Had cupcakes from them at a child's party that my family attended. My child thought they were very tasty and we all thought the decorations on them were very appealing. Everyone was happy and all the people were asking the party host where she got the cupcakes from. read more

Wow, the cupcakes here are definitely on par with some of the better bakeries in the city. Ordered a few mini cupcakes to get an idea of how they are....sooooo good...every single one of them were moist and the frostings perfectly sweet. Highly reccomend. read more

Horrible worst customer service ever. Very rude over phone totally butchered my order

Amazing! I just moved to the neighborhood and needed to find a bakery that had the mini cupcakes. They were a huge hit at our housewarming party! This place exceeded my expectations and ordering from them again for our baby shower :) The assorted chocolate minis are the best! read more

I went in early on a Saturday morning for the first time. The place is adorable and smelled delicious. A gentleman assisted me and he was a sweetheart. 18 mid size cupcakes to go, they were assorted and it was about 40 bucks. Everyone loved them, I would definitely go back!!!The cupcakes were beautiful. I'm sorry I have no pictures. THANK YOU Cupcakery. read more

I came in for some cupcakes today. I had an assortment of flavors. The person behind the counter was extremely rude to me and my daughter. We each took a few bites from the cupcakes. They were absolutely disgusting, had to spit it right out. Tasted very moldy and bitter. read more

They made my son's first birthday cake. Exactly as what I wanted and it matches my mickey theme. It was so delicious. It's a 2 layer cake with a mickey head, the flavors are chocolate cake with raspberry filling and yellow cake with cheesecake filling. My cake wasn't only beautiful but was also delicious and very fresh. Everyone loved it! They communicate really well and helpful- the price is good too. I am definitely ordering again on my next party and will def recommend them to everyone. Thank you again NY cupcakery. Till my next event!:D read more

NY Cupcakery - cake made NY cupcakery for my son's first birthday! - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

This place is awesome! The cupcakes are fresh and delicious! Way better than crumbs! They made a beautiful cake for my daughters 1st bday! And they were soooo fair with the pricing! The cake was amazing and absolutely delicious! Thank you guys so much! Will def be back for another cake in April! Best buttercream ever. You guys are awesome! Sad that people leave stupid reviews! I've been to your place many times and the cupcakes and cookies are moist , fresh and Incredible! :) I posted a pic of the cake! Thanks again!!! read more

NY Cupcakery - Beautiful cake amazing taste! Thank you!!!! Will def use you guys again! The best!!!!!!! - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I can definately recommend this bakery. Im very happy with the Elmo Cake we received for our sons 3rd birthday. It looked great and tasted great and on top of that it wasnt overpriced. I will definately come back here and order cake!!! read more

We ordered a cake for our baby's gender reveal and we were not disappointed! They offered several options and we loved what they came up with (forgot to take a before picture; we were just too excited). Not only did the cake come out adorable, but it was super tasty, too! Love that the icing was thicker, like a cream cheese icing, instead of the typical buttercream. Very helpful and courteous customer service. Will definitely be going back again. Glad to have this gem so close by! read more

This place is awesome! Fabulous customer service. And the cupcakes were excellent! Moist cake unlike the dry cakes you find at most bakeries. I will definitely be back here again. read more

I ordered two Custom Cakes two weeks ago I sent them specific pictures of what I wanted I go pick up the cakes today and it's nothing at all close to the pictures I sent them. They look completely horrible also Somewhere there was a miscommunication the design was horrible the owner himself was actually at the bakery and was disrespectful. He also spoke to me rudely and charged me an extra $70 for the mistake of his employees. Completely disappointed definitely would never go back and I will put the same review on every site possible. read more

See all

Stopped in here when I still lived closer, and the store had literally JUST opened. I love that they sell cupcakes in three sizes, small ( a tiny little cupcake), regular (a normal cupcake similar in size from when you were a kid), and large (a crumbs style big cupcake). The cupcakes themselves are quite moist and tasty. Though I admit to being a little underwhelmed by my go-to favorite the red velvet, the other flavors are def. worth a try. If you're in the area and you're a cupcake fan, you should stop in! read more

Wow I can not believe all these great reviews! Was I there on a bad day. I bought and assortment of 12 mini cupcakes, and 1 regular size cupcake. The 1 regular size cupcake was the rainbow cookie one. It was so dry that I cut it open, at the inside of the jelly, and then threw it out. It was actually horrible and did not even taste like a rainbow cookie. Just plain bad. As for the little ones. I think the flavors were there, but they were just so incredibly dry. Seriously some of them were so gross and dry I needed so much water to get it down. There was like one cupcake I remember that was awesome. I think it was the cookie dough one. It was very moist and the icing was yummy. I remember I was shocked this one was in the bunch because it was so different from the others... I am sad this place was not good and confused by the other reviews. read more

I'm SURE you know that these kinda places are very EXPENSIVE! lots of "show" and little else.

I usually don't do this . But I am upset! My huge house warming is TOMORROW and TODAY my loved one picked up my cake and sent me a picture! My name is spelled absolutely WRONG and the cake is supposed to say "Jasmin's First Apartment." My cake clearly says Jasmin's First Department . This is HORRIBLE ! Before my loved one picked up the cake, I called NY CUPCAKERY & asked them to send a picture of the cake before I pick up . His response was "Take a picture when HE/SHE comes in and they will send it to you." This could have easily been avoided if a picture of the cake was simply emailed to me . HORRIBLE HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE . I asked to be compensated for the horrible customer service and errors to the cake . He refused to give me extra cookies or try to accommodate me any further; for now going out my way and getting my loved one to go back and fix the cake . What a disaster ! read more

Very bad experience with my husband's 40th birthday cake. So dissatisfied.. Between the design and cake. Very dry/stale. When I expressed my dissatisfaction was told my fault since I never sent them a picture of my husband to put on cake( the cake design wasn't based on that) and that the dry/staleness of cake is just the way that cake is! I have had better experiences here in the past, but this experience had turned me off this place permanently. read more

I ordered 10 dozen mini cupcakes from here to be delivered to the restaurant I had my baby shower at this past weekend. They arrived on time and they were moist and delicious. Everyone had 3 and 4 each. I was a little nervous because I didn't have much other then fruit for dessert to serve to my guests if the cupcakes weren't up to par.. But everything was perfect. The order, the delivery and the fact that they were so fresh and moist there was no doubt they were baked the morning of.. They did charge a delivery fee of $25 but I felt it was worth it instead of rushing around before the party to pick them up. The cup cakes aren't cheap but if you go around tasting and comparing you'll find yourself back at NY Cupcakery spending the extra few bucks a dozen. I will be back for my sons baptism and 1st Birthday Party cakes.. :-) read more

Great products... delicious. Kind and courteous service even during quarantine. Little pricey but worth it... have gotten several times for special occasions... birthdays, anniversary's, v-day etc... ENJOY read more

Purchased cupcakes for a dental hygiene graduation party. The cupcakes were to have a decoration of tooth, toothbrushes, toothpaste etc. the cupcakes tasted good but the designs looked like a child made them. Also the food dye that was used stained the fingers of every cupcake eater. They were kind of embarrassing to put out at the party, but at least they tasted good. Most likely wont order from here again though. read more

I wish I could give 0 stars! We had an absolutely TERRIBLE, TERRIBLE experience with this place. The sad thing is this is the 3rd time we've used them for expensive, custom cakes. The first time was amazing, the second was so-so (they spelled my daughter's name wrong on a $200+ cake and the cake was reasonably different from the photo) and today's was the last time we will ever use them. I ordered a themed birthday cake a few weeks ago. I explained that I did not want the characters in fondant and would bring them in, they wrote it on receipt. I emailed them a photo of cake, my daughter's age and name and any changes to the cake photo I wanted. I got no receipt of email, but I paid the deposit so I figured we're all good to go. On the day of the birthday party we went to pick up the cake. I brought the two figures that were listed on the receipt to add to the cake. The only thing I regret is not taking a photo of what they showed me when I went to pick it up. It looked as if my husband and I had taken a baking class and then stuck figures I brought on top of the cake. There was NOTHING on top of the cake - NO fondant, NO Happy Birthday or name and it did not match the photo I gave them. It was BARE on top of the cake and my two small figurines were definitely not going to cover it. It is almost comical that they had a clear picture and made a different cake.... In the back, they put on the figures I gave them and scribbled Happy 3rd Birthday. It looked worse than a Carvel or store-bought cake - (the picture clearly showed Happy Birthday cut out in fondant) I asked for my deposit back and then I had less than 30 minutes to find a cake. (I went with Carvel and the Happy Birthday looked the same or better, but this cake was for $100+ less). The sad thing is if the cake was beautiful, I would have paid more money than I was initially quoted. The sadder thing is they LOST a customer by not trying to accommodate and still expected full payment and anytime ANYONE asks about where to buy a custom cake, I will make sure I tell them NOT to use this place. read more

Order arrived two hours late to an event. Didn't mention we needed to provide a credit card number until the day of and decided not to deliver until we called them with one. They told us we could pay in cash weeks prior. Good cupcakes, disastrous communication and service. read more

Ordered 6 cupcakes for 15 bucks , they are classic size not huge ....pretty good ...were fresh . Store front not so great ...display is a mess hard to see any real variety of what shop actually has ......staff friendly but busy ....can't complain to much about price being that it was located in merrick ...rent is probably a fortune ...I will probably go back to support a local small business read more

I have tried other so-called cupcake places and they can't even compare to the NY Cupcakery! This little place has the best cupcakes! The cake taste like real cake and the creamy frosting whether it's buttercream or chocolate or Caramel or carrot with cream cheese frosting or red velvet etc, not too sweet , light fresh and creamy. If you don't like these then there is something wrong with your taste buds. read more

I had the cake last year so I decided to order some cupcakes they were delicious. I ordered them the same day and I was so happy they where able to for fill my order read more

They just did a cake and specialty cupcakes for my husbands 40th bday party. They did a great job. It was almost exactly what we had discussed. The cupcakes looked amazing. Everyone said that everything tasted great as well (I only tasted the cake). Would def use them again. I did speak to them on the phone but also followed up in person and confirmed via email. I would suggest that everything you want is specifically written into the order. I tried to post the pics, but it wouldn't cut and paster- sorry! read more

I picked up an assortment of 17 mini cupcakes a few days ago for some friends that work at a local animal shelter. I ate 2-3 cupcakes myself. It was really good. The cake had a nice consistency, moisture, and overall taste. The icing was delicious. The surprising different flavors tickled my taste buds similar to a mixed box of chocolates. Almost made me cry to see it all disappear so quickly. Next time Im in the area I plan to buy a few more.. read more

This bakery is excellent! The cookies cupcakes and regular cakes are all delicious. I got a cake for my son birthday and everyone was asking me where I bought it. The prices are more expensive but you get what you pay for read more

I was super disappointed at this bakery. The cupcakes are just an imitation of the Cupcakery on the West Coast. They are smaller but just as pricey and not as delicious. The cupcake itself was too sweet and the frosting was bland. What a ripoff. The store inside was dinky and there were a couple of flies inside. The service was mediocre at best; the person that helped was curt and not at all friendly. read more

ordered cake pops from them. They were delicious a little bit too sweet but everyone loved them.

Delicious !!! I bought 10 assorted cupcakes for my husbands birthday get together and they were amazing!!!! Do not hesitate to try them, you won't be disappointed. read more

Ny Cupcakery did a last minute order for my baby shower that was held yesterday! I was skeptical considering I was never there before. Found them on the internet & took a chance. From the girl taking the order on the phone to the delivery & set to the first bite all I have to say is amazing. Great service! Delish Cupcakes! Friends & family were asking who we used! Ps... I just had one for breakfast #pregoproblems ! Thanks again !!!!! read more

My sister recommended this place to me for my husband's birthday cake and I have to say everyone was amazed how delicious and gorgeous it looked. We had a custom design (in the shape of NY Nets basketball) and it turned out perfect. I also ordered matching cupcakes in different flavors and they were equally as delicious- even a few days later they tasted the same. The cake and cupcakes were so moist, which is especially hard to do with red velvet since it can get dry. Loved it! Prices are great as well! If you book them, I would recommend to do it in person or follow up a few times. I had to call them a couple of times about my order and I'm glad I did since they didn't have my order scheduled for delivery as originally agreed. I will definitely use them again and recommend to others. read more

NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I will be using them a second time for a cake. I had just ordered today, I have to say, the first one i tried was from a kids birthday (cake smash) cake for a photo shoot. The cake itself was great, and the butter cream was perfect. I went ahead and ordered one for my Nephews 1st birthday in May. Curious George Theme, Butter Cream- I couldn't have been happier with it. This time around, I ordered one for a Surprise 50th Birthday, I ordered a custom cake fondant. Looking forward to how it will come out, but I trust they will do a fab job! read more

I've been here numerous times to pick up orders and just as a walk in. Great place and the owner and staff can't be more helpful with the choices I made. Thank you for expanding my waistline!!! Yummy... I'll be calling to set up an appt for a christening!! read more

Very disappointed. So this Saturday would have been the second time I used Ny Cupcakery and I am extremely disappointed. The first time wasn't bad at all but the second time I have to say I am so displeased. I ordered a super Mario cake for my sons 7th birthday which cost me $286. Now I don't mind paying for what I want but for that price it should be absolutely know imperfections what so ever. So I get the cake and the cake looked some what like the photo not as neat as I would I like, but I excepted the imperfections and went on my way. The real problem that I have is the fact that once I got my cake to the party destination literally 45 minutes later and I put the cake on display, the entire cake to toppled over and fell apart. It was so soft that it couldn't even hold its shape. The cake was not exposed to extreme heat temperatures as we drove it In a car in January temp. I mean who pays $286 for a cake that turns to mush bc its to soft to stand on its own. If there cakes require all day refrigeration and must be eaten cold (gross) I should have been told that. Oh and after speaking with one of the party guest who also use to use NY Cupcakery she informed me the same thing happened with her sons lion king cake which is why she never returned... I too will not ever be returning. read more

Thank you so much, for the amazing NY Giants helmet cake for my boyfriends 40th. Not only was it amazing visually, everyone loved the cake. Everyone was asking where I got it. It was delicious and fabulous!!!! I highly suggest the NYcupcakery for all your needs. Thank you again for an amazing experience. read more

Yummy food, great service and location. No complaints! I definitely recommend

I can't say enough about the NY Cupcakery!! I've tried just about everything on the menu and have never been disappointed. The staff is friendly, helpful, and so accommodating. The cupcakes, specialty items and custom cakes are AMAZING!! We won't use anyone else for birthday's (adults and the kids) or the holidays. But don't take my word for it, go in and try for yourself! read more

I ordered a cake for my daughter's 1st bday. The cake was incredible. They made it just like the picture i had given them. I also got mini cupcakes and they were delicious. The staff really took care of my order well. I gave them the cake stands and topper and they executed the setup extremely well. At the party we received a lot of compliments from our guests. Thank you for making our daughter's day very special! read more

NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York