The cannolis were outrageously good. They are made fresh before you buy them. Also love the sesame cookies.

Pleasant and friendly owner and staff. I picked up St. Joesph's pastry. After tasting, I'm pretty sure that I'm team sfingi. Also, a few pignoli cookies are now $48 a pound; rainbow cookies; and a Napoleon. It was so good to be in the old neighborhood. read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Very stale cakes. Second time. No refund and rude. Live in the neighborhood and will never go back Disgusting place. Stay away

Cute bakery. Two girls working there were super helpful. Answered all my questions. Bought a lulu & banana filled eclair thingy. Food was delicious. read more

See all

Great bakery. Under new management. Delicious bake good and bread. Open 7 days a week. Excellent service. Very clean. Sells coffee to go. Also sells milk. Such a nice pleasant owner. Best bakery in the Mill Basin area. read more

Any occasion, my family buys desserts from Palermo's. If we just want a random cannoli or if we're celebrating someone's birthday, we always go here. I personally recommend their cannolis and their rainbow cookies. The best. I've gotten a lot of different types of desserts from this bakery but by far these are my favorite. I think the flavor of their food is just top-tier among the other bakeries in the area. They're a little bit pricey but the quality and staff are really nice. It's a cute interior little shop and I would recommend going here. read more

See all

I ordered a special cake for my granddaughters 24th birthday and the cake was baked a few hours before I had to pick it up! It was so fresh and delicious! Everyone loved it, even my son in law who usually doesn't like cake thought this was excellent! It was the BEST cake I ever had and everyone at the party agrees! THANK YOU Palermo Pastry Shop read more

The pastry shop was amazing. Sold anything you could think of and the staff was friendly.

Excellent quality of food. Family owned the generations. It takes pride in there, quality of ingredients.

I always come in this place to try to get a cake or desserts and they never really have anything.

Two words; Hairy Cannoli Inedible and the cannolis had long hairs throughout, it was completely disgusting Also neighbors complain the owner is rude and burnt birthday cakes for customers and try and cover them with the wrong colored frosting. Look elsewhere for pastry and sweet nibbles read more

The best Cannolis in Brooklyn I go there all the time the girls are so sweet and nice definitely a 5 star

Writing my 999th review to express more love for Palermo's. My original review addresses the food itself. I don't get over here as much as I used to as life has gotten busier, but luckily I have a friend in the neighborhood (thanks Olu) that gets me my fix. I've been buying cookies and pastries from Josephine, Debbie, Enzo and the others for literally my entire life. I remember sitting on the glass counter as a small child. And I still am an absolute pain in the ass every time I go, picking out each type when I buy assorted cookies, just like I did as a kid. As you get older, so much of your earlier life fades away to only memories. Palermo's at every major holiday is a constant for me. My Grandma had been buying everything here since they opened in the 70's, and this is one of the last major connections I have left to her. It doesn't hurt that Palermo's still makes the best overall cookies (ie: rainbow, assorted) I've had anywhere in NY either (including Villabate, Alliota's, Artuso's, Cuccio's etc). I will be coming here until I die or they close. After that, I may have to open a bakery myself. Long live Palermo's! PS: Apparently Yelp doesn't count updates as new reviews, so technically not my 999th. Oh well, I tried. read more

I should have written this review last summer when I visited NY, but better late than ever! I absolutely LOVE this place! I really wish there was one in AZ, where I live now, because the Cannoli's are to die for!! The staff is super friendly and encouraged me to taste different things- this led to a $72 cookie run; it was worth every penny! Also, the cakes are absolutely beautiful! Definitely get to Palermo if you are in the area! read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Worth every penny! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Cake was delicious. The bread was exceptional and the service was wonderful. No complaints here.

4 cookies at $3. Huh??? Something is wrong with this picture. This is highway robbery. I realize there is no consistency here. You get different amounts of pastry depending on the server. Very disappointed. read more

Bought a red velvet cake yesterday for my father in laws birthday. It was delicious and very fresh! They have great customer service and the shop is very clean. I will recommend to others! read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Red velvet cake - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Excellent cake whipped cream is amazing I believe it is whole milk cream not shortening. Wonderful go to Bakery for every occasion

Very, very tasty rainbow cookies. Cannolis are pretty good. I love the filling. Creamy, delicious and completely fill the shell. But, the shells aren't crusty. At least the few times I've had their cannolis this has always been my complaint. I keep hoping it will get better. read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Red velvet cupcake Large eclairs Large canoli Napoleon - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Stopped in for a box of assorted cookies. We had the chocolate chip, rainbow, chocolate butter with chocolates filled with chocolate dipped in chocolate, chocolate chip butter filled with chocolate and dipped in chocolates, and rainbow sprinkle butter with jelly filling, and fried rugulach style style cookie. My favorite was the chocolate chip cookie. I think it was the freshest of the bunch. read more

One of my favorite bakeries cheese cake is amazing their cookies are so good & flavors are yummy love this bakery

I have been coming to Palermo for many, many years. I think I began going here once I could walk and hold a $10 bill out to one of the nice ladies behind the counter. This bakery is tiny but amazing. You can smell the freshly-baked goodness once you open the door. There are displays full of cookies, cakes, and any other dessert that your sweet tooth could desire. They also have fridges with the fresh fruit cakes (their strawberry cake is AMAZING) and milk. The prices can be a bit steep (10 bucks for a pound of assorted cookies) but it's worth the cost. They will even fill their cookies with chocolate, instead of jam, if you do so desire. And who doesn't love a bakery that still uses the old school string dispensers that hang from the ceiling? It's a classic touch. read more

Its beyond comprehension how this little wonderful bakeshop makes the BEST CHOCOLATE CHUNK cookie in creation. I searched for the perfect chocolate chip cookie for years and little did I know that they were here in my own back yard. Everything here is equally good. read more

Ordered a last minute cake for my husband's birthday here. The owner Enzo agreed to make it for me thank god.(I live around the corner and I'm a procrastinator.) The cake was soft, fluffy and the ricotta filling was delicious. The cake decoration was okay; nothing to write home about. I was glad that it was not a special occasion, just a birthday BBQ. Anyhow, the lobster tails, rainbow and pignoli cookies are finger licking good!! The pignoli cookies can't be beat!! Yummy yummy!! read more

Very bad attitude the woman owner. I need pastries to be protect for a private jet trip so they would not break. It only took thinking outside of the box. I showed her it could be done. She said i was the only special person that needed it that way. I live 3 blocks away. I guess my business catering jets is not what she wants. She does not need my business. She is not the only good bakery in Brooklyn. Sad that is how she treats her customers. Especially someone who can be a regular repeat customer. Shame on her. read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Palermo is the best! We've ordered multiple cakes for special events and have been so pleased every time. Awesome customer service too, which is much appreciated! read more

I would like to thank Enzo, the Owner, for creating the most beautiful 90th Birthday for my mom's celebration. It was so fresh and delicious. He made us a heart shaped cake with cannoli and french cream filling decorated with fresh whipped cream and airbrushed it beautifully. My nephew drove from Long Beach, LI to pick up the cake early in the morning and bring it back to Bellmore for the celebration at the restaurant! We have been patrons here for over 30 years from when we lived in Canarsie and continued to come when we moved to Massapequa and we continue to come for every special event like guest visiting from out of state or when we travel. The freshness and flavor can't be beat! The prices are fair and reasonable! read more

Palermo Pastry Shop - Cannoli and French Cream with Fresh Whipped Cream outside! - Bakeries Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Reasonable price but outrageous quality and service. The teenage girl made us fresh lender tarts as they were out. I dare anyone to not like anything here. The owner, smiles all the time. I moved away from OMB 14 years ago and still come back. Met a woman there who lives in NJ and returns there. read more

Palermo is an old school Italian American bakery. 5 stars for fresh filled cannoli. They have good quality at great prices. How do you not love them. read more

I will never shop in this bakery. After going into the store and asking for My money back cause the cake was the wrong one . The girl behind the counter gave out the wrong cake . . It was told no strawberries and the child is allergic to it. They sold a cake with strawberries in it. The cake went back uncut. Owner is rude and nasty and he doesn't stand behind what he sells. He's ripping customers off. Refused to take the cake back. The bakery should be sued for selling the wrong cake . Allergies can be life-threatening. read more

Palermo's is the best. The best cannolis, rum baba, and you must try their Lobster Tails with french cream. I send anything I can to my family in Florida. You won't be disappointed. read more

The young girls who work behind the counter are very nice and accommodating. As for the owners I can't say the same. Very nasty and unfriendly. Will be avoiding this place when only the owners are working behind the counter, especially the female owner. read more

This is my favorite bakery in Brooklyn. A Brooklyn fixture since the 1960s. The business is family-owned and operated. They own the 2-story house that the bakery occupies which is why this bakery is able to keep their prices very low. Their cakes and cookies are amazing. They also make one of the best tasting vanilla & chocolate pudding birthday cakes ($14) I have ever tasted. If I lived near this place, I would be stopping by there every week. read more

Superb lobster tails and canolis. Been going here for 30+ years and never had any issues when it came to taste and quality. Everything always tastes fresh. I still drive an hour just to get pastries from here on holidays. read more

Best chocolate mousse cake...light and airy. I highly recommend this bakery for lovers of mousse and well textured creme.

This place has the best canoli's, stuffed lobster tails, and great cookies. But let the truth be told there is no reason people should stand on line because they don't have enough help. Two people working the counter at 7am on Christmas Eve when you know there is going to be a line out the door with loyal yearly customers is nuts. The stress that I was put under while telling the staff what I wanted to order was unfair. I have also tried on several occasions to place orders and I have been told they don't take orders. Well, while waiting on line yesterday and talking to various customers I was told they do they orders if you are a steady customer. It looks like Michael's Bakery for me next holiday. Where the customers come first, and the staff is pleasant. read more

My favorite bakery in the world. It's a tiny little place that serves up the best cookies and cakes in Brooklyn. This makes me wish I still lived in Old Mill Basin. They make the best rainbow cookies (I can't eat them anyplace else-literally for my communion my mom purchased an entire sheet of them and had them write my name on it.) It might not seem like much from the outside, but this place is a gem. read more

A staple in my family since childhood. Bar none, the best cookies you'll ever have (the rainbow cookies are the stuff of legend). Their cheesecake is also incredible - it's more "cakey" than a standard cheesecake, but that's my preference and it's outstanding. Soft and fluffy goodness that will keep you coming back for more. No holiday is complete without a pound of mixed, and a cheesecake. :) read more

This used to be the best bakery in area. Have been going here for over 40 years. Seems like every time we buy cookies or cakes lately they are stale. This has happened 4 times in the last 2 -3 m ok months. Time to find another baker. Sad! read more

The apple turnovers are delicious here as well as everything else. Great selection of cookies and friendly girl at desk. We got a selection of cookies, turnovers, cannolis, Napoleon, and chocolate mouse cake. This is a nice old fashioned bakery. read more