It's been a while since we ordered from Jilliano's Pizzeria, and we chose them last evening. How pleasantly surprised to find the same great products. We started with Antipasto, it was fantastic, the three of us devoured it with pleasure! My wife thoroughly enjoyed her Seafood pizza that has won an award for Jilliano's. Still excellent choice if Seafood is your desire. Highly recommended! My son and I tried the Tropical Chicken BBQ for the first time. What a pleasant surprise we enjoyed. It has Grilled Chicken Breast, Pineapple, Banana Peppers, with a hint of Cinnamon. I enjoyed this minus the Banana Peppers, and my son enjoyed the Banana Peppers. To me was so good, refreshing change from the standard old pizza. It's really worthy of a try by anyone that loves these ingredients. One last word on the ingredients, it's very easy to tell making our purchase from a small independently owned pizza shop that our dinner was made with care, nobody weighing out each ingredient so as not to put too much to save a penny for corporate. Jilliano's is in business to simply give you a great product for dinner. Even though they do not deliver to my area, it's worthy of my drive for such great service, and pizza and no doubt in my mind everything else you would choose to enjoy from them. So happy to give them ***** rating! read more

I wasn't surprised by the great food, but I was surprised to see the great prices. I'm heading over right now for lunch read more

I really don't understand how this place has such a low review rating. We love their pizza and it's the best bang for your buck around here. Very good!! We have been 5 times since we moved here a year ago and have yet to be disappointed! read more

Went into Jilliano's tonight to pick up pizzas that we had ordered. I was completely shocked to see that the lady preparing the pizzas was not only not wearing gloves but also no face mask. The sign on the door stated masks must be worn to enter but she was not wearing one. The young boy working the counter was wearing a mask but he took payment at counter and then also assisted in finishing the toppings for my Taco Pizza without changing his gloves. I love to support small businesses but if this is how Jilliano's staff and owners handle cleanliness and especially during a pandemic, I will not give them my support. read more

Love the deep dish it twas like pizza tasted 25 years ago! Would def order again. They only offer one size. I have yet to try regular pizza!! read more

This is a small locally owned pizza place. The staff is always nice. The pizza is very good and has a lot of toppings. Some of the best I've had. read more

Waited two hours because the driver got lost. Told the girl on the phone when I called that i was concerned about it being hot/fresh. She said it would be fine. She lied. It was neither hot or fresh. The breading on thr mozzarella sticks was mush, the cheese was hard, the pizza was room temperature. The driver finally arrived only gave me half my order and I had to ask for the other half. They didn't charge me, but honestly, I would have rather paid for pizza that was actually hot and good. read more

Jilliano's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

Omg...finally, found my new #pizzahome! Pizza done right. From the prices, hospitality and food, Jilliano's is on the money... I think I can speak on behalf of most pizza lovers, we like toppings "to the edge". Thnx, Jilliano's! #pizzaexperts #satisfiedcustomer read more

Jilliano's Pizzeria - Yum! Toppings to the edge! #doneright - Pizza Near Me - Amherst, Ohio

My family and I have a tradition to have pizza almost every Friday. In the last few years or more, the quality of pizza has declined. We tried Jilliano's pizza for the first time last week and we loved it!!!!!!! They serve the best pizza in this area! Thank you Jilliano's for your great service and superb pizza! You have given back what we have been missing, DELICIOUS Pizza!!! Truly Thankful, The Scott's read more

My fellow Americans. Do you know how bad and disappointing a pizza place has to be for me leave a yelp review? I PLEAD with any of you who are looking for a new pizza spot in our areas to NOT come here. I am not a Karen. I love small businesses. Hopefully I don't ever experience something this bad again that I will have to write a yelp review to spread awareness. read more

I last reviewed Jilliano's 2 years ago. We haven't ordered it as much the last year or so because of the Marco's PTO nights. We ordered a few months ago and I didn't really like it but my husband still did. We ordered again last night and something seemed different, even my husband didn't like it. Usually I just stick with the cheesy bread because the pizza sauce is too sweet for me but even that tasted different. Like they started using cheaper ingredients or something. It just didn't taste very good and it's the most expensive pizza place we go to. Think we'll be moving on. 3 stars because my kids ate it and no one got sick so that's positive! Lastly, and I hate to judge a restaurants food by their staff, but every time I've ever ordered, whoever answers the phone and takes the order sounds as if I'm ruining their day. Not rude or anything just annoyed that I've called. If they had online ordering I would order that way just so I didn't have to call and bother anyone read more

We moved to Lorain about 5 years ago. We have tried a number of Pizza places with mediocre to average selections. Yesterday (11/2) we finally made it to Jullianos. What a pleasant surprise. Ordered a large Signature crust with onions, banana peppers, and sausage. The crust was exceptional, the pizza itself was quite large excellent flavor and enough for two meals. Worth checking out. read more

My favorite pizza place in Amherst. I love the signature crust on their pizza. It has a crunchy coating on the bottom. The only negative is that it is not always available. read more

Very rude manager. Will take our business elsewhere. Would not honor a coupon from entertainment book.

Although last week they delivered to my home, ( and we tipped very well) I got a call back today that "I'm out of their delivery range" all good... The pizza was great, but that's a damn joke. I'll go next door and pick up a pizza. read more

Great Pizza, one of the BEST in Lorain for sure. Staff is great and priced right. Highly recommend this spot!

We are new to the area and have been searching for a locally owned pizza place. Luckily we found our new favorite in Jilliano's. Previously our favorite was Angelo's in Lakewood. Jilliano's is as tasty, if not better than good old Angelo's. The service and quality is always great. You gotta try the deep dish that's available on the weekends. Truly a lu read more

I had to write a review based off the current 1 star that Jo P. felt the need to leave. Jo P, why don't you pretend you're a man and actually SPEAK to the employee if you want something. Way to be passive in life then go and write a bad review on a good business because you can't vocalize your request at a PIZZERIA. Now for the review.... If you live in this area you know there are not many good places to get Pizza. There's mostly just chains, which aren't necessarily bad, the local Domino's actually isn't bad, but that's about where it ends. As far as this area is concerned, Jilliano's is really only 2nd place to Lorenzo's in Oberlin. The staff is friendly and family owned, and I've gotten delivery about a dozen times and it's always timely, about 30 minutes which is fine as I'm about 10 minutes away to start with. They've never forgotten anything (which I can't say for the chains... mostly they always forget the 2L. or sauce(s)) which is a huge plus. Admittedly we've only ever gotten Pizza, wings and salad. All of which were very good and like I said, if you've ever had Lorenzo's you'll know what I'm talking about. The sauce is very good and a little sweet (but not Romeo's sweet, [Read: pure sugar]) and the pizza is always the same quality, which also reminds me of Lorenzo's. So the quality is always the same, it doesn't vary like some chains, where it's a roll of the dice if you're gonna get a different tasting pizza each time. So in the end, I would give the taste of the food 4 stars, the delivery 5 stars, the consistency of quality/taste 5 stars. It's better tasting Pizza than any of the local Pizza Hut's, Domino's, East of Chicago. Like I said, it's really only 2nd to Lorenzo's, but they vary in quality sometimes and I've gotten a few Pizza's that weren't up to normal standard from there. So that is why I overall rate Jilliano's a 5 stars. read more

My son and I went in here for lunch one day and stood there for several minutes and even though the girl looked at us, she never said a word, she even walked outside to bring food to the only other customers there, and ignored us. Needless to say, we left without ordering anything. read more

just moved to amherst saw an add for wing special on Tuesdays. all i can say is they need to add staff. do they think 1 person can run the counter answer the phones and cook? and oh they close at 9 on Tuesdays but if you want anything call before 8:35 they stop answering the phone. you think im kidding try it! i am sure they are saving so much by only hiring 1 employee that they dont need my business read more