Love this place..would be 5 if they delivered! They have the most amazing bagel flavors! read more

very tasty, certainly because of the abundance of sauce and cheese. Kind of a chaotic morning rush but the workers keep it moving and have a good vibe. read more

Best breakfast sandwich I've ever had. Amazing service everyone is very nice. Open kitchen gives a nice ambiance. read more

Olmo - BEC - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Even on a Sunday Morning . The shop was very busy , but ordering on line made pick up quick . The best bagels in New Haven ! Great sandwich choices and staff are polite and friendly. read more

The Everything Everything Bagel with Spinach Artichoke Schmear was the perfect snack to munch on as I walked around town on this cold rainy day. It was warm and toasted, with great flavors and complementary textures. I easily ordered it inside at a self-order kiosk, and service was quick, with helpful and kind people behind the counter. I'd love to return! read more

Olmo - Menu 4/3 - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Food was good. I ordered a pastrami breakfast sandwich on a union salted Bagel. I can't speak for their customers service since I order to take out. I have order at least 3 times and different things and I'm not disappointed. read more

Pastrami bagel slay. Eggs bacon bagel slay. So simple. World take note. Come here. Set the bar high. Service with a smile. That's chill. Would drive out of my way to eat here 10/10. Would send my daughter to Yale to make this somewhere I could eat daily. read more

great food and amazing service! A little crowded but always quick and tasty! Staff even know me by name which is a wonderful touch :) read more

I probably just don't like bagels that much. This could have been the best bagel ever and it probably only scores so high. The thing in question here primarily is the relatively expensive prices and the relatively long wait for each sandwich. The staff was constantly reminding people to order from the kiosk which means they aren't obvious or the workflow is tricky. Additionally it took a minimum of 10 minutes for each sandwich after it was ordered which created a logjam of people waiting in a small space. Overall would recommend somewhere else read more

Olmo is one of the premier bagel spots in East rock. this place is always packed and sometimes can take a little bit to get some bagels. The bagels are on the chewer side if that is how you like the textures of your bagel. I have had many bagels from here of all their flavors. The chili cheese bagel is pretty good. All of their cream cheeses are amazing as well. The staff here are amazing and very friendly. If you are able to get a sandwich there, the sausage, egg and cheese is a food porn for the masses. Seriously look at that photo of that cheese pull. I definitely recommend the spot and will definitely be coming back. read more

Olmo - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Best bagel I have ever had. The variety of options is perfect. The crunch to the bagel was immaculate. The online ordering was smooth. The service was quick and the vibes were unmatched. There is no reason to not love these bagels. I will be dreaming of them forever. read more

See all

Was in the area unexpectedly and needed lunch. Checked out this place and was not disappointed. The staff was extremely nice and I even got an extra treat for being a first time customer. read more

Olmo - bacon, egg and cheese on and everything everything bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

My go to bagel spot! Bagels are always fresh and never disappoints. The staff are very nice and super helpful. Definitely would recommend read more

Olmo - Everything Everything Bagel with spicy scallion schmear - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

First off... I was not expecting how good their ham egg and cheese was. I always pass by it when I'm making stops into Yale. And finally I said "why not"... I'm usually picky with my bagels and how they are made cause I'm from Jersey "lmao ny/nj bagels babaaaaay!!" Welp this place changed my mind in less than a second. Ordered a casual ham egg and cheese on a plain bagel and with a slice of tomato....service was fast and the workers weee polite. You can order from the counter or from their machines and just wait to be called. The pics don't do justice. I wish you can taste it through the pics lol. read more

See all

Sitting in the parking lot next to Olmo devouring these delish breakfast bagels and had to write the review. Some of the best bagels we've had. Service is quick and nice. You order off of a iPad and is very ease of access to order. The crisp outside and cheesy goodness with a bag of chips on the side. How can you beat that? You can't... read more

Olmo - Turkey Bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Phenomenal bagel shop! I have always been skeptical of cream cheese (or as they call it schmear) on an egg sandwich but this place will make you fall in love. The spicy scallion adds the perfect amount of heat to the melty sandwich. Despite there usually being a line, the service is quick and everyone serves you with a smile. There is sitting outside when it's warm out but this is definitely more of a grab and go place during the winter. read more

Olmo - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

If you want to eat a bagel in New Haven, this is the place to try. Bagel was phenomenal and lox with cream cheese was chefs kiss. They have lots of bagel options and same goes for the shmear. They don't have seating inside but there are cute tables outside. They also have a good variety of teas that were pretty good. Service was really good and efficient. Will definitely come back here. read more

Olmo - Lox with Love - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Best bagels in Connecticut! Excellent service. Long line with a quick turnover. They also visit Coventry farmers market every summer.

Delicious bagels, egg sandwiches and brunch boards. I've ordered multiple times including catering - awesome.

Had an amazing breakfast here a few days ago! Woke up on Sunday morning craving a breakfast sandwich. I browsed Yelp and found Olmo, and remembered I had been here about a year ago and the meal was good. I decided to order ahead as it was a Sunday and I figured it would be busy. I ordered a bacon, egg and cheese on a cacio e pepe bagel with scallion cream cheese. My boyfriend had a bacon, egg and cheese on a plain bagel with bacon jam. Both sandwiches were absolutely delicious! read more

Olmo - Bacon, egg and cheese on a cacio e pepe bagel with scallion cream cheese - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

19 Oct. 2024 I posted previously saying how great this place is. Reliably excellent bagels and really efficient and friendly staff. That said, the last two batches of bagels we have gotten have been a tad uneven and not quite up to the normal excellent quality. In one instance they were overly dry. In the other, see photos, one of the Everything bagels is burnt to the degree that the spices have turned bitter. It is really not a big deal, but at these prices you want to be able to consume all the bagels you have purchased. It just takes sorting and maybe throwing out the ones that are overcooked or putting them in a half-price bin. read more

Olmo - Everything Olmo Bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

Olmo is the best bagelry in Connecticut, I'm pretty sure. The delicious options and combinations are endless. Try "The Gregory" which is an everything bagel with egg, cheese, bacon, and bacon jam. (Note that all these options are real but sadly The Gregory not an official menu name...yet. I will patiently wait.) We like to get a bakers dozen and schmear from Olmo on Whitney or on Saturdays at the Wooster Square farm market. Or one of those delicious sandwiches like The Brick or The Gregory. My son enjoyed his bagel so much this morning that it made him lose a tooth. His sandwich cost him $5 but the tooth fairy will bring him $5 which is like a free bagels forever loophole. read more

The bagels are Good. They make them fresh, probably one of the better bagels you will find in the New Haven area, but why do I have to use a self service Kiosk to order a bagel with cream cheese and a coffee? You wait in a line to go up and order on a screen that took me way longer to figure out than just telling the staff that I want a bagel with cream cheese and a coffee. Not the vibe for a blue collar worker looking to grab breakfast on the way to work. Nice place, clean, friendly staff, would go back on a weekend and eat a bagel in the park. But it's just too much of a process and a hassle to get a simple breakfast. read more

ALWAYS a good experience when visiting this hidden gem! The bagels are the best and the employees are very welcoming. Highly recommend a visit. Oh yes, and the coffee is good! read more

We placed a catering order for delivery the next morning (late). Anthony answered all our questions, helped make recommendations and decisions. Our hungry athletes devoured the assorted sandwiches. I particularly enjoyed the BLT . Oh and delivery was prompt as requested! read more

What a great find for us! The bagels and coffee were outstanding. We'll definitely make this a regular stop during our trips to New Haven.

Food: 5/5 ‍ Drinks: 4/5 Services: 5/5 Atmosphere: 5/5 Pricing: reasonable Overall: 4.5/5 One of the best bagels in town. I got the Lox in love and a small vanilla ice coffee. Their spicy scallions cream cheese perfectly blend well with the rest of the toppings. I would recommend getting light spread because the cream cheese can overcome everything else. The coffee was okay in my opinion and it was legitimately small. The place is small and packed with customers for the majority of the time so I'd recommend coming early. Overall 10/10 would recommend read more

Olmo - Lox with Love - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Look I think it's important to admit when you're wrong. I was wrong about Olmo. Their bagels are not classic New York bagels, and I stand by that assessment. But for what they are, they're really extremely good. I think Olmo bagels really shine when it comes to sandwiches. They've got the perfect exterior crunch and interior chew to really stand up to other ingredients without being too much to handle. I also REALLY enjoy the bacon jam. All told, I regret my earlier harsh take. Olmo is a great addition to the area, and I find myself craving it pretty frequently. read more

Great customer service the staff willingly walked me through the ordering process. Delish food with unique flavors.

Olmo is a New Haven treasure - incredible offerings and a consistent aim to innovate. The menu has something for everyone yet it is hard to veer off from long-standing favorites. The shop is welcoming and the owner and employees are warm and clearly committed to their mission. Their camaraderie is inspiring! read more

Nice, cute little area. Friendly people. Bagels areeeee soooooo delicioussss! Outdoor seating/takeout. read more

Olmo - BEHIND THE SCENES!!!! - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

See all

1000/10 - best customer service I've ever seen in my life This is by far the craziest thing that's ever happened to me at a bagel place and how gracious, helpful, and awesome everyone that worked there just speaks volumes about Olmo. I was there today and my airpod case dropped, launching the right airpod. For an hour I searched on the ground with full cooperation and help from the staff but because it was busy I said I'd come back at closing. Using FaceTime and flashlight, we discovered it had literally bounced below the cabinet under a barrier. With the whole teams full help, we managed to scoop them with tongs and miraculously get my AirPod back. I have never witnessed a staff so helpful and more than that - enthusiastic to help. They were so kind, didn't make me feel stupid for dropping it or act unbothered or too busy to help. Everyone immediately sprang into action and even turned off the music so we could find it. From the manager to all the employees, the ethos and general vibe of this place is the best I've ever come across. I don't live in New Haven but I come here once a year and once a year I will 100% be making an annual trip to Olmo in honor of this. Thank you so much Craig, Tori, Jay, Luca and everyone else that helped - this really means a lot to me, and honestly is such a good sign that there are still kind hearted people in the world. read more

Great bagels. Friendly service. It was very crowded on Sunday around noon. It took a while to receive my order, but it was worth the wait.

The food here is amazinggg!!! I've been here 4 times within the past two weeks and they haven't disappointed. The spicy deluxe sandwich is so good!! Definitely will recommend for a quick breakfast stop.The service is great and food is done in a timely manner. read more

Really good bagel, great texture the spicy scallion cream cheese was my favorite wanted to try a different bagel but they ran out so get there early read more

Olmo - Everything Olmo Bagel - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Heard many remarkable things about this place, so I decided to skip my spartan breakfast (literally plain greek yogurt and multigrain bread lol) and treat myself instead. -BLT Everything Everything Bagel Sandwich: 5/5 I opted for no mayo and less bacon for health™ reasons, but wow everything was so tasty! The toasted bagel was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The ingredients tasted sooo fresh. -Slice of Cinnamon and Butter Babka: 5/5 This melted in my mouth; it has the softness and sweetness of a cinnamon roll!! I was tempted to get a whole loaf since one slice is $4, but I don't know anyone I'd share it with. Maybe one day I'll come back with people to share an entire loaf with because the goodness is too good to not be enjoyed with company! Staff was super nice and friendly with customers. I can see why people love this place and keep coming back for more. read more

Olmo - -Olmo BLT Everything Everything Bagel Sandwich (no mayo, less bacon) -Slice of Cinnamon and Butter Babka - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut

Love Olmo. Very good vibe- busy, but very friendly & efficient, I love their BLT & Breakfast special (bacon, egg, cheese, avocado & spicy aioli). I especially used to ADORE their toasted banana bread. Even my mom said it was better than hers! HOWEVER, I think they've changed their banana bread recipe. It is no longer full of that flavorful deep banana moist goodness. It's still sweet & still has that toasted brown butter crust on the outside, but the inside is the color & texture of a fluffy slice of potato bread. Please go back to the old recipe! It was delicious and decadent. This latest version is just not quite hitting the mark. read more

The best bagels. The workers are so friendly, and are happy to customize your bagel the way you like. I find myself craving this spot all the time. Their bagels are the perfect size. I personally like the everything everything bagel, which has gochugaru. They are seeded the night before baking, so the seeds don't fall off. As you can see from the picture, it's generously seeded, top and bottom. Pair it with some scallion cream cheese, and it's a perfect day. read more

See all

This place is just awesome. We use the simple Local/Toast app to order which texts the time for pickup. The pickup is seamless and always on time. The BAGELS are just top tier fresh and flavorful. The people / staff are so pleasant. The egg sandwiches are fresh made. An OLMO BEC is a must have. Overall, consistently great and friendly. read more

Perfect service, delicious bagels and tea! Everything is fresh and great combined, not too salty, just as necessary. I had sesame seeds bagel with lox, tomatoes and scallions shmear read more

Olmo - Sesame seeds bagel Lox with Love - Sandwiches Near Me - New Haven, Connecticut