Checked out this gyros spot called Mayo Grill down New York St last night. If the gyro is any indication then it's a great new option for getting some Greek and/or American fast food. The place is really only for takeout as there's only chairs for waiting for orders available but the inside was clean and well kept. The staff are really nice and when I asked them if they had a gyro salad that I could order because I didn't see it on the menu they said they could make it. It came piled with nicely cooked gyro slices and the Greek salad underneath was loaded with fresh slices of cucumbers, onions, tomatoes and a bunch of feta and Kalamata olives. The salad came with tzatziki and packages of Greek dressing but I asked for a pita on the side and made myself a gyro with some of the salad. Even with a packed sandwich there was still plenty of meat left to enjoy with the salad. For $14 it was a good value too. Looking forward to being back the next time I'm in the mood for a gyro or any of the other tasty looking things on their menu. read more

See all

Great sandwiches! Generous servings! Quick delivery! I'll definitely go again! Seasonable prices read more

Okay. Well. The Takeout Queen is here and...here we go again. Tonight's adventure in UberEATS roulette landed on Mayo Grill because, after living in the South for over two decades, sometimes a girl just wants catfish and shrimp. Not a five-star culinary experience. Just some comforting Southern seafood. Instead, I got a life lesson. Before I get into it, I want to be fair. Almost every review I found says this place is fantastic, so maybe I caught them on an off night, or maybe Mercury was in retrograde and my catfish offended somebody. The order arrived about 30 minutes later than expected, which probably did not help the temperature, but what followed went well beyond cold food. I ordered: - Pick Two Combo with shrimp, catfish nuggets, fries, tartar sauce, and cocktail sauce - Grilled chicken salad with extra ranch - Extra ranch - Blue cheese - Special sauce A special request: Asking them not to salt the fries and to upcharge as necessary First, the positives, because there were some. They followed my requests perfectly. Everything was neatly packed, utensils and napkins were included, there was plenty of ketchup, the sauces were separated nicely, and the order was packaged with obvious care. Whoever packed it deserves recognition because they clearly cared. The portions were generous too... assuming you could eat them. Which brings me to the confusing part. The salad was incredibly underwhelming. Just limp greens with what seemed like Cajun-seasoned chicken tossed on top. It was not offensive. It was just sad. It had all the personality of an office waiting room. Then came the seafood. Friends... I have eaten catfish in tiny roadside joints, gas stations, family diners, and places so remote I was not entirely convinced they had electricity. Every single one of them was better than this. The catfish nuggets were almost entirely hard, crunchy edges and skin with very little actual fish. One sharp piece actually cut my gum. They tasted old, overfried, and suspiciously stale. Looking at them, I honestly wondered if they had been frozen, forgotten, rediscovered, and then fried out of obligation. The shrimp somehow managed to be both tiny and floppy at the same time. Temperature may have played a role, but texture and flavor were problems all on their own. The fries were cold, stale, and somehow tasted like absolutely nothing. Even if they had been salted, I am not convinced they would have developed a personality. Then there were the sauces. Everything leaned oddly sweet like someone had quietly replaced half the ingredients with corn syrup and hoped nobody would notice. I am giving two stars because I genuinely think there are two separate issues at play: The delayed delivery The actual quality of the food I received Given the overwhelmingly positive reviews, I am willing to believe I may be the exception rather than the rule. But based on this meal alone, I simply cannot agree with the praise. The seafood did not taste fresh. The catfish tasted old and stale, the shrimp seemed over-frozen, and the entire meal lacked the care and quality I was hoping for. Even the seasoning somehow managed to be simultaneously overdone and underwhelming. Most disappointing of all, I was not looking for perfection. I was looking for comforting Southern seafood. Instead, I paid to become a seafood detective. Maybe I will give Mayo Grill another chance someday because so many people seem to love it, but I would genuinely like to see photos from someone else's seafood order just to reassure myself that this was not some bizarre one-off experience. I finished the evening disappointed... and still hungry. And one final note. Absolutely no disrespect to the staff. Restaurant work is hard, and this review is not about the people. It is about the meal that ended up in front of me. I sincerely hope this was an exception rather than the standard. read more

See all

The food was fantastic. We ordered a burger and a Philly. Both were great, large portions, and the service was excellent. Highly recommend.

Tried this small family-owned takeout spot and was really impressed! The double cheeseburger hit the spot, and the chicken wings were just as good. They also make milkshakes that looked amazing--definitely getting one next time. What really stood out was how friendly and welcoming the person at the front counter was. Great food and great vibes--I'll definitely be back! read more

We've been here twice. I got the steak sandwich both times. It's definitely the best steak sandwich anywhere around Aurora, Montgomery or Oswego. The parking lot's a little hard to navigate out of and it's not very close to us, otherwise I'd probably stop by weekly. The workers are very friendly and professional and it's obvious the food is made to order; no fries that have been sitting so long you don't want to eat them once you get home, like a lot of places around here. read more

Excellent quality and friendly service. I particularly love their fries with lemon pepper. I've tried their spicy chicken sandwich and gyro burger. Both are good and for the price you are getting much better food than similar spots in the area. The ambiance is nothing special but it's clean quick. Consider substituting bbq sauce for the ketchup and mustard on the gyro burger. read more

Delicious food and good service. Every time my family goes, we are greeted warmly and by name. The portions here are generous with great taste. This restaurant is definitely in my family's monthly rotation when treating ourselves with takeout lol read more

Food was amazing. We are very picky about our gyros and this place has all our future business for sure!!! Owner was very personable as well which is always a plus! read more

Really good quality for a grease pit, and nice family owned. They have a crispy Philly cheese steak that's unique, like a pizza puff shell with philly cheese steak. Not bad, and the fries were above average as was the quality down to the tomatoes and lettuce. Check it out read more

I go there every week to get me a pizza puff and have good costumer service everything on the menu if good.