Went here last night to redeem a Travelzoo voucher (5-course dinner for 2 people, $79.50). Please bear in mind that this is based on my 6th visit to Oceanique (3 times on Wednesdays for the lobster special).
The dinner was good, although by this time I had noticed that their amuse bouche is always a ceviche with flavored oil, radishes, and a potato chip. So nothing new there. Sorbet was blood orange, which was good and which I've also had before. As our appetizer course, my friend and I ordered the day boat scallops with kimchi, which were perfectly done and very flavorful. I had the seared Hawaiian tuna and my friend had the Artic char. Both good, though I highly recommend the char. The tuna paled in comparison. The portions were tiny, which I will attribute to the fact that it was a multiple course dinner. For dessert, we had the chocolate cake (delicious) and chamomile-infused creme brulee (not bad, but not sure I like the chamomile addition).
My gripe is this: being a pretty regular customer, I'm familiar with their course setups. Their 3-course meal is amuse, appetizer, sorbet, main course, dessert. So.. basically my 5-course dinner was a 3-course dinner (I did not expect this). That's okay considering I still saved about $5 off the price of each 3-course dinner.. but wait, there's more. According to this voucher I was redeeming, the value of the voucher was $160 and a gratuity of 18% would be applied. First of all, the value of the voucher was probably more like $90, based on it being pretty much exactly like the weekday 3-course special. Fine, whatever. But then I was charged 20% gratuity, even though "18% gratuity added" was hand stamped on my receipt. So, I was charged $32 instead of $28.80 on a bill that was worth $90 (which would have made 18% gratuity $16.20). I hadn't noticed before I handed them my credit card, and it seemed like a huge hassle over $3. In the end, I paid a total of $127 which was more than the ~$115 or so I would have spent just getting two 3-course dinner specials straight up.
So, the lesson is this. Oceanique has great food, but for your money's worth, either get a Restaurant.com gift certificate or book with VillageVines. Then again, you probably wouldn't be able to order the prix fixe menus in combination with those offers. This "deal" and my server overcharging me on top of overcharged gratuity pretty much killed any future desire I have to return.
Don't get me wrong, it's great food. If you want to save money though, just go for the Wednesday lobster special. Everything else will probably end up costing you, a lot. At this point, I'm not sure if it's worth the price tag because of the tiny portions. Also, there's not much variety month to month. You'll probably want to end up coming back on a bi-annual basis.. maybe the creativity was there once, but I think it's petered off. read more