There is a new spot in the 78704 right at the busy corner of South 1st @ Oltorf. Phoebe's Diner recently opened in Sept 2017 and now is serving breakfast and lunch till 3pm. The location of this place is in the heart of 78704, so for the people that live in this extremely high rent area of ATX, it is in walking distance for many. I will say, it seems already inherited into the community.
Phoebe's Diner enters into the very competitive Austin breakfast market. Many people know that for Saturday & Sunday mornings, breakfast is highly sought out for in this city. If somewhere in Austin has good breakfast, the place is usually packed and you will have a wait. It is a hot breakfast market if your restaurant follows the popular formula. First off the location of Phoebe's diner is in a small strip mall near a Texaco gas station. There are parking spots but not many, so hopefully you can get one. The venue itself isn't very large. It is a long and narrow rectangle style restaurant. Rent in Austin is quite disgusting and I can imagine for a restaurant the same rule applies. Phoebe's Diner is certainly using every single bit of square footage they have available. Right when you walk in, there are tables on each side. There is a small booth to put yourself on the list. The only waiting area is outside so if it is a cold day in Austin, you better be ok waiting outdoors. The venue has roughly about 18 different booths/tables. If you are larger than a party of 4, your table options are limited, so put that into account. There is about 8 stools available to eat at the counter. Waiter service was attentive, friendly and informative.
Now onto the stuff that actually matters is the food. I posted a few photos of the 1 page menu. It certainly follow the style of a diner menu. You have mostly breakfast options with a few lunch choices. You have typical American style breakfast, migas, Phoebe's benedict, breakfast burrito, pancakes, french toast, biscuits & gravy, and even the option to get 9+ hour smoked brisket. I asked the waiter, said the head chef was big on brisket, so he has his own personal smoker behind the store. I ordered Phoebe's breakfast and swapped out ham for bacon. I was encouraged to stick with ham, but that's just not my style. Eggs were quite well cooked and fluffy. Holandise sauce was very light. Bacon is actually pork belly as other described. It is certainly a thick cut of bacon. I did not like the hashbrown casserole at all! Onions didn't go well with it, and just not the perfect mix to the breakfast items. I did not try any pancakes, but certainly looks like you can customize them how you want. This place makes excellent thick fluffy biscuits. It went well on this item. Menu has all sorts of drinks such as coffee, cappuccinos, espresso, teas, juices, beer/wine, mimosa and so forth. Also what would a diner be without the pie of the day.
The menu prices are fair for the quality of food and service. This place is already known by locals in the near by areas, so expect a wait if you come during peak hours. I had different opinions on visiting Phoebe's diner. First I always enjoy to see any new spot come into the very crowded and busy Austin breakfast spots. Secondly, I think the minimal square footage of the restaurant is a minor inconvenience. I would see waiters constantly have to navigate around each other because there is simply very little walking space. Place is certainly noisy, but if it is a diner, shouldn't that be already assumed? It is also hard to fully judge a place on just ordering one item from the menu. I try to base more my ratings on food quality than the locations, service, or decor. However they still factor into the overall Yelp score. I have gotten to experience a lot of different Austin breakfast spots. The low key mexican restaurants, the long time breakfast places, and then the fancy downtown breakfast for the people that live in downtown and dont mind shelling out $20-30 on FREAKING brunch. To each their own, everyone has different tastes. So where does Phoebe's Diner fall into all of this? My review is 4/5. Good food, creative menu, small sized venue, and attentive staff. There was just a lot more I was expecting out of this place and only some of it delivered. Don't worry, this place looks like it will always be busy and packed. Phoebe's diner is a good new breakfast addition to south ATX, but I'm not sure it belongs on a top 5 breakfast spot list. read more