I had had my oil changed at another shop in town, and afterwards, I had a check engine light and an oil pressure light come on. I brought it in here for a second opinion to figure out what was wrong. The person I was working with was Brian. Brian ran the code, and it said that the oil pressure sensor was stuck in the open position. As he got into the diagnosis, apparently when the other shop did the oil change, a prong from the oil filter had broken off, and was blocking the oil pressure sensor. I went back over to the other shop, and spoke to the manager. The manager called over to Brian to find out exactly what had happened, and Brian went over it in detail. Based on what had happened, the manager at the other shop agreed to cover the cost of repairs to get my car back on the road. My car got fixed with no out-of-pocket cost to myself, and even though it was only three days before Christmas, when I brought my car in, Brian had my car ready the following morning. Two days before Christmas. I highly recommend this shop. They will take very good care of you. Thank you to Brian for getting my car done, and for having my back in this situation. I can't recommend this shop enough. read more

If you're a AAA member or considering this shop, I strongly urge you to read this entire review. It's lengthy and detailed, but the seriousness of what occurred makes it worth your time. Reading this could save you thousands of dollars, along with unnecessary stress, expenses, and avoidable damage. On Friday, November 14, 2025, my truck was parked outside my residence and would not start. I contacted AAA for towing assistance. The AAA-approved towing company transported the vehicle to Old Town Auto Service in Eureka, California, which is also a AAA-approved repair facility. I was present during both the loading and unloading of the vehicle. At that time, no damage was visible, and the tow-truck operator appeared competent and to be following proper procedures. On Monday, November 17, 2025, Old Town Auto Service notified me that the vehicle was ready for pickup and reported that the non-start condition had been caused by a failed fuel pump, which they stated had been repaired. Upon entering the vehicle, I immediately observed that the interior fuse-box panel cover on the driver's side was missing. I reported this to the mechanic, and two employees located and reinstalled the missing panel. When I attempted to drive the vehicle out of the parking lot, I immediately detected an abnormal steering condition accompanied by an unusual noise. I returned to the service office to report the issue, and an employee accompanied me outside to inspect the vehicle. This steering issue did not exist prior to leaving the truck in Old Town Auto's possession. The mechanic opened the hood to inspect the engine bay. At that time, I observed that the fuse-box cover in the engine compartment had been improperly installed and was misaligned sitting sideways rather than properly seated and secured. I also observed a smashed spray-can cap lodged near the hood-latch area, which had left a clearly visible circular mark on the vehicle. Multiple service managers and mechanics were present as I raised these concerns. The mechanic suggested the noise might be related to the power-steering pump. However, the reservoir was full and there were no visible signs of leakage. I then inspected underneath the vehicle and discovered that the CV-axle boot had been torn open. The grease was clean and free of dirt or debris, indicating that the damage was extremely recent. Another mechanic independently stated that the damage appeared "very fresh." During this time, an employee from the front office made a joking remark about replacing the axle; given the circumstances, I did not find this appropriate. When I asked how the vehicle could have been declared road-ready, no meaningful explanation was provided. I was told only that "these things happen," and the damage was attributed to the towing company without any supporting basis. However, I could not even drive out of their parking lot without immediately noticing a major steering problem. If a test drive had actually been performed, the mechanic would have noticed this immediately. Furthermore, the CV-axle damage is significant and very obvious. Both the tow-truck driver and I would have seen that damage during loading, and we would have reported it upon arrival. Additionally, several mechanics had moved the vehicle, pushing it into the lot, repositioning it onto the lift, and allegedly test-driving it. Any of them would have noticed such visible damage. I was told that the shop would keep the vehicle to further inspect the damage and contact me the following day. However, Old Town Auto did not contact me. On the morning of November 19, 2025, I called the shop for an update. I was informed that the CV axle was broken and required replacement, and that the water pump was also leaking. Neither issue existed when the vehicle was delivered to Old Town Auto. The sole reason the vehicle was originally brought in was to address a fuel-system failure. I was further informed that although they had previously stated the vehicle was road-ready, they could provide me with a quote if I wished them to repair the newly reported damage. These circumstances are completely inconsistent with the condition of my truck when it was placed in Old Town Auto Service's custody. After raising these issues, the manager contacted me, offering $200 on the condition that I not pursue any claims or post anything negative about the shop, while simultaneously refusing to address the damage to my truck and insisting it be towed off their lot. This attempt to silence legitimate concerns only underscores the lack of accountability, professionalism, and honesty I experienced throughout this process. Based on the available evidence and my firsthand observations, I have every reason to believe the damage occurred while the vehicle was under Old Town Auto Service's care, custody, and control. I do not recommend this shop to anyone, especially AAA customers who expect reputable, trustworthy service. read more

See all

I have a 22-year-old VW camper that I love and am determined to keep on the road. Bill, Byron, Joey, and Zack are guys I can depend on. Really good service. Great communication. Excellent service all around. Caution: Bryon makes the coffee super strong. read more

Old Town Auto Service - Auto Repair Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

these guys are fantastic! i had called several mechanics in the area and these were the only responsive guys! Even gave me a ride to pick up my car! very courteous and friendly! will definitely come back! read more

Let me start by saying the staff is awesome. Took my vehicle here for a diagnostic. They were very responsive and had great communication both through phone calls and text messages. I ended up having to leave the vehicle there longer than anticipated due to unforeseen family medical issues and they were very understanding about that. Now here's where the 2 stars comes into play. I was quoted a ridiculous amount of money to fix the issue. Every other shop I've called says they have no idea how they came to that price and every one was thousands less than what I was quoted at Old Town. So, if you're okay with overpaying and really want awesome staff, this is your best option. read more

I dropped my car off for a rearview mirror replacement and although additional parts were needed, they quickly got the repair completed for me to take a planned trip. They also went beyond what would be expected by replacing the battery in my key fob. I noticed it needed to be replaced when I picked up the car. They drove to 3 places to find a battery! They didn't charge me for the additional service and I left for my trip with much less anxiety knowing the key fob and my car were in good working condition. read more

To the best team of mechanics in Humboldt County, from Bill in the front office to Daryl and his team of expert, professional mechanics. Thank you for taking going care of our vehicles!! I brought my son's old Ford Ranger pickup in with little hope of having it fixed because it had so many problems. within a week, Daryl and his mechanics worked around the clock and put my sons old truck back to factory condition. They even worked to get the best prices on each part. Take your vehicles to them. You won't regret it. They truly take care of their customers and go above and beyond. There isn't anything they can't fix. Thank you again for taking care of me and my son's truck. I haven't seen him this happy since he got his first PlayStation as a kid. read more

The Old Town pro's correctly diagnosed the problems, recommended the repairs that were necessary, and performed the work. All within the promised timeframe. And. Daryl worked with me on alternative transportation while my car was in their shop. For me, it doesn't get any better than that... read more

Management's unwillingness to read an invoice, even when they KNEW FOR CERTAIN mistakes had been made, turned a three-day job into a two-week job. Since they like to argue with bad reviews, I'd love to know what their justification is for this. I was vaguely promised a price cut by an employee before the manager stepped in and actually raised the price on me. Unpleasant all around. I used their sister shop, Eureka Brake & Automotive for years, never had these kind of problems with their staff. read more

TERRIBLE SERVICE. THEY FUCKED MY CAR UP. The one good thing about this place is them is the carpool service. They changed me $2,000 to do 4 spark plugs and 4 ignition coils with additional services I did not approve of. I ended up replacing these same parts 8months later due to them being faulty. I will never go here again or recommend the service. When I talked to one of the employees giving me a ride home he told me he was inexperienced in being a mechanic. DO NOT COME HERE UNLESS YOU WANT YOUR CAR FUCKED UP. read more

Old Town found some unexpected issues that the dealer missed. While not an emergency, not fixing them could have resulted in a breakdown quite soon, leaving me stranded. I had to wait for the repairs and the waiting area was comfortable and clean. Thanks Old Town! read more

I really appreciate the quality service I received at Old Town Auto Service in Eureka. They are very thorough and I was grateful that they explained everything to me in detail of what was wrong with the car and how to fix it. Now it runs like a dream! Highly Recommend! read more

I just got quoted $600 for my front two brake pads. No rotors, nothing except brake pads on two wheels. Wild. I had to pay a $100 diagnostic fee as well. 5% veterans discount though, so they can have 1 star for that. I'm now at Ray's old town, they're doing my brakes right now for $250. read more

I took my 2005 Avalon in for an oil change and inspection. For several years the car had been loaned to family members and had not been serviced since returned to me . Old Town did a complete inspection, and I already knew brakes/rotors were poor. With all the odds and ends it was several thousand dollars, but I now have an old, low mileage car that will safely last many more years. And spread over the last ten years where it received minimum attention (oil changes, of course), the cost not too bad...I keep telling myself. Expensive, but cheap doesn't stop my car. There were bolts that had not been loosen in 18 years, leaks, and that sort of fun stuff. And fixing things right instead of just okay takes a little longer. And that takes time, which alas, is money. So good job, and thank you. read more

My son was traveling and his car broke down. Old Town was one of the only shops that could look at his car promptly. And one of the most professional. Tow truck dropped off at 2pm and we had a call by 8am the following morning with estimate and ETA of noon. Shout out to Bella and Darrel. They were extremely helpful and attentive to our situation. read more

Excellent, timely service. On vacation our car broke down, was very impressed how quickly they were to get us back on the road again! Friendly, reliable and quick! Highly recommend Old Town Auto Service!! Five Star read more

Excellent service and quality The shop was incredibly clean was able to see the progress of the work being done with talking with the tech

This is the second time I have left my car. Everyone is very courteous and professional. They do not make me feel pressured to have extra work done. I especially appreciate the rides to and from my home with Sweet Bella. Another big plus. read more

Absolute ripoff and borderline criminal. Blindsided me with a $400 diagnosis (despite me telling them the codes I had found), then quoted me $1500 to fix it. A mechanic friend told me to get it out of that shop asap. I did and realized they were going to charge 750 for parts that cost 150 (I bought them). To make it worse, they responded to my complaint saying its hard to run a business in this economy. Yeah, so rip off your customers. Look elsewhere read more

Great service, very knowledgeable, highly recommended. I will definitely use them in the future for any work needed on my 4WD pickup.

I think I reviewed old town auto, But I don't mind giving them another review, they have been doing an excellent job taking care of my Mazda three for many years and before that I had a Mazda 626 and they did an excellent job taking care of that too. I miss Wally Cunningham :-) I continue to utilize old town auto services while I live in Eureka. Thank you very much for providing the wonderful service :-) read more

Just had my Camry Hybrid serviced at 130K miles and like many past visits to Old Town Auto I was not pressured to have any unanticipated work or diagnostic testing done now or in the near future. The crew did the service needed in short order and called me when completed. I received a complete report of the service checks, and timely and courteous service. There may be cheaper shops around, but Old Town has been competent and trustworthy with me which means everything! It's worth using one of their online coupons to bring the price down a bit. - Tom D read more

I have been taking my car into Old Town Auto for about 4 years now. Last time I was there in May they found a problem that another shop couldn't find in a day and repaired it. Today I took it in because I knew my starter was going out. Through the inspection Mike called me to let me know every time something came up, he gave me a price right away and on the phone waited patiently when I didn't have an answer right away. The repair shop is always AAA certified shop 10% off on the labor fee. The one thing I was disappointed about was the rental car they gave me because a part wouldn't be in until Monday. The car had a cracked windshield, was on E and rear view mirror fell off after adjusting it. They offered me two cars to choose from and I went with the bigger one because I had walked down with my clients with disabilities who I work with in their home. I would still recommend them to others and to thank Mike for making sure I knew everything that was going on with my car. read more

Old Town Auto Service - The rental car which was told it was once the owners. - Auto Repair Near Me - Eureka, California

See all

I brought my car in because of a code reading a misfire in the 2nd cylinder and when I dropped it off I asked if they could check the spark plugs and coil first so I wouldn't have to pay for the engine diagnostic test. I was still charged for the engine diagnostic test and the problem was the spark plugs and coil. It made me feel like I was being taken advantage of because i paid over $600 to replace my spark plugs. read more

While visiting from San Jose - staying at my sister's in Eureka, my car key would not turn in the ignition. I called several auto repair shops and the responses included "we are booked for several weeks", "try calling a locksmith", "we don't work on that kind of repairs", etc. I called Old Town Auto Service because they are an AAA certified shop. Darryl said that I could have my car towed to their shop right away and they would diagnose the problem by the next day - which they did. Once the issue was diagnosed, Darryl advised me that the part would need to be come direct from the manufacturer (VW) for the replacement part as it had to be ordered using my car's key code and that it could take as long as 6 weeks! The part came in less than 3 weeks - but unfortunately it was defective. Darryl contacted me to explain my options for proceeding with the repairs. We decided to return the defective part as it was under warranty and reorder. The 2nd part took a little longer to arrive, but Darryl responded immediately when I emailed for a status update. I finally have my car back - YAY! and it is working fine. The five stars are for the following reasons: - They took in my car immediately, no waiting. - Darryl kept me up to date on the repair status and responded promptly to my queries. - When I left my car at the shop, I wanted to bring home two car seats. I tried for about 20 minutes, but was unable to get them unbuckled. I went back in the office and asked Bella (at the front desk) for help. She came out and struggled with them for another 20 minutes without much luck. One of the mechanics (Jeremy?) saw our struggles and came to help. It still took another 30 minutes or so, and a screw driver, to finally release the car seat. I feel this kind of service is above and beyond what is expected! read more

Old Town Auto misdiagnosed my truck three different times! They charged me a ton of money to replace parts that they had previously said were fine and never did fix the problem...which turned out to be a ball joint that just needed a little grease. I'll never go back.​ read more

Worst experience I've ever had at a mechanic. It doesn't cost 500+ to replace a spark plug. They saw that I was dressed nice and tried to over charge hands down. Don't go to them!!. And the guy at the service counter even said that I was right as I was leaving after I expressed that I called another mechanic. I was right that what they said needed to be done..didnt need to be done to reach the same out come!!! I dont want leave a Yelp review..not too mention contact the better business bureau. But this is robbery!! read more

Amazing service! Fast and convenient. They were so friendly there and the coffee was great!

Great customer service. We brought in an RV to be inspected before purchase. As we started to realize it had issues, they worked with us on the price of the inspection cost, which made the situation sting a little less. Thanks you guys. read more

You would think that after paying 100 dollars for a diagnostic they would find what is causing a specific problem in your vehicle. Not in my case. Gave them a visit, they gave me a quote and said that after replacing this part and paying nearly 2k it would fix the problem. Paid for the parts and labor and after taking it back home and giving it a week, I still have the same problem. They said there is another part they think might be the root cause and that it will cost another 1.5k. If you have a problem with your vehicle I recommend that you take it to that specific dealership of the make of your vehicle or you will end up like what I did, paying for their process of elimination because they don't know how to properly diagnose a problem. I am a disabled veteran and I am also going to school so 2k is a lot of money but for them to shrug and say I don't know what to tell you really shows you what kind of business they are. They will probably follow up with me writing this review trying to "CUSHION" their fall BUT BE WARNED, I WILL NEVER BRING MY VEHICLE HERE AGAIN NOR WILL I RECOMMEND IT TO ANYONE. IN FACT I WILL DO THE OPPOSITE. If you LOVE BURNING YOUR MONEY AWAY YOU KNOW WHERE TO GO. I would love to hear what they have to say as a response to reading my HONEST REVIEW read more

We brought our Civic into Old Town due to a blown head gasket. Most of our discussions with Steve were over the phone. Steve was very forthcoming and honest! He gave us complete competitive estimates and let us know what possible complications were likely before we started so there weren't any surprises. Steve kept us updated with progress and finished on time. The car runs great again and we are very pleased with his work. Thanks very much! read more

Stopped by here on an unexpected issue with my car during my road trip. Employees and the owner (I think he was the owner) were nice and the waiting area was clean. I wish there was an​ auto shop as nice as this in LA. I ended up paying more than the initial quote on the phone for the exact same job that I inquired but I wasn't super overcharged like many other auto shops scam with their customers. Initially was told 30min but had to wait for a little over an hour. Stop by here if you are around Eureka and need some TLC for your car! read more

BEWARE!!!..... DISHONEST LIARS!!!!! ....WOW....what a nightmare my experience has been with this shop!!! I took my car in for a simple issue,a power steering issue that needed my alternator to be replaced. I paid $179.00 to have my alternator checked only to be told it was in perfect working condition. I was shocked to hear this as I tested it myself and it showed 11 volts before I took it in. Brian and the mechanic assured me it was working fine and that they had to go through my electrical system to fix the problem. I was shocked but trusted them. My father was in ICU and old town kept my car for a full week, so I was forced to rent a car to get to my father. After old town automotive completely tore my electrical system apart, to call and tell me that they we're wrong...it was the alternator after all!!!!! When I finally got the call my car was ready to be picked up....they tried to charge me $1017.00 for the misdiagnosis they're mechanic made and for the time wasted on my car (3days). Lacy ...the woman in the office was very unprofessional and the last person I would have dealing with the customers. She literally tried to steal my money by falsely charging me for the mistake they made!!! I ended up paying $599.40.....after refusing to pay for their mistakes. They also refused to reimburse me $758.00 for the rental car I had to get due to them keeping my car for 1 week, when it only took them 1 day to fix after trying to charge me 1017.00 dollars and straight up lying to my face. ALSO.......when I picked up my car, my radio was on full blast and both seats were not in they're correct positions. Also my milage shows that they drove my car 60 plus miles !!!!!!!!!!!!Now I have to waste my time and more money with taking them to small claims court and dealing with the BETTER BUSINESS BUREAU. I have NEVER been cheated like this before!!!! Do not take your business to Old town automotive.....you will regret it!!!! Now I have electrical issues with my vehicle due to them not knowing what they are doing!!!! read more

We were traveling from OR and having issues with our 2004 Suburban. These folks squeezed us in, with no prior notice, on a busy day. They treated us right, fixed the problem in a couple hours and the price was fair. Can't do better than that. Thanks! read more

Old Town Auto Service has serviced our vehicles for the past 10 years. They are professional, kind, and always deliver within the estimated time. We are satisfied with the quality of their repairs and service. When I took in a vehicle that was in really bad shape, they gave me an estimate but also suggested that it may not be worth the cost of repairing due to several factors. I was happy that I could trust them to give me honest feedback and service and not try to force an expensive repair. They care about us as a long-term customer and show that with the follow-up calls to determine our satisfaction with their service. I recommend them without hesitation. read more

I was sold a lemon of a car and I put a lot of work into it with old town auto service. 4500 originally for the first fix and then 700 to fix it again. It has so many problems. I appreciate the fact they Steve and the guys tried to help me and make everything right. I think Austin was one of the mechanics and he was very nice and understanding with my frustrations. Also bill is very nice and helpful. Thank you for your compassion for me. read more

The customer service here is top of the line. I had my Mazda repaired and they called me, emailed me to make sure I was 100% happy. I had a slight issue a few days later and Steve could not get on it and take care of it fast enough. They care. Even sent me a free car wash coupon. 9 I respect this staff so much. I can not believe the customer service. Well done . You are my stop from here on in Thank you read more

Great service, went to two different shops before getting my car repaired at Old Town Auto. Differently will go back. Very nice and trust worthy. read more

This shop told me they could perform a service they knew they could not, kept my car for 2 hours, then happily took my money for doing nothing. read more

I've never written a Yelp review in my entire life. I don't actually like this app that much but I've gone to the dark side. I downloaded this app just to write this one review over this one business. I'll shorten it up so I don't waste your time. I very specifically asked Old Town Auto repair yesterday when would be a good time for an oil change, they said tomorrow at 8:30. I was very adamant on not wanting to get anything checked, because I had already done that myself with my brother. I just needed the oil change and didn't have the time to do it myself. I dropped it off at 8:30 and they said it would be done 'later on that morning' whatever that means. I got a call around 11:30 saying I need a new carbon filter and some other stuff, and that they were going to charge me $432 for everything. I told them very politely that I just wanted an oil change and was wondering when it would get done thinking it would be maybe an hour. They said they were going to start the oil change, and call me when they're done. So I dropped it off at 8:30 for no reason? They ended up charging me $150, despite the fact that I asked them not to do any break checks. I know my brakes are good you know? So, instead of going to loop Central in mckinleyville, I listen to my girlfriend and went to a place near me and got fucked in the ass. You really think I plan on spending $150 for an oil change this morning? I got my vehicle back close to 5 hours later. Go there if you want but you're going to physically feel them putting the lube on your a****** when you pay way more than you're supposed to. read more