My husband and I got tons of wonderful compliments on our wedding in NYC on January 18, but the ones we heard most often were always about our cake. How beautiful it was, decked out in snowflakes and sparkle and jewel-toned florals, but mostly about how absolutely freaking delicious it was. One friend told me it was the best wedding cake she'd EVER had. And that was all thanks to Joseph at NY Cupcakery! He made every step in the process incredibly easy and efficient, which is exactly what a stressed-out bride needs. Our stunning, decadent cake was the result of one brief phone call and a few text exchanges because Joseph knew exactly what to do when we told him what we wanted. He's a consummate professional and a true artist, and I wish I could eat my wedding cake literally every day. (My husband and his sweet tooth agree.) Do yourself a favor and get your cupcakes, cakes and other treats from NY Cupcakery and nowhere else, literally ever. Thanks, Joseph! read more

This is the best place for your cupcake needs! The owner goes well beyond expectations! Cupcakes are fresh and delicious! Thank you Joe for all your help! Much appreciated! read more

Ok so as of now I only stopped in here for something sweet to bring to my buddies house. So I grabbed a dozen cupcakes, picked out by the wonderful girl working here. I wasn't too picky but I seen her choices and she did a fair share of chocolate and vanilla type cupcakes so i was happy (I'm a huge vanilla fan). So I go hard for desserts, like super picky on my sweets because I love them so much. Welp.....these cupcakes.... blew my tastebuds away!!!!! Moist, cakey, sweet base with a delicious frosting not only on top but in the centers on these classic cup beauties. The icing was skillfully placed on all the different designs and truly gave me a reason to be happy I stopped in here. They were a huge hit, my friends (being from the area) asked where I got them and I had to rave. They do personal cakes with beautiful designs, have a great Instagram that shows it all off and they do all types of treats. I am excited to be able to keep their number in mind to now order something special from them one day. Thanks NY Cupcakery for crushing the cupcake game. I can't wait to stop in and grab some more sweet treats next time I go by my friends. read more

NY Cupcakery - It must have fell out - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Cupcakes are always so good from the local bakery! This is my 2nd time in 4 days. Try the Boston creme and carrot cake! read more

See all

Despite some of the negative reviews, I ordered a custom graduation cake from here. The place was adorable and nicely decorated. The price was very fair considering the other quotes I have obtained. The cake was a total hit and came out amazing! I couldn't have pictured a better cake. Not only was it beautiful, it was delicious. read more

NY Cupcakery - Custom graduation cake. - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Service was great! The man that helped us was friendly and awesome. The cupcakes were delicious. We got jumbo s'mores and a jumbo Oreo. I like mine cold so I put in the fridge overnight. Took a lot not to eat it at nighttime. Not really room to eat there, more of a takeout place. It was worth the ride out to Bellmore. It was very cute read more

Amazing. This is my third time ordering detailing was beautiful and the taste of the cake is amazing

I was very impressed with this place. I looked everywhere for a place that would make alcohol infused cupcakes and they delivered! I wasn't sure they would be able to make it since I ordered just a day before I needed them but everything came out great. I had to provide the alcohol, which I didn't mind and they didn't seem to mind that I brought in 2 different bottles. I ordered cookie dough w/Hennessy and cookies & cream w/Baileys Irish and they were sooooo good! They were a huge hit at the party and the whole process was easier than I expected. The only reason why I'm not giving 5 stars is because it's a small place and I got a little bit of a weird vibe from the girl who initially greeted me. The cupcakes were a little pricey too, $70+ for 24, but they were awesome so definitely worth it! Now that I know they will infuse my orders with alcohol I'll be getting all my cakes from here ! read more

NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Terrible brownies. My pregnant wife was craving brownies a few weeks ago and I tried to surprise her with a good brownie. I live in north Seaford so this wasn't a 2 minute drive. I paid $14 for old, crunchy, crappy brownies. The guy who rang me up acted like they were just made, I also thought it was strange nothing is in the display case. Everything is stored in the back behind a curtain. Won't be back read more

I ordered 2 dozen full sized cupcakes for a party. These were super small. It's almost as if I was charged for full size and received mini cupcakes. The cupcakes were fine, but nothing special. Low rating is based on price/value. read more

NY Cupcakery - Can of cat food and cutie for scale. - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

I send them a picture of what I wanted and they matched it perfectly. My daughter was so surprise how beautifully it was. Kudos to the decorators d bakers they were delicious read more

NY Cupcakery - NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Four stars for Yum! Presentation is a 5 star! People are super and even offered to switch out the icing... said it would just take a sec. but it wouldn't have been chocolate.. If they had more cream cheese based icings it would be a 5 all around.. (not a butter cream fan/hydrogonateds) lol I brought a few minis home, and the chocolate cherry went over huge. Decorating is awesome. read more

See all

Great experience with custom cakes for our daughters first birthday! Called on Valentines Day (Sorry again) and of course they were swamped, but super nice, attentive and great customer service over phone and email. Despite all the factors, they turned the cake around with 2 days notice. Gave them a photo and they matched it exactly. Thanks guys! You made it a great 1!!! read more

NY Cupcakery - Rosette cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

I paid a lot for a custom cake expecting high quality and size. I received a tiny, 5" one-layer cake and the design I requested was completely messed up and you could see where items and lettering had been taken off the cake. Looking homemade would be an understatement. The women I spoke with regarding the issues was extremely unprofessional and would not even offer a discount on the messed up cake. In addition, the cake did not take good and was rubbery. Do NOT recommend. read more

Sadly, I was hoping to have a good experience but was unable to make an order through the Cupcakery. I asked to deliver a dozen cupcakes to a location and was told they do make ddeliveries for small orders. The person on the phone was polite, but I could hear her manager instructing her and telling her what to say. I was hopeful to have done business with them but will have to look for another place to order from. Bummer! :( read more

I ordered a cake for my mother's birthday, went over it in detail what I wanted with the owner who was less than thrilled looking to be taking this order honestly, but I had specific detail on what I wanted (which he wrote) colors (pink and gold) roses dipped in gold looking etc they brought out a white cake! It wasn't ugly bc he added flowers and glitter to it but it wasn't what I asked for. Everyone thought the cake looked beautiful so I let it go but once we tried the cake it was BONE DRY! So so disappointing, and the bottom cake (as it was two tiered) was suppose to be yellow cake with strawberries inside NOT strawberry mousse. So so upset read more

Cupcakes are awesome and reasonably priced. They have many different options and I've never had bad experience here. Definitely recommend.

Friendly service and fresh tasty cupcakes even though we decided to try this place right before they closed. Price wasn't that bad and they did curb site delivery to us due to the covid 19 concerns. I will be back for sure read more

I ordered from this bakery for my husband's birthday party and I was not disappointed. They have a diverse selection of cupcakes and they tasted amazing! The presentation, the flavor, the friendliness of the staff, and the convenience of curbside pick up make this bakery phenomenal. I would highly recommend them for any event. read more

Just okay cupcake bakery in Bellmore didn't have the largest variety of cupcakes or cake pops. It's a tiny little storefront nicely decorated with one small table off to the side if you wish to stay. Bought a half dozen to bring home and some cake pops. The cake pops (vanilla and chocolate) were quite small and had a strange after taste. The cupcakes themselves come in two sizes, kind of small and tiny. Tried a raspberry, chocolate swirl icing chocolate cupcake. Though the icing was nice, the cake part was a bit too dense and dry. The red velvet cupcake was bland and again, dry. It's not expensive, $14.99 for a half dozen cupcakes that weren't that great and service at the counter was patient and helpful. Not sure if I can recommend this place but to each his/ her own I always say. read more

NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

I went there to get some cupcakes, it was so convinient since it was last minute. The guy behind the counter was very helpful and welcoming. I got a mix of cupcakes and all The cupcakes were delicious. read more

Most UNHYGIENIC and DIRTY place to order a cake! The person who made the cake did not wear a mask. My father in law and sister got COVID after eating their cake! Avoid this place at all cost! read more

This bakery has excellent customer service. I needed a custom cake made in less than a week and they made it happen without any issues. Not only was it gorgeous, but it was delicious and affordable! read more

NY Cupcakery - Custom cake - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

Ordered a beautiful tray of mini cupcakes for my daughter's shower! They did a beautiful job for a very fair price. Pretty presentation of delicious cupcakes-will definitely order again!! read more

I should have known better when I walked in, but wanted to support a local business. The place was dirty and had very few cupcakes on display. It did not have the cheerful vibe it had for many years before. The owner was arrogant and annoyed to answer questions and felt like he was doing me a favor assisting with my order. He did not use gloves. When I got home, the cupcakes were turned upside down as they were put in the wrong size box. I immediately called the store & was told they've never received a complaint before mine & had the choice to come back and buy new ones (& then was hung up on). Hard to believe as I spoke to many others in this town who had a similar experience. Fast forward a week later, my credit card number was stolen and had only been used in the last month at one establishment. Coincidence?! read more

Best cupcakes I've ever had. Went in today and the display case was pretty empty, but they had plenty in the back and decorated the cupcakes I wanted to order. Delicious! read more

I cannot day enough great things! I threw my dog a 2nd birthday party today and the pupcake was AMAZING. I ate it too . It was moist, flavorful, and huge hit at my party. I called the store yesterday from a recommendation from a friend. They helped me out in a jam. I will never buy another dog cake from anywhere else. read more

See all

What a disappointment! Went there this morning and wanted to buy some cupcakes for a play date. We walk in and it is so small, not inviting at all. The selection was horrible and nothing looked fresh. There was hardly any variety of cupcakes to choose from. The icing on the cupcake was here we are in a tiny store with one girl behind the counter and she doesn't even say good morning or can I help you? She is just staring blankly at us. We decided to go to the a bakery down the road instead. Don't know how long they have been there but I can't see it making it long term with the selection and the service. read more

So attached are two photos one is a supposed sample of a cupcake centerpiece that this bakery said I would get what actually arrived is the " kindergarten project". It provided my guests bridal shower guests with a chuckle but for what I paid I didn't find it funny. The owner took my deposit and then became unresponsive until a day before. I would advise anyone thinking about using this bakery to find another one . I think the pictures tell the story. Keep in mind the first picture they sent to me as their sample! N read more

NY Cupcakery - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

I WILL NEVER EVER ORDER ANYTHING FROM HER AGAIN!!!!!! I threw my MIL a surprise 65th bday party in Atlantic beach. I live on the north shore and was afraid to order the cake by me for fear that I knew it needed to travel well over an hour to get to the party. So someone told me about NY Cupcakery. I called and ordered a two tier cake for 50 ppl. Over the course of the planning I spoke to the same person there several times and we went over the exact design that I wanted. I even sent some pictures of cakes I liked. I was very specific!!! They gave me a big quote. I knew it was a TON of money but I felt that I was going to blown away w/ the end result so I ordered it anyways. Well yesterday was the party and I can't begin to express how disappointed and angry I am! The cake was huge - could have feed over 150 ppl - and so amateurish - there was no attention to detail at all!!!! It was plain and empty. SO NOT WORTH WHAT THEY CHARGED ME! What happened to all the details we some about? Ive ordered several specialty cakes before and I just love the reaction guests have to an amazing cake. But guess what? Not one person said anything about this cake that I spent a ridiculous amount of money on!!!!!!!!!! There are way too many amazing cake people around. Call Taste in Woodbury, Sweets by Jennie in Plainview, Dortinos in Levittown but DO NOT Order a specialty cake from these people!!!! I know I never will again. The party was Sat. I called immediately to express my disappointment and request a phone call in return. Today is Thursday and I still have not gotten a phone call about my complaint. I own a biz as well and that's just awful customer service! read more

NY Cupcakery - Does this cake look like its worth $350?Yes its huge,I didn't need huge. We were only 50ppl.I wanted OMG AMAZING!Disappointed! - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

We got our daughter's baptism cake from here with nutella and bavarian creme filling, and it was phenomenal. People kept coming up to me at the party, telling me its one of the best cakes they have had. The only small issue with the cake was the writing did not look very professional, but the flowers and other decor was very nice. In addition, we ordered mini cupcakes and cake pops. The mini cupcakes were a huge hit with the children. I loved them- I had the mini hostess cupcake, which was amazing, so good. I could eat 100 of them. The cake pops were the favors. There was a small issue when I went to pick them up and the service was great. They corrected the cake pops and delivered them to our event, which I thought was really outstanding customer service. The only small issue I observed, was that the top of the cake pops were flattened and the cake part is visible, but I guess that is to see what flavor pop it is. A friend of mine, who is somewhat of a cake pop connoisseur, told me that she had never had a cake pop like this, and it was by far, the best one she has ever had, which really says a lot. Overall, our experience w NY Cupcakery was A+ and we will definitely frequent this cakery again. read more

I found this bakery through the reviews on Yelp, and even though the reviews were a little up and down, I decided to give them a try anyway. I ordered 2 dozen custom cupcakes for my brothers bday party and they were AMAZING from the service to the taste! The price was a little steep ($30 per dozen for classic size cupcakes), but definitely worth every bite, plus you can get them filled. They have tons of different fillings you can choose from for a little added bonus once you bite into the middle! Everyone LOVED the cupcakes! i will definitely order from here again, as well as recommend them to all that I know! read more

The staff at this place are all very friendly. The counter girls are helpful and friendly and the owner will stop and chat if he's in. I've called before right when they were about to close and on many occasions, they've offered to stay open just so I can come in for one cupcake. They have a great variety of flavors and are consistently introducing new ones to the mix. They'll also put together whatever you'd like if you don't see what you're looking for. Their cupcakes don't always hit a home run but what they lack/miss in flavor, they make up for in AMAZING customer service. That alone has made them my automatic go to for bakeries. read more

NY Cupcakery - A dozen of their minis. - Bakeries Near Me - Bellmore, New York

See all

Its a shame that they don't know how to make the cake that you ask them to. I had a cake made for my daughters communion, and we wont over the design a few times. I picked it up and it was nothing like I had asked or hoped for. Time was tight with no time to repair it, I left unhappy with the cake. although it was very tasty and fresh, the minis that they had in the case looked as if they were going to fall apart. read more

I'm SOOOOO happy I don't live closer or I'd be 150lbs! I adore their fancy treats! Delish! read more

This place was great. The cake and cupcakes were very moist and not too sweet which was great. Would definitely use them again. The prices were also very reasonable. Very happy read more

Love this place !!! Great cupcakes ! Favorite go to spot in Bellmore. If you love cupcakes, this is the perfect spot for you

This has become my go-to place when I'm asked to bring a dessert somewhere. I get a tray of the mini cupcakes. They have a bout 30 flavor choices so there is something for everyone. They are always a big hit. And, I'm happy to say the owner is an animal lover. I stopped in one day when looking for bake sale items for North Shore Animal League and he happily donated without hesitation! read more

Ordered two dozen mini cupcakes and the free I tried had very little flavor. The girl at the counter needed some more training, she didn't know flavors or prices of anything. Won't be going back. read more

Cute little shop! I got a dog friendly cupcake for my dogs birthday and they even squeezed happy birthday jax on it. They were very friendly and even have 2 frenchies of their own so I automatically like them. Will be back for sure read more