I've left reviews for Olde Town Pizza House, but it's been a while since I've been there. I met a friend last evening and had the best service and pizza! This time we each ordered the deep dish with pepperoni and extra sauce. It was cooked perfect! It was delish! I seriously can't wait for the left over tonight! You just can't go wrong with locally owned pizza shop! Thank you Olde Town and crew! read more

I was hungry for deep dish, so I drove here. Dark cozy wood, family friendly atmosphere. Had a nice pizza. Honestly it wasn't perfect; it was a little overcooked on the bottom, but it's the best deep dish nearby that I know and I'm sure I will go back to try more items on the menu. read more

Olde Town Pizza House - The outside of Olde Town is a neat mural - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

See all

Hands down the best pepperoni calzone pizza! Lets not even get into the chicken paprikash soup! Served every Wednesday! As always amazing service! read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

See all

I had heard great things about this restaurant, but sadly our visit fell flat. Our table ordered a few pizzas, salads, and kids meals. It took almost an hour for our food to come out and when kindly asking our server for an update she was not so kind. The food was okay, nothing to get excited about and nothing that would take as long as it did. I get everyone has their off nights, but sadly the pizza was not worth the experience there read more

The grilled chicken salad is divine. There is grilled pineapple on it. That is a bonus for me. Also, a fresh baked bread stick is included. The pizza is delicious. I recommend Old Town to everyone. I live in Elyia but will travel to Old Town in Amherst. That's about a 15-20 minute drive. read more

The pizza is absolutely amazing. The crust is soft yet crunchy, and the cheese was so gooey. The pizza also saves well for leftovers and heats up great. The service was good for a lunch rush, and the prices were average. The location is cute in downtown Amherst and the inside is so fun with how it's decorated. read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Large sausage and small pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Service fantastic waitress so kind and patient. Ambiance: it is all new inside since we were there years ago. So cozy and comfortable. Food: my father in law had the penne pasta with Alfredo and broccoli. Excellent My husband had a calzone with pepperoni, sausage, green peppers. Excellent. I had a pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, sausage. Excellent but not a fan of the sausage. Salads: so fresh and good. This was the best blue cheese dressing I ever had. Highly recommend this place!!!! Thanks to all staff!!! read more

Delicious Pizza with a small town feel! First things first, the service here is amazing. Any server who walked by checked on us. The owner came out and was chatting with us and with every other table--in a genuine caring way, not the corporate "well how is everything folks" way haha. He even boxed up our leftovers at our table. The pizza we had was amazing! We get the heart shaped pizza every year for our family Valentines celebration and it never disappoints. Generous cheese and the the crust is high on the edges because of the hand made steel form they use to make the shape. The owner mentioned they have the heart shaped pizza all year which is good to know for special occasions! We also enjoyed the family salad and house dressing. We will be back soon! read more

Had some family in from Minnesota this week and decided Olde Town Pizza fit the bill to feed the group. Ordered a sheet pizza and the big salad and we were not disappointed. The pizza was great and the salad could not have been fresher. Everyone was so complimentary. The salad was so big, we had enough for dinner the next meal. Just a reminder why we continue to patronize them. Soooooo good! read more

Pepperoni and Sausage pizza was yummy. Crust was golden crispy on the bottom just the way we like it, sauce was tasty, plenty of cheese and toppings. Staff was friendly and atmosphere was calm, relaxing, and we had a great time. Blueberry sangria was also great read more

I absolutely love this restaurant. The servers are so pleasant and are willing to make your experience a good one. I see a lot of regulars when I done there. They enjoy a wide variety of dishes, with pizza being the signature dish. Darrell runs a fine establishment that really is a jewel in this community. read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

I got the Large BLT fold over with extra bacon. I would recommend this to anyone who wants something different & don't know what to get. I love this BLT I'm addicted. read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Large DLT fold over with extra bacon so yummy - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

This is one of the very BEST family owned business. The food is always SO FRESH and TASTY!! I have no clue why the salad taste fresher, crisper than any other restaurant that I have ever been to. I can visit and just have the salad bar and it's so good I feel like I'm cheating. The one thing I can say that I did miss the ham pieces they used to have as part of the salad bar. They call their sandwiches "sangwich" on purpose. It's because it's special not just a bread, I haven't had it in awhile so ask them. They are known for their great pizza and "Woogie Bear". It's lIke a calzone done a'la Olde Town McCarty way! I've been visiting this place for over 21 years. We take suppliers from out of town. They always say "I want to go to that quaint pizza shop for a "Woogie Bear"! Oh and you can stuff them with different ingredients. My husband had a meatball mozzarella stuffed one. He loved it! Even more special are that the owners, their children and employees are all so professional, humble and truly care about their customers. Today Daryl (owner) came right up to me to say hello and walk over to my husband to say hi. The wife (owner) is so kind and both are very dedicated hard workers. They went through construction years ago to make their space bigger and more comfortable. The decorations and color scheme are very nice. I think they're close to 30 years of business or more. The building outside is very cute. They had life size cutouts of McCarty husband and wife sitting on the roof. I didn't look to see if it's still there. They're across the street from Huntington Bank on the main road. Good luck McCarty and Family always!! read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Fresh yummy . - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Great pizza My husbands family had a tradition of ordering from here since his aunt was a big fan. I will say the pizza is good but we usually get carry out. Only ate in the restaurant once and don't remember much about it. read more

Pizza is fabulous! Always good service. Decor is fresh and appropriate. Menu offers something for everyone.

Best Calzone around, I've been coming here for almost 30 years and it's been made the same way the entire time. The thin crust family pizza is amazing too! The staff is always friendly! read more

Great pizza! Love the mini deluxe pizza. That and a salad is a great meal for 2. We always do carry out and it's always hot. read more

Wonderful pizza. I also get the calzones and woogie bears. Their salads are also top notch.

It's been awhile since I've eaten here. Use to work in Amherst. I am pleased to say the food is as good as I remember. The pizza, calzone, and woogie dough is the best around. All the food ordered at my table was delicious. The grilled chicken salad was huge. The fettuccine was awesome. Thanks Olde Town for still being as good as I remembered. read more

Not sure about all the good reviews, my guess is old timers or locals who don't have experience with much else or are being supportive of their neighborhood pizza place. The beard bro on the floor was rude, and great at ignoring paying customers needs. The pizza here was the smallest "large" pizza I've seen in my life. It was a pile of cheese on top of flavorless sauce and meh crust. Definitely not good pizza. It's a bad sign when you try to pick up a slice and all the cheese falls off, anchored into the giant glob in the middle, not melted into the crust. Cheese was barely melted fully, not much color. Waste of $. read more

For the area, it's decent pizza, but having lived on both coasts including Chicago, I'm probably a pizza snob. Having said that, this place is still decent. read more

This is our favorite place to get pizza. We go here almost every Friday night. It is family owned and when you're here you are treated like family! The pizza is amazing...chewy crust and fresh toppings. The Woogies are to die for. They also have a very tasty gluten free pizza. Great beer selection with rotating drafts. read more

A small but great place in the heart of Amherst. I ordered the salad and soup bar. With a order of garlic bread with cheese. The ingredients in the salad bar were fresh and tasty. The soup of the day was: Buffalo Chicken soup. I absolutely enjoyed every bite of my meal. The cheese bread was just perfect cheese goodness. I will keep coming back. read more

Olde Town Pizza House - a plate of food - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

On our quest for the best eat in pizza shops in Ohio, we found Old Town Pizza House in Amherst to be very very good. Our waiter was Max and he did a fantastic job of going over the menu with us and pointed out some of the more popular items. We had a salad where you get to choose your toppings which is great as this minimizes food waste. The salad was great. We ordered traditional crust large pepperoni and an italian sausage woogie bear. The pizza was cooked well done as requested and had a good crunch and chew. The pepperoni was fresh and the sauce had a hint of sweet and spicy. The sauce sat well with both of us - no heartburn.. The pizza serving pans were dimpled which is critical in keeping crust from getting soggy. The woogie bear was fantastic. Chris loved the italian sausage and felt it stole the show. The marinara dipping sauce was excellent. Max was our main contact and he was fantastic, but the hostess, and other staff wirk together as a team to make the experience and service top notch. We will be back soon to sample the thin crust and foldovers. If you havent tried it yet, go try it yourself. They have made our top 5 shops for perfect execution and great food. Chris & Trudy approved! read more

Being relatively new to the area, my wife and I have been seeking input from locals regarding restaurant recommendations for various ropes of food. We both love pizza, so we are eager to find a go-to pizza place. A few people had recommended Olde Town for their pizza and we finally had an opportunity to give it a try. The parking is limited, but there is a lot across the street. The restaurant is pretty small and loud. Table are sandwiched in and the booths are extremely cramped. Service was excellent (friendly and attentive)! In addition, the manger is constantly roaming around making sure everything is good. We went with friends who recommended the salad bar, which can be ordered with a meal for about $4-5. My wife and I ordered a large thin crust pizza with sausage, green peppers and onions to share. The salad bar is small, but ample. Everything was fresh. The pizza was another story. Admittedly, we are pretty fussy about our pizza. However, I would venture to say at anyone that enjoys thin crust, NY style pizza would be disappointed. The crust is far from thin, there was little to no sauce and the entire pizza was covered with a very thick, gooey mozzarella cheese that dominated the the flavor of the pizza. To be honest, we have had frozen pizza purchased at the grocery store that was better. We were very disappointed as we were hopeful. The sandwiches we noticed delivered to other patrons looked good. If we were to return, which is doubtful, we would try that. If I were to rate the restaurant solely on our experience with the pizza, the rating would be a notch or to two lower. read more

We moved here 2 years ago, and finally got around to eating here after having friends and neighbors rave about it. For the life of me, I can't understand what all the fuss is about. My husband got the salad bar, which seemed nice and fresh and he enjoyed it. We decided to get a large, thin crust pizza with sausage, onions, and green peppers. It was hot when it arrived, but the crust didn't seem cooked enough. There was very little sauce, but loads of cheese. Lots of toppings, but the rest of the pizza wasn't any good so the toppings couldn't save it. Super disappointed in the pizza. Only good thing was service, which was excellent. read more

See all

always a staple in our family. food is beyond excellent. pizza and woogie bears are to die for! family owned business where the family is involved, and knows the customers read more

Great food the owners are awesome very friendly every time you go there I would recommend this place,

My husband and I along with our twin newborns decided to give this place a try on a Friday evening. We were so glad that we did! The servers were very attentive and friendly. The owner came over and greeted us and gave us menu recommendations since this was our first time. We had the salad bar which was so delicious and fresh, then we had the garlic bread with cheese (amazing!) and finally the Chicago style pizza. We loved our entire meal and will be back soon! read more

Olde Town Pizza House - Chicago style pizza - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Always have a good dinner or lunch! Great family salads and their homemade dressing is great!

I purposely arrive 10 minutes after the time given by the person answering the phone and still stand in the waiting area for another 10 minutes. Service is absolutely terrible and unapologetic. read more

The Best Service in town all the servers worked the restaurant like it was their own. The owners were right with their people making sure every single person was taking care of. Thank You for the Best dining out experience my wife and I have had in a long time. We know you are faced with the lack of help these days way to handle it. I would recommend this place to everyone. read more

Prices have gotten crazy at Old Town & the quality is slipping. I don't necessarily mind paying more for my pizza since prices are going up on everything, but if you're going to charge me more, at least give me the same amount I was getting last year before the increases. Now we're paying more & they're skimping on the topping :-( read more

Great Pizza place! They even have gluten free pizza, garlic bread and sandwiches. I highly recommend Old Town Pizza House.

Very. Good. Pizza. Subs great too. L lots of cheese on excellent crust! With plenty of toppings! Nice people.

I've been there about four times now, it is always so good, and everybody is very friendly. I'll be sure to go back again.

Always great pizzas and calzones. Very consistent with both. Haven't tried anything else. salads good with homemade dressings

Wow! Everything about this restaurant is 5 stars! We had heard really good things about this family restaurant from friends and liked the history of the family business on their website so we thought we'd give it a try. After just one visit, it immediately became our favorite Italian restaurant! Service was so personable and friendly. After they learned this was our first visit, despite being super busy, the owners came to our table to introduce themselves and welcome us to the restaurant. The food is delicious! Everything is made fresh, from scratch. We started with the soup of the day and breadsticks. It was so flavorful and fresh, I would go back just for those menu items again! We each ordered a mini pizza (personal size). The portion sizes are very generous and each pizza was loaded with toppings. Prices are very inexpensive, portion sizes are very generous, service is very friendly and the taste, quality and freshness of the food is having us come back for another visit. Even our finicky Thai grandmother who only wants to eat Thai food, said she was so happy we stopped here instead of getting Thai food for dinner. She even said she wants take us all out to dinner at Old Town Pizza House when she comes to visit us again. read more

Went to buy a gift card at the carry out. Waited five minutes, nobody came. Went in the dining room (no customers in there). Workers in the back, some looked off the clock, they saw me but didn't acknowledge me. They didn't tell anyone working that I was there. I left, will get a gift card elsewhere. Disappointing. read more

This place is fantastic. Their fold overs are great! Service is great! I haven't had anything there that hasn't been wonderful! I had the schobel fold over and added hot peppers and black olives to it. Fantastic! read more