So for the last few months I've been conducting my own personal search for the best buffalo chicken pizza in Wayne and I think I found it ::insert fanfare!:: Ok so what's so good about it?? Unlike other spots in town Pizza One uses buffalo sauce as the base on the pizza, which is the only way go! Topped with mozz and buffalo chicken it's simple and so so good! Other places in town use a red sauce as their base which does not make sense to me. Another spot in town uses buff sauce but drowns their dough in it and that is just too much sauce, man. Pizza One has figured out the right sauce/cheese/chicken ratio. Their regular cheese pie is a winner too. They do a really nice thin but not too thin crust here which works for a plain pie but also is a nice base for loading up with the toppings too. I also have to talk about their garlic knots. Also the best that I've found in town (so far anyway..). They are big, fluffy and loaded with garlic. They are served w/ marinara but if you've got an extra buck I'd suggest you spring for the vodka sauce - it's sooooo good w/ the knots. No complaints re: service or wait times for pies. Pizza One is just a super solid spot in town to get food. Bonus -- if you order online they've always got some sort of deal going on - ie: a large cheese pie and 12 wings for $26 or 3 large pies for $42. We often order the pizza/wing combo (when I'm not insisting on ordering the aforementioned buffalo chicken pizza..) and when you compare to other spots you're saving at least $5 which is not nothin'. read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

It's a solid 3.5 star joint. I appreciate the amount of cheese on the drunken grandma but the pie was undercooked cause it had so much cheese. Would have appreciated more seasoning and vodka sauce. Barely any sauce. The Churros were good. I would have preferred the chocolate sauce on the side to dip. Pretty pricey for the pie $35 and churros were $12. read more

Pizza One - Drunken Grandma - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Best eggplant in Wayne. The breading is perfect and fried to perfection. The cheese on the dinner Pargm is generous, however, the sauce is more on the sweet/citrus side. Portions sized are huge and reasonably priced. Customer service is great! read more

Pleasant experience Clean and comfortable seating. Just enough ambient noise. Staff helpful and smiling. Pizza crust had a crunchy crisp to it. It's an efficiently run business read more

Stopped in for lunch. They have a very large selection of pizzas which are on display once you enter. Once we got to the counter the cashier took our order and put our slices in the oven. There is plenty of seating at the restaurant, which is nice. We sat at a booth to eat our pizza. It was a quick stop which is exactly what you expect a pizza shop to be. The pizza was good but I cannot say it was top 3 of the pizzas I have had. If I was in the area and needed to grab a bite I would stop in. However, I would not travel out of my way to get a slice. read more

See all

The food was some of the best I ever had. Service was spot on. And they renovated the restaurant and it is so confrontable and nicely done. They will make whatever you want to your likening. I go back twice a week. Try it you'll like it read more

Poor man's review. Over all, I like this place. The portion sizes are good and usually taste pretty good to exceptionally good. Salads have a decent amount of topping to them. All parm sandwiches (like eggplant, chicken, or meatball) are good. And they don't skimp on the cheese on any parm sandwich!!! Which a lot of places cut that corner to squeeze an extra small profit out of you. I am not saying they are the world's best but they really try to give you a good value/ portion for your buck. That line make me like them as they don't forget the customers are the reason it is open read more

A pizza place with more options that you can image and not just on slices, you have rolls and sandwiches and garlic knots with chicken parm! I had a corner Sicilian slice, garlic knots and a pepperoni roll. Everything was very good. The sauce is a little on the sweeter side. The pepperoni roll has a nice kick to it. Regarding dessert you have a selection of various pies, tiramasu cheesecakes, Gelato and zepplois. I need to come back and try the zeppelin they can be stuffed and then gad tons of toppings They offer a full menu of dinners, pastas, soups and salads. The ambiance is a step above a typical pizza shop. BENCH seating lines the walls with these high top tables, by the window you have 2 tables for 4 people with soft fa ric chairs, the jazz music playing in the background provides a relaxation feeling. The service very friendly and welcoming . One of the owners used to work in Eastchester at another shop. Overall 5 stars and will be back to try a dinner!! read more

See all

The workers are so sweet! The food is fantastic!! Huge variety of pizza slices! I have had mango habanero and sweet chili slice. All soo good! The inside is calm and a good vibe for a pizzeria! read more

The food was absolutely amazing. I ordered the American Burger. Perfect! The meat was very good quality and lots of it. The toppings were fresh and delicious. It came with an absolute mountain of seasoned fries. One of the best burger and fries meal that I have gotten anywhere. The ambiance was very nice. The dining area has large cushioned booths and tables available. I would definitely recommend this place to anybody. read more

Specialty sandwich's , gourmet pizza slices, sit down seating with no table service. Must order at counter and they deliver. Clean and comfortable. read more

See all

I ordered take out and I'm glad I did. The spinach artichoke pizza was a hit even with the kids. It was the perfect amount of toppings with the ricotta, spinach, artichoke and mozzarella. Will definitely be ordering again! read more

Pizza One - a whole pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Best pizza I've had in a while. Staff is friendly and the place is clean. Highly recommended!

Just ordered for the first time while with friends and was floored by all of the options on the menu, even more blown away by how amazing the Stromboli was! Neglected to get a photo because we inhaled everything so quickly. Highly recommend the Italian Meat Stromboli and a starter of Pickle Chips! Definitely plan to order again on a future trip to the area! read more

The past year the Wayne location has been spiraling down hill with attitudes on the phone when taking orders, subbing out pecans with walnuts (like we are stupid and wouldn't notice) ridiculous prices and then tonight the final straw, a piece of a rubber glove buried in my salad. Im 99% sure I swallowed a piece of finger portion..see photos. read more

Pizza One - Plastic glove pieces buried in my salad. - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

The worse meatball parm sandwich! What a soggy mess! Very why even called it sandwich. What a joke! read more

Pizza One - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

Working far from home sometimes is hard to know where to go for good takeout. I'm 40ish mins away from home and I'm not familiar with the area. At my job not everyone gets take out or isn't as warm and fuzzy with new employees. I've only ordered delivery from here and their food is delicious!! I'm sorry I'm not able to tell you about the ambiance or service because it's usually delivered to my job. I tried a salad with chicken, and their Jay Kay chicken wrap. At work I cant always take pictures of what I eat because I'm soooo hungry I inhale it lol . But next time I order I will update and post pictures. Loved the portions! And totally worth it! Maybe one of these days I'll invite my family over here to try it! I recommend everyone tries it!! Enjoy!!! read more

Never disappointed food is delicious staff friendly .. we ordered almost everything on the menu and it has never disappointed

Ordered catering last week for a family reunion - the food was over the top great! (as usual) Deivery is always right on time, food is hot and always delicious. I will order from here again And again!!! read more

best pizza around and I'm a pizza snob! Try it you won't be disappointed especially if your from NYC

When they first opened up in Wayne, their sicilian margherita (Ringwood's favorite) pie was phenomenal. After the renovation, their dough has changed and tastes slightly stale even when eaten right away. It seems like they changed the ingredients or recipe. I hope they return back to their original glory. read more

The pizza was so good I didn't even take a picture. I almost opted not to write this because I don't have pictures. We had a bbq chicken slice and a Buffalo chicken slice and wow! They were so good. The Buffalo slice here was different than other places because it had celery pieces on it as well. I was hesitant but man those pieces gave the slice a delicious crunch. This was a random stop on our way out of town but we will definitely return and I will take pics then! read more

Great pizza. Wonderful crust and fresh ingredients. Meatballs are also delicious. Fast and hot delivery.

Good morning so I'm a regular customer here the food is delicious. My go to favorites are the Stewie salad, the Miami Beach salad, the Ricotta Bites omg. Last night I was starving after work an I got the Miami Beach salad add chicken an the Ricotta Bites with side marinara an Chipotle ranch sauce they were absolutely delicious an hit the spot after a long days work. read more

Pizza One - This is me last night eating the Miami Beach salad with chicken, an the Ricotta Bites, delicious hit the spot. - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

The first thing you see when entering Pizza One is a case FULL of variety after variety of pizza. While we came in with the intent of having a slice of pepperoni, our eyes were immediately drawn to the salad pizzas. I chose the chicken Caesar pizza. Calling it pizza is somewhat questionable though - it was on pizza crust, it was cut into a wedge but it only had cheese baked on - no sauce - not quite cheese bread/not quite pizza. The crust was loaded down with romaine, lots of shaved parm, Caesar dressing and a good amount of freshly grilled chicken. It was good, not something I'd order again - it just wasn't the best of both worlds. My dining partner had the eggplant salad pizza. The cheese crust was topped with copious amounts of fried eggplant, lettuce, onions, balsamic dressing and I'm not quite sure what else. She said it was really good but once again, it just wasn't the best of both worlds and she wouldn't order it again. The restaurant was quite busy but the line went quickly. There was a little seating for eat in but it looked like most orders were carry out. I'd like to come back and try their honest to goodness pizza - everything else in the case definitely looked worthy of a try. read more

Pizza One - Eggplant salad pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

We just had lunch at this brand new Pizza One in Wayne, it was fantastic! I had a salad pie slice, my husband had the Chicago style pepperoni, deep dish with crusty cheese around it - both were outstanding! My husband also had a slice of chicken Parmesan, which was also delicious. I had to take a salad slice home because we don't live very close to this restaurant. The staff were very friendly, the music was great. It was clean and brand new decor. I highly recommend Pizza One, we used to go to the one in Haskell all the time before we moved away from that area. Will definitely be back to this one! read more

See all

I'm not a usually dough guy (I throw away my crusts) but their new thick slices are . Had the chicken sriracha and even reheated it was so good. Also, the new bar pies are amazing. Highly recommend. read more

Excellent find. Great taste and quality. Many choice of pizza. Inside is clean. They have a large staff to serve you .

Loved the pizza and wings. The wings especially blew me away, very tasty and premium feeling. Workers seem helpful and attentive. I haven't tried other menu items but it seems like a good variety. read more

Sorry, no eat in because of the coronavirus, they do not have an outdoor dining area, but they are open for pickup or take out. My wife was nice enough to pickup lunch today. The food was on point as always. She got the "Miami Beach" salad, it's her favorite. I got the "NY islanders" aka a Rueben sandwich, pastrami & Swiss w/cole slaw and thousand island. I'm not a fan of cole slaw, but for some reason if you put it on a pastrami sandwich, it works! Served with a pickle and chips. They have a great selection of salads and sandwiches, hot or cold including cheesesteaks and burgers. Paninis, wraps, Stromboli, calzone, appetizers, pasta, drinks, deserts and pizza. They have some of the best pizza around. Fresh, quality ingredients, put together with care. Every bite has the right combination of cheese and sauce. They have specialty pies, or chose your toppings including my favorites, soppressata & prosciutto. The staff is always friendly and accommodating. They have a hand sanitizing station, everybody was wearing a mask and following social distancing guidelines. I'll be continuing to give them my business whenever I'm in the area and I strongly recommend you try them at as well for lunch or dinner. read more

Pizza One - NY islanders sandwich. - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Best Italian sub I've ever had. 10/10 love it. Best service around town. Very friendly love the workers. Karim was the best employee I've ever met. Very charming and helped me get my food delivered very fast. Love love love read more

There are no words... just simply delicious. Grilled chicken, crispy bacon, melted cheddar cheese, sautéed mushrooms, topped with honey mustard. Always made fresh to order! Nice and toasty as well read more

Pizza One - Create Your Own Panini - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

I ordered a cheese steak that needs to be taken off the menu immediately. Super greasy and low quality beef. Tasted exactly like a steak-um!!! I'm really disappointed in this as I was starving. read more

Pizza One - Cheese steak - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

See all

Ordered pizza one for a business meeting! It was great the staff was super helpful when it came to placing and picking up my order. The pizza was good and everyone was satisfied, I would visit again! read more

Omg I haven't heard of eggplant salad pizza until I heard about this place. Definitely something new to try, I don't eat eggplant much but this was pretty good. read more

Pizza One - Eggplant salad Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wayne, New Jersey

$3.00 Delivery Fee. WTF. Most pizza places deliver for free. Way to stick it to the man. Prices are high enough and you delivery people use their own vehicles. Should be ashamed read more

Great Italian spot. I tried the slices to go and they didn't disappoint. I am looking forward to coming back and trying more.

Great Staff! Great Food! Great Music on the "Juke Box" ! ! ! Brilliant! Thanks! Gracias! read more

They are good. Fast service. I like there bolognese sauce. There salads are good too.

I ordered a large pie. It was so salty you wouldn't be able to eat it! It's a shame that I had to throw it in the garbage. They need to watch the salt in the cheese and their sauce. Also the workers are arrogant. Not a pleasant place. Don't know what the hype is going there. I won't go back. read more