Would highly recommend-- the simple outside appearance leads into a delicious wonderland; the food is insanely good. Firstly, in assessing their basic cheese pizza quality compared to 27+ local pizzerias, they scored #1, due to their chewy crust, gooey cheese, and satisfying overall experience. Secondly, they have a range of iconic types of pizza, such as Tortellini Alfredo, my personal favorite. Lastly, their pastas are also tasty and have worked well for catering. A must go! read more

See all

Quite simply, their pizza is amazing. Light, crispy, and tasty. It is what you expect from Jersey pizza. I've had some of their dinners such as their broccoli rabe and chicken parm and it's always on point. Service is always friendly and quick. Highly recommend to anyone to try a slice or three there! read more

Always on point. Good pizza every time. Delivery is always very quick and hot. Thank you

Love the food, service, and serving size . Nice and clean. The pasta is amazing and our waitress Berta was so warm and friendly as well as the people at the pizza counter. Best Italian place around and now they even have a bit of Spanish food as well if you're in the mood. BYOB and enjoy!! read more

Pennington Pizza Grill - Double birthday celebration - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Amazing pizza every time! We don't normally sit in to eat but I have seen them renovate the interior to be a nice calm space with comfy booths. Service is always great. HIGHLY recommend the Brooklyn pie! read more

Best pizza in the area, hands down. Consistently good. Other pizza places in the area aren't bad but Pennington has the best flavor. We've had their mozzarella sticks and calzones from here too, also yummy. Can't speak on their pastas or salads, need to try. They do a heart shaped pizza for our kids for Valentines Day, so cute. Definitely recommend. Easy to get to on 31. read more

Pennington Pizza Grill - a heart shaped cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Tried the buffalo chicken pizza and the pepperoni pie here. I was not a fan of the buffalo chicken it didn't have a lot of buffalo sauce and I've had better elsewhere. The pepperoni pie was really great though and I'm a big fan. Service here was good the cashier was nice. Ambiance is similar to that of a classic pizza joint. read more

Great food. Great service. Fast delivery. Try the Old Fashion Traditional. Lots of tomato sauce and flavor. Like an old Trenton tomato pie. It's the best. Great sandwiches also. read more

Is there a zero star? Literally the worst pizza I've ever had. Soupy sauce , congealed cheese, tasteless crust. Toppings literally slid off the crust it was so wet. Got my order wrong. Garbage pizza. Stay far away. read more

Pennington Pizza Grill - A soupy, gloppy disaster - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Ordered $50 worth of chicken sandwiches for some ppl doing work at my house and for myself. I wasted too much time with an employee who had great difficulty getting my 3 digit house number right. After that I asked for 5 chicken club sandwiches, L/T/mayo. Order arrived, the chicken in the sandwiches was borderline burnt and bone dry. No mayo on any of them. Dryest sandwiches honestly i ever had also the others eating them were very dissappointed. How does a restaurant owner serve food that badly prepared to the local people in the area? Save your $$ WAYY better food right around the corner. Most money I ever spent on bad food across the board. Myself nor the 5 other people who partook in that order will 100% never eat here again. read more

For a little pizza joint you wont be disappointed....pizza is gourmet to classic and delicious. The food is very very hood and generous to say the least. Service is always warm and attentive. Except that Your drinks can add a bit to the bill i have nothing but compliments. My go-to place when I'm in the area. read more

worst pizza place in pennington!!!!!!!!!!!!!!do not order from this place they messed up our order today and the ownwer said its our fault pizza is cold did not get our ff but it my fault!!!!! then blames it on the driver well i worked in a pizza place the cooks get the delivery ready not the driver so 2 lies!!!! never again and we have been ordering from here for a long time but there is no way a ownwer is going to tell me its my fault so i asked for my money back and he say ok ok i give you back (cuz they do not speak good english, thats the 1st problom!!!!! i asked for the trans number and he say i return i return no you did not but its ok god will get you you pos!!!!! i guess you need the 35$ more then i do!!!!! read more

Pennington Pizza has ALWAYS had excellent pizza, sandwiches, and prepared dishes. The Brooklyn pizza is delicious. Eggplant, cheesesteak, & tortellini pizza are some of our family favorites. The soups are always fresh & hearty. The pasta & meat dishes are plentiful and served with soup or salad and amazing fresh made rolls!! This is a local family owned business that we always bring our out-of- town guests to so they can experience AWESOME Italian food. Thanks P-Pizza!! read more

Ordered the Brooklyn Pie which is a bit pricier due to it having FRESH Mozzarella. I'd honestly love to understand in what world this is FRESH Mozzarella ‍if fresh was unavailable this should have been communicated immediately read more

Pennington Pizza Grill - Regular cheese used on the Brooklyn Pizza which reads fresh mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - Pennington, New Jersey

Best pizza in the area. Perfect crust thickness, cheese-to-sauce ratio, etc. Even re-heated this pizza is great. read more

Ordered here last night. Three cheese steaks with peppers, onions and mushrooms. Chicken tenders with bbq sauce. Got home. Cheese steaks were under filled and had ZERO mushrooms and peppers- maybe a few onions and very little cheese. Tiny serving of fries and honey mustard instead of bbq sauce. Over priced and underwhelmed. Will not order from here again. read more

Great pizza. Great crust. No flop and a great crust. Owner seems like a good guy. Place has been there over 40 years. I used to go as a kid and I happen to be in the area so i went. Still the same great pizza read more

Absolute bust of a pizza place. Essentially zero selection of slices- on a Saturday! Pizza was fine, nothing special. Plain slices lacking some sauce and pretty cheesy. Good crust though. 5.8- that's a review. read more

OUTSTANDING!! Stopped here for lunch on the way to Flemington from Princeton. Having grown up in New Jersey and moved to Pennsylvania I craved a real piece of pizza. Pennington Pizza Grill was the perfect choice. Excellent pizza and pasta dishes that did not disappoint. Great service as well. Will be back next year when visiting again. read more

(2.25 stars) "Alright" pizza; the crust (thin, but not dry) and toppings (abundant and good quality) clearly trumped the sauce (thin and acidic) and cheese (off-flavors). Their sandwiches are also pretty good. Typical pizza house environment, with plenty of parking. read more

Owner is rude. I will never go back there again. Our large group included a boys basketball team and their parents. We called ahead to reserve some tables. When we got there we found that the boys were sent to another room out of the dining area even though there were plenty of tables empty next to us. When we asked what was happening the owner/manager explained that he was keeping those tables open for other customers. We felt like second class citizens. The pizza is average at best. The dough is bland and the tap soda has a funny taste. Stay away. read more

Mediocre pizza. Very little taste and our pie had too much crust. Might give it one more try but going to need a big rebound.

We just moved to the area. We ordered pizza and a chicken francaise entree. Both were delicious! The portion size was huge for the chicken. They were also accommodating and put the pasta on the side with red sauce. Definitely looking forward to ordering from here again. read more

I don't know why this place isn't always busy, the pizza is great. Much better than Piccolos, and is definitely worth every cent. The staff seems to be directly from Italy, and they're very kind. The sauce is delicious and the dough is fresh. Definitely try the Hawaiian pizza, my girlfriend and I eat an entire pie together. Try this place out read more

I went to high school in Pennington and have since moved out of state. On the rare occasion I pass through town I stop in for their tortellini deep dish Alfredo pizza that on my opinion is unbelievable. The first time I ordered it was 15 years ago, the last time was yesterday and it was still as amazing as it was then. I also love that the same people still work there as they did when I was in high school which speaks volumes for the family owned welcoming vibe they give off. If you're into constantly good pizza served by nice people, this place is a must. read more

Pennington Pizza isn't anything to write home about. The sauce on the pie was bland. The crust was clearly pre-made frozen crust - not fresh at all. The cheese slid off the slice. I agree with Steve G on his assessment too. read more

I was on a road trip from Rhode Island to Virginia. I stopped in here for a late lunch/early dinner. The food was excellent and the service was great. They have an extensive menu and it was very clean. Wish I lived near the place. read more

My favorite pie at this place is the California cheeseburger pie! So good! I haven't had any of the pasta dishes but whatever pizza i get here its normally quite good. read more

I am basing my 5-star review on one item only - the chicken with vodka sauce pizza. I don't typically enjoy overly thick slices of pizza but it is quite necessary in this circumstance. One slice of this should be a sufficient amount for lunch for most people. read more

This has been our go to spot when heading to North Jersey on Thanksgiving Eve for 5+ years. Good paninis and soup. The kids got pizza and that was good too. Plenty to choose from. Good traditional Italian service. We'll keep coming back for more! read more

Giving 5 stars because of the quality of their pizza. It can get a bit expensive (I would probably give it 2.5 $), but you will not be disappointed by their tortellini pizza or anything with a deeper crust. 5/5 read more

I've always had a great experience at Pennington Pizza. All the employees are friendly and your food comes out quickly, which is a plus if you're in a hurry. I've visited several times and have enjoyed all of the food. The pizza is decent, albeit a little greasy. If you're looking for comfort food, choose the Tortellini Deep Dish--covered with cheese sauce and perfectly cooked pasta. My favorite pasta dish has always been the rigatoni a la vodka--the perfect portion of pasta for lunch, with creamy sauce and pasta cooked al dente. It's also a great deal--only about $8 or $9 for a generous portion and delicious bread! Ordering a dish for dinner sets you back around $13 or so, depending on what you order, but it comes with salad or soup, and bread that comes brushed with olive oil. All in all, it's a decent pizza place and a good place to come if you want a casual Italian dinner. read more

I don't know why I go to this place. Maybe it's because all the rest of the pizza places in Pennington are about as terrible. The pizza crust is always too thick. It never cooks through and the dough has bubbles and is sometimes raw. Pizza dough needs to be hand tossed and thinned out to cook properly. These guys don't seem to take any care to do that. They have a Brooklyn pie, and let me tell you as someone who was born and raised in Brooklyn, I've never had any pizza that looked or tasted like that. I wish I could find a pizza place that knew how to make a proper pie. This place is definitely the worst in the area though. Might as well go to shop rite and buy a boboli. read more

Great pizza, decent prices. Great selection. This is what you want from a local pizza/Italian joint.

they make some great thin crust pizza, a great taco pizza, fresh mozzarella and tomato pizza, and the best cheesesteaks/cheesesteak hoageis around! their fries are killer too. read more

Way better than Vitos. Pennington Pizza has great baked ziti and other pasta dishes!

They make the best chicken and rice soup around. Real authentic Italian food. Consistently excellent. No frills but the real thing.

Been going to Pennington Pizza for decades; noticed recently that the staff seems to have changed, in particular the chefs, and none of them are particularly friendly, quite frankly they're downright rude. Food is fair at best. Not like the old days. Won't be going back. read more

The food here is as good as any Italian restaurant that you will find in the area. Pizza is great and the menu is large. They offer many chicken and veal dishes and all are great. It can be very crowded on Friday night, but tables open up quickly. The staff and owners know their stuff and will try to make whatever you are in the mood for. read more