On days when I want to send special mail to family or friends, this place is right close to the local post office. They sure get a good crowd most of the time I've been there. Their service is fast, friendly, and heat up sandwiches pretty quickly. To be Frank, however, the tomato caprece taste can feel capricious when you know you can do the same at home, so when we go somewhere: it's nice to expect something a bit more authentic and flavorful: which goes to show that rushing anything too much, especially a beloved sandwich that they also make in Barnes and Nobles quickly --can take away from the flavor--and that goes with friendship and family relationships, as well. To do a good thing, people fix what is there. To do a great thing, cooks, or people in general, try new ways to make the classic even better. The tables and decor, however, are nice and homey. read more

Ended up here because the place around the corner was closed on a Tuesday. Prices were reasonable and they even had ice cream. read more

Vito's Pizza - Slice and tiramisu gelato - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

should have a talk with your staff about how to take phone orders. talking with others instead of listening me might have helped. I think Kayla needs some retraining! read more

Tortellini was disintegrating and broth was watery. I'm never impressed with the soups here. read more

Vito's Pizza - Chicken Tortellini Soup - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Food was good but website/online ordering has a lot to be desired. Ordered delivery for lunch through online ordering portal. Inaccurate time for delivery provided. Staff indicated it was a known issue and they just lived with it. Feels counter intuitive in a customer service industry to not prioritize getting the system adjusted to provide accurate expectations to client. Timing was off significantly (greater than 20 minutes). Staff was friendly in attempting to address my concern. read more

The people are all very kind and patient. The food does not take long to get. It's very comfortable to sit around with friends and eat at. The food isn't the best but if greasy or cheese is your thing- jump right on in! read more

Today I had the pleasure of visiting Vito's with co workers for lunch and I have to say that from the second I walked in to the second I walked out I was treated with exceptional professionalism and service. As I approached the counter I was met with a bright smile from a young worker. She proceeded to ask what I would like and took my order while maintaining a smile. This is important and I believe she knew it. I ordered a small meatlover calzone that was prepared to the T. The dough was cooked to a perfect crisp which in turn helped all interior ingredients reach the perfect temperature for a perfect bite everytime. Thank you much! To the cooks we appreciate you guys and girls for the hrs spent in making sure all food is prepared to satisfaction EVERYTIME. Consistency is key! I am excited about my new hat purchase. The color is perfect. Thank you Vitos for being a great example of how day to day food service business should run. I hope to see you all again. Humbly Submitted, Andre Watts - Beigene read more

Vito's Pizza - Vito Merch (Grab a few) Holidays are near! - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Very good pizza. Not the best and not the worst. The large pie is more like a medium. The sauce is a bit on the sweeter side and the crust is thin and crispy. They have other options on the menu that are all decent as well. You really can't go wrong with anything here. When I'm in the area it's my go to place but nothing to go out of the way for. read more

See all

When I moved back to Lawrenceville, the search was on to find a great pizza place. Vito's seemed to fit the bill. Lately, the quality of the pizza has gone down hill. Last night, we picked up what was basically a flat cardboard circle sprinkled with a bit of cheese and tomato sauce. This is completely unacceptable. I should have looked at it, but I was coming back from a trip and the family was hungry. We called it in, picked it up, and came home to this. I'm afraid the search is back on for a good pie. read more

Vito's Pizza - Cardboard circle sprinkled with cheese and tomato sauce.... - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

See all

We've been ordering from Vito's for 20 years and have always been happy, however tonight will be the last time. We placed an order for a pepperoni pie, a Brooklyn pie, and a broccoli white pie. What we received was a plain pie, a Brooklyn pie and a broccoli white pie. We called to let them know and the person who answered the phone apologized for the mistake and asked if we wanted a refund or a replacement pie. Since it was late and the game was already on, we just asked for a refund. A few minutes later, we get a call from someone else at Vito's saying their policy is to not refund so they could either send us pepperoni to put on the pie ourselves (!!) or a whole new pie. After some back and forth, we agreed to just take the new pie. In the meantime, which was 30min, my children who were waiting for the pepperoni ate some of the plain slices. At 840, the doorbell rang and the driver handed over the pepperoni pizza and said "my boss wants the other pie back" to which my husband responded "the kids were hungry so they started eating". The driver shook his head and walked away. What a disgusting display from a so-called neighborhood pizzeria. First of all, why didn't the person on the phone say they wanted the other pie back? Secondly, what were they going to do with the other pie? Was it going to go to someone else's house who ordered a plain? Might I add, this was the second time we ordered from here TODAY alone. Good luck with that customer service! read more

I've been going to Vito's for 30 years. They make the best Brooklyn pie ever. Service is good. It's a small cozy pizza restaurant in downtown Pennington. read more

Pizza is very good and fresh and is not to oily. Would defiantly recommend.Also the service is amazing they are nice and get the food out quick and smooth with no problems. read more

Best Traditional Pizza Around! Vito's pizza is consistently delicious and the staff is top notch. They offer a few custom pies like buff chicken and French frie pies which are awesome! If you're not in the mood for pizza you can certainly fill yourself up with some super tasty sandwiches and salads! My favorite sandwich is the Chicken Med Sandwich! Last but not least you should also be sure to try a cheesesteak! Philly is proud of you Vito! Thanks for the good times and great food Vito's Pizza!!! Ps the ambiance is straight up Jersey Pizza Place! read more

I was meeting some friends for a bike ride on a cold January Sunday afternoon. After the ride, we stopped in Vito's for quick lunch. Vito's is clean and pleasant inside and has a lot of seating. The staff was very friendly and efficient. I was pretty hungry and just went with two slices of the plain cheese pizza. The pizza had very good flavors and the crust was on the thinner side and crispy. It was a not the best pizza I have ever have ever eaten, but still very, very solid. Vito's has hot and cold sandwiches and some salads. It is a really good place to stop by when your in the area and want something fast but decent. Pennington is also a cool little town. 3.5 star for Vitos. read more

Vito's Pizza - Interior - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

See all

Vito's Pizza at the corner of N. Main and W. Delaware in the heart of Pennington, NJ, looks nice enough and has friendly staff, but it failed to make a good first impression. I stopped in for a light dinner before crossing the river to home in Bucks. Great location and a decent layout for a pizza parlor. I just wanted to try their eggplant parmesan submarine and a slice of regular pie as an app. I found a seat at a small table in the dining room, and watched families coming in and out. Seemed like a wholesome crowd. I could see why Vito's was a popular place. It just may not have been my night, or I made bad choices, but my food wasn't what I hoped. The slice had good firm crust and a balance of sauce and cheese, but was overly salty. The eggplant looked great on the plate, with lots of melted parmesan cheese and red gravy atop that, all cradled in a toasted torpedo roll. My approach to big sammies is to go at them with fork and knife first, to clearly taste the contents and separately chew on the bread afterwards. I found the sliced nightshade heavily breaded to a thickness greater than the encased eggplant. Although sauteed, the coating had little taste, yet overwhelmed the intended star of the show. I couldn't taste anything but sauce and cheese. I took a bite of the roll. It was average, and not worth the calories. I felt the heaviness in my stomach for hours, despite consuming only half. Inauspicious beginnings. read more

See all

A good solid slice of New York style pizza! Conveniently located right in the heart of Pennington, it's definitely one of my favorites in the area. In addition to standard NY style, they also have a few other styles, such as Sicilian and Chicago style. The "Brooklyn" (Parmesan, Fresh Mozzarella, Basil, Crushed Tomato Sauce) is a favorite of friends of mine. You definitely can't go wrong with Vito's! read more

What an establishment. I mean WHAT an establishment. I love establishments, and this has gotta be one of the best. -Neis the Prius read more

This is my favorite steakhouse in town, I love to have my meal there at anytime... I want to be with my friends and family here it's really a wonderful place to be read more

Vito's Pizza - Hamburger is always my favorite - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Will glady drive 25 minutes from New Hope to get Vito's pizza. One of my favorites is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza. Thinly sliced chicken, mozzarella, bleu cheese and the oh so tangy Buffalo sauce. I prefer their Plain to any other pizza in the area too. It's what I think of when I think "pizza party". Cheesy goodness. If you are there to order slices, get the Buffalo French Fry. French fries are coated in Buffalo sauce then spread across the pizza and topped with bacon, cheddar cheese and ranch dressing. If this combination was on a shoe, I'd eat it. Their sandwiches are really good too. My go to is the Vodka Chicken. It's topped with mushrooms and Swiss cheese, smothered in vodka sauce - served in a fresh, house made focaccia. Overall, the food is fresh and palatable, so I keep coming back for more. read more

I love their Brooklyn pizza. Is like a margarita do not get confused! I do not have an opinion about the rest of their menu; because I just have try their pizzas. read more

Great sandwiches! Very fresh and tastes amazing. Loved it, and a definite must try! Enjoyed the mozzarella sticks as well.

Here's the deal. Great pizza, no question about that. However I was put off by them using their hands for everything without washing... taking money, credit cards, back to picking up slices with bare hands, putting in oven... touching their mask, taking more cash, hands right back to touching the pizza without washing or hand sanitizer. Cmon Vitos... you can do better than this. I won't be back. read more

Vito's grew up with me, or rather I with it. When I was younger, Vito's was always a treat after a long day of school. Barely able to peer over the counter, a couple of slices of cheese pizza and powdered sugar zeppoles were perfect. Covered in white stickiness, and grease stains painted on my clothes - Vito's was the best. A couple of years later, growing into myself and everything else - Vito's was the cool hang out. I'd cram into a booth and people watch with friends. I'd also by this point, picked up the girly habit of blotting off the grease of my pizza with a napkin. Grease soaked napkins piled next to my vegetable pizza and water - Vito's still hit the spot. Spring break from College; when I returned to visit my family - Vito's was the obvious choice, as soon as I got of the plane. Their gourmet buffalo chicken pizza, topped with blue cheese dressing - and lots of garlic was a new hit. The menu had definitely expanded alot since elementary school, as well as Vitos. No more napkin blotting. Bootilicious blared on the radio, as I ate. Years later, a college graduate - a trip to Vito's would be the result of a lost Poker game. Armed with 200 dimes; - I traipsed down to Vito's, intending to purchase a large pepperoni pizza - for the Poker Champion - my brother Owen. The same pizza guys were there. There were even faces I recognized from middle school retrieving their take-out. It was all so strange and unfamiliar, yet strangely so familiar. And then, as I basked in the nostalgia of it all, I was promptly awakened by a thick Italian accent: "Excuse me miss - I'm cool with the 200 dimes and all; but you're short 34 cents." Damn you Owen. No longer covered in powdered sugar - but still looking like an A$$ at good ole Vito's. read more

Whenever I am in Hopewell I have pizza at Vitos! Vitos is, in my opinion the flagship pizza place of the town. They have excellent Grandmas/Old Fashion pizza, with the thick slice and sauce on top of the cheese. Tried their rice balls, so delicious! And the prosciutto sandwich, with cheese, spinach onions and balsamic, oh, you would think you have died and gone to Parma! The place can get busy for lunch and taken over by highschool crowd, but dont let that stop you from going. They expanded their building a while back and can handle a crowd. 2017-update, still amazingly consistent. Recently I've really enjoyed the Jersey Strong salad. A gigantic Jersey tomato and cucumber salad with oregano, Croutons and small cubes of Parmesan. I could eat one of these every day of the summer! read more

Came here on a recommendation from a friend who is a Pennington-ite? I liked the atmosphere of Vito's. It was comfy and cozy. I also ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich on my friend's recommendation. The sandwiches they have are served on their own baked ciabatta bread. Vito's also has many different types of pizza from Sicilian to Chicago Deep Dish. The sandwich took a bit to get made, but it was probably due to the amount of phone-in orders since I got there just before lunch. The sandwich was delicious. Soft, tender, juicy chicken, yummy cheese, creamy blue cheese, moderate spiciness, and a tasty ciabatta roll. I'm definitely coming back here again if I happen to be around. I wanted to try some of the pizza since it looked really good but I went with my friend's recommendation. read more

Vito's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

I called to have a large order delivered last minute on Christmas Eve. They were super nice and accommodating. Can't say enough good things about Vito's! I highly recommend giving them a shot. read more

The cheese pizza is really great because of the way it is made. The crust gets better with age! Great fresh and also keeps well. This is our favorite pizza place. The whole family loves it and we order every week. They deliver locally too! read more

I almost didn't come to Vito's because I was tired and it seemed like a long drive from Ewing. Boy am I glad I did. Very friendly staff to start with. They were busy and I was staring at the menu trying to figure out what I wanted. No one rushed me. The person behind the counter answered all my questions, gave me recommendations, and let me take my time. The salad was just what I needed after eating road food for the past couple of days. The pizza was terrific. Great combinations for toppings. The only thing that could have made it better would have been if it came from a brick oven. That is the only reason I didn't give them 5-stars. If I could do four and a half I would. Lastly, it had that small town local pizza joint feel. I swear the counter staff knew everyone that walked through the door. Great little town too. I wish I could have spent more time in town to explore. read more

Vito's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

I've known Nate since I was a teenager going into the Hamilton Square shop. I remember when he opened the shop at Kings Fairground and then Pennington. I hope Nate and the family are well. I don't know if the heavy set kid working there today is part of the family or just a worker, but his customer service sucks. My wife and I were waiting on sandwiches. I was eating a slice of pizza. I asked this kid if they could bring the sandwiches outside because we wanted to sit outside. He tells me they'll leave them on the counter. I wasn't in the mood to be confrontational, so I let it slide. I left a $5.00 tip when I paid the bill. For what? So they could do their job and make our food? Don't be an idiot kid. Get over your entitled self and treat the customers that give you a living the way they should be treated. read more

Vito's is probably the most consistent slice in the Pennington area. While not the best, it's always there and almost always the same exact slice every time. That slice is pretty consistently good too and I would call it the best ny style slice in the area read more

This resturaunt is completely amazing, i love their pizza and garlic knots!! They make my whole familly happy!

Rating: 3.5/5. The pepperoni in addition to the sausage and peppers slices were delicious. All ingredients were fresh. The crust was thin and crispy. If the inside of the crust were to be more chewy, it would have been perfect. read more

I mean it's Vito's it's great pizza from jersey. The buffalo chicken fingers are great!

Best pizza in the area! Sicilian, traditional, or grandmas style, you can't go wrong. I've tried all of the pizzas in the area, and this is a must visit. Very addicting! read more

First time here this weekend. I had HALF of Italian cheesesteak, an order of fries and a beverage. I think I paid $12 after tax. It wasn't just ok. It was wonderful. It was enormous. Sandwich was piping hot. Bread was toasty. Meat was lean and plentiful. Fries were generous and crispy (those were not quite hot so I assume the timing of my two food items could have been better- hence the absence of a fifth star). I will be trying other things on the menu anytime I find myself close to Pennington anytime remotely close to a mealtime. read more

Fastest service I've ever seen! Pizza is piping hot from the oven because it moves so fast. Crust is a 10. Sauce is a 9. Toppings are plentiful. Really can't say more, you just have to try it . read more

Vito's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Vito's Pizza is located on Main Street in the heart of Pennington. I went to school at the public schools in Pennington and often visited Vito's for a quick slice of pizza after-school with friends or before I started my part-time after-school job in town. Their pizza is delicious, but very oily. A friend of mine used to always blot her slices of pizza with napkins to absorb all of the excess oil before eating. read more

Very fast home delivery. Price is good. Specialty pies rock. They have so much to pick from. I love going in and grabbing a few different slices. Vito's Pizza is located on Main Street in the heart of Pennington I can only hope that they change their picture on this listing. That is a paper plate with a sandwich just thrown on it. Come on even McDonalds stages food. Just trying to help read more

I TAKE OUT Great Brooklyn Pizza ! Also good salads. Owner very congenial,

The food and service were basically good, but very disappointed that the girl handled our pizza slices without gloves or utensils. I should have thought more quickly and asked her to put them back and get other ones properly but didn't. I spoke my concern to several staff on leaving, but it didn't seem to register. Planning on phoning the manager today to express my thoughts and ask his input, suggesting a possible phone call to the health department. read more