Their pan pizza is the best in Elyria and I have tried all others! I really love their toppings and crust.

This place has amazing food, no matter what you order. Best wings I've had in 20 yrs. Orders have always been correct, hot, and delicious. Counter help is very polite and friendly. We drive 30 minutes out of our way to pickup food from here. Totally worth it. read more

This pizza is trash. It used to be good. The previous owner knew what he was doing. The new owners? Nope. No clue. Orders incorrect, staff is rude and incompetent . Customer complaint on the phone as I was picking up. The employee threw her hands up and called another employee and talked shot about the customer who was calling with a valid complaint. This place has become white trash to the core. I had a bad experience several months ago and I thought I'd give them another try. Mistake. I just had a NEVER AGAIN experience. DO NOT EAT HERE read more

Great pizza and quick delivery!! Really enjoyed it! Will definitely order again. The crust and the ingredients were amazing.

They may have changed ownership, but it seems they kept the recipes, thankfully. I would match the wings with any in the city, and the pizza is truly fantastic. A no frills establishment, but great food. read more

Great pizza. Very friendly staff. Wide variety of options. ............

We had A couple pizza delivered a pierogi and a big burger. The Big Burj was Amazing, the Pierogi was different but good. My coworkers enjoyed the Burj the best. read more

The employees know how to do their job!!! They are pleasant and actually listen. The pizza is amazing!!! I always get the taste of Coz and a pepperoni pizza and have never been disappointed. They even have apple or cherry pie pizza which is sinfully delicious. The dining room is small but serves its function. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Menu options - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

This place is INSANE. Some of the best pizza I've had in Ohio! We got half Pesto Margarita, and half Chicken Bacon Ranch. The crust was perfect! Soft and fluffy but crunchy on the outside. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

See all

We are fairly new to the area. We have been trying different pizza places to find our favorite. We had Lu's a few weeks ago in Grafton and really liked it. Today was our first time ordering here. We ordered the supreme minus green pepper and green olives and substituted for black olives with no issue given. The banana peppers on this supreme were a delicious added touch. We agreed, this is the best pizza we've tried. We will for sure order again. We had our pizza delivered tonight and it was delivered perfectly hot by a really nice man, maybe the owner? Thinking the Hawaiian next time. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Supreme minus green pepper & green olive add black olive. Soooooo good!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

This is a pizza take out place. No frills but great pizza. Also, no delivery. They have a Taco pizza which is what drew me to this place.

We were traveling through and had pizza and BLT sub delivered to our hotel. Pizza was AWESOME and the sub was delicious too. Delivery was on time and the driver was very courteous! Wish we had this place in our town. Highly recommend! read more

When we moved to Elyria we had to find a new pizza place. We've tried a few but the absolute winner in the end is Cozzeria. We have only ordered from them for the past year. And will only order from them in the future. Their pizza's are so good, especially the meat lovers, but all of their specialty pizzas are awesome. Their drivers are so nice. Service is always great. We LOVE Cozzerias!!! read more

This was such a fun experience. An older gentleman made a balloon dog for my son while we waited for our pizza. He gave us some history on this location and welcomed us personally to stay and dine as we had a long trip back home. The pizza was really tasty and we met an older couple who also dined in and gave us a few recommendations from the menu. The pizza was made to perfection, and we ate every last morsel. We will return if we ever find ourselves in Elyria again. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

See all

Delicious pizza! Love the buttery, crunchy crust and fresh toppings! The wait staff is polite and courteous.

This pizza is so good. We get pepperoni and it is always really good. I only have gotten the food delivered so I dont know what the restaurant is like. read more

Now this is a beautiful pie! BBQ chicken pizza and garlic cheese bread. Delicious food and wonderful service! read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Now this is a beautiful pie! BBQ chicken pizza and garlic cheese bread. Delicious food and wonderful service! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

We were driving from Virginia to Chicago and stopped over night in Elyria. We wanted pizza and found Cozzeria Pizzeria. Its total take-out and it was fantastic. Seriously the best pizza we've had in a long time, and that's saying a lot as Chicagoans. Prices are very fair, especially for a pizza this good. (We had the Hawaiian. I know, not considered a real pizza by purists but I don't care). We also had side-salads, which were fresh, cold, crispy but not especially memorable. Just saying. Ordering in advance over the phone was friendly, easy and they got it right. Give it a try! read more

Really good, basic, pizza shop. Nothing fancy. I consider it a mom and pop joint crossed with a pizza hut's pizza style. The food is great. Fast. Always hot. The garlic crust coating is amazing. They put a ton of cheese on, so order light cheese if you want a more normal amount. When I get a pepperoni pizza, it is generally covered 100% in pepperoni....or close enough that it doesn't matter. Amazing food, for what it is. Best pizza in Elyria. You'll have to leave elyria to find a place that can compete with them. read more

The pizza there is always good and they take orders well over the phone and it's always right. Delivery is always on time. Not much for ambiance but that's most of Elyria. read more

Food has been good when we ordered, but it hasn't been our go to choice as a nearby pizza place for some reason. Still searching for "the one." read more

Very good pizza and fast delivery. I will use them again. It's now our go to place for pizza. read more

We're from out of town and stopped here for some pizza due to all the positive reviews we saw. Agreed with the reviews - good pizza and really friendly folks. Enjoyed the chat and the pizza from a great local restaurant. read more

Wow. GROSS. NO. Surprised people think this is good pizza. It's barely edible. We ordered a sausage with green pepper, extra chees and a seafood pizza. Pieces were so small couldn't even taste. Hardly any sauce, definitely not extra cheese. read more

I ordered a pierogi pizza and I can't stop thinking about it! It was so good! Creamy, rich and delicious! My husband got the meatball sub and said it was really good as well - great price too - and my mom was super happy with her chicken mandarin salad, which was huge! I'm from out of town and the next time I'm back, I'm definitely ordering it again! read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Pierogi pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

Cannot recommend Cozzeria on Cleveland St. enough! Mr Houssein, the owner is like family. He is the nicest guy and will remember your order by heart. Mr H. And the staff of Cozzeria even went above and beyond and sent pizza when my dad passed. This shows you how incredible they are. Never a bad experience and their pizza is by far the best. Support your local businesses and enjoy Elyria's finest pizza at Cozzeria read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Big burj and pierogi pizzas - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

We have been to Cozzeria a few times now and I get so excited every time we are in the area so we can order from here! I'm by no means a pizza connoisseur, but there are definitely pizza places out there that are just average and this is not one of them. Their menu has a lot of different options for sizes, toppings, wings, and other sides and salads. The 16" pizza is our go to with extra cheese, sausage, and mushrooms and it is always still hot by the time we get it home. The real secret is to add the extra garlic butter to the crust. It's only an extra .50 and trust me it's totally a game changer. I also LOVE their boneless wings in either ranch honey mustard or the garlic Parmesan. These do not taste like your freezer aisle boneless wings. They are crispy, flavorful and I don't know who the genius was who decided to make a sauce out of ranch and honey mustard combined but it is to die for. Their garlic parm is seasoned well and flavorful- not packed with oil and overbearing with the garlic. They are just coated in the sauce- definitely not swimming in it. These are some of the best boneless wings I've had. Overall this is a great choice if you're looking for pizza and wings. Totally worth the drive even if you're not in the area. read more

Tastes like east of Chicago, we were not a fan of the cheese pizza and gyro fold over, the service was amazing but the food was not our liking- it was hot and freshly cooked we just did not like the flavor profile read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

This place has very good pizza and very friendly people. It's like talking to family when you go there. My wife and I had a pepperoni gluten free pizza and our cousins had a Hawaiian pizza. Both were delicious! read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Hawaiian Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

See all

I decided to try this because o read a review of someone who loved Angelo's in Lakewood but moved to elyria and that's exactly my situation! I've lived in Elyria for over a year and have been afraid nothing will live up to Angelo's and this is spectacular pizza! I got sausage, pepperoni and mushroom and it was very much enjoyed by my husband and I, my new favorite elyria pizzeria read more

Best pizza i have eaten in a long time. People are friendly and welcoming. Had cheese pizza with onions and pepper. Was well cooked. While i was waiting for my pizza. Saw multiple take outs and delivery guys stop by. Would definately recommend this place read more

See all

Excellent pie, we've had 4 different ones so far and they have been perfect. Not sure there's a better local place in Elyria yet. These guys will be tough to beat! read more

I have lived in Elyria for about 2 years. Transplant from Lakewood. It doesn't compare with Angelo's but nothing does. This is definitely the best I've had in Elyria and I've had probably about a half dozen different places read more

Small pizza place located in Elyria. Great atmosphere with great customer service. Pizza was yummy and excellently made. We ordered meat lovers and the pizza had a good amount of the meats and the crust was toasty and buttery. Willl definitely order again! read more

Great pizza, good prices and nice employees. Try the pierogie pizza. You just can't get this anywhere else you won't regret it! read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

See all

We moved to Elyria 3 days ago and came to Cozzeria Pizza to support Windsor Elementary School. Little did my sons and I know we were in for an amazing and special hands-on pizza making experience! Thank you Hussain for treating us so well and welcoming us to Elyria. We will be back and pledge that Cozzeria is our new go-to pizza place! read more

See all

A great mom and pop shop with good value on their specials. I pickep up a large pepperoni for like $10 and it is bigger than a large from the chains. Worth trying! read more

Amazing!! Tried the new creation - pickle pizza! So yummy. Also suggest the pierogi pizza!

We are so happy to have found this pizza gem! So delicious!!! The deep dish has a tasty crust and the pizza is so cheesy and flavorful. We live 15 minutes away, but we will come back again and again even to pick up. The service is also wonderful. So inviting. read more

Cozzeria Pizzeria - This is literally the best pizza I've had in a long time!! About 15 minutes away from home and worth it! - Pizza Near Me - Elyria, Ohio

See all

Wanted to try something new and ordered take out. Built my own Stromboli with pepperoni, banana peppers, cheese and spinach and was ok, I wish I would've got different toppings but I still enjoyed. I also ordered garlic bread that came with a good amount of sauce and for more is only 50 cents! The bread was delicious, and the pizza crust is really good, I love a good deep dish pizza! the employees were super friendly and accommodating! I definitely recommend this place and will be going back! read more