I never noticed this tiny pizza parlor nestled at the end of a small strip center with only 4 shops, but my never ending search for the perfect tomato pie brought me here late last week as the clouds gathered beckoning rain. Although small in stature, the menu is large with the usual suspects to be found in an Italianesque joint that has to move fast and be creative to complete in a universe full of larger predators. When I walked in, I was greeted by a short man (from central casting), wearing a backward baseball cap and speaking with a warm Spanish accent. I asked if there were any slices of tomato pie available. He apologized for not having any at the ready, but immediately offered to make a personal size TP for me if I had 10 minutes to wait. Of course I did. I watched as he retrieved an aluminum dough container, peeled out the slowing rising mass and slapped it onto his cool granite countertop. Fingering, spreading, stretching, spinning, tossing it just enough to get it to the right size without over-manipulating it to toughen the finished product. He laid out the mozza neatly around the disk, and then flicked globs of chunky tomato sauce on top like he was Michelangelo in his abstract period. Satisfied, he slid his wooden long handled pizza mover underneath, turned, and gently shook it off onto the hot oven floor. About 8 minutes later he was walking toward my table with a steaming large plate on which sat my personal Tomato Pie. It was beautiful and its heat wave struck my nose and eyes at the same instant, causing me to catch my breath and shed a small tear. I picked up the first wedge and held it for a moment. It was straight and true, never wavering nor bending under the weight of the topside. The under carriage was beautifully scorched, but not burnt. First bite was amazing. My teeth cut through the tomato and cheese and felt the heat on my upper palate. My lower jaw clamped down, closing mid slice on a crisp firm crackery crust. Magnificent! I had intended to eat half and bring home the rest, but it was so perfectly balanced between taste, texture and eye-rolling excellence, that I knew it would lose something essential if I did not eat the whole thing at that moment. So, I did, and skipped dinner that night. It's hard to tell if this experience could be duplicated, or if I had just stumbled into a apex moment that was beyond everyone's ability to recreate. Regardless, this time was mine, and I offered thanks for having lived this one. read more

See all

UPDATE: so, I don't know if my first pizza from this restaurant was lightening in a bottle, but ordered again this weekend and was SUPER disappointed. Pizza was bland, very little sauce, crust was meh at best. NOT the perfect, heavenly bite of crisp and chew that the first pizza was. Couldn't be more disappointed, didn't even finish one slice. The first pie? Literally couldn't get enough. My guess? Do NOT order on weekends. Stick to Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. Personally I won't risk it again. I will try something else. SUCH A BUMMER! read more

I just started working in the area and a coworker took me here. Nottingham Street seems like an area that time forgot, which all of the strip malls and homes having last been updated in what appears to be 1987. Nottingham Pizza has some great lunch specials for $7-8 that include fries and a soda. I enjoyed my cheesesteak and will definitely stop by here regularly for lunch in the future. read more

After seeing Gerald's review I was dying to try this place that I can easily walk to. But I strayed from his suggestion in 2 ways. Instead of personal size I opted for medium, and instead of eating in, I took out. I will be the first to admit that take out pizza is not my first choice. Even a 2 minute drive can impair the pie. But many people rely on takeout so maybe this review will be of service to them. I selected plain with garlic and waited inside while it was being made and baked. There are only about 4 tables so for most people take out or delivery is the preferred option. At 5 there were no other customers and only 1 phoned in order. My pie came out quickly and as I glanced at it being boxed up I knew this was not their best work. The cheese was not bubbling, but just barely melted, and the outer ridge of crust was not golden brown, but pale. It smelled great from the sauce and fresh garlic. At home I quickly heated up my oven and finished it off in there. Now the cheese was golden bubbly and the crust was gaining color. It was decent but not in Delo's league. Sauce thinner than I like but good flavor, too much cheese, and not crispy enough crust even after further baking. I would advise readers who saw Gerald's review to approach this place in the exact way. Personal pie eaten in house. I may return to do just that, but probably not very soon. 3.25 Yelps read more

After having our food delivered we opened the food and realized it was the wrong food-- another delivery driver pulled in with our real food so I tried to give him the food back and he said he didn't want it back because of COVID-19... 15 minutes later the other delivery driver came back and tried to pick it back up after we had opened it and touched it.. we told him that and he said he would go back and tell the owner-- then the owner called and said they were coming back to pick it up which he did and when he pulled out of our driveway he headed in the opposite direction of their restaurant to go and deliver it to the real customer... absolutely disgusting-- especially during A PANDEMIC! read more

Ordered a hoagie for myself and a bacon cheeseburger for my grandson. Looked at the clock and told my grandson I was going to get in the shower - the food should be here in about 1/2 hour. By the time I got out of the shower, the food was here!!!! Delivery was awesome!! My hoagie tasted exactly like I wanted it to! It was DELICIOUS!! And the provolone cheese on that sandwich... oh the provolone!!!! Spectacular!! If I could give this place 10 stars, I would. read more

Food is positively delicious. Best mozz sticks in Hamilton and the cheese ravioli is perfectly seasoned and cheesy! The zeppoles look hot and fresh. Definitely will be hitting this place up on the weekend. read more

Just ordered from here for the first time. The food was delivered on time, hot and fresh! The driver called to let me know that the food was in the porch. How did I not know about this hidden gem!? Will definitely order again!! read more

Pizza came perfectly hot. Portions for salad were generous. Pizza is deceivingly good... with so many great options around I was not displeased by ordering here. read more

I called Nottingham Pizza and Deli for delivery at 11:30 am on a Monday morning. I ordered a personal pizza with mushrooms ($7.75) and an order of calamari ($9.99) according to the menu. When I asked what the total would be, the person tells me it would be $22.45. I said ok and hung up. About a second later it occurred to me that that didnt sound right so i called back. The same man answered the phone and when I asked if the prices had gone up, he started yelling. He had broken English and it was hard to understand what he was saying but basically he was yelling that the prices were the same, nothing went up, things are expensive, etc. When I asked for him to include a menu with updated prices with my order, he started yelling again about the fact that hes got 10,000 old menus and its too expensive to make new ones. I asked him how he came to that total? It should have been about $18.00 plus tax. He told me that there was a $1.50 delivery charge. That still would only come to $20.48. But, ok. I said that was fine because I just didnt feel like being yelled at anymore. About half an hour later, my food showed up. When i opened the bag that had the calamari in it, i noticed ketchup packets. I thought that was odd. I opened the box and could not believe what I saw. A few pieces of calamari on the bottom left of the box and the rest was FRENCH FRIES and a wilted STEAMING HOT SALAD of lettuce and tomatoes. WHAT IS THIS???? To be clear, ive ordered calamari from this establishment before. It was a big serving of calamari in a styrofoam box with lemon and sauce. NOT this mess. I immediately called and the SAME guy answers the phone. NOW I was mad. I asked him what in the world this disgusting mess was that he sent. He tells me he didnt make it and started yelling and screaming again. I explained to him that the last time I ordered this was not what I got, I didnt want french fries or this disgusting greasy hot salad. He started yelling again about things are expensive. I told him to send that delivery guy back immediately and i wanted my $25.00 back!! He tried to tell me that I would have to go there to bring the food back. I told him that if i didnt have my money back in 30 minutes id get the police involved. $25.00 for food that was misrepresented and disgusting. He yelled dont ever call here again!! This is how people treat customers now?? Needless to say Ill never order from them again. And the delivery guy came to get the food and returned my money 5 minutes later. read more

I used to order from these guys online, and I don't do it any longer. I would order from them late at night when no other place was open and I was looking for a late meal after a long day at work. The last few times I have ordered, they told me that the items I wanted "Were out of stock." A couple times, I pressed and it turns out that they just never updated their online pricing and that certain items have jumped in price. When I told the person on the phone that this happens repeatedly, he was unapologetic and didn't seem to care, even though I ordered from them dozens of times in the past. I eventually canceled my last order, and told them I won't be doing business with them again. AND WHAT DO YOU KNOW, they still charged me anyway!!! Talk about unsavory business practices! I was infuriated when the charge went all the way through and was ready to storm into their store to have a heated argument with the manager/owner, but I realized that based upon who they have hired and permit to represent them, I would be wasting my time. I called my bank and disputed the charge, but I will never, ever order from them again. Steer clear of this place! read more

I was excited to try a new place for pizza and wings. I placed my order through Yelp (Eatstreet - a company I've never had a single issue with.) So in past while using this app to order delivery, I would enter my address first. If it is not within the delivery zone, it tells you and will not let you move any further. You can't even view the menu. Nottingham's did not do this so I made the logical assumption that they had no problem delivering to me. So I place my order and pay (including delivery fee and 30% tip). 10 minutes later I get a call from Nottingham's: "we don't deliver there." He said within 2 miles. I guess it doesn't matter that I'm 1.9 miles away. Ignorant. So I placed an order, paid above and beyond what the food actually cost only to be told that not only will I not get my food, but now I need to contact Eatstreet to get a refund. Now it's 3 to 4 business days for a refund and I'm still hungry. I can't give zero stars? And it's too bad. For all I know the food could be delicious. But I will never know. 7 Brothers Pizza it is! read more

Just found this place! WOW! Gave away all our pots, pans, and cookware, won't be needing them any longer. This place is fast, easy to order with explanations of each dish, and the flavor is excellent. No skimmping on the ingredients, not the cheap cheese like most places try to pass, the garlic on pizza is real, not powder, and always fresh and hot when it gets to my door..... can't write anymore, delivery man is at my door......clear off the couch, Storage Wars and a Nottingham Pizza fresh hot meal is waiting for me! read more

We have had food from here several times and it's always been good. A few times we ate meals inside, one time picked up a breakfast sandwich on the go, and other times we had pizza delivered. The last time we ordered a pizza and picked it up the staff was extremely appreciative of our business during COVID19. read more

I have been ordering pizza from Nottingham pizza for years.... Always good always hot...tonight we were told half hr for delivered pizza.... It took 1 hr and 15 minutes..... After calling they said they were on their way...they showed up 30 mins later when it was 3 mins away... Totally disappointed... Back to Brothers on rt 33 I guess...or Padrinos.... read more

Great takeout at nice prices. The pizza is great and so are the wings. I can't wait to try other things like breakfast perhaps. Close to work and home such a plus...Fast delivery too! read more

Prices were overpriced and the sign above had wrong pricing. Didn't honor the price they presented. Not the best pizza in the area.

The fastest delivery around. The chicken, broccoli Alfredo pizza is very good and they have the best potato skins I've ever had. Can't go wrong with their cheesesteaks, either. read more

Finally found a good, consistent pizza place in Hamilton. Excellent pizza and pretty good French fries. Very affordable and was ready to pick up in a timely fashion. I definitely recommend. I am going to have to try the wings and cheesesteaks next! I read more

This is my go to pizza place, there's more then pizza here too, there's some of the best pasta I've ever tasted and great cheese steaks. There pizzas are great and bring out the best flavors for amazing prices. read more

This place rocks. I've never had a bad experience at this local pizza place. They're sandwiches are huge, their wings are delicious, and they're salads and sandwiches do not disappoint. The pizza is good as well. They're quick to deliver and always very courteous. This is the normal spot on nights that cooking sounds like pulling teeth. read more

Have a very hard time ordering on the phone when the guy answers who speaks practically no English. Their cheesesteaks are pretty good for the most part. We went in for pickup one night and the pizza on display looked awful like it had been there since morning. read more

We ordered pizzas from here last night. They weren't ready when my husband went to go pick up. When he brought them home and we opened them, there was barely any cheese and a handful of miniature pepperoni scattered only on the edge of one side of each pizza. They also charge you twice for a topping on Grubhub. If you use the Slice app and use their coupon, they will go in and recharge your card for more. read more

I used the eat24 application and ordered a cheesesteak,eggplant parm, mozzarela sticks and vodka rigatoni. The eggplant tomato sause was very bland I had to season it up. My son said the cheesteak was good. Mozz sticks about average. The vodka rigatoni wasnt bad. The app said 45min and they were here in 45 min. What I liked most were the prices. Very reasonable. I will defintely use them again read more

Terrible delivery service. Ordered online and was told 30-40 minutes for delivery. After an hour I called to check on my order and was told 20 more minutes because they're busy. .... all I ordered was one pizza... read more

Decent food. I ordered the vodka rig dinner special. It was delivered on time. My only complaint is that my pasta was supposed to come with a salad and instead I received a grilled cheese sandwich. Not even close to a salad. I was disappointed because I was looking forward to the full meal. Such a careless mistake. Also the driver did not follow specified delivery instructions, I asked for him not to ring the doorbell or knock and to call first and what did he do? Ring the doorbell. If my order was correct I would not have been as upset. read more

I ordered a Chicken Soup, Egg & Cheese on a Kaiser Roll, and a Chicken Cheese steak with Peppers and Onions. I placed the order through Yelp. It arrived within 45 minutes. The order did not include lemon and a spoon for the soup, as per my request. The cheese steak was ok, and the soup and egg sandwich were OK. The price was right, but I have definitely had better. read more

Order delivery from here all the time since I found it to be so close. Food is consistently good. Chicken soup is very good as are the calzones and cheese steaks. They also deliver breakfast food all day if available. Gotta love that. read more

Excellent slice deals, 2 slices and a coke for under $6 clean, Friendly staff. Dine in, carry out or delivery. Best philly cheese steak sub around! read more

Super fast delivery....best cheese steak hoagies around....fantastic salads. Best place around. We love your food read more

I've had lunch here several times mainly pizza which has always been tasty. Today my girlfriend brought me home a Philly in Beantown Panini sandwich which was absolutely DELICIOUS !!! OMG this was SO good. Honestly one of the best tasting sandwiches that I've had in a long time.... I think I've just discovered a new favorite. I will be back for another soon ! read more

I ordered a panini but I requested a salad instead of fries. They took the onion, lettuce and tomato that would be used for a sub and tried to pass it off as a "salad" read more

This place is banging and one of Hamilton best kept secrets. Flavorful HOT soups sandwiches pizzas with a secret spice which is awsome. My neighbors and I keep it for ourselves but these guys..they are the real deal!! ;LOVE THEM! read more

Food was great. Huge salads, delicious paninis and homemade soup. Delivery option is a real pleasure. We have family at the rehab close by and at times we have to supplement his food and eat ourselves. Nottingham's makes our lives tolerable. Thank you. read more

We discovered this place shortly after we moved to the area, couldn't have been happier with the first few times we ordered from them but it quickly went downhill, we ordered over the phone for delivery and when 40 min went by and we called back we were told that they "had no record" of our order and it would be another 45 min... ok, we had enjoyed the food the first few times and willing to give it another shot, today my wife ordered in for us while i was on my way home from work, she was told the weather was bad and that the expected time was 45-50 min, she immediately called back and asked to cancel the order, they tried to talk her into to keeping the order and when we explained that it was ok we would most likely order again this weekend she was hung up on... never again with this place, food is great but whoever picks up their phones makes it not worth it... abysmal customer service read more

This place is unreal.. how is it open . Honestly the frozen pizza from the dollar store tastes better.. i feel more nauseous then my pregnant wife.. wow read more

Friendly atmosphere with excellent food, sandwiches and pizza large and priced right, special menu items including delicious wings come with beverage bottles . ONE OF THE BEST PIZZA IN THE AREA, I AM DEFINITELY COMING BACK. read more

I have been living in the Hamilton area for a year now and I have to say this is by far my favorite place to order from. When I first started going to Nottingham there was a new manager took over. I had not been impressed until the new management pumped new life into this establishment. I give Nottingham a five because for a hole in the wall deli, it is great! They are quick, nice, and the good has almost always been really good. Although calling in an order can be a little challenging at times, they always go out of their way to accommodate. This has become our go to for pizza but their lunch deals are great also. I also have to praise their salads. I have always been a meat and potatoes kind of guy so even suggesting a salad somewhere is a first for me, but their grilled chicken with house dressing is great! huge portion, great chicken and plenty of veggies, not just a bunch of lettuce. If you haven't given Nottingham a chance, or its been awhile, I suggest placing an order with them. enjoy! read more