Easily one of the better pizza spots in Wayne, tucked into a convenient strip mall across from the high school and near a Whole Foods. It's the kind of place where you can grab the kid from school, order a solid pie and knock out your grocery shopping in the same trip -- a small luxury that feels surprisingly efficient for townies. An excellent white pie which pairs even better with spinach if you're feeling like a filling meal. read more

Wow, honestly some of the worst service! I came here hoping to get a quick slice, I ended up waiting more than 10 minutes for them to heat up two slices I ordered. Not only did they burn my pizza, I don't understand how you can cook it that long and have it come out soggy. The pizza itself was horrible and I mean it! Don't waste your time and money here, now I know why this place was completely empty and under a 3.5 star review. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Haven't been to Neil's in a long time and a friend suggested It was excellent cue was superb It was a self pickup and everything was ready Had Grandmas pie and it was The best grandmas pie. Will be back for sure read more

Neil's is the BEST of the BEST!!! Amazing food AND amazing customer service. Been faithful customers for months now & not had one bad experience. they're always so accommodating, prompt & eager to help! It's so fresh and delicious. Today my mom and son went for pizza and got stuck inside due to an unexpected thunderstorm & an employee walked them to their car with an umbrella- just above and beyond, truly! They've even offered to cut up my toddler's pizza into little bites whenever we go. just love them! no bad things to stay! read more

Used to be much better! About a year ago, Neil's changed their dough recipe. No longer the standard NY Slice base, closer now to a cracker or even heaven forbid a matzo! We still eat there because it's convenient and the Sicilian slices are still standard type dough. read more

The pizza is still good as it was in the nineteen hundreds, but the service just sucks now. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Stopped by Neil Pizzeria after hearing some good things, and overall, it was a nice experience. We tried the Classic Buffalo Chicken pizza, the Arugula Special, and an order of French fries. The Buffalo Chicken pizza didn't quite hit the mark for us the flavor just didn't work the way we expected. But the Arugula Special was fresh, tasty, and definitely the highlight among the pizzas. And surprisingly, the French fries were amazing crispy, well-seasoned, and a total winner. Service was quick and the place was clean. Would go back, but probably to try different pizzas next time. read more

See all

Good food, good service, bring back short rib pizza for a 5/5 stars best pizza that was there! But for now 4/4

It has a classic do it yourself ambience where you pick up the delicious food at the counter to go, or you seat yourself and the incredible service does the rest. read more

Best buffalo garlic knots, best pizza deliciosa! We return frequently! We also loved their baked ziti and penne pizza .

The best pizza spot for specialty slices. The pesto and vodka slices are the best I've ever had from any pizzeria. Their regular vodka slices are so thin and crisp! Tried their buffalo slice last time I was there and it was excellent as well. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pesto chicken, vodka, buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Still one of the best pizzerias in Wayne ! And there are plenty of them. There specialty slices can't be beat. I always enjoy the vegetable or spinach . Fresh garlic knots are always good too. read more

3.5 stars I had not been to Neil's Pizzeria in years, but happened to be in the area recently, so I stopped in with a friend to grab a slice. The staff was very nice and friendly, which is always appreciated. While the traditional place offered a variety of pies, baked dishes, sandwiches, and more, I just wanted something small and loved that they had such a huge selection of random slices for purchase. I wound up selecting the "Pizza Deliziosa", which utilized a thin layer of sauce topped with sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and garlic. First of all, the thin crust was nice and crispy. In addition, since the cheese had been added in slices, the pizza was less greasy, and you could easily remove the cheese if you wanted to. While I enjoyed the Deliziosa and found it well-seasoned and not oily, I also did not think that the mozzarella had any flavor. I would go back to Neil's if in the area, but there are also many other old favorite pizzerias I might revisit first. read more

Still the best around. Been going there a long time and I still think their pies are the best. Sandwiches are great and the dinners superb. read more

A hidden gem, if you were in the Wayne area this is definitely a must try. Everything is amazing from their customs places to their homemade salad, Caesars my fave. You can stop by for a quick lunch or a nice dinner! read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Large pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

The food here is amazing every time I come here they never fail staff is friendly as well

Pizza was nice and hot right out of the oven. Staff was friendly and the place was spotless. We always get our pizza and antipasto's there. Highly recommended!!!! read more

A Staple in the Wayne community. If you don't know about the Buffalo chicken Sicilian pie then I hope this review persuades you to order it. The Buffalo chicken Sicilian pie. Indulge in the tantalizing combination of spicy Buffalo chicken and the savory goodness of a Sicilian pie. The fiery kick of Buffalo sauce paired with the hearty Sicilian crust and blue cheese drizzle creates a flavor symphony that's bound to elevate your taste buds. Treat yourself to a culinary adventure and savor every delicious bite of this uniquely satisfying pizza experience. read more

Good local food. Take is excellent And customer service is excellent Ambiance is average read more

Always enjoy their pizza. Ordered a Grandma's pizza this time. It was great!!!!mussels were good too, but the sauce was a little spicy for my taste read more

Have been a customer for over 10 years. Have ordered this sandwich hundreds of times. So NO! That is not a 10.75 sandwich and they made it twice! The excuse I got was they were busy. 4.00 a gallon for gas and two trips to them thanks but no thanks! This customer is moving on!!! read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken Parm sandwich - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

I've tried this pizza twice in the last month but wanted to check out the restaurant being it was local and sit down with a slice before I wrote this. My first experience was my sister ordered from Neil's for a small family get together and I'm normally not blown away by many pizzas at this point because I know what I like as an Italian in NJ being here my whole life and eating pizza my whole life! But the sicilian was exceptionally good, I especially enjoyed the sausage on the pie which I'm pretty picky about. Cooked well, tasted great and not too fat like some sicilian slices/pies can be. After that I kept saying I gotta try them again so we stopped here for lunch the other day and it was slightly busy but plenty of seats still and no real wait around 12 on a weekday. Ordered 2 sicilian slices, a plain and a pepperoni and sausage slice, was still very good but a little under heated IMO but not ice cold or anything. Service was friendly, restaurant was clean. 3.5 stars, Def worth stopping for lunch or ordering a pie for a Sunday football game or dinner! Would eat again 3.5 stars on the pizza/yelp scale! read more

See all

My favorite pizza place to stop by and eat when visiting Wayne. Their food is fresh and delicious. So many options for pizza, the toppings were endless. There is penne alla vodka, eggplant parmigiana, Chinese style chicken, veggie pizza etc. Their subs are also delicious and can be modify anyway. The sub was crispy and soft on the inside. It was wonderful. Very friendly workers. I basically ate here for 3 days straight for lunch. Do your self a favor and go check this place out. read more

See all

Great food and great service. They always have a huge selection of slices and are so welcoming with the kids.

Ordered takeout online from here last night. Good spot in town and have ordered dinners and pizza in the past and it's great service and quality. This time I ordered a cheesesteak. I grew up near Philly and was spoiled with cheesesteaks so I am picky with them. First time I tried their cheesesteak and wow! Quality bread, steak and cheese. Was cooked perfect and they were not cheap on meat and cheese. Ratio of bread to steak was perfect! Will definitely order a cheesesteak from them again. I highly recommend Neil's overall. Never had a bad meal from them. read more

I've tried all the pizza places in the area and Neil's is hands down the best out of all. The crust is thin but not too thin and has great bite in it. It folds just as a pizza should fold, and the cheese and toppings don't just slide out. This is exactly what your classic Jersey-style pizzeria should be. I've ordered pastas salads here a few times and their portions are all very large. If you're like me and you don't carry much cash, they don't bother you with some $10 credit card minimum. There's plenty of seating and the place is generally kept very clean. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Pepperoni slices - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Amazing buffalo chicken pizza! Very spicy, but you'll still go for another slice Paco (i hope i spelled it right) was so nice on the phone and made sure my order arrived right on time. Pizza comes with different toppings and their sandwiches are yummy too! Great place for pizza! read more

See all

Great pizza delivered when asked. Thank you very nice service. Had large cheese pizza. Will order again . Had a slice of pizza and wings with my grandson. Loved both very good thank you. read more

Pissed because there pizza is so good but there delivery guy is horrible,so he brings order,I'm paying with a card so I notice he already added a 30 percent tip so as I go to swipe my card I tap no tip on the device,he all of a suddens NO TIP NO TIP YOU THINK I WIORK FOR FREE STUPIDO So I said excuse me i was giving you a tip in cash but now your not getting nothing, he turns around & says watch next time SO BEFORE HE DIES SOMETHING TO MY FOOD,I WON'T CAN'T TRUST HIM read more

The Chicken, Parmesan hero was not THE BEST AT ALL. It was literally chopped up chicken that they were about to throw on pizza for the chicken Parm pizza. Which is probably a lot better. I never had pizza at the spot but the pizza looks 10 times better than how the sandwiches are made. a lot. Better myself. I wish I stayed home and cooked. Very disappointed. I came here hungry left disappointed Lol read more

My husband called Neil's and accidently said good morning during the afternoon, so they hung up on him making a joke and then didn't allow him to place an order after that. What an interesting personality these people have, a customer cannot even make the simplest mistake without being harassed. read more

Staff is great - very friendly, specialty slices around lunch time are awesome, pizzeria interior recently refreshed. Great take out. Some of my favorites are: Fresh tomato slices Chicken pesto pizza Buffalo chicken pizza Mini round fresh tomato and garlic personal pies Can't go wrong here. Strong lunch crowd from the local high school. 4 stars for what it is - a local pizzeria offering tasty, fresh pizza and delicious specialty slices. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken pesto pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Horrible customer service . My order was completely messed up.The Food was cold. When I went to pick up the correct order,they were so rude and nas,like it was my fault they messed it up.I will never return there read more

I needed to change the rating because it wasn't fair enough. This man working at Neil's made fun of me with his coworker because I calmly asked him for a second refill. I completely understand he cannot give me another one and he is doing his job. I am not disappointed by that at all. He felt the need to make fun of me with his coworker right in front of me. The employees at this restaurant need to be put in order because I may never step foot into this place ever again. I proudly present this place with one star. read more

Food is just OK. Can be nasty on the phone. Portion are normally good. Quality would be better than quantity.

I for one think they do a great job here. I've ordered plain pies and sandwiches recently and was never disappointed. The food was cooked just enough for my liking, people who prefer it closer to burnt/crispy might be turned off. I thought the way they made it was perfectly fine. read more

Since high school, this has been my favorite pizza place in Wayne. I love how they have so many different specialty pies. My favorite is the pesto chicken and buffalo chicken. In the past I have tried the spinach slice as well. Recently I had the chicken bacon ranch and it was a little dry/needed some more ranch and maybe they could've skipped over the fries. Anyway, when I am in the area I always try to stop here for a hearty slice. read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Buffalo chicken and pesto chicken - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

This place is great. I'm not in the area often but a friend recommended this place and now it's my "go to" when I'm in the area. I went a while ago but still remember my first bite, the owner confidently said it was the best... he wasn't kidding!! I love their buffalo chicken pizza the service was fairly quick.. it's a hidden gem!! read more

The food is fresh. It's always served warmed, the delivery is good with time.I enjoy all the pictures in the wall of different high school teams and the paintings. read more

This Chicken Montese is by far my favorite thing on the menu and my guilty pleasure! Totally treat myself to this as soon as I have a slightly bad day! :) read more

Neil's Pizzeria - Chicken Montese - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey