Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mr Pepperoni

    3.6 (124 reviews)
    InexpensivePizza, Italian, Greek
    Closed 11:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Mr Pepperoni Takeout or Delivery

    Mr Pepperoni Photos

    Business Info

    MR PEPPERONI ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Quiet
    Good for kids
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mr Pepperoni

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    This has got to be one of the best pies...ever!
    Ray N.

    Piping hot pizza! Fresh veggie toppings that are well cooked. The crust has a crunch to it. The sauce is lovely. Everything just comes together perfectly. Say hello to Mr Pepperoni right here in Herndon, Virginia 25 minutes west of Washington DC and 240 or so miles south of New York City. The menu - fantastic and extensive( please check out the photos) with gorgeous garlic bread, delicious salads( we got the tuna), Chicken gyro with pita, the Italian specialties like Lasagna just to mention a few of the crazy good items that we ordered for the sixth Sunday of the 2022 NFL season; then devoured with love, napkins and loud appreciation. The owner here is a beautiful man who is warm, welcoming and so very kind. The same goes for his weekend Manager Freddy who is just a great guy. The way he brought out our order to go and showed us each item was extraordinary. A lot of love here! They are very generous in their portions. There was great energy and smiles, fun and lots of laughter in the kitchen as I waited for the food. This is a cosy restaurant that is open 7 days a week and has loads of parking up front. Mr Pepperoni is absolutely Mr Extraordinary. This NYer who travels all over and gets homesick has found a small and delicious taste of home.

    Mr. Pepperoni - Herndon, Va
    Gail G.

    We just moved to Herndon (va) and have been so busy unpacking and repairing or updating things inside and outside, that we are too tired to cook. We got a flier, in the mail, just days ago. we ordered on line and it arrived pretty quickly to our house, super nice delivery man, who i think works directly for them. i love their flier/ad, it says "your taste buds & wallet will thank you".. they were right! you get a lot of food for the price with ONLY a 3 buck delivery fee, but we gave a nice sized extra tip as well. we will "dine in" next time, and try some other foods but this time the hubby had the hot pesto chicken philly & cheese sub. he loved it. and i had the ham and cheese sub. very fresh!

    Zucchini fries, very good.
    Mary Y.

    I'm giving 5 stars for several reasons. Taste: we got a special, extra large 3 topping for $12.99. the taste was quite good. I know some from NY say it's as good, I don't agree but it was good. Second: that price! $12.99 for an extra large, you can't beat that. Third: their delivery was quick and food was hot. We also got the zucchini fries and they were very good. Quick suggestion, offer marinara and maybe ranch to dip in. All in all we were pleased. We will order again. Well done Mr.Pepperoni

    BBQ Chicken Pizza
    Ajay S.

    Name got my attention. I went inside and ordered couple of pizzas. Good quality, friendly person working. Next time I'm in the area I'll definitely try something different.

    Tiffany W.

    We decided to order from here last minute and we were all very pleasantly surprise. I got the Bianca pizza and it was excellent. So garlicky and full of flavor. I also tried a piece of the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza and wings- all very delicious. so much so that I drove from Fairfax City to Herndon to carry home some pizza tonight when I started craving pizza.

    Ang K.

    I ordered from here through ubereats and was happy with the quality. Pepperoni pizza was pretty good, wings were good, and the side salad was pretty big.

    the menus on the wall

    See all

    Photo of T W.
    0
    2
    0

    16 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 4 of 4

    Ask the Community - Mr Pepperoni

    Review Highlights - Mr Pepperoni

    I've been going to this place for many years now and have always gotten the gyro salad.

    $11.99 Gyro Salad

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 23,103 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Cantina D'italia - Veal, eggplant?, spaghetti

    Cantina D'italia

    3.9(328 reviews)
    0.7 mi
    $$

    First off - our server was great! So no complaints there. We are new to the area and are obviously…read moretrying new/non chain restaurants when we can. The restaurant itself is old school Italian with the drippy candles in wine bottles and dated decor. It could definitely use a facelift - and still maintain that classic Italian restaurant vibe. The food was the most disappointing part of the journey. Calamari that was chewy and not at all seasoned - clearly frozen and out of a bag and our meals were no better. I LOVE veal saltimbocca and get it whenever I can. The veal was thick, mozzarella wasn't fresh, and it was drowning in canned mushrooms. Nothing about our meal said fresh. We were leaving the next day for a quick trip so we did not take our leftovers home, but I can honestly say we wouldn't have even if we didn't have a trip planned.

    I had this out of the blue chicken marsala craving and did a little research and decided to give…read moreCantina D'Italia a shot. I will start off by saying that I had low expectations given the track record of non-chain Italian restaurants I've tried since living in northern VA of which 85% have been terrible (remember I'm from NJ where Italian food should be the state food). But I said YOLO, crossed my fingers and ordered the marsala via GrubHub. The moral of the story is that I was PLEASANTLY SURPRISED by Cantina D'Italia overall because the marsala was pretty tasty, spaghetti cooked almost perfectly, garlic bread with cheese perfectly seasoned and cheesy and they sent an added little unexpected bonus of a pretty side salad with a homemade vinaigrette and fresh Italian bread and butter! Oh and the portion was HUGE! Totally got 2-3 meals out of it. Cantina D'Italia has given me hope ... or I should say at least gave me an Italian restaurant I just might frequent and explore all the other menu options :)

    Photos
    Cantina D'italia - Fettucine Mediterranean - Crab Meat, Scallops, Shrimp in white cream sauce.

    Fettucine Mediterranean - Crab Meat, Scallops, Shrimp in white cream sauce.

    Cantina D'italia - Spaghetti carbonara

    Spaghetti carbonara

    Cantina D'italia

    See all

    North Italia

    North Italia

    3.9(530 reviews)
    1.1 mi
    $$

    This was my first time dining here, and everything was a 10/10! The drinks were amazing, and I…read morereally appreciated that they were able to custom make something for us that wasn't even on the menu. Edwin was our server, and he provided truly outstanding service--easily 10/10 customer care. He was attentive, friendly, and made the whole experience even better. We ordered the lasagna and the chicken Parmesan, and both dishes were absolutely delicious. The food exceeded our expectations. I would definitely recommend this restaurant and will be coming back!

    This place is really good but WAY overpriced. The plates were melamine....sorry way overpriced to…read moreserve in melamine. It reminds me a little bit of Vapianos, esp with the open kitchen concept. We went for mothers day. The lady could not find my reservation. i had to show her. but something is wrong with their system because this happened to a friend of mine back in February as well. They ran out of ranch and N/A prosseco. It is okay bc the food was good. We ordered the fried zucca chips. OVERLY SALTED. did not enjoy. The burrata was delicious. I would get that again. The chicken parmesan was delicious. but it was odd it came with mac and cheese ziti or some kind of cheese sauce. Usually you serve chicken parm with spaghetti and sauce? The Bolognese was delicious and same with the chicken pesto. My sister got a arugula steak salad. The steak was really rare and they didnt even ask how she wanted it cooked. the little gem caesar was good but it had way too much dressing. way too much. the dessert was delicious. butter cake was amazing! Drinks: Cocktails were really good but OVERPRICED. $16-$17 dollars for a non fancy italian spot is wild. Ciao Bella was delicious though. I would probably come here again but it is overpriced.

    Photos
    North Italia
    North Italia
    North Italia

    See all

    Heirloom - Bucatini

    Heirloom

    4.4(175 reviews)
    1.1 mi

    My friends and I went here for drinks and Alex was the best ever! She was so accommodating and…read morefun:) We stan Alex.

    It's discovering places like this that I feel compelled to write reviews for Yelp. My husband and…read moreI were picking up our son at Dulles and wanted a nice restaurant to try since we had to make the drive from Richmond. This was number one on the list when I searched best restaurants in Reston and it did not disappoint! Heirloom is tucked away in the distillery and has a cozy speakeasy feel with green velvet booths and an eclectic seafood forward menu. Cocktails : Manhattan - top notch My sweet side piece - fun presentation with table side bubbles! Feels a bit like a fall drink. Warm spice. Very tasty and too easy to drink fast lol Apps: We got the baked shrimp and the beef carpaccio. Both outstanding and so flavorful. Just needed some bread to soak up the sauce in the baked shrimp. The lemon rind in the shrimp was a perfect compliment to the sauce and the carpaccio was perfectly seasoned and the thinnest slices I have ever had which made it delicate and delicious. Entrees: We got the sea bass and the short rib bolognese. Blown away by how good both of these were and so very different. The short rib bolognese had a rich but not heavy flavor with fresh pasta and a delightful velvety spiciness - not heat though. The sea bass was crispy on the outside and perfectly cooked with a carrot ginger puree that was sublime with the spinach and fish. We loved both of these entrees. Really wanted dessert but sadly not more room which was better for our stomachs and our wallets. It's not a cheap endeavor here but worth the cost for a fabulous meal out and a very cool vibe.

    Photos
    Heirloom - Inside with bar

    Inside with bar

    Heirloom - Burger and steak

    Burger and steak

    Heirloom - Non alcoholic drinks!

    See all

    Non alcoholic drinks!

    Pazzo Pomodoro - Pesce Spada Alla Ghiotta Mediterranean herb crusted swordfish steak sautéed

    Pazzo Pomodoro

    4.2(664 reviews)
    7.4 mi
    $$

    I came here with my bf to celebrate his promotion and had a great time. Food was good, staff was…read moresuper friendly. Our server (Katie? Karly?) recommended we get the baci di sofia Loren to celebrate. DELICIOUS. Will becoming back.

    Service was great. We were easily accommodated when we requested to move to a different table…read moreaway from the door ( it was cold and damp and every time the door opened cold wind blasted inside, even with the double doors). It was much appreciated. As for the food it was hit and miss. Our husbands had the short rib raviolis and-although it was flavorful, there was not enough meat inside the raviolis nor were there enough raviolis to justify the price tag. Since the sauce was extremely flavorful I forced my husband to share some of the skimpy sauce to dip my pizza crust on it. Luckily the guys had enough of the wonderful fried mozzarella and bread to not be grumpy. One tip that our whole party agreed on was that the sauce was better suited if it was paired with chunks of lobsters instead of of the stuffed short rib raviolis. I was happy with size of my thin crust pizza and it was way more than I could eat. However, I am not sure if I was actually ok with how the ingredients were divided jn the quarter a fourth of the pizza contained olives ,another fourth was the mushrooms, ,another fourth was the prosciutto and for the life of me I could not remember the fourth ingredient. I'm still ponedering whether I am a fan of this. My friend had the Marguerite pizza and she was extremely satisfied with it. As to the place itself, it's nothing fancy, it's just your typical pizza place in a strip mall. It's just ok. One thing I noticed about it is the dim lighting, but to be fair it's a normal complaint for most eating establishments. We all had to break out our IPhone flashlights to read the menu. I wish most eateries would have a dimmer switch by your table so that when you are ordering, there is sufficient lighting as you read the menu and when done can be adjusted to mood lighting. I noticed most of the upper forties and up patrons did the same thing as us when ordering.

    Photos
    Pazzo Pomodoro - The Vintage Room

    The Vintage Room

    Pazzo Pomodoro - Fettucine Gamberi e Pesto*

    Fettucine Gamberi e Pesto*

    Pazzo Pomodoro - Crazy Tomato in Inglese.

    See all

    Crazy Tomato in Inglese.

    Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse - They have popovers as their "table bread" when you sit down!

    Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse

    3.9(130 reviews)
    2.3 mi

    I had seen this chain a few times during my travels but never went... until this time! What a…read moregreat experience this was - Definitely a "special night" or date night experience!! This was a business dinner and when we first entered I was amazed at how big and beautiful it was inside. The bar area was large, oval, and really upscale and nice! They also offer valet here, which is helpful given the area, it's tough to find parking! Our server was great! She offered many good options, offered up very helpful insight, and did a great job keeping an eye on our table. Their wine list is large, with so much to choose from, whether Italian or New World - They have a nice selection of bottles! They even have their own label (not sure who makes it) which I tried and it was decent, but we opted for something else. It was tough to select a salad, an appetizer, and an entrée, as we wanted to be able to eat everything and there was so much to choose from which looked so very appealing on the menu. I started with their arugula salad and it was excellent! Such a simplistic salad like this has to be made with fresh greens and this definitely met that mark! I did ask for a side of balsamic to drizzle a tiny bit in - but it really didn't need it. Dinner consisted of their braised short rib - AMAZING! So very tender and flavorful... YUMMM!!!! A nice balance of flavors, sweet and savory in this dish. Their pasta menu looked so very nice that I wanted a pasta too, so prior to the mains, I split their smoked chicken pasta with a colleague and that dish was crazy - so smokey and flavorful! The pasta was spot-on al dente too! Definitely a rich dish, creamy, flavorful, and very powerful - but tasty! We were all too full for dessert, so a couple of us just chose some Sambuca to sip as we ended the dinner and that was great, served perfectly chilled with the coffee beans. Highly recommend giving them a try, I'll most definitely return!

    We came in for a company offsite dinner and were promptly seated, as we had a reservation. The food…read morewas very good, flavorful, and well prepared. They also offer a strong wine selection. However, we were disappointed by the strict policy regarding outside wine. We were prepared to pay a corkage fee so we could enjoy a bottle we had brought for the occasion, but the manager explained that it was a firm policy set by the owner and could not be overridden. While we understand the need for policies, a bit more flexibility for special occasions would have gone a long way. Overall, the experience and food were very good, but policies like this can impact repeat business. Parking nearby is somewhat of a walk. Alternatively, valet parking is available at the nearby JW Marriott, which may be more convenient. I think the restaurant may have its own valet parking although I did not see it being offered the day we came.

    Photos
    Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse - Inside, menu

    Inside, menu

    Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse - IG @ SpicyAivy crabcake

    IG @ SpicyAivy crabcake

    Davio's Northern Italian Steakhouse - Bloody Mary

    See all

    Bloody Mary

    Zeffirelli Ristorante Italiano - Pappardelle E Ragu

    Zeffirelli Ristorante Italiano

    3.8(324 reviews)
    0.9 mi
    $$$

    We were there to celebrate my friend's birthday and it was a great experience!…read more Food: I didn't care for the appetizers- we ordered the burrata which was deep fried? And the octopus salad was very tasty. The main courses were delicious ! We ordered the lobster ravioli, Cleopatra seafood special, Linguine Vongole. The food was served hot and we didn't wait long for it. Generous portions too! The pana cotta was absolutely divine!! The best I've ever tasted. I was full after the meal but couldn't resist eating it! Service: Raul was fantastic! He was professional, warm and friendly. He kept us entertained during the night with great enthusiasm and service. Highly recommend!

    Five star service! The front of house was absolutely amazing getting us seated right away and…read moremaking some wine suggestions. Her humor and thoughtfulness was appreciated during the meal as well. She folded napkins when we used the restroom and joked when we couldn't find the restroom. Our server made amazing recommendations and checked in frequently enough that we didn't feel forgotten or overwhelmed. Food came out piping hot, and silverware was replaced for each course. For the appetizer I would have to say that the octopus was my absolute favorite! The Char on the octopus mixed with the variety of flavors made it robust and so delicious! I highly recommend the octopus over any other appetizer at this point! The zucchini blossoms were perfectly fried and absolutely delicious. They were perfectly stuffed not to overwhelm, but to perfectly embrace the delicate nature of the blossom. For my entrée, I ordered the veal Ragu with peperdelle noodles. It was absolutely delicious and big enough that I had it for lunch. The next day is leftovers. They boxed the meal very nicely to go bag. The sauce was thick and perfectly balanced with a lot of flavor. The noodles were perfectly cooked and weren't sticky or overly chewy. The tiramisu was absolutely delicious! It was so moist and so light that I didn't feel overly stuffed when I left. We actually debated getting dessert because we were so full, but decided to go for it and I'm so happy that we did. During our dinner service someone had a birthday and we brought a dessert. Not only did they encourage everyone to sing, but they also brought out a beautiful dessert that had happy birthday written and some kind of cocoa or coffee powder. You can tell that thoughtfulness was put into every meal and effort was placed to make everything just perfect. I absolutely love the atmosphere of this restaurant. We watch the sunset over small old town Herndon and it felt very quaint. The old school setting of the restaurant mixed with that atmosphere was rather romantic and calming. This is a great place to come for birthdays, anniversaries, or any other special event you want to celebrate.

    Photos
    Zeffirelli Ristorante Italiano - Entry way

    Entry way

    Zeffirelli Ristorante Italiano - L'Insalata di Arugula

    L'Insalata di Arugula

    Zeffirelli Ristorante Italiano

    See all

    Mr Pepperoni - pizza - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...