We ordered a cheese pizza or as it's called up North, a plain pie, along with the Manhattan supreme. I didn't personally try the cheese pizza, but the supreme was good, but not OMG good. In MY opinion, I want a thinner crust, and when we got this pizza home, the supreme looks like they have a pepperoni pizza made, and just sort of throw all the other toppings on, which means they fall off. It was okay, not bad, just not great. As my 11-year-old granddaughter said, you should have gotten Domino's, and at twice the price, I almost agree with her. I didn't notice anything special about the sauce, which I think is fine, and let me add, I dislike Domino's. I ordered the elote bites, and they were good, although I'm sure they come from a huge food distribution company. Would I give them another chance? Maybe, but like a couple of other places, I'd get something other than pizza. It does look VERY clean, and the girl at the counter was nice. The dessert case looked good, too, but maybe another time. read more

Got takeout pizza which was really good. Easy to order online and include special requests. Price was reasonable. Will be back!

We love their pizza. Best in town. Homemade crust, plenty of toppings, and we really like the extra large crust because it comes out kind of thin but delicious read more

Let me start by saying I normally love their pizza and have great experiences. Today I order a bbq chicken pizza half with no tomato or red pepper. First order they cook it normal, I tell the manager this is not correct. Ok he refunds my money and remakes the pizza. Second pizza they put onions on half and everything else normal. I tell them this is not what I ordered. They make it again this time it looks correct. I get home my family starts eating why does my BBQ chicken pizza have no bbq sauce!!!??? I call them come back. The manger and pizza maker meet me in the lobby. The pizza maker tells me there is bbq sauce on there it's just cooked in. Sir please don't insult my intelligence we both can see there is no freakin sauce in this pizza. He is remaking the pizza again now. To say I'm pissed is a understatement. Update: see remake picture now this is what it is supposed to look like. Why could we not do this the first time. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Update correct pizza after 4th remake - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

The two things that really shine are value and customer service. Every time we come in, we are treated with courtesy and a smile. The staff has always been responsive and nice. Love that about this place. The amount of food for the price cannot be beat for the area. Dishes as low as $9.99 and most of the entrees can be two meals. Solid options for desert from gelato to cake. This is a great value option for Italian food in the area. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

This place is a lot like the smaller restaurants I tried in New York City...just bigger and nicer. There are a ton of different menu options. I tried the chicken Alfredo and a Caesar salad. Both were really good. The cashier was very helpful, since it was my first time. Overall, I'll be coming back! read more

I love their pizza! It's always fresh and delicious every time!!! I recently tried more items on the menu and they were delicious as well!

BLUF: Pizza arrives quickly and hot, and chicken wings come crispy. But... we will not be visiting because we personally did not like the pizza nor chicken wings. Selection: (+1 star) Good selection of pizza and some pre-reciped varieties for you to choose. When you arrive, the menu is a little difficult for me to decipher given font/writing on the wall, but you can figure it out. We chose the BBQ chicken pizza as it was our first time. Can't go crazy on a place when you don't know their quality. We also ordered the chicken wings to start. Quality: (+0.5 star) The pizza arrived quickly and hot. The chicken wings were crispy and generally fried well. A few notes on the pizza. They would definitely receive a lower score from David Portnoy's review. Very floppy, crust could be crispier, but has plenty of cheese. The chicken wings did come out crispy from frying, but each chicken wing was not uniformed in size. Flats were not all the same, drums the same. We had a few flats which were miniature in size. At $15 for a basket of 10 wings, I would expect the wings to be uniformed in size and you'd get your money's worth. Relatively small wings for the price. Taste: (+0 star) Hot Honey BBQ sauce was okay and the ranch dressing was very creamy - think hidden valley ranch dressing creamy that has a texture similar to mucous. Not my preference, but this doesn't affect overall rating. The pizza had reasonable BBQ flavor on it, but was dominated by the cheese amount. While I don't have an issue with cheese, I did order BBQ chicken and prefer to have more sauce than cheese. The chicken was more white meat, which meant the chicken was tougher and drier than my preference. I appreciated the non-crust thin-ness, but it wasn't crispy in any sense of the word. This contributed to the floppiness of the pizza and slight chewy bread texture. There is minimal BBQ sauce on the pizza, but it seems the chicken might have been marinated in BBQ. Yes, it's a BBQ chicken pizza, but it's not a pizza with chicken and BBQ sauce. The crust is a little crispy, if not a little burnt. This is odd since the rest of the pizza isn't crispy. Cleanliness: (+1 star) The facility is overall clean. Bathroom is the same. However, the men's bathroom stall has no door, so I hope you enjoy dropping a deuce and wiping in front of other guests. Tables were clean and you get plastic wrapped utensils, so no issues on cleanliness. Staff: (+1 star) Staff was nice and courteous. They just deliver your food but don't provide a 2nd touch. read more

Amazing customer service every time I come. I only order pizza and the hot & honey wings. The last time I came my wings weren't all that great & I had more drums and probably two flats. I tried to loaded fries, but they tasted like greasy and burnt. The fries weren't all that good. They should move the crinkly fries. However, the customer service was great and I will return for PIZZA! read more

Very good pizza with high quality ingredients. The specialty pizzas are very good. Manhattan is among the very best in a crowded NE Raleigh market. read more

When they get the order right, the pizza is quite good , however it is very inconsistent . Many times when you order extra cheese or light cook , you don't get what you ordered . Also, I had a gift card given to me for their store and used it twice on a phone order and when I went to use it the third time the manager on duty said that they couldn't take gift cards on phone orders. That makes no sense and they had done it twice before in the same period of 2 weeks. So, I just wish that they would get their managers and their staff all on the same page and their Cooks more accurate and careful with the orders. read more

Excellent food and service at Manhattan Pizza in this Raleigh location. We enjoyed yesterday's pizza.

Great convenient location, with good, quick service. The pizza can be somewhat overtopped and some of the combinations are very salty, but it is always hot and freshly made, with good chewy crust. My favorite options are the wings; both bone in and boneless are generously sized, well prepared, and reasonably priced for what you get. Garlic knots are the best in the area, albeit not NY/NJ-good but excellent for NC. The hand washing station in the dining room is a great touch. read more

I ordered an XL Greek pizza, house salad, and garlic knots to go on 18OCT2023. Our food was ready at the time indicated on the website. The Greek pizza was really delicious and 2 slices were plenty for a meal. The garlic knots were crispy on the outside, had plenty of garlic butter, and were very tasty. Since we were full from the pizza and garlic knots, I had the salad for three meals for several following days. The salad had mixed greens, sliced cherry tomatoes, red onions, cucumbers, diced cheese, and a vinaigrette dressing and was very reasonably priced for the serving size. It was a nice meal prepared quickly and tasted great. Nice job Manhattan pizza! read more

After that 1st bite of Truffle Porcini pizza, everything else was just so so. Margherita, meh. Caesar salad, meh. Protein salad with dressing satisfied tho. Everything was ready to go at pick up time. read more

Always very easy to order through the app. Ordered steak & cheese sub & calzone. Both were fantastic.

I don't know if I've ever given a review so this should mean something. The pizza looked amazing and it was good and quick customer service. However, the taste or lack there of was the worst pizza I've ever had. My wife said it tasted like cardboard. I'm not sure if it was a bad batch but that was the most flavorless pepperoni pizza I've ever had. Also the pepperoni bite things were the same way. read more

Their garlic knots were really good. As well as their tiramisu. But the pizza was lacking big time. I can't say one thing I liked about the pizza. Not the crust, cheese, toppings or sauce. I wouldn't eat here again unless I was getting dessert or garlic knots. They do have salads so might try a salad with garlic knots next time. read more

See all

I took 1 star away for charging a petty $1 for an extra small cup of pizza sauce needed to finish my garlic knots. Seriously, just give me a scoop of sauce Otherwise the supreme pizza and knots were delicious. I'd consider returning and recommending, despite being salty about the sauce charge. Enjoy! read more

We decided to give Manhattan Pizza a try last night for dinner and we were blown away! We did delivery which had a pretty quick turnaround with a friendly delivery driver, missed his name. But everything was delivered hot and as we ordered. My husband ordered the Small Buffalo Chicken Pizza. He absolutely LOVED IT! He said it was full of so much flavor and cooked just right. The chicken he was impressed with because unlike other places the chicken was REAL, had a smokey flavor and did NOT come out of a can lol per his words. He really enjoyed it. I actually tried the Chicken Wings (Hot) with an order of Seasoned Fries. The wings were DELICIOUS ! The sauce had just the right K I C K to it, not too spicy but just right. Savory, to say the least. The wings were fried just right, to where they were not dry. It came with celery and HOMEMADE RANCH. My ranch lovers KNOW what that homemade means lol soooo good ! The fries were still hot and granted we do stay 10 mins away from the restaurant just another brownie point for them lol. We really enjoyed our experience and will definitely be back really soon read more

See all

Very disappointed with the service and pizza. The delivery was 45 minutes late and I tried calling the store twice and was on hold for a total of 15 minutes and nobody answered. The pizza and wings both came cold and the pizza quality was not worth the price. read more

We ordered take out. Food was good & staff was friendly. Nice selection of salads, definitely not just a pizza place. We have also picked up dough to grill pizzas at home, which turned out great! read more

Some damn good pizza Buffalo chicken And the wife had the spinach veggie. Simply delicious! This is a must do at least 1 every 2 weeks! read more

I recently went to Manhattan Pizza when they were given away a free 10' Pizza for their customer. When I arrived I parked in the parking lot. The parking lot is huge because its situated inside of a shopping center. There was a line when we arrived. There were a few people in line with my son and I being #4 we were able to enter some giveaways and look at the menu while we waited. When we walked in there was already a line inside but the line moved quickly. I also ordered a 5 piece wing which was about $6. We drank water. They gave both my son and I a cheese pizza and it was good. The staff was very nice + pleasant. They answered my questions, I even got a chance to speak with the owner of that particular location and they even gave my son some pizza dough to play with. Overall nice pizza shop, lots of options and great atmosphere. Ps, they had live music. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

The pizza from this place is really good. I would venture to say some of the best you can get in town. Not saying that there aren't better places but close to my house this is pretty much it. The one thing that really makes it good in my opinion is that they are consistent. You know exactly what you will get every time. The bake is on point, the sauce to cheese to topping ratios are perfect. About the only negative I would say is I wish they used a better quality Italian sausage. They are the only real pizzeria in my neighborhood that doesn't use canned mushrooms. I hate canned mushrooms on a pizza. read more

Does NOT taste like good pizza. Mildly warm, messy toppings. I wouldn't return. Better off going to NYX.

I have loved this place for years. Till today. typical order for lunch a slice of pepperoni. They got the order wrong. no big deal, I asked nicely tandi mentioned I order pepperoni. they refused to fix it. I don't get it. Anyway, I left and won't be back. read more

As a fellow New Yorker I was super excited to try this pizza place. Although I didn't get pizza my food was perfect. The fries were crispy and hot! My wings were all drums, which I believe the cooks were mind readers because those are the only ones I like. They were cooked to perfection and perfectly sauced with their hot honey bbq and house made ranch was literally a perfect pair! The Stromboli was also delicious a perfect balance of cheese and meat! Oh and the marinara 10/10! Now the atmosphere, definitely a modern design clean and the workers were attentive and super friendly! 10/10 recommend! I will be back for the pizza! I scarfed my food down before I could get a good pic! read more

I love Manhattan Pizza. I live down the block and work from home so I often go to the store and take home a lunch special to eat at my desk. I did this today but when I got home, I was very disappointed. They stacked the two slices of pizza on top of one another in the small box. So the two slices basically melted on top of one another into a big mess. Again, I love the pizza and its delicious. Just wish I could have had the two slices separate instead of on top of each other. read more

Manhattan Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

Ordered a large pizza my receipt said order would be ready at 6:45. (Was ordered at 5:45) can share a picture of my receipt if needed. Got there at 6:22 to pick up and the pizza was cold. The box wasn't even warm. The gentleman's at the counter would not RE make it as I asked when it was taken out of the oven and he said around 6. So when you order online be prepared to NOT go by what it says and head straight there to get your pizza. If not you will be stuck with paying $25 for a cold pizza. They could have at least offered to RE make it when I showed the receipt. read more

My whole family always loves everything from Manhattan Pizza. We are especially big fans of the salad selections (we've tried many and they are all always good), wings (they let you order with the sauce on the side), pizza and pasta (my daughter loves it for dinner and the extras for lunch the next day at school). read more

Good pizza! I used to go to the big name pizza guys like Papa Johns and Pizza Hut. One day my wife and I stumbled upon this place and chose to dine-in. Food 5/5 (dine in) This place constantly shines when we dine in. The prices are spot on and the pizza sauce perfect. The pizza is great if you dine in!!! Service 4/5 - Decor 5/5 read more

Manhattan Pizza - Nice lounge - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Best Tasting Garlic Oregano Pizza You'll Have Around. At least that's how I like it :) Wings Are Top Tier Combo with the Pizza. Always kind service & welcome ambience. Good stuff Manhattan Pizza. read more

The wings are the best that we ever had. My wife loves the turkey club. Also, the pizza is the best in this area and the delivery people are so much better than Ubereats, postmark, etc. The food is delivered hot and fresh without the soggy pizza that the other delivery options provide. read more

Such as disappointment! The service is as poor and not helpful at all. The pizza was a soggy mess of grease and raw dough. This is my second or third time trying this place and it's maybe average pizza. To say it's Manhattan style is an insult. If you like soggy, undercooked pizza that looks better in the trash than in your plate give it a try. read more

First time ordering a dish because of the fear of getting something that did not looked like what I ordered.Is this the correct quantity for something worth $7 and why is it burnt? Stay with the pizzas people! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Chicken Alfredo - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

First time here and for it being a quick fix on pizza crave, it was pretty good. I love the decor inside and the prices are pretty reasonable. Their menu is pretty decent size with many different options for everyone. I ordered a to go small pizza with mushrooms. Sounds simple right? You wouldn't believe how many places make something this simple taste so bad. But it was pretty good! 10" pie hit the spot for just $9. I think next time I'll try their lunch specials. I'll be back! read more

See all

Sandwich was great! Fresh ingredients! Hit the spot! Delicious! I would definitely recommend! read more

Manhattan Pizza - Italian Hoagie - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

This was our 1st time here and we are really excited about this restaurant being so near by! We ordered the family special and it was fantastic!! It came with salad, spaghetti and a large pizza. The pizza was good. A good crunchy crust, good fresh toppings! We also got a side of meatballs- very well done. There's also special gelato and ice cream. It's delicious! Like custard style soft serve and make your own gelato popsicles! And the pepperoni rolls!!! Wow!!!!!! Will be back for sure. read more

See all

Placed a take out order, waited 30 minutes for it to be made, and then went to pick it up. Walked in and they hadn't even started making the order. There were no customers in the store and about 4-5 employees "working". Had to wait another 10-15 minutes for it to be made. Won't be coming back here read more