The most incredible pie. We went large tomato pie. No tables. No chairs. No BS. The best pizza in NJ. Yes. All of the usual suspects nearby have been frequented and this place beats the 2nd best in the state which is down the street. iykyk read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

Got the fajita corleone. There's no sauce at all. I only asked for the meat and hot peppers. Got everything else. But the sauce! What a waste of a big pizza. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

I'm at about 3.5 stars for the Corleone pie I recently had here. It's similar to a Sicilian but thinner, possibly Detroit size. The sauce was robust and not sweet, nice cheese to sauce ratio too. I just had it with fresh garlic that seemed to be skimped on, but I liked it overall. As another reviewer pointed out, this is strictly takeout unless you want to stand outside. With that caveat I might return to try a regular or specialty slice, probably not a whole pie place for me. Service was fine. read more

My son and I took a roadie here to see if it was worth the TT hype. It's a "to go" joint primarily; however, there is a small counter. No Sally, but staff was great. Got a meat lover's side slice and a margherita corner slice to eat while we waited for a pie to go. Great crust, unique taste. Quite different from what we get north of there. We will definitely hit this place up next time we are in the area. read more

See all

This is the first time I've ever given Pizza Grill a less than sterling review. We paid $10.50 for three extra toppings, and they were skimpy skimpy and skimpy. read more

Great wings and order was ready when I got there The pizza was very good too as we got the speciality pie that they recommended read more

We used to love Marcello's Pizza-Grill and ordered from here at least once a month. But my son is allergic to wheat so I'm no longer supporting a place that considers food allergies a big joke. Gennaro's makes a great gluten free pizza and they're not going to threaten to beat you up if you ask for it. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - Apparently if you ask for gluten free you're going to get beat up here? I guess we'll have to stick with Gennaro's. - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

Sally slices!!, We had a blast and the best experience from the second we walked in. Got there right when they opened, so we were able to watch them still making some of the pizzas. The inside is fairly small with no seating, but they do have standing counter top with lots of pictures. We were greeted by Sally's sister Gabriella who was as sweet as pie! We talked to her for a half hour before we even ordered our pizza. What a sweetheart! Then we finally looked over to the delicious varieties that Marcello's offered. Asked what she recommended and got those. It did not disappoint! Fresh and hot pizza. Absolutely delicious! Ingredients were top of the line and the dough is tasty and perfectly cooked! While we were indulging Mr slices walked right in. We were standing at the counter top right by the door. We went up to him and talked to him. He was very humble and made us feel like family! 100% recommend!! read more

See all

When you strip away the PR hype and histrionics from Marcello's, you're still left with a very tasty Sicilian pie. Nice crust and generous toppings are the cost of entry and the pizza makers here don't disappoint. Is it the "best pizza in NJ" as their many advocates would have you believe. Well, when I get around to trying every pizza in NJ, I'll let you know. Otherwise, if you're in the mood for some terrific Sicilian Marcello's is a required stop on your journey. Five easy stars. read more

Takeout only but the pizza is always great, especially the Corleone with ingredients sourced from Sicily!! Great service and always friendly! Highly recommend. read more

Definitely worth the hype! Great pizza. Perfect crust...just enough crunch and doughiness. Sauce was great. Service is top notch! Greeted with smiles from beginning to end. Was checked to make sure I was okay and asked "hows the pizza"....which is always encouraging to see/hear...especially in the service industry. Prices are reasonable...paid $5.50 for a corner slice and can of soda. Their current menu prices are very reasonable, given the current prices/cost of food in general. I was very happy to see every single employee hustling...making food, taking orders, other preparation. Small but adequate parking lot shared with a few other stores. I hope to return when I am in the area again to try some other slices/items. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - a man giving a thumbs up - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

See all

Placed an order a day ahead of time to be delivered at 7pm, and the restaurant canceled the order over an hour after it was supposed to be delivered over 24 hours after the order was placed. This place is extremely unreliable do not order from this place. read more

So my coworkers are always ordering from here and I usually cook so I typically bring my own food from home. The one time I decide to order along with them there's hair in my food, so clearly no one is wearing a hair tie or net. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

See all

Stopped into the home of the famous Sally slices! Wanted to try the Corleone that they are known for. Was extremely surprised that how light this was. I was figuring it to be like a Sicilian, but it is much lighter. I would definitely choose the corners, as that is where all the well done melted cheese is crusted onto the edges. Very good sauce, and very good ratio of cheese to sauce. The flavors just great! I tried the pepperoni, and the pepperoni with hot honey. The one with hot honey gave it a sweet first bite and then a little bit of heat after you finish chewing. So good! Even though the restaurant was extremely busy, Sally slices was able to take a few seconds out to say hi. read more

See all

Delicious chicken piccata, pizza and chicken soup.. Great service and staff also. They are always on time with our orders and are very cordial read more

his sauce comes from a can. most disgusting pizza . Customer service is poor but idk too much about that. The guy behind the counter gave my wife the creepy feeling by the way he was looking at her. This is about the food though. Not worth $6 even. I'll go other places for my pizza. read more

My family and I came to New Jersey to vacation and I made the suggestion to try Marcello's. This was the best decision ever. Walking in, there are pictures everywhere on the walls of Sallyslices from TikTok. I spoke with a delivery guy who was absolutely honest that the wait was well worth it. I picked up the Margherita Corleone which it was absolutely amazing. You can tell there is a lot of heart and soul in the flavor of the pizza. My fiance had the Fettuccini Alfredo and I tried a bite which I wished I had a small plate of with the pizza. I highly recommend this place for the amazing food and the friendly service. My only wish is can you bring a shop to South Carolina?? My only regret is that I didn't get to meet the TikTok star. To the staff and more, thank you for making my day with your amazing food. read more

See all

Amazing pizza. Definitely worth trying. The staff was very friendly. The place was clean.

My family and I have been coming here for more than a decade because our office was nearby and now we live around the corner. Food and service are great. This time we had a plain Corleone pizza, appetizer sampler, and garlic knots. Buffalo. read more

Went there for family lunch 7 of us. We sat in the open air part of the restaurant. 1 star great surroundings partial opened roof fresh air and great decor with plants. 2 stars our server was very knowledgeable about the menu gave recommendations if asked. Answered all questions perfectly. I was impressed. 3rd star We ordered 3 appetizers arancini, calmari and clams casino we shared. There arancini was really good, calamari above and clams casino was good to. Everyone enjoy tasting. For me it's fun to share. 4 star 3 different flat breads were ordered. Dad had Trenton style he was born in Trenton and he's tough. He said its really good but not like old school tomato pie. My Sister had the Bella she loved it. My brother in-law had the Diablo spicy so it took him some time to used to the long hot pieces but he killed the whole thing. 5 star I eat light at lunch I had the spinach salad with bacon and blue cheese it came with a dressing that was like a cross between honey mustard and balsamic. Cleaned my plate. My Son had Chicken Parm sandwich I didn't taste it but bread was toasted plenty of cheese looked tempting to me. HAHA Mon had some type of Lobster Ravioli but had a spin on it I think some citrus like orange she ate it all. We didn't leave anything left over including the bread at the beginning. That never happens. And the prices were not outrageous. So i would give it 6 stars if I could. It's a great place for a nice lunch. We all had a very nice time. It checked all the boxes. read more

Great deep dish pizza! Probably the best pizza I've had when visiting the east coast.

We came across this pizzeria in Hamilton. We love tomato pies and Trenton style pizzas, so we gave it a try. This place is very small, they have a little area with a counter top to eat some slices but basically they are more of a take out place. In any event we ordered the Coreleone pizza and it was delicious! We have been back several times and took some pies back home and put in our freezer. It's a bit of a ride for us but well worth the trip. If your in the area definitely try the Coreleone Pizza, you will not be disappointed. I will definitely return! read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - a man standing in front of a window - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

See all

My husband and I have been trying a different local pizza place every Friday, and we recently went to Marcello's. First, know that it is takeout only (no dining room.) It is located in a very unassuming strip mall. We got a pizza and a caprese salad. We loved the pizza; very fresh-tasting ingredients and the crust was baked perfectly. The caprese salad could have been better. The tomatoes were not very flavorful. But, go for the pizza and check it out! read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - outside - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

See all

The pizza was beyond outstanding, simply delicious. We also purchased the sauce which was mouthwatering. I can't recommend this pizzeria enough. After you have eaten the food you'll know it's not your everyday pizzeria...there is love put in it. Brian and Jeannie S. read more

Always delish when we order from here! Their Corleone pizza is really good- Sally's favorite, which is pepperoni and hot honey, is our go to and each piece is fantastic! The crust has a nice crispy crunch to it. The pasta dishes are also really good. The chicken pastina soup is also fantastic and was perfect side during the winter months and cold season. read more

Seen this pizza all over TikTok & had to give it a try when visiting my brother and his fiancé in Jersey. The staff was friendly for takeout, atmosphere inside was welcoming, wait was not bad, and taste was delicious- crust was perfect & pizza was garlicky (my fave). Can't wait to try the square cut next time in nearby. We drove from Marcello's about 30-40 minutes home and pizza was still warm. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - Corleone Pizza Cheese / Half Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

See all

Had a few slices with the family along with some garlic knots. Will be back. Was always fan of this type of pizza. A few places in NYC that have this. Nice and crisp also. Weird thing was that i came in around 12:15 on a saturday. There were only a few slices left. They didn't seem to be in a hurry to be making more. Was a little skeptical as the slices looked a little bit like they were sitting there for a while but after a few moments in their rotating oven, excellent slice. Good sauce and good mutz. Sal took care of us. He didn't seem his jovial self as he is in his TikTok's. All good tho. read more

Absolutely amazing, the manager and staff were awesome. The manager went out of his way to make sure we were happy and satisfied; he even took the time to play with my little nephew. Also, the managers playlist was totally vibing read more

On a road trip-bucket list from California to the east coast and decided to drop in on Sally and have some of his pizza. We loved it and now back home missing it so we jumped on the band wagon and are waiting for our frozen pizza delivery now.. read more

So my brother did a takeout because everyone was too lazy to cook on Sunday and he ordered the Corleone pizza with onions as well as the veggie pizza and garlic bread with cheese. Hands down I enjoyed the Corleone pizza more than the thin crust veggie pizza! The Corleone pizza is square shaped cut and it's basically sicilian but a little thin. It's definitely different than your normal sicilian but very tasty! I wouldn't say the bestest pizza ever but it was good! Will order and try different pizzas from here. read more

See all

Good pizza, unique corleone style pizza that definitely lives up to the hype of "Sally-Slices".

Great Crispy crust and very flavorful pizza. Definitely worth the trip. If you are in the area give it a try. read more

So in the ever so crowded pizza space in Mercer County/Hamilton, NJ......it is tough to distinguish your business/pizza, and this place has done it! Why haven't I been here before? Well when you open you place and call it "Pizza Gill.com".....I have had a stigma in my head that it was a cheap attempt to create a non-chain online ordering pizzeria "back in the day." (good news is that this name has been dropped, and it is called "Marcello's Pizza-Grill") So why did I give this a shot? Solid reviews on Yelp- specifically about the "Corleone" style pizza. If you are asking, what distinguishes it? Well think if a sicilian pizza (in terms of shape/size) crossed paths with a Chicago deep dish (in terms of the bottom/crust texture).....you get something unique vs. the (2) norms in this area (tomato or "normal" pizzeria pies). This is not a sit down restaurant, instead- clearly geared for take-out. I'll assume they do well, based on the large amount of staff on hand/amount of pies they looked to be making. Would I come back for their pizza? (even though it isn't directly in my "neighborhood").....you bet! Give this "Corleone" style pizza a shot! read more

Corleone was focaccia bleh Ellis frozen had more taste this was all hype very disappointing and a waste of 65 dollars for two pies and a salad read more

Disappointing. Was hoping for so much more after all the hype about the Corleone. Everyone was super friendly but the pizza was mediocre at best. read more

I took the hour and a half drive to experience this TikTok sensation. Sal took care of us at the pizza counter. We knew better so we ordered the best of both worlds- a corner and a side. It was tasty. Sal and his boys run a nice shop and a friendly and upbeat. Not a lot of seating inside but they did offer the ledge outside to dine at. If you're in the area I would stop by...if not watch the TikTok. read more

Marcello's Pizza-Grill - A corner and a side! - Pizza Near Me - Hamilton, New Jersey

Da best Sicilian style ANYWHERE. PERIOD. The chee is heavenly, the pepperoni is off the chain... Da' crust... Let's discuss. That crust is the platform where angles audition to St. Pete. Always perfect. Never sloppy floppy. N-E-V-E-R!! YOU GOTTA TRY IT!! read more

Not sure what all the TikTok hype is about but the corleone is just ok. Very doughy and a bit dry. The people behind the counter are friendly but there are much better places in the area for pizza. You have Delorenzos, Papa's, Palermo's, Slice of Brooklyn and even Jojo's to name a few. If you're looking for good football pizza, Nonnos or Joey's will hit the spot. read more

Good pizza at a great price. I prefer maninos but this place is good as well. Not a fan of the corleone. I stick with the regular pies.

Awesome pizza! The best!! Went because of the viral tik tok but we will be back whenever we are visiting family again..came from California Never had the pizza quite like that! Truly top 10 pizza of all time read more