was tasty but one out of three is a complete fail in my books. I have just tasted today's fresh, old fashioned Apple pie and will not eat the whole thing. The big upshot to all this is that my need for a Piefection fix now and again has been permanently quashed. I am referring to the Mesa location on Brown. Ruth Martens read more

Awesome pie, love both the fruit pies and cream pies. New one in Queen Creek and now I can walk there.

We dropped in at the new QC location and purchased a Peanut Butter Dream whole pie and the kids each picked out a slice of their own. Love that you can get individual slices and whole pies! read more

Expensive, but we'll worth it for a delicious treat! We bought two pies for my dads birthday and they were both great! One lemon merengue and one apple. I will definitely be back to get more pies. They even sell by the slice, or mini individual pies. Great little business! read more

Been here several times and am never disappointed, I especially love their apple pies, Highly recommend!

Oh my goodness! These pies are amazing I love the cherry pie but the cream pies are amazing also can't go wrong here .

You can get a better pie at Fry's grocery for less than half the price.Maybe not the assortment,but $23 dollars for a mediocre pie.No thanks. read more

Got a banana cream pie for my birthday. It was too sweet to eat. We threw it away. A friend had a birthday, got an orange pie. It was too sweet, so nobody ate it. I felt bad I didn't warn them. The pies here are gross. read more

I love this place! The coconut creme pie & almond joy are my favorite. You can almost always find the almond joy in the single slice section. The fruit pies are so good too. read more

Piefection - Individual slices - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all

Their caramel apple pie is divine! The inside mix is a perfect blend of apples, spices, and caramel sauce. Their crust is also fantastic! The lime coconut pie tastes similar to a Pina Colada...it's tasty! The key lime pie is rich and the graham cracker crust is perfect. Review for the pot pies: we tried the green Chile pot pie...let's start with Marie Calendar's..who? This pot pie is AMAZING! Crust is perfect. The filling has just the right amount of spice! This is a MUST try for all! They have a new location off of Via Linda and 90th Street in Scottsdale, which is run by a group of younger gentleman who are very kind and helpful. read more

This place is ALWAYS good. Every flavor is incredible. The staff is friendly and the decor is cute. Highly recommend the chocolate peanut butter brownie pie. Definitely 10/10. read more

Pie is great Service is terrible! I went into Piefection 10 days early to order and pay for my 95 year old mother in law a special order pie for her 95th birthday party at 11:00am. When we went to pick it up it had not been done. So they did get it done in the afternoon too late for her party. And all we got was oh it was a mistake..No discount no offer to do anything about it. Had I ran my business like this for the past 29 years I would have no business. read more

My husband is a major banana cream pie fanatic and after trying piefection, he won't buy one from anywhere else! they are so fresh and delicious. The entire family loves them. Highly recommend! read more

I order my first two pie from them never never ever will I get another one.The peace was not to bad but the rust was not made right. The lemon was really bad. There was no flavor at all.it was hard to so not for us. read more

So frustrated with Piefection. Their pies are excellent and they're only a ten minute drive from my house. But for some reason they won't let you place an order for holiday pies, which is about the only time of year we purchase pies. (Except strangely enough, they'll let you order ahead for their custard, keto and sugar free pies.) When you're getting ready for a big family dinner, the last thing you want to do is go stand in a long line for an hour or more with sick people and restless kids. Then you make it to the front of the line, only to find that they don't have the pie you want. Their big cheery excuse is that they have tons of pies to choose from (this is a fact) but I didn't waste 90 minutes in line to get a pie I didn't want. (This happened to me last Thanksgiving.) I cannot for the life of me understand why they can't do what seemingly every other business in town does and just let you reserve what you want ahead of time. After my sour experience last year I ordered ahead with another pie place in Scottsdale this Thanksgiving. It was a 35 minute drive and the pie just wasn't as good. All I could wonder and hope was if Piefection would ever get it together and change their Stone Age ways for next year's holiday season. read more

Strawberry rhubarb pie was very delicious but I probably wouldn't repurchase just because it's one of those pies that you take 1 or 2 bites of cause it's so decadent. The green Chile pork pie IS TO DIE FOR. Cannot wait to go back and buy another one of those. read more

Piefection is our go to for bringing a dish to a party! We always pick up a pie for one of our parties too. We love this place and always will! read more

Yet to have anything I didn't care for. I'd have to say the triple berry pie is our fav! Pot pie & rolls are delish! read more

Everything about my last review stands; this review is solely based on my experience last night. I went in to get a savory pie (because seriously, the triple berry pie changed my life) and a slice of strawberry rhubarb for desert. I was pretty disappointed, to be honest. The potpie was mediocre - it tasted like they just dumped some canned veg and canned chicken in and called it a day - and the strawberry rhubarb pie was nothing to write home about. In all seriousness, I've had frozen potpies that were better and costed less. I even felt pretty nauseated after finishing the potpie and was slightly concerned it had given me food poisoning. If you're looking for a dinner pie, I'd skip this one. If you're looking for a sweet pie, I'd still recommend the triple berry because it is legit that tasty. read more

We love Piefection and are always struggling to pick which pie we want! So many delicious choices and amazing service on top of it!

Been here once & will definitely be back. Great pecan pie in particular. Apple pie and cherry pie were great as well. read more

Real good crust. Very generous of Piefection bakery for letting us celebrate national apple pie day in this tasty way -Kayden

Flavorful and delicious pies, friendly and helpful staff! If you're looking for a delicious treat, I highly recommend giving them a try!

They are NOT taking online orders at a time in life where that could not be more important. You cannot call and talk to them either. I went inside to voice my opinion. "Just Come in and pick up your pie" lol The lines will be double the length and no guarantee you will get anything outside the average everyday pies. We want specialty pies, the whole purpose of trying to order ahead. They should offer "appointment type" scheduled day/time pick ups similar to what Village Inn did to control this would be fiasco, but no. My health is compromised and I don't need to be standing around with twice as many people as there should be this holiday This was a very poor decision and it is not going to go well for them. I will use my grandmas pie crust recipe and make my own Tangy Orange Cream pie ( similar to key lime/tangy but orange) and it WILL be better and I will save the $50-60 ish. We seriously wont be back until you use simple consideration of your "would be customers". You may or may not get what you want after standing in twice the line this holiday. Happy Thanksgiving (eye roll) read more

Delicious pie, but nothing to write Home about. Pretty friendly staff. Nice clean shop.

Very disappointment. It was my job to provide an awesome dessert for thanksgiving and I thought I would get a unanimous vote for best thanksgiving ever after spending $75 for three pies and waiting in line for an hour. Not sure if their pies are usually this bad or it's just because they make thousands for this day, but I'll not ever be going back. We ordered a French Silk, Pumpkin and banana cream. The French Silk is more like a thick chocolate frosting pie. It literally tastes like chocolate frosting and there is no silk in it at all. The pumpkin is overwhelming with clove spice? And nasty. I didn't actually try the banana cream because that just isn't my kind of pie, but the family said it was ok. By far the best of the three but nothing thrilling. I would have done better if I would have just got three frozen Marie Callander pies at the grocery store for $20. Could have saved $55. Don't waste your money. read more

Piefection - French silk pie, as you can see there is no silk to it at all. Should be called a Fudge frosting pie. - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

This is a good place to get pie. Have tried from both the Mesa location and the Scottsdale. the Arizona orange pie, the strawberry rhubarb, custard, caramel apple, French silk, and the southern pecan. Also have tried the pot pies the green chili and the chicken. Wasn't a fan of the custard pie, but the rest were solid. Both Pot pies were really good. I will probably return to satisfy my annual pie cravings. read more

Called Tuesday to order a special rhubarb pie & left voicemail to call me back; never received a call back. Called Wednesday and left another voicemail; did not get a call back. Went to store Thursday morning at 10:20 am and the pre-made pies were few. Of course, no pre-made rhubarb pies. Only strawberry rhubarb. Location appeared short staffed as I had to wait, along with 3 other walk in customers. A disappointing PIEFection experience. read more

I love buying pies from here for all of our celebrations- birthdays, Thanksgiving, Easter, etc.... I love the amazingly buttery and light crust and my favorite are the coconut cream and lemon blueberry sour cream, although we've ordered several different flavors. I also like that they have multiple locations and one close to my house. read more

Such a cute place! Amazing pies! They have sweet and savory pies, the best of both worlds!

Some of the best pies in town. A wide variety of pie both fruit and cream pies. Always a clean atmosphere. They have a very friendly and welcoming staff. read more

Piefection has an unbelievable assortment of delicious and beautiful pies! The atmosphere is the shop is also adorable! A must try!

Well made the journey to far out Mesa due to a blueberry craving. The pies average about $18 and based on my one pie purchase it was a worthy price. I just had a hard tie deciding between whipped cream and ice cream for the topping at home. The blueberry pie itself was outstanding and the crust was also really good, not so flaky. It was just pure wild blueberries in the pie, so if you like this kind of fruit, then you will enjoy the pie. The chocolate cream is next to try. read more

Piefection - Blue - Desserts Near Me - Mesa, Arizona

See all