The sides were basic, service was slower, and the meat was... well, it was meat. My expectations were high. Having lived many years in a place with an actual barbecue culture, it is understood that you do not branch out in new directions without first mastering some aspect of your food (e.g. you have the best ribs in town, you really know how to smoke and season a brisket, or your mac and cheese is to die for). I say these things not to be pretentious, but in hopes that they might challenge Meat to become better. Everyone had strongly recommended Meat saying things like "It's the best BBQ I've had", which leads me to wonder whether it is objectively good in its execution or if it's the ONLY BBQ these people have had, in a near cultural wasteland. Maybe you're trying, and maybe this is just the beginning, but I've sat through multiple meals at Meat thinking that I could have stayed home and made this, myself.
It doesn't matter what you put ON your flavorless mashed potatoes, but what you put IN them; they were dough-like, covered in a layer of melted and separating shredded cheese, with bacon sprinkled over it. The mac and cheese, while homely in texture and consistency, also lacks any sort of distinguishable flavor or BBQ style (try adding more salt, hot pepper flakes, use smaller noodles, don't overcook the noodles, add a layer of crunchy panko breadcrumbs over the top layer of shredded cheese, this isn't difficult). The sweet cornbread: some would disagree with this practice, but I enjoy it. Both of your slaws are pretty good and add a lot of flavor to your dishes. The nachos, despite the host's recommendation, are not that great; I appreciate the fresh ingredients, but maybe substitute raw jalapeno slices for pickled ones (an opportunity to get into pickling) and a liquefied cheese (bland). The chicken wings had good seasoning and were smoked nicely - definitely the highlight; would eat again. Your pulled pork tasted like pulled pork - not a lot expected, not a lot delivered (needs more smoke, and are you brining long enough?). The brisket, even the wet, was dry and not very flavorful (needs more smoke).
The sauces: the mustard and garlic-buffalo sauces are excellent, with distinct flavor profiles. The traditional Jazzy Q and Black Magic sauces were extremely sweet, and it was difficult to find much difference between them, when sampled with food. Your vinegar mop was standard, delicious, and non-offensive - I enjoyed it the most out of the three BBQ sauces.
You serve everything on paper-covered metal trays, which is not an uncommon practice, but always questionable. It apparently surprises everyone I've been with, at Meat, to where they verbally comment about it. If you're eating just meat (i.e. something with moisture, touching the paper), you will also probably be eating paper, by the end of the meal. I haven't eaten at a place that's solved this problem yet, but I also don't care; chalk it up to locals' dining inexperience.
If you aren't familiar with a place like Mission BBQ, it should probably be your end goal. They are doing everything that it looks like you're trying to do, but they've turned it into a reproducible standard of BBQ execution and experimentation. If you're familiar with a place like this, you may have some strong criticisms about it: how Mission BBQ isn't "good" BBQ, how it's not really southern, how specific nuances disqualify it. But they're killing it. They're making good, locally sourced food while constantly improving because they know there are other places out there coasting on the notion that they're the only "BBQ" joint in town.
So I am left contemplating: if a BBQ joint takes advantage of the local population's underexposure to BBQ, and no one is around to challenge the overwhelming public sentiment of the inexperienced, does that make this BBQ joint inherently good? To be honest, I'm just as bad as the rest; I'll probably keep eating here because it's all there really is. read more