I've eaten dinner here a couple of times in the last two months, and have been to the bar perhaps 6 times in the last 6 months.
First of all, this is a good restaurant. Presentation is excellent, service is very good, selection of ingredients is very good.
Why only three stars? In my opinion, it's a poor value. I very much enjoy continental cuisine, and am not looking for 16 oz. of meat with a sprig of parsley. I get it. I am a whopping 160 lbs. male, so I don't eat that much.
Last night I had a chicken entree for $27 which is quite expensive for chicken in these parts. While the menu described it as chicken breast, our server informed me before I ordered that it would be leg meat that night, which was even better for me. At that price, I expected a whole leg at a minimum.
The plate was dominated by a large portion of mashed potatoes. I almost asked if the chicken was coming on a separate plate when I realized there were a few little pieces over on the side. I eventually found these little morsels and realized it wasn't a mistake. I swear, the total amount of chicken might have been 1/2 of one normal-sized thigh! If I ran this restaurant, I would be profoundly embarrassed to have served that dish. Any self respecting $10 diner dish would have triple that amount of chicken, and for about $12-13, Turtles on So. Willamette will give you a half of a rotisserie chicken with a very substantial side salad! More expensive because it's free-range? Fair enough. Three-four bites in a $27 entree? Sorry- no go.
I had strawberry shortcake for dessert. The shortcake appeared to be house-made and was excellent. The strawberry portion was meager but reasonable. I am not sure, but my guess is that the whipped cream came from an aerosol can.
On my previous dining experience in May, I sat on the patio with my business guests. It's a lovely setting, and the service was very attentive. I ordered the lamb dish ($28 entree). It was very tender, but also quite fatty/greasy- not unlike an inexpensive chuck pot roast that was very slow roasted. The flavor was very mild; if I hadn't ordered the lamb I honestly might have thought it was a pot roast. I often buy lamb tenderloin chops at a local meat shop that gets them from a reputable local source, and the flavor is far superior without the greasiness. Not sure how to explain that. But I will say other than the fattiness, the portion was much more reasonable.
Last night I had a Rhone wine (didn't note which one and the by-the-glass menu isn't shown on their website). It was a delightful medium-body red, great balance of fruit and dryness, and I often get it when I visit the bar. But it is $10 for the glass, and I wouldn't say it's any better than an $8 glass elsewhere. My out-of-town colleague had the Broadley Pinot Noir ($12 for the glass) which I had recommended. Considering I can buy the bottle in single quantities for $18-19 locally, this seemed to be a steep markup to me. The bottle list is substantial, and they offer quite a number of European wines, which is welcome to me.
So to sum up, I don't think I'll go there for dinner again, even if it's a business meal. While preparation and service are generally first-rate, I think it's quite a poor value for what is delivered.
On the other hand, I would go to the bar again. The offer a hamburger with fries for $13, which is likely the best hamburger in town. I believe it is a hand-formed patty, with a delightful house-made mustard that adds just the right spice. I would not hesitate to recommend this when you are in the mood for a gourmet-quality burger. And the bar service and drinks are excellent. Again, the wine pour is not generous, but it's a delightful ambience with a variety of small plates. So I would recommend the bar.
Last of all, it's the same menu either side of the house. But if I'm getting a burger, I prefer the bistro ambience of the bar to the restaurant side seating. read more