Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Odd Duck

    4.5 (1k reviews)
    Open 3:00 pm - 12:00 am (Next day)

    Odd Duck New American Restaurant Photos

    ODD DUCK ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Moderate noise
    Hipster
    Trendy
    Outdoor seating

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Odd Duck

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Craig H.

    What a surprisingly great restaurant and meal! The menu is so creative and the food quite tasty with truly exceptional combinations of ingredients so cleverly composed. We had deviled eggs, a super fresh crudo, amazing salads, and some incredible proteins. My wife has two rather complicated allergies--cilantro and high fructose corn syrup--and the staff and kitchen went out of their way to mark up a copy of the menu for her so she could safely explore what options she could eat. We are from Los Angeles and my son moved to Milwaukee recently. Odd Duck felt like a place we would have discovered back in Southern California. The sophistication of the dishes, the flavor profiles, and the quality ingredients really added up to a stunning meal.

    Rabbit and ramp gyoza
    Em J.

    We had the pleasure of dining last night and the meal and the service were fantastic. We started with the marinated olives and the garlic naan. They used fiddleheads in one of the sauces which is something not commonly seen in the Midwest and was very delicious. The rabbit and ramp gyoza were the best thing we ate that evening. Perfectly balanced. Finished with the butternut squash pasta and the bison cheek. Beautiful restaurant and beautiful food serviced by lovely and caring staff. Thank you.

    Fried Crispy Oyster Mushrooms Plate
    Lindsey F.

    Outstanding! We came in on a Saturday night with a reservation (seems critical - it was packed) and were seated right away. They have a rotating menu and are very accommodating to food allergies! The waitress took my menu and had the kitchen mark it up and discussed variations. The drink menu is fascinating and they have a big wine menu too. Our waitress recommended 2 plates per person and that seemed to be a good amount and so we got to try 8 things split 4 ways (though I think this is the max you could share one plate). The flavors were interesting and unique and overall delightful. The table's favorite was the duck ravioli with squash with the potatoes at a close second for me. There's a variety of vegetarian options. The business chooses to publicly display their values through signs signaling that they aim to be an open and inclusive space. They offer gender neutral bathrooms and accessible spaces.

    Charred Broccolini $17
    Irene Y.

    **June 2025: Tuesday Dinner Visit** My friend and I saw so many positive reviews for the Odd Duck and the restaurant was a happening place despite being a weeknight. We arrived around 5pm without a reservation, but thankfully there a table near the window opened up for us. I think if you're interested in dining here making a reservation would definitely be recommended! https://oddduckrestaurant.com/reservations/ The style of food here is Asian fusion and the portion size is small plates. It's a hipster/trendy setting and the bar area seems like it'd be a cool place to hang out. Service is also friendly. We settled on the following dishes Charred Broccolini $17 Chili deviled eggs $6 Ricotta and duck confit tortellini $21 Haitian griot pork cheeks $19 Everything was beautifully presented and flavorful. Among the dishes we picked the Ricotta and duck confit tortellini though I would gladly enjoy them all again. Congrats to Chef Ross Bachhuber and Samuel Ek on being a James Beard Semi-finalist in the Best Chef in the Midwest category. Your dishes were amazing!

    Duck Confit & Mushroom Doppio Ravioli
    Taylor C.

    I've dined at Odd Duck 3 times. The first time was in 2019 at its previous location, and the three of us liked every dish we shared. The second time was a about 3 years ago at its current location, and the two of us liked the dishes a lot (particularly the vegetarian dishes). I visited the restaurant once more with my family in December 2025, expecting the same delicious food with balanced flavor profiles. The menu has completely changed from what we saw a couple of years ago, indicating that the restaurant keeps innovating and offers different dishes as the season changes. What was disappointing, however, is that the "new" dishes had either one overpowering flavor (e.g., sourness) or nothing to distinguish themselves from those at much cheaper restaurants. The following were the dishes that we shared. - Honeycrisp Apple Salad. The taste was overwhelmingly sour due to the dressing, and most people could have done better at home. - Smashed Potatoes. The ingredients looked very good, and the taste was pretty good as well, although none of us were really impressed with the flavors. - Fried Oyster Mushrooms. The dish was ok, but there was again nothing distinguishing. - Chinese Allium Pancakes. This was a complete failure as the pancakes were just cooked pieces of flattened dough with green onions inside, whereas Chinese green onion pancakes are supposed to be crispy with many thin layers (like puff pastry). - Duck Confit & Mushroom Doppio Ravioli. This is by far the most tasteful dish of all. - Wood-Fried Goan Sausage Ring. The dish was very good also. - Wood-Fried Bavette Steak. The steak was cooked properly, and the flavor was fine, although some of the pieces were a bit chewy. The dish again had nothing to distinguish itself from similar dishes at much cheaper restaurants. Overall, we had high expectations but were rather disappointed with the quality of the dishes we ordered. Innovation is for sure a good thing, but the restaurant seems to offer a bunch of new dishes without carefully testing and refining them, damaging its own image in the minds of customers.

    Charcuterie and Cheese Boards
    Bradley K.

    We had a wonderful experience at Odd Duck while in MKE for a wedding. Between the 4 of us we ordered everything from the vegetarian side of the menu except the potatoes and ordered a couple of carnivore items as well. I can't say there was a single dish that missed the mark. Our server, Andrew, did a wonderful job or pacing the meal, making suggestions, and just was an overall great presence for our dinner. He never rushed us. He never failed to meet expectations at all. We were so engrossed with our eating and discussions that 3 hours later we looked at our watches and were astonished we'd been there so long. Highlights for me were the fried rice, the eggs, and the duck tortelloni. Really fabulous meal. Excellent Georgian Orange style wine. And a nicely decorated restaurant with tons of duck figurines and a warm woody interior. I'd definitely come back again.

    Alexander D.

    Solid! We went here for an impromptu date night as we have always wanted to try it and use some rest credit we had there. For starters I will say we enjoyed the service as we were promptly seated and walked through the menu. We do think the space was quite warm for a summer night. We thought the bar space was pretty cool. We loved the food though but were unsure where it fell on value with other places we have tried at that price point. We loved small bites but were unsure where this fell and think the value is probably 4/5 with taste being 5/5.

    Rie U.

    TLDR: 100% recommend if you're ever in Milwaukee. The menu is quirky, the servers are quirky and the place is a little quirky. What's not to love?! We had such a great meal for a really reasonable price (compared to Chicago)! The Duck Confit Tortellini was nice and soupy with the chanterelle mushrooms. Really great umami flavors. The Fried Piri Piri Chicken was excellent. Just enough kick to it and perfectly juicy yet crispy on the outside. The Fried Wild Rice with white kimchi was nice and spicy but a little too salty for me. Our server was super knowledgeable and also a little quirky but in the most AWESOME way. We definitely appreciated his guidance on everything. We'd definitely love to come back when their menu changes next season!

    Rebecca F.

    Was so impressed with the quality of food to the price that I came back again in the same week! Food: -pork chop: cooked perfectly with the right level of sweetness -BAVETTE STEAK: cooked perfectly with meat retaining its flavorful juices, paired well with the garnishes and potatoes for clearing the palate -beet salad: this one I was rather disappoint with. Despite the nice arrangement the beets themselves lacked any flavor. I've had much in many other places. -charcuterie: had the Schroeder Kase and Sopressata, the plate also comes with the chef's choice of bread, grapes, dijon mustard, pecans, pickles, and candied apricots. Everything tasted fresh. Would recommend. Could substitute as a dish -bay leaf soft serve: never had soft serve in this flavor before. Got a hardy bowl and the crunch of the nuts complemented the flavor well Overall food: these are smaller plates or one charcuterie and one dish. So be ready to order two plates to get you belly full. I would consider this a $$$ spot but good for a casual night. Service was top notch. Both at the bar and at the table. Every server knew how to explain the menu and what to recommend. I was checked on at just the right frequency. Parking is to be expected in this area of Milwaukee, street as you can find it.

    Jessica J.

    Well, Odd Duck does it again. This was my first visit to their new location (I know, I'm late), but I was delighted to check it out and both my husband and I thoroughly enjoyed the experience! Our server, Andrew, was fantastic. Just an overall friendly guy, very attentive, lots of great recs. I needed a refresher on the menu and best way to order, since Odd Duck is primarily small/shareable plates, and he walked us through how many plates are recommended for two people, and some of his favorites. As soon as our wine arrived to the table (sauv blanc for me and flavorful cab for my husband), we decided to put in some items from the cheese and charcuterie menu. Wow, loveddd the gouda and the serrano ham. They came plated with a few other bites like grapes, bread, and marcona almonds (YUM). We went on to share the wood fired brussels sprouts, the duck dish that definitely had some spice (in a great way), and the chorizo chicken. They were all fantastic. And I hate to say it, but their menu is always rotating so you may or may not be able to get your hands on these ones in particular. The good news? Everything on their ever-changing menu sounds delicious and there is a reason their chefs been nominated for James Beard Award. Lovely atmosphere, kind and attentive staff, unbeatable food. Come here if you haven't already.

    Delicious drinks.
    Lynette H.

    It was a birthday outing. Going to the Odd duck I always know it's a special occasion. And it did not disappoint as usual. We had reservations for two so we were seated promptly. The service was wonderful and everyone was nice. The gal delivering food to the table could have used a smile or two. We enjoyed the ambiance. They seat you quite close and you can hear your neighbors conversations without trying too hard. That being said we enjoyed our food. We tried the deviled eggs....yum!! The oyster mushrooms ... they were our favorite. The smoked duck...very good flavor. The braised bison cheeks....a must try. The lamb quesabirria....probably our least favorite but still good. And of course we had to have dessert, the pecan brownie with cream....a great way to end our special night out at The Odd Duck. Just a heads up it is not a cheap night out, however, worth it especially for a special occasion.

    Fennel and Citrus Roasted Olives and Altos de Iberia Serrano Ham.
    Fernando L.

    No other place like this around. Food is unique, friendly staff and perfect atmosphere. Bar opens at 3:00 pm, they serve snacks and drinks. Full menu opens at 5:00 pm.

    Suya-Spiced Fried OYSTER MUSHROOMS, Lettuce Cups, Tostones, Lime Aioli, Habanero Pickled Onions, Peanuts, Cilantro

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    8 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Kaelyn A.
    110
    19
    0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Just a note to say still fabulous. It looks like I've been eating here for over 7 years now

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    5 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Francis L.
    169
    72
    40

    2 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1
    Photo of Aaron H.
    205
    57
    71

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 months ago

    What a gem! The food was amazing-just the right amount. The bartenders were friendly and skilled. Highly recommen.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tien H.
    70
    229
    254

    3 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Not my cup of tea. Too many better options in the area. Parking can also be challenging.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 1

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Really, really pleased with the new location and the attention to detail to the patrons.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 27

    Odd Duck Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - Odd Duck

    How late is the kitchen open to take bar orders?

    The kitchen doesn't close at a specific time, but you have to be here by 10pm to be seated for food, even in the bar. So if you sit down at the bar at 9:59pm, you can take your time and have a leisurely meal. But if you get here at 10:01pm, then we… Read more

    What seasonal vegetables does Odd Duck plan on offering this spring?

    We print our menu daily, so we are always changing based on when things start coming in from farmers. We actually use local produce all winter long too, when possible - our farmers grow things like greens, peppers and microgreens hydroponically… Read more

    Is your dining room open again?

    Our dining room has been open since Spring of 2021, but we have been closed for the last week due to the surge in Covid-19 cases in the Milwaukee area. We re-open tomorrow. Our open hours typically are Tuesday through Saturday, 5pm to 10pm. The bar… Read more

    Does the Odd Duck have an extensive wine program?

    They have lots of wine options, unsure if it is necessarily "extensive".

    Does odd duck use MSG in their dishes? am allergic to msg and had a very distinct reaction after eating there last night. According to the waiter and the kitchen, they DO use msg in their pork shoulder dish, I wonder about others?

    We only use MSG in dishes when we feel like it is culturally necessary to the integrity of a recipe. If you have a concern or allergy and ask the server, they will be able to find out if we use it in any dishes at that time, and which ones they… Read more

    Don’t See Your Question? Ask Away!

    You might also consider

    The Vanguard - Red Curry Berliner

    The Vanguard

    4.2(572 reviews)
    1.9 miBay View
    $$

    While visiting Milwaukee on a short weekend trip with my husband, we decided to come to The…read moreVanguard for a late lunch before we checked into our hotel downtown. Parking was fairly easy as we managed to grab a spot on the street out front. We decided to sit at the bar and soak in the ambience. When in Milwaukee ... eat all the comfort food. We started with an order of cheese curds and poutine. The cheese curds were perfectly fried salty goodness and the poutine had plenty of gravy, sautéed onions, and of course, more cheese curds. We also ordered a Milwaukee-style bratwurst and a Chicago-style cheddarwurst. We both thought that the Chicago-style cheddarwurst had great flavor and delicious toppings. The Milwaukee-style bratwurst was tasty, but we both felt that it needed some type of sauce or something to bring it all together. Needless to say, we left completely full and actually did not even have room for dinner that evening. So if you find yourself in the Milwaukee area and looking for some delicious comfort food, come check this place out.

    I love Vanguard because it's a Bay View staple with an interesting theme and decor. It's heavy on…read morethe bourbon for craft drinks and fun with TV kitsch like 80s wrestling and old sci-fi. My favorite will always be the fried potato ball covered in cheesy goodness with sour cream and chives. I opted for the new Sammartino which is a brilliant combination of ingredients. Who could refuse an Italian sausage on a toasted bun with crispy bits of pepperoni, pesto, marinara and cheese. If you don't like spice do not get this sandwich because the Italian is a, medium hot which was a little too spicy for me. Also I think the sausage could have used a little more fat for mouth feel but that's a personal preference. Note that all the Italian sausage is made spicy because my friend had one with sauerkraut and it was spicy. I can't wait for it to be warm out to grab a beer and a craft hot dog on the outside patio.

    Photos
    The Vanguard - The entire top shelf and half the bottom shelf are all bourbon and whiskey

    The entire top shelf and half the bottom shelf are all bourbon and whiskey

    The Vanguard - Seasoned Fries Yt Watson Vegan Chili Cheese Fries

    Seasoned Fries Yt Watson Vegan Chili Cheese Fries

    The Vanguard - New Glaurus spotted cow

    See all

    New Glaurus spotted cow

    Himalayan Yak

    Himalayan Yak

    4.1(38 reviews)
    1.4 miBay View
    $$

    The food is outstanding. Each dish is clearly prepared with care and authentic ingredients. The…read moreflavors are rich and well balanced--perfectly spiced without overwhelming the palate. The momos (Himalayan dumplings) are especially memorable, and the curries are deeply flavorful with tender meats and fresh vegetables. Their naan and rice dishes complement everything perfectly. What really makes Himalayan Yak stand out is the authenticity. The menu offers a wonderful mix of Nepalese, Tibetan, and Indian dishes that you don't find everywhere. It's a great place both for people who already love Indian and Himalayan cuisine and for anyone looking to try something new. Overall, Himalayan Yak is a fantastic dining experience. Delicious food, generous portions, friendly service, and a cozy atmosphere make it a place you will want to return to again and again. If you are in Milwaukee and enjoy flavorful, authentic cuisine, Himalayan Yak is absolutely worth visiting. PS, You can share one meal and still have leftovers...

    We came here tonight as a large group and everything went well! The appetizers were very tasty, we…read moreordered a variety plate and a beef jerky plate. We also enjoyed tasting the complimentary chips and dips. All were delicious and easy to share with a group. Service was very attentive and friendly. We all enjoyed our entrees and loved the bowls of delicious rice.

    Photos
    Himalayan Yak - Large back room seating area.

    Large back room seating area.

    Himalayan Yak - Himalayan Mix Grill

    Himalayan Mix Grill

    Himalayan Yak - Interior

    See all

    Interior

    The National Café & Takeaway - Inside The National

    The National Café & Takeaway

    4.2(328 reviews)
    0.5 miWalker's Point
    $$

    I love The National Cafe and Bakery for their breakfast options. I am not vegan, however my little…read moreone has a dairy and soy allergy (and an egg allergy that he has since outgrown) so that made eating out nearly impossible. The National Cafe and Bakery was able to accommodate without a problem--they don't use soybean oil or soy based butter in their vegan options. Most vegan options at restaurants are soy based so this was such a refreshing change. The vegan French toast is so good and hearty! I also love their baked goods and look forward to being able to enjoy a treat there. I hope they continue to to serve my neighborhood--I love the farm to table concept. 10/10. A Milwaukee staple on the Southside.

    We came here on a Sunday morning, so it was fairly busy. They only have street parking and it can…read moreget a little complicated if you want to be really close to the restaurant. We ended up getting the full English breakfast, I had a London fog latte and my fiancée had a regular coffee. They do have oat milk and soy milk if you prefer that instead of regular milk in your coffee. The full English breakfast has baked beans, tomato, bacon, sausage, mushrooms, eggs and toast. I have had this numerous times here and it has always been my favorite! the baked beans are just a little sweet n tangy, the eggs are however you like them cooked, and the mushrooms at a bit of earthy flavor. If you have ever been to England, the only difference is there is no white or black sausage here. I don't exactly like it so I am glad the sausage here is more like a broiled regular one. The London fog here is the ONLY one I like in MKE! They always put just the right amount of vanilla syrup and milk in it. Most places end up making it super sweet but this place is PERFECT! I come here occasionally because it's also cute and we like to sit in the window and people watch. The service is great and you just order from your phone at the table you choose and pay using Apple Pay or a card.

    Photos
    The National Café & Takeaway - Inside The National

    Inside The National

    The National Café & Takeaway - Posters For Sale

    Posters For Sale

    The National Café & Takeaway - Inside The National

    See all

    Inside The National

    Ni Burmese - Pork Eggrolls

    Ni Burmese

    4.7(49 reviews)
    1.1 miBay View

    This place blew my mind!…read more I have had Burmese food in Los Angeles and San Francisco, even in the famous Burma Superstar, but Ni Burmese was absolutely perfect. It truly felt like a fine dining experience without the fine dining cost. The staff member who served us was delightfully friendly, welcomed us so warmly, and took the time to provide not just service, but a guided experience through the dining journey. Their menu has what appear to be hand-drawn watercolor images on it and it looks like a fancy cookbook (in the style of Salt Fat Acid Heat)! The location is unassuming, but everything inside appears to be so thoughtfully decorated. At the recommendation of our server, we had the Mont Hin Ga (soup) and the Tea Leaf Salad. I was so full, but finished that soup to the very last drop. Tea Leaf Salad is such a unique blend of flavors and textures. The occasional burst of tomato and the crunchy tidbits in it make each bite such a surprise. YUM! Because you only live once, we also had the chicken curry with coconut rice and an iced tamarind juice. Who can say no to coconut rice? And the chicken? So tender, so juicy, so flavorful. I have always been a fan of tamarind, but this is one of the best "aguas de tamarindo" that I have ever had. Also, big shoutout to the Falooda for dessert (even though we were so full, we couldn't resist trying just one more item from their menu). After going home I proceeded to send a friend pictures from Ni Burmese's Yelp page to tell them about how tasty everything was. And my mouth has been watering ever since. Cannot wait to go back - I have my eye on their Spicy and Sour fish. Thank you to the Ni Burmese crew for one of the best meals I've ever had! (I showed someone this review before posting and they said I sound like AI, but I am not - just a delighted eater)

    First of all, what a gem for the Milwaukee community to have!! The restaurant is beautiful, sleek…read moreand modern, but also lots of beautiful Burmese touches. The service was very quick, and they there the right amount of attentive. And the food was lovely!! Would highly recommend and will certainly be back when I'm in Milwaukee.

    Photos
    Ni Burmese - Bright modern space, with comfortable lighting and lots of wood tones.

    Bright modern space, with comfortable lighting and lots of wood tones.

    Ni Burmese - Coconut chicken noodle soup

    Coconut chicken noodle soup

    Ni Burmese - Ice Grass Jelly drink and Ice Tamarind Juice (my friend took a few sips before photo)

    See all

    Ice Grass Jelly drink and Ice Tamarind Juice (my friend took a few sips before photo)

    Honeypie Cafe - Breakfast Burrito

    Honeypie Cafe

    4.1(942 reviews)
    1.7 miBay View
    $$

    Service was outstanding, extremely friendly and attentive. I hadn't been to their new building yet…read moreand was pleasantly surprised to see some really cool retro pictures, hand stitched artwork, and classic wallpaper. It's a fun space and felt very welcoming. The chilaquiles were fantastic! They make their own hot sauce in house that was a good addition to the dish, along with chorizo. Highly recommend this one. It was also a huge portion and ended up feeding me for two meals. Make sure you get here early to avoid the extremely long lines; we planned to be there right when it opened and by the time we left, there were already people having to wait outside. Worth the wait though!

    Huh. I've heard good things about Honeypie and I'm confused now. I tried to get brunch with my…read morefamily at another area spot, but the wait was too long so we opted to try Honeypie. We reviewed the menu while we waiting for seating, which took far longer than we wanted, more than 30 minutes standing in the cramped lobby area with a bunch of other people. Hats off to their host for being friendly and even a little entertaining and I like that you can order coffee at the register area and drink it while you wait. Too bad you can't get a cocktail out there. The menu sounded great and we were ravenous so we were excited to order. By the time we were seated we were limited to about 40 minutes to get to a ticketed event, all in. I told that to our waitress so she could pace the meal accordingly. While I understand that she can't control the kitchen time, I don't think she showed any expediency or attention to my statement. Spoiler alert - we were late. Two of us ordered the biscuits to start with jam. I was happy to try them and they were good. My coffee based martini hit the spot, but it was spilled a little when it hit the table and our server didn't say anything or wipe it off. My mom liked her bloody Mary and it was decent. When our food came I was immediately disappointed by the appearance. My chilaquiles looked like they had sat under a heat lamp for ages - the egg was dried and over firm. My chips were spicy, but 100% soggy and nasty. My black beans were - meh. Not a good dish overall. My mom actually didn't find fault with her Honeypie Benedict. I tried the hollandaise and it was fine. My cousin did not enjoy her Hopple Popple skillet at all. (Potatoes, bacon, caramelized onion, mushroom, bell pepper, cheddar, two scrambled farm eggs) She found it difficult to find any egg, as it was apparently shrunk into tiny bits. The potatoes were like fries and it was overall bland. Not a winner. We certainly won't be back. The dishes don't live up to the interesting descriptions of them and the hype seems to be from an earlier, better time for this restaurant.

    Photos
    Honeypie Cafe - Comfortable dining area.

    Comfortable dining area.

    Honeypie Cafe - Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

    Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

    Honeypie Cafe - First time at Honeypie - Milwaukee!!

    See all

    First time at Honeypie - Milwaukee!!

    Odd Duck - newamerican - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...