The pizza served here is comparable to &Pizza in terms of size, shape, and their flatbread-like crust. Since the restaurant is small, if you don't get there right at 5pm (when it opens) to snag a table, you might have to order carryout or wait a while. They have a separate kitchen area to handle carryout orders, and they were churning pizzas out a lot faster than the dine-in orders. There's limited selection on the menu but pizzas can be customized by adding or subtracting toppings ($2 extra for most additional toppings). I tried the margarita pizza, summertime, and goat cheese/artichoke. The summertime pizza (pesto, sweet corn, grape tomatoes, mozzarella, crab meat, basil) was the best of the bunch - "summertime" is the perfect name for it! I really liked the sweetness and bite of the corn with the lumps of crab. However, you couldn't really taste the pesto. Just a quick note about their toppings - they are not distributed well. Typically when putting toppings on pizzas, you sprinkle them so that it's everywhere on the pizza. At Pie - at least for the pizzas that we ordered - they seem to take a stingier or "delicate" approach: a topping placed in this space, another topping placed in this space, etc. so that the toppings don't overlap. I didn't really like that... I like my pizzas loaded with toppings! The only topping that the pizzas were loaded with was cheese - warning: all of the pizzas were super cheesy! The goat cheese artichoke was a glorified white pizza. It also comes with pesto and sundried tomatoes, but again, you can't really taste the pesto. The margarita pizza is pretty basic (so to jazz it up we added artichokes). The crust of the margarita pizza was actually more doughy than the summertime and artichoke/goat cheese, but it was probably just a different batch of dough. Service was average. There's not a lot of attentiveness required once you bring out the pizzas and let people have at it. As with all of the other beach establishments that I've been to in the area, there were flies flying around. Also, the place got smokey, so if you're sensitive to smoke, you should probably go elsewhere or order carryout. read more

I like the pizza especially the Black and Blue. The special red wine was ok. Overall a nice choice and a good deal/value.

Pizza was really good, but service was definitely subpar. We will likely come back because of the food, but with low expectations for everything else. Edit...went back and gave them another try two days later. Same result - great pizza and horrible service. Maybe this will be a place we take our from? I do highly recommend the food! Just be prepared for crappy service. read more

The best gourmet pizza in Delaware! A real treat for the taste buds. My personal favorite is the beef & blue. A great place to wind down with a cold beer or glass of vino to accompany your "pie." The staff is friendly and always smiling. Excited to see the remodel and enlarged dining area for the 2017 season. read more

Placed an order over the phone and picked it up at the restaurant. My boyfriend and I ordered the Beef and Blue and the Better than Pepperoni. We paid for parking and decided to eat on the boardwalk. We opened up the box and to our surprise it was shaped in a heart! The pizza was delicious. Loved the thin crust. I would recommend grabbing a lot of napkins though the toppings seemed to slide right off. We did have some leftovers, but I wouldn't suggest splitting just one pizza. Would love to come back here and try a different pizza. Some of their options are a little pricey in my opinion, but overall great experience! read more

Pie - Beef and Blue - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

Really good pizza for 3 of the 4 in our party. Unfortunately we had one order that was incorrect and we had a heck of a time getting service from our server. It looks as if the server's name was Mike, so be forewarned that our evening was nearly ruined by his lack of attention to our table and whatever chip he has on his shoulder. Good thing the pizza was on point. The cheese on the pizza was really good, great crust, good marinara. Only complaint was that the pizza could stand a little more sauce, but that's nitpicking. Highly recommend if your server isn't named Mike. read more

What a great find! Started with delicious meatballs made in house. And then found out that not only are their pizza pies wonderful (ordered the Summertime and couldn't have been happier!) but they have wonderful homemade dessert pies! My father had the peach while my mom and I shared the chocolate pie. They were excellent. My dad is a dessert connoisseur and has already mentioned going back for another piece of pie! read more

Worth a visit if you're in the area and looking for pizza. It's not the best pizza I've ever had, but it's solid and they have a lot of interesting choices. The beer, wine, and cocktail selections are good too. read more

Last time I was here I didn't like Pie. I said I would come back if there was a new head chef or manager. I was told there probably was one of them because they added on. For an appetizer I had the Caesar salad. It was delicious, but was a large sized portion in my opinion. Then for an entree I got the Italian pizza with sausage. When I had it, under the cheese it felt moist. Besides that probably the only other thing I wasn't to much happy about was is that the cheese kept sliding off. Besides those two things everything else was great. read more

Pie is currently open for lunch from 11:30am-10pm. Gluten free options, friendly staff, excellent libations, delicious gourmet pizzas and over the top pie desserts! Small town locally owned business dedicated to the town of Bethany and surrounding areas! Currently doing a happy hour from 3p-6p!! Check out the cute dining space and bring your appetite! read more

Service was good, prices right and pizzas and salads were solid. Pizza with short ribs and onions and one with sausage and broccoli rabe were both very good. Would definitely go back next time I am in town. read more

The Willow pizza and margarita drinks are absolutely amazing! Good service too. We've been here before & like it. But now Pie will be in our regular Bethany restaurant rotation. read more

Good food, good wine. We had a party of six and had to wait a bit for a table. Once seated, things went smoothly. The pizza options were varied and all looked good. I had a glass of red zinfandel that was also quite nice. My go to pizza is a white pizza with funghi and they had it. I asked for a side of arugula - which they were happy to provide. Nice experience, we'll go back. read more

I love gourmet pizza, probably a bit too much. Pie satisfied all of my desires for gourmet pizza and more. We (my parents and I) arrived on a lovely Thursday evening after a nice day at the beach. We sat down in a cozy (but somewhat tight) dining area after a brief wait, but they had a lovely porch where you can sit and wait to be seated. We ordered wine and some salads to begin with and had some pretty prompt and nice service. I ordered the tomato/mozzerella salad, my dad got the same thing but added olives, and my mother ordered the caesar salad with not anchovies. The salads were delicious! Fresh tomatoes, crisp lettuce, and dreamy mozzarella cheese made it incredible! I got to try my mom's caesar salad, and found that to be very good as well. The croutons were also very good and had a lovely hint of parmesan cheese. Then we had our pizza. We ordered two pizzas because they can be big and we also ordered salads. If you've ever been to &pizza, Pie's pizzas are about the same size. We ordered the prosciutto pizza and the goat cheese artichoke. Both pizzas were really quite good. We did wish that we had ordered the special that night, which was a peaches pizza with an Italian brie cheese. It sounded so heavenly! Oh well, next time we'll order it!! We did not sample their pies, but we really liked that their pies are seasonal, so perhaps next time we will sample them. One last thing that makes this restaurant a huge cut above the rest, the bathrooms. So usually in restaurants you have a ladies bathroom and a mens bathroom, so there can be a wait for the ladies room depending on when you go. Not this place. They have a ladies room, and a unisex room. I really enjoyed this from the perspective as a woman, because it is super annoying to wait for the ladies room. I love that Pie did this and I would really like to see more restaurants do this. read more

10/10 recommend! This is a great place to relax with a calm beach vibe. The portions are great and the taste is fantastic! Not your traditional pizza, there are many unique options! Salads are fresh and dressings are savory. Many IPA's on tap and bottle adult beverages. Mixed drinks are good as well. Ask for Bri, she will take care of you! read more

On vaca, dropped in for dinner. Got 2 pizzas, 1 salad, club soda from tap, beers. First, the local craft beers were very good, chilled and tasted great. Pizza was yummy. Pizzas are one size with homemade crust and great topping combos. You can make your own as well. Sodas, as in most Beach restaurants are now $3. This was a bit shocking, but likely the norm. Just get beer or water - this way you don't feel like you are getting ripped off. I would gladly go back, food is quality and scratch made. read more

Pie has a great atmosphere- the Feta dip was fabulous. Bethany (our server) was very friendly, helpful and efficient. The pizza was very good. Would definitely recommend. read more

I love the pizza here, but I'm not planning to go back very soon. There are a few reasons why. The two times I've been to Pie this season, I felt there was something not right. I was sitting by a a window and The sun was starting to set. The brightness was blinding. Unless it's raining , this happens every day. Why haven't the owners installed blinds to block the sun? Also pizza is one of those foods that are fun to share. Not so much here. The plates , which are they have, are the size of saucers, barely big enough to hold one small slice of pizza. Their salads are large;large enough to share also, although you've got the same saucer size plate to share. I asked for spoons to divide the salad up, and the server brought me ONE and said that was all they had. It seemed that anything I asked for to make my meal more enjoyable, was denied. Considering whose restaurant this is, the culinary trained daughter of Patsy, owner/chef of one of the very best restaurants in Bethany Beach, Patsy's, I'm surprised that she's cutting so many corners at Pie. I'm giving Pie 3stars rather than 2, because the food is so good. read more

Really enjoyed this. Brought the kids (two 11 year olds) and had a really nice meal. We ordered two salads (Caesar and mozzarella and tomato) and two pizzas (Italian and Margarita). Everything was excellent. Service was excellent and the food was both tasty and served promptly. Not a bad thing to say and we'll be back at a time when we DON'T have kids for a nice dinner for two. read more

My wife and I had heard good reviews from this place so we decided to try it out last Saturday night 6/24. The place had a few diners but wasn't very crowded. The young very nice hostess decided to seat us in the back since she did not feel like wiping off one of the empty tables from a previous diner in the front. Sitting in the back of the restaurant is not a great experience since this is where the overstaffed workers congregate to s the s and discuss their current "weed" situation. I counted nine young workers in one area not doing much of anything. I think one of the guys in the group that appeared to be the center of attention was not an employee, but rather the boyfriend of one of the workers. The place is obviously not managed very well. Now on to the food: The $12.00 Caesar Salad was horrible. We ordered the pepperoni pizza, it was actually very good. Probably wont be back. There are several other good pizza restaurants in the area that are far better managed. read more

Fantastic new pizza place in Bethany Beach! Loved the pizza! In fact, I'm trying to figure out if I can convince my family to go there again tomorrow! It's a tiny place and gets a little smokey and warm in there. Otherwise, just a great new place! read more

Very good pizza! GREAT service and beer selection. Only draw backs where no kids menu :( our kids don't love pizza - I know- crazy! But they ate it... Also no crayons, coloring paper or anything to keep kids engaged. Over all good experience read more

Pie - Beef & Blue - Pizza Near Me - Bethany Beach, Delaware

See all

Not your typical pizza, since we are from Philly we are a bit spoiled when it comes to pizza. We like a pizza that you can hold and fold and the crust made here is far from that. I would not even compare this to a good flat bread, the crust was so hard and stiff you could not bite it and it was tough even using utensils to cut it. I asked our server if the pizza was made fresh and she said it was but the crust was more like something that was frozen. Quite disappointed since we were expecting something far better. I choose to avoid the chain pizzerias and shop elsewhere but I will pass on this place in the future. read more

Great wood oven pizzas and fresh salads. A great selection of specialty wine and beer

AMAZING food!! Definitely get the summertime pizza. Totally worth the price and plenty of food for 2 people to split.

Greetings. Tonight I ordered 2 pizzas and a Cobb salad. I thought the shape of the pizza was cool. I'd describe it as resembling the outline of a very large bean. Let's start with how awful the pizza was. One pie was the "better than pepperoni" and I'm honestly not sure how they came up with that name, because nothing is better than pepperoni. The other pizza was cheese, half cherry pepper. Both were ordered well done, none were received well done, or good tasting. The crust is god awful. It tasted as though it had been frozen since the 80s. If you're familiar with hard tack, that's the flavor of the crust. Or, if you've ever eaten cardboard on mistake(or on purpose) that also shares similarities with the taste and texture of the crust. It's just pretty awful. The pizza as a whole was flavorless. The salad hasn't been touched yet, as I'm still searching for my extra side of balsamic. In closing, I have no clue how this place exists based on the food I ate tonight. We threw away the pizza we didnt eat, went to the grocery store at the end of the street and bought a digiorno instead. I'm not fooling around, that's what happened. I've even put a big mac in the fridge for later....and I tossed this mamamiapizzzzzaaaapie read more

AqOMG- over an hour to get a pizza! We waoted since most places were busy BUT never again Only in the off season! The pizza are good if you can them before you leave..... read more

Terrible pizza and service. Pizza is expensive There were very few toppings on the pizza. For instance we got shrimp pizza and there was one little shrimp per slice same with pepper etc. The dough was fairly thick and not to our taste. most importantly the service was terrible. we could not get through on the phone so we are at online. we were told there was a two hour wait. we went there in an hour and a half and the pizza is done and Luke warm which meant that have been ready for quite a while I do not recommend this place read more

WAY too much cheese and minimal sauce. We were looking forward to this and we were hungry. Came away disappointed.

My family ate here last night for dinner. Short walk from the Bethany Beach Boardwalk and so worth it! It was bigger than I thought with a bar and several tables. Our server was was wonderful, upbeat, and very helpful with making recommendations (I feel bad that I forgot her name). We got 4 pizzas for the six of us to split and that was more than enough. The summertime one with crab was my fave and the boys enjoyed the Beef and Blue. The cherry on top was the delicious pies for dessert. Chocolate Peanut Butter, Blueberry, and Pina Colada...yummo! Would highly recommend! read more

Fantastic fresh gourmet pizza! Great atmosphere and awesome craft beer selection. If you're looking for tasty fresh pizza this is the place!

Four of us tried PIE tonight even though the reviews have been mixed in 2019. Well , we had a most enjoyable time and the Pizza's were great. We all started off sharing a couple of salads which not only were very nice, they were huge. We all will definitely be back . read more

Fantastic pizza and a great addition to Bethany Beach's lackluster restaurant options. Came with my family (including a picky 6 year old) and Abby, our server, was personable and very helpful, and made our dinner delightful. The pizza is original and creative, the salads are thoughtful, and they have a great wine and craft beer selection. Our family left full and happy and I'd highly recommend for both families and couples. And of course, ask for Abby! read more

If your idea of a pizza is something heavy and possibly a tad on the greasy side, than walk right past this place. But if you like a craft pizza that does not talk back at 3:00 in the morning, then give this one a try. We have been there about 20 times. The menu is limited to craft pizza and salads. They do have a nice wine list, craft beers, and a full liquor license. Ambiance is a joy. Staff are pleasant and courteous. read more

We love pie! Every time we come to Bethany, we make a point to go here, or at least bring in pizza from here. Their pizza is fantastic, and so are their salads (and that comes from people who live in a city with tons of great food and more specifically, pizza options). The artichoke goat cheese is my favorite, and my husband tends to go for the pepperoni (ish) one. read more

Just had a wonderful lunch a PIE. Sat at the bar. Our server was Riki, who was warm and personable. The two pizzas we had, both recommended by Riki were absolutely wonderful! Pizzas are really gourmet style. A thin baked crust with just the right amount of toppings. Great selection of craft beers on tap. We loved this place! Just what Bethany Beach needed... a high quality pizza restaurant. We will be back... frequently! read more

The pizza was amazing. Beef and Blue, Better than Pepperoni, and Crab and Prosciutto pizzas were out of this world. The house salad was even great. We ordered the blueberry pie which was the best pie I have ever had. Service was great. Very friendly and welcoming. We will be back on our next trip to Bethany Beach. read more

Definitely come here after a day at the beach. The crust was extremely tasty (great texture, delicious flavor) and the variety of pizzas that we had were very good. One person at our table was troubled by how much cheese was on hers, but I am a sucker for cheese and didn't mind. I did end up spicing up my pizza quite a bit, so I could use a little more flavor, but overall, it's very satisfying. read more

Absolute worst service of all time. Waited an hour and half for our pizzas only to have one taken away. Messed up the order many different ways and to add insult to injury we were with small children who they obviously have little experience with. Pizza, when it came, was highly mediocre. Will never return and we vacation in Bethany every summer. read more

I had the summertime pizza, delicious. Just beware these pizzas are each an individual portion size.