I have to apologize in advance, I'm going to make a lot of comparisons to Podnah's in Portland, because it is the standard by which I judge BBQ, and the experience I have been trying to recreate since we moved here almost 4 years ago.
I never liked brisket. My daddy made ribs, my brother made ribs, when I thought BBQ, I thought ribs. Pork, beef, didn't matter, just give me a bone to gnaw and I am a happy camper.
My several year stint in Texas never did anything to change this particular obsession.
The first time I tried brisket at Podnah's it wiped all thought of ribs from my mind forever.
I have spent the last several years trying BBQ here and there, even branching out to Detroit and Chicago suburbs trying to find excellent BBQ.
I have a rule: if I don't smell smoke I'm not eating.
It seriously limits my choices in Michigan where many places seem to wind up the smoker once or twice a week tops.
Meat is the first brisket I've had in 4 years that made me smile.
If you have had brisket at Podnah's or the Texas hill country, you will be pleased, though perhaps not thrilled. It's well seasoned. It's tender. The fat is tender enough. But it's not Podnah's tender, and the brisket definitely isn't Podnah's juicy. I partly blame the paper in the bottom of the to go container which does an excellent job of keeping the juices from spilling all over you, but also of wicking juices out of the meat. The paper was soaked so clearly the juices were there to begin with. Personally I'll happily take messy instead of drier brisket, but I may be alone in that...
Podnah's didn't put paper in the bottom of their to go containers. I'll have to eat in at Meat one of these days and compare, I expect as long as there isn't paper on their serving dishes it won't be a problem.
I know Podnah's had to get specially trimmed brisket that leaves more of the fat cap (the standard in Texas hill country) so that could play a role too. Juiciness aside, the brisket made me happy enough to give up my plans to buy a smoker. My 4 years of longing have been relieved.
With my brisket plate I got the creamed corn which is good, it seems like maybe they use some kind of thickener which makes it a bit sticky rather than creamy. But it's tasty stuff. Only critique is I'm not a fan of super spicy sides which the ones we got were, including the corn.
I also got the Mac and cheese, which was also spicy, but good. It isn't great, I have family all through the south, the Mac and cheese is authentically southern, but not authentically great southern. But it's solid.
My husband got the chopped pork meatwich with the BBQ pit beans. They were good, although apparently some of the beans were undercooked (not the small bite I tried) and again, they are pretty spicy. The pulled pork was a bit dry, I'm not sure if they trim the pork before smoking, I notice many reviewers here in Michigan complain about overly fatty meat, so maybe it's just a preference thing. That's fair enough. When in Rome and all.
I'm not sure what sauces we got. Two tasted like they might be the coffee one, it was my favorite. The mustard was indeed spicy, very thick, but excellent. There was another that again I think we got two of, that tasted strongly of chili powder (though wasn't very spicy).
Also they have AWESOME lemonade. Incredible. Fantastic. OMG good.
Overall, I'm thrilled, I'll be back, probably relatively often (given the two hour drive) and I cried tears of happiness over my brisket, it was just what heart, soul, and taste buds needed.
Oh, and if you're a Texan, they have Shiner.
Perfect! read more