Could be one of the best burgers in all of Westchester! This hidden gem in the heart of Rye is a must! The staff is very friendly and attentive. The chef is amazing and everything that comes out of that kitchen just tastes great! After you have your meal, the homemade desserts are to die for!! I can't wait to go back! read more

The most amazing freshly baked crumb cake ever! Also, the home fries are to die for. The zombie latte made my morning and the owner makes a happy face latte for springtime. Food is fresh, owners and staff are extremely friendly. We had the Eggs in Purgatory and crab and goat cheese omelette-delicious. We'll be back for the pancakes and parmesan and chive omelette! Awesome little getaway breakfast place for me and my boyfriend. read more

Small place, very friendly service, and great food. What more can you you ask for? We went for breakfast. The Eggs in Purgatory and the crab & goat cheese omelet were delicious. Freshly baked crumb cake was so good we had to order an extra one to take home. The delkcious organic and freshly made food far out weighs the small menu selections and cash only draw back. We definitely will go back to try their lunch menu. read more

It was good, the place is cute, menu somewhat limited but quality of food was decent and service was good. I did expect more from this cute brunch spot but I will return to give it another go. read more

I just got back from On The Way Cafe and I have to say the decor looks much better than it did before. If that wasn't enough the food was excellent. I had the Philly Cheese steak and fries and a friend had the braised ribs, both were excellent. I will most definitely be recommending this place to friends and will return soon. The new owners were on site and very friendly. Great place for a bite! read more

This place is overrated , food is nothing but average .People in charge especially the lady greeting people in the front of house, has no costumer service skills at all . She doesnt even acknowledge returning customers, and when the place is a little busy she keeps telling people that wait is long when the place is EMPTY !!! Lets not forget (cash only!!) and written on the menu for integrity of the food , no substitution , no changes . People at this place are simply rude .Not coming back read more

We stopped by for late breakfast on the way to the beach, which is across the street. Pancakes are scrumptious, eggs w/sausage and the best hash browns in town. The owners stopped by the table and all is definitely well here! read more

Friendly staff and good coffee. A fairly unoriginal menu that was exactly what we were looking for: standard breakfast fare. One of the (presumably owners) was almost too friendly for our NYC tastes and said at our table talking just a hair too long - it was hard to enjoy the breakfast and coffee while keeping up extended smalltalk. But she was very nice and friendly so our NYC bubble probably needed to be burst a bit. read more

All I have to say is WOW!. This place is a bit pricey but I was satisfied with the food. I had pancakes with eggs home fries and toast white bread with and a toast bagel with butter and 1 egg. The eggs taste like eggs which is a plus, the blueberry muffin was awesomeness. My wife really like the homes fries cause it has flavor and didn't taste like boiled potatoes and salt. I was happy with stumbling into this place by accident. read more

Our son and his family live in Rye, so our visits from Baltimore always include a meal at On The Way. I have enjoyed talking to Grace and George over the years, and they always make us feel so welcomed! The food is great, and I was so impressed recently when I asked if they could prepare a completely salt-free meal for my husband who now has to follow a special diet. He was able to enjoy himself with our family. Kudos to Grace and George for a lovely, welcoming restaurant which is a gem for Rye! read more

Disappointed - came for a late lunch. Were no longer making half the menu...no paninis, no wraps and no substitutions on the few things they WERE serving. Food we got was ok, but nothing special... read more

I was visiting family nearby and was researching new lunch spots to try. I stumbled upon this place and was intrigued by the high brunch praises. I came in on a sunny Friday afternoon for lunch with my mom and brother. The restaurant is very unassuming from the outside but once you come in, you're transported to a cozy cafe. I ordered the grilled chicken wrap with roasted veggies. My mom ordered the salad and my brother got the pastrami sandwich. My wrap was amazing! The wrap is homemade and is soft and warm. The grilled veggies and chicken were cooked perfectly. I finished my whole plate, which is a rare feat for me to pull off. I sampled my mom and brothers lunches and they were also delicious. For dessert we ordered the Nutella and carrot cake to share. They were both delicious. If I had to pick, I preferred the Nutella cake, I never had anything like it. It was light, fluffy, and had great flavors. The staff was extremely kind and attentive. It was a great overall experience. I'd definitely go back next time I'm in the area! read more

Charming cafe, I came here with a friend for breakfast and we are glade we stopped in. I had the Organic Egg White Frittata with mushrooms, onions & tomato with a side of toast without home-fries because that was not even offered on the menu. We shared two Plain Short Stack Pancakes covered in a powered sugar with homemade whipped cream on the side that was just delicious. The portions are not large and that is just fine who can eat so much food early in the morning. The place has plenty of tables inside including counter seating. The prices are reasonable but they only take ca$h. The parking lot is not large so parking is tight, and I do not know if they have off street parking so you should call them and ask. On weekends this place is a madhouse so it is best to come during the weekend. read more

If you want breakfast they stop serving it early even though they are only open until 2:30. Overpriced and overcooked. Our chicken paninis were dry and dull and ridiculously priced. $15.00 for a panini and a couple French fries! Will not be returning. read more

Food is good, not amazing but prices are very high. Took my wife here for Mother's Day. There was a limited menu with very high prices (15 dollar range for simple eggs). We didn't think the food was anything special. Caveat is that perhaps they limit the menu and food quality suffers with the flow on Mother's Day. Even so, they did not give us reason to come back. read more

I just had brunch at On The Way and it was wonderful. I had a Truffle Goat Cheese Omelet with the best rye toast I've had in a long time. The coffee was special too. The staff was helpful and extremely pleasant. The upgrade to the physical setting was welcome. I could see bringing my family here in the future as well. Bravo for bringing back an old favorite with a new twist. Dale read more

I'm not sure I'd return to this establishment. I guess I had high hopes this would be our next Saturday morning go-to for breakfast but we left feeling let down. I had a bacon and cheddar omelet, that came with home fries and toast. The bacon was diced so small that I barely tasted it, the home fries were bland and the toast was your standard wheat...good coffee though! I am sure many folks appreciate fresh whipped cream with their pancakes and french toast, but prefer good old fashioned maple syrup, and there is a $1 additional charge ($3 for organic syrup). I was surprised to see "Cash Only" on the menu. I always use my charge card so thankfully I had enough to cover breakfast in my wallet. I was also disappointed because we were shown this fresh baked muffin that looked delicious and we certainly would have gotten a couple, but I was afraid I only had enough cash to cover our breakfast. (I was told there's an ATM, but I don't have a debit card.) The staff was very pleasant and attentive, and that's where I'm torn. I really wanted to love this little local spot, but I was really turned off by the syrup charge and cash only policy. read more

Great food! Ran out of a few key things but overall wonderful lunch. Grilled chicken and BLT wraps were fresh and tasty

I'm all about small family-owned businesses, and I had heard this place was good so I wanted to try it. Unfortunately I was really disappointed. I hope the owner reads some of their reviews so that they can improve... The woman who came to our table was very nice, and told us a little about the menu. However, she also told us there was only enough dough for 1 wrap. She said she'd come by in a few minutes to tell us more about the menu, since my mom had not arrived yet, but she never came back. A waiter came to take our order; we asked for the last wrap, but it was already taken. That was 12:15. (I just don't understand how when the most interesting of your sandwiches are in wraps -- and they said for the ones I wanted that they would ONLY do it on the wrap) -- on the lunch menu, how you can only have enough for 1 wrap that early.) It's a very small menu so that left little else to order unless you wanted a burger. I got a salad which was okay, but not much too it. I knew this place was overpriced because I looked at the menu online in advance, but the quality was mediocre. My salad was not bad, but it was nothing special. My mother ordered an open-faced grilled cheese; the cheese was not totally melted. My husband ordered a turkey club. Again, just average, and there was hardly any turkey on it. For $12, it should at least be a hearty sandwich. A deli would have been better and less expensive. read more

I have been coming here since I was a kid and have watched it change owners one too many times now. Used to be a favorite Sunday breakfast spot, not anymore. Food is decent but not for the price or the wait. overhyped at this point. When I was younger the charm was that the menu items were named after Playland rides and it was yummy and cheap. Now it is a upscale breakfast spot but the food doesn't match the price at all. read more

This is one of my favorite places! I'm reading some of the reviews below, and I'm shocked. I have nothing but great things to say about this place. The staff is always so kind and welcoming, food is amazing. Sure, you're paying a little more than the Mamaroneck diner, but you're getting fresh food! You can totally taste the difference!! I would highly recommend On the Way Cafe. read more

Horrible, horrible customer service..... I asked the waitress for a grilled chicken wrap. Apparently, they were out of wraps. So I asked if they could put it on any other type of bread. The chef absolutely refused. I asked why.. I was told that it needed to be on a wrap. I said. Can I order a price of grilled chicken and seperately order some bread? No. That was it. NO CUSTOMER SERVICE!!!!!! I will never come here again. pS. I just got an email from the owner calling me "pathetic" for posting a complaint. She noted that I am a baby and bitch and moan and that should she get me a bottle. I think this proves my point about how poorly they treat their customers and about avoiding this place. Great customer win back strategy!!!! read more

Great atmosphere. The staff are sooo nice. And please when you go, don't leave without trying the crumb cakes they make themselves (especially chocolate caramel one) . You wont regret it!!! Great place definitely going back. read more

Love On the Way Cafe! We eat here for breakfast every time we're in the area. The food is really delicious and the service is friendly and prompt. Make a reservation as the place is small and apparently very popular. If we lived locally we would be regulars. read more

It takes a lot for me to write a bad review. I am a positive person and only write reviews when I feel the necessity to. But I really felt I needed to write this review. If I could leave 0 stars I would. The staff was incredibly rude and had no customer service skills. After trying to park in their very uncomfortable and way too crowded parking lot for a good 10 minutes, we finally got inside. We waited patiently for another 10-15 minutes without any acknowledgement that we were even there. Finally we were told, very rudely, that it would be a 20 minute wait for just 2 people and told in a way that made us feel like we were being pushed out and not wanted there. Meanwhile, there were MANY open tables and 2 open seats at the bar. Only a few of those tables said reserved on them and the bar seats were clearly open. Instead of saying good morning or any greeting, they were rude and nasty with an attitude when saying how long the wait would be. They didnt want us there and we certainly didn't want to be there. So we left after that happy to not give them our service. I would stay away from this place and instead head to Poppy's in the town of Rye. Great food and service there and they actually appreciate the customer instead of being happy to drive them away. read more

Never judge a book by its cover. When coming in from outside I had my second opinion. That all change when I sat down. They provide the service we need for having a newborn with us. I love that they have draft soda. They also have glass bottle soda. The host was outstanding describe the food. Where it came from and how they cook it. The coffee is on point. I recommend the philly cheese steak. So good and Cholula hot sauce to go with it. Most definitely coming back to try their breakfast. read more

From the outside you would not guess but this place has amazing fresh food. Reasonable prices and wonderful service. Homemade from scratch pancakes and baked goods and organic eggs ...full bar. Just remember cash only but no worries ATM on site incase u need a little extra. read more

On the Way Cafe has by far, the BEST salads and wraps in the area. My favorite is the caramelized onion and Gorgonzola salad with sauteed pears. It is absolutely delish! The cookies are equally as enticing. Although small, this charming little cafe is a terrific for lunch with the girls or Sunday brunch with the kiddies. read more

My husband and I had a nice lunch there. Our experience was that the staff were friendly and attentive. Their gruyere grilled cheese sandwich is fantastic and their fries were even seasoned to perfection. Glad we live nearby. Please note the date of the bad review below is from January of 2007. read more

Friendly staff, good service, great homemade fresh foods with many locally sourced ingredients. Love the organic local eggs and the homemade baked goods! I've only been on Sunday for breakfast but looking forward to stopping back in for lunch sometime. Best breakfast I've had in the Rye area hands down. read more

Best blueberry pancakes I have ever had. Doesn't look like much from the outside, but once you open the door you are greeted by a warm, cozy atmosphere. Staff is super friendly and prices are fair. Trust me, you won't regret eating here! Already thinking about going back for more pancakes! read more

so friendly, so good and so local. a perfect breakfast or lunch spot (warning it can get crowded but that just shows how good the food is). I came here with family friends last year and it was great, but a little crowded. then I went back on the morning of my high school graduation (to escape the madness that is my mother) with my two aunts. the place was basically empty and the food was great, we even order a crumb cake and took one to go(we normally are not dessert people but this was the best crumb cake I have ever had) I went back with my sister a week later on a weekday around 10, there was only one other table at this time. the owner was so nice, she stopped and talked with us for a good 5 minutes and even remembered my aunts and I stopping by on my graduation. once again we ordered the crumb cake and I am happy to report it did not disappoint. read more

Was there this morning with my wife and 3 kids. Got there before my wife and kids and immediately was told I had to wait till everyone showed even though they were 5 mins away and place was empty!! OK no biggy. Sat down Looking at menu an Omelette with peppers and cheddar 14 bux.. Comeone it's 3 eggs.. I know it's Rye but ripoff central.. My wife ordered the Sunnyside egg with ham on the Tuscan toast.. So she says can I have the eggs over medium.. He goes nope can't do it.. That was it for me.. I got the omlette with enough homefries for a 4yr old.. My son got scrambled eggs with bacon.. My daughter's shared a small stack of pancakes.. 2 coffees and 3 kids milks 70 bux Last time for me.. PS I ask for butter for our toast, one tiny square in a plate.. Cash only establishment Go to nautilus diner eat like a king! read more

Fantastic little find. Took the kids and my wife here for Mother's Day brunch and it was a little gem - great food, quick service, and really reasonably priced. Would definitely recommend. read more

What a wonderful place! Out of the way, may take a little effort to find, but worth the drive and time to enjoy. There were two of us, and we were greeted warmly. We arrived, seated promptly, and served attentively. Both of us enjoyed eggs brought from a local farm, perfectly portioned smoked bacon, and a short stack of blueberry pancakes that tasted like my grandfather used to make for me when I was very young. Good conversation from the proprietor, and a wonderful quiet atmosphere. We'll be back for sure! I travel for a living, and this will definitely be a place worth seeking out again and again. Highly recommended for local flavor and color. read more

Great place and great location!!! The food choices are excellent and amazing. Healthy choices are in the menu as well. I don't even call this cafe it is like a fancy restaurant because of how great the waiters are and how they are always asking if the customers need any thing. This is why I put this as a 5 star restaurant!!! read more

On the Way Cafe provides good clean food. They have a great breakfast and lunch selection. The owners are very attentive and friendly to their customers of all ages. This is that place where to can spend some good quality time with your family or friend(s). And Playland is walking distance from the cafe. They also take reservation for special Holidays such as Mother's Day and Father's Day. ;) read more

Great breakfast spot! The menu is focused on eggs and pancakes but everything is delicious!! The staff i are all very friendly and take care of their customers. You. Can make your own omelettes, the hash browns are fresh and tasty and pancakes are delicious. I highly recommend On The Way and plan on going back soon! read more

Stopped here for breakfast on my way from NYC to CT and I hope I can stop again! Very friendly greeting. I sat at the counter to a lovely placemat and white cloth napkin. Very nice touch. I had the pancakes with bananas and walnuts. It was served with a side of fresh whipped cream. Absolutely delicious. I also bought a crumb cake to go. Hands down best crumb cake I have ever had. I'm hoping I make this trip again soon so I can stop here. I highly recommend it! read more

Great place, nice staff. Perfect breakfast (scrambled eggs and eggs in purgatory), they serve excellent italian latte. 4 stars because of the chocolate chip scone that was too dry and very simple. Apple crumble cake would have been a better choice but next time we gonna try it. They were nice to my 2years old son too. We liked the place! read more