Recently, a flyer for Mr. Pepperoni arrived in the mail. We had never heard of them before. It turns out that they've been around for more than 10 years! The flyer offered coupons for family meals. We don't need that much food for the two of us. Since the flyer included their entire menu, we looked it over and decided to order a pizza and a side of zucchini sticks. Rather than have our food delivered, since they aren't very far from where we live, we went there to place our order. To order, walk up to the counter, and your order will be taken. A very nice older man, whom we thought might be the owner, took our order. We decided to order a "rustica pizza" which consists of: "Italian sausage, bacon, roasted red peppers, black olives & mozzarella cheese". We ordered a medium-sized pizza, which was large enough for us to get two meals out of. The pizza was good. It did have a little kick, and it held up well as leftovers warmed in the microwave. The zucchini sticks came with a side of marinara sauce. They were piping hot and, for the most part, the batter adhered well to the zucchini. I say "mostly" because one piece had the zucchini sliding right out of the coating. Still, we thought that, as far as fried zucchini goes, it was better than many we've had. We waited inside while our order was being prepared. The dining room is kept very clean. They have photos framed on the wall showing New York City and Chicago from the past. If you dine inside, soda is either self-serve or bottled. When our order was ready, the older man noticed that it had started raining hard. Fortunately, we had a parking spot right outside. He held the door open for us, which was kind. We both agree that we would return at some point. read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Rustica - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

See all

I'm really picky with my pizza....so y'all can take my opinion with a grain of salt haha the staff was very friendly and their pricing is shockingly low. it took about 10-15 minutes for the pizza and garlic knots to come out. they had a coupon for an XL pizza for $8.99 - garlic knots for $4.99. I didn't try the pizza until we got home, 20 minutes later. the pizza was ok. I'm more used to a NY style pizza since that's where I am from. garlic knots were a little bland, could use more garlic seasoning on there if you know what I mean. overall, I think this place is great if you want something quick and cheap. if you're a pizza snob like me, probably don't get your hopes up here. read more

As a big avid pizza eater I don't think nothing compares to how well they made my pizza with the perfect amount of cheese and crust was well baked and soft. The wings were good but nothing over the top. I'd give it 6/10 wings but the pizza 9/10 it was well cut slices too although the prices could be better. Still I'd choose this over Pizza Hut or dominos if I lived in Herndon area read more

I usually go nextdoor to Chen's Kitchen--the best Chinese food on a budget in the area imo--but they were closed today. So I went here instead. I might have to alternate between here and Chen's that Gyro was so good. Full of meat and a good amount of vegetables, I finished it a little too quick because I just wanted to keep eating. Staff is very friendly and polite. Like Chen's the place is cozy and also like Chen's is never as full as the quality of food deserves. I am absolutely coming back and absolutely trying the whole menu of sandwiches. To pick one bad thing, because every review should always have at least one thing they didn't like to maintain a balanced outlook, I would have to say I wished for more onions in the gyro but that might be simply that I love onions. A little more sauce wouldn't be amiss either. But these are minor complains of a person actively looking for something to complain about. The food was really good. I'm definitely coming back. After a few more visits and more dishes sampled, if the quality remains as it is the review will go to 5 stars. I never award 5 after just one visit. And I plan to have many more. read more

Piping hot pizza! Fresh veggie toppings that are well cooked. The crust has a crunch to it. The sauce is lovely. Everything just comes together perfectly. Say hello to Mr Pepperoni right here in Herndon, Virginia 25 minutes west of Washington DC and 240 or so miles south of New York City. The menu - fantastic and extensive( please check out the photos) with gorgeous garlic bread, delicious salads( we got the tuna), Chicken gyro with pita, the Italian specialties like Lasagna just to mention a few of the crazy good items that we ordered for the sixth Sunday of the 2022 NFL season; then devoured with love, napkins and loud appreciation. The owner here is a beautiful man who is warm, welcoming and so very kind. The same goes for his weekend Manager Freddy who is just a great guy. The way he brought out our order to go and showed us each item was extraordinary. A lot of love here! They are very generous in their portions. There was great energy and smiles, fun and lots of laughter in the kitchen as I waited for the food. This is a cosy restaurant that is open 7 days a week and has loads of parking up front. Mr Pepperoni is absolutely Mr Extraordinary. This NYer who travels all over and gets homesick has found a small and delicious taste of home. read more

Mr Pepperoni - This has got to be one of the best pies...ever! - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

We just moved to Herndon (va) and have been so busy unpacking and repairing or updating things inside and outside, that we are too tired to cook. We got a flier, in the mail, just days ago. we ordered on line and it arrived pretty quickly to our house, super nice delivery man, who i think works directly for them. i love their flier/ad, it says "your taste buds & wallet will thank you".. they were right! you get a lot of food for the price with ONLY a 3 buck delivery fee, but we gave a nice sized extra tip as well. we will "dine in" next time, and try some other foods but this time the hubby had the hot pesto chicken philly & cheese sub. he loved it. and i had the ham and cheese sub. very fresh! read more

Mr Pepperoni - Mr. Pepperoni - Herndon, Va - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Seriously good pizza, something sadly lacking in our area. (Im from NYC and have enjoyed amazing pizza!) Great crust, more than ample fresh toppings. The Fairfax location is new, not yet very well-organized, and short staffed, although we're doing all they could. Originally made an incorrect pizza for my on-line order, so I ended up having to wait (with several other customers cooling their heels, too) for the pizza-maker to make and bake a new pizza. And not yet well-coordinated with the Slice App. I will try them again; it was worth the inconvenience, at least for a new quality pizza. read more

This is a new location for Mr Pepperoni. I remember some time ago visiting in the old location. I had a craving so I ordered a steak and cheese with French fries. Fries and chips are offered with the sandwiches. The place has an interesting décor inside, old style pictures of NY. Nicely done. Nobody in the restaurant, at 5pm on a Tuesday. My food is ready and I head out to the car. I already had a beverage in the car plus I like to listen to the radio. Sandwich is exactly as ordered. Bread is crispy (better than Subway) on the outside and obviously fresh. Meat is cooked well and fries (seasoned, not quite my thing) are fresh and hot. For the price, this place is a good value. If you're local, worth the trip. read more

Food- I got steak & cheese no LTM but with grilled onion and mushrooms and 2 cannoli's I give it a 9 out of 10 for sandwich and dessert. Could use a little more of the filling of cannoli but it was delicious homemade for sure . Service- carry out Ambiance- the guy waited on me opens the door for me and was really nice Stop by food is pretty good inexpensive and people read more

i've been ordering from fairfax location. their food is awsome. tastes great, fresh ingredients, and the prices are awsome. also my husband is diabetic and he loves their greek dinners. i switch rice or fries to salad. read more

We tried this restaurant for lunch recently, and were very pleased with the gyro platters we both ordered. The portions were generous, and service was fast and friendly. We will certainly return to try the pizzas! read more

I'm giving 5 stars for several reasons. Taste: we got a special, extra large 3 topping for $12.99. the taste was quite good. I know some from NY say it's as good, I don't agree but it was good. Second: that price! $12.99 for an extra large, you can't beat that. Third: their delivery was quick and food was hot. We also got the zucchini fries and they were very good. Quick suggestion, offer marinara and maybe ranch to dip in. All in all we were pleased. We will order again. Well done Mr.Pepperoni read more

Mr Pepperoni - Zucchini fries, very good. - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Best pizza in herndon with better subs always on time with hot food. and never the long they tell you. Ted A read more

Name got my attention. I went inside and ordered couple of pizzas. Good quality, friendly person working. Next time I'm in the area I'll definitely try something different. read more

See all

We decided to order from here last minute and we were all very pleasantly surprise. I got the Bianca pizza and it was excellent. So garlicky and full of flavor. I also tried a piece of the Philly Cheese Steak Pizza and wings- all very delicious. so much so that I drove from Fairfax City to Herndon to carry home some pizza tonight when I started craving pizza. read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

See all

Love their pizza, gyros, chicken tenders and fries. Quick delivery and friendly service.

Very affordable, good food, delivery was 30 minutes early. They got every single item right. Can't complain

I ordered from here through ubereats and was happy with the quality. Pepperoni pizza was pretty good, wings were good, and the side salad was pretty big. read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

The burgers are huge!!! Really tasty, large portions. Kids had the pepperoni pizza and stated "Its the best in NOVA". Even the crust was good! read more

Mr Pepperoni - the menus on the wall - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

See all

This place has THE BEST PIZZA in Virginia. Not only is the pizza amazing but the service is exceptional. Every time we have ordered they've been incredibly sweet. I just ordered over the phone a couple minutes ago and was treated so kindly. Please order from here, you will not regret it. read more

Does not look like a nice place if you walk by, but go in and you won't regret it! The actual restaurant was a little dirty, especially the bathroom. But we all enjoyed our pizza orders. The lunch special ends at 2 pm and they refused to give it to us at 2:03 pm. There is a great variety of pizza and appetizers available. I got the bruschetta, which was delicious with marinara dipping sauce on the side. The place was completely empty but they were very nice and accommodating. read more

In town visiting from Buffalo NY - being known as real pizza snobs! We were delighted with Mr Pepperoni! Had Steak & Cheese gourmet pizza. Order was ready exactly at time delivered - right out of oven. Extra large pie (16") for just $17.55 - unheard of in NY. All ingredients were freshly cut and the crust was perfectly baked. DELICIOUS! There is large menu selection. Our kids live just minutes away - yet had never tried. They'll be regulars now. RECOMMENDED! read more

Pretty solid delivery option. The pizza is decent with a thick crust. Vegetable pizzas are generous with the toppings. Fries are have a good coating, soft inside, but need to be reheated/crisped when it gets to your house. Chicken philly type sandwich is tasty. Pasta carbonara is a large portion and the sauce is good. Calzone is large, could be a bit more stuffed though. We picked up once and it was somewhat depressing inside. You could see the kitchen and it was clear they were heating up frozen fried food. read more

Better than Little Caesar's but not one of he best. Very inexpensive place. You can get a pizza lunch deal - two pieces and soda for $5. Can't beat that in his neighborhood. Very friendly people and they will explain what you can get read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

I got a Stromboli and it is soggy and cold. I asked for pepperoni and there were maybe 4. Way too much cheese whatever it was ricotta or feta don't know. Very gross read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Ordered a supreme pizza from here for the first time...we LOVED it! Great to have a "go to" place now for awesome pizza and salads!

I'm going to miss this place when I move to another job. Some of the best pizza in town, and their calzone is one of the best ones I have had in many years. Always fast and friendly service. Outstanding! read more

In the space between "great" pizza and frozen pizza, you will find Mr. Pepperoni. We tried this place the other night, and decided to keep it simple with a medium (the smallest size; when did every pizza restaurant in the world decide that "medium" now means small?) pepperoni to go. The gent who took my order was polite. The pizza took about seven minutes to come out. I watched the news on the tv in their dining room while I waited. The pizza was good, but nothing to write home about. Think "late night and nothing else is open" level. That said, the medium *coughsmallcough* pizza with one topping was over $12 with tax. Definitely *not* a good value, unless, again, it's quite late and nothing else is open. Sadly, they are also not open late. read more

The food is pretty good here. I like to older right here on yelp. I always get the Gyro and ask for a order of fries. I wish the gyro had a options to get fries instead of chips when ordering online. But it is always good. I have also tried the wings they were pretty good. Not bad for a pizza place. Funny i never tried the pizza but i will soon. read more

Never honor their advetised coupons that are on their website. They always claim "we cannot honor this price at this time" and then argue with you about the fact they're false advertising. read more

Mr Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

the pesto pizza is so good!! super fresh and tasty. the garlic knots are super big and tasty. great food and service

This is the gluten free pizza I have been looking for! It has been perfectly cooked both times I have ordered from them (it is common for GF pizza to be burnt to a crisp unfortunately) but this was perfect. I highly recommend this place, they are also on the Slice app for easy ordering/delivery. This local spot makes the best pizza! read more

In my books, Mr. Pepperoni does a fine job. I have gone back repeatedly over the years. Not weekly, not often, but steadily. Yesterday I called in an order for a large (14") cheese pie and a gyro salad to go. They said 10 minutes. I arrived at 11 minutes. It was ready. I paid the pleasant man and took my meal home. The pie was very tasty. The crust was thin, crunchy but tender. The sauce complimented everything with perfect balance. And the cheese was nicely browned for a great taste and texture. The salad had a generous amount of gyro meat, a nice pita, creamy Italian salad dressing and Tzatziki sauce. I enjoyed every bit of it. read more

Mr Pepperoni - Gyro Salad for Takeout with Creamy Italian Dressing, Pita, and Tzatziki Sauce. - Pizza Near Me - Herndon, Virginia

Went here to buy pizza for the first time yesterday after a colleague recommended it. The pizza was AMAZING. We will be regular loyal customers. Been in business since the 1990s for a reason. read more

Ordered here more than a couple times and honestly everything is perfect. If you haven't found a regular favorite restaurant / take out food place; then this one is for you. Food is priced more than fair and tastes great. Pizzas are solid and better than every chain pizza place. Everything about this place is great. Been years since I looked for a place to get all my comfort food and I'm glad to have found it. read more

Extremely disappointed. Pizza was bland. Chicken wings mild were also tasteless. The cheese cake was nothing but a little sliver.

I have never been disappointed at Mr.pepperoni. I recently tried their broccoli cheddar bites and they were also delicious. The pizza is thin and different from what you get at the big chain pizza shops. Try their wings as well. read more

Ordered from Mr Pepperoni for the first time yesterday. I got a chicken gyro salad. This is one of my favorite dishes in general, and at first I was super excited to eat it because it looked very nice aesthetically. Normally I guess it comes with a side of tzatziki and a side of dressing of your choice. I opted to substitute the dressing for extra tzatziki. That ended up being a good decision, because both the two TINY cups together barely covered the large salad to any significant degree. The tzatziki sauce itself was good, but very watered down, meaning one of two things: a) it was watered down on purpose to be economical for the restaurant or b) someone made a bad batch that night. Either way, I was skimped out on the most exciting part of the salad--not a good value for $10. Consequently, the salad had little flavor, even after both sauces were dumped in. Honestly most of it was like eating straight lettuce, which personally I don't prefer. I tried to disperse the onions in such a way that each bite might pack a little more flavor, but in the end I just ended up dumping on some Italian dressing I (luckily) happened to have in the fridge. Even that ended up overpowering the rest of it. It was a sad night for me. The chicken in the salad was good--well-seasoned. It may have been a little dry, but overall it--like the onions--helped me further solidify very strategic bites at this point. I ordered a side of garlic bread to meet the delivery minimum. It was so-so. read more

Tried Mr pepperoni for the first time. There's a standard Delivery fee. The order arrived pretty much on time though my request not to cut the pizza was ignored. The hand tossed pepperoni and onion was middle of the road as far as texture and taste. read more

I'm giving it 5 stars because of all the pizza places we have tried in Northern Virginia, this is the best of them. It has been surprisingly hard to find good pizza here (and we're from Minnesota) and Mr. Pepperoni has a good selection on its menu, and for a good value. read more