Nearly all of Randy's pizzas are very good. This location was very welcoming from the time I stepped in until I left with a pick up order. Loved the pizza and wings but waited a little too long to eat the thing they sell that's like funnel cake. Was not good cold and we didn't have a microwave where we ate lunch. read more

I have tried the subs they are great now I ordered a meat lover pizza with added ricotta and meatballs. The pizza looks great and tasted amazing. Great flavor on the crust as well read more

See all

The crust was floppier than I thought it would be, but the slices were HUGE! Tomato pizza literally has my heart. Service was great read more

Randy's Pizza - Sausage and tomato pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

My wife and I shared a pizza from Randy's last week, and it was so good. We ordered it well done, and it was perfect. Keep up the good work! read more

Pizza was good, but the staff took our order and told us we had 10 minutes to eat after they served us.

Just had my first slice from Randy's and it sure did remind me of home! Authentic NY pizza.

The 2 slice combo is ridiculously sized for under $10. It was not only huge but delicious and ready within 10 minutes. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

I got the pizza and garden salad combo and it was fabulous!!!! Fresh salad!!!!!! Huge piece of pizza!!!!! Definitely going back!

If you're a fan of white pizza, you have to try theirs. It's rich and creamy with ricotta, mozzarella, and just a hint of garlic, topped with fresh spinach. The crust is soft but has a wonderful chewiness. I paired it with their house red wine, and it was a match made in heaven. The ambiance is perfect for a date night or a quiet dinner. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Solid New York pizza. We've used Randy's several times over the years. It's a good choice when hosting several people.

The service was really great! Had a cheese slice and was great! Definitely worth trying

Love the food but EXTREMELY long wait times and lazy & rude staff The steak sandwiches are pretty good as well as their pizza! read more

As a NJ native, pizza is a lifestyle for me and Randy's has done it. The slices are massive, reasonably priced, always fresh with friendly workers to top it off. And if you ever want to feed a group, this is your place! I haven't eaten in, but my food rarely makes it out of the parking lot lol read more

I'm a Jersey Girl relocated to Raleigh and Randy's is expensive but worth every penny. They go all out in quality and flavor,

The cheese pizza from Randy's is still my favorite in Raleigh. It's your classic New York pie for a good price.

Had the mango habanero wings and a pepper pizza. Both were very good. New York large sliced pizza was good with big foldable slices. The wing were great the right amount of heat yet kept the flavor. read more

Randy's Pizza - Habanero mango wings - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

My wife and I are huge fans of Randy's cheesesteaks. The secret has been the bun. So this evening we decided to do our usual: shared cheesesteak combo with fries to eat there. Tonight was not their best work despite there being nobody else in the dining room. They forgot we were waiting and the food was just about cold with nothing from the manager other than we are busy. No offer to replace the fries or anything. The gall is their payment system asks for a tip up front when you pay. Waste of $20+. My wife says she noticed the lady who used to manage this location is no longer there and things have gone down hill. They are off our list for a bit. Looking for recommendations for a good cheesesteak. read more

Should be voted best pizza in town. The Cheese Steak is also great. Friendly staff they also deliver. You should really give it a try exclamation! read more

Randy's Pizza - Delicious and affordable, the Philly cheese steak is another favorite. You cant go wrong here everything is great - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Walked Into this location at 8:15pm I was given eye contact but nobody said anything, I get to the counter and they tell me they only have one slice. Its 8:15 so you're telling me by 8:15 slices are no longer sold to people that may want more than one? I feel bad because I was told to come to this place, lot was my first time but unfortunately it'll be my last due to a lack of a warm energy when walking in a overall bad customer. I'll make sure the attorneys I work with avoid this place as well. read more

Great New York style pizza, I go out of my way just to grab either a slice or a pie. The slices are huge and quite filling

Moved to Raleigh from NYC and was told the pizza here is just as good. Had a 16'' half pepperoni pie. The cheese is good and not overly greasy. My only small knocks is that there's not really much sauce on it besides what you see on the border of the crust/cheese and the dough needs another minute in the oven to replicate that crispy NYC style crust. Overall solid slice and I could eat an entire pie myself read more

Randy's Pizza - a slice of pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Lady who took our order was very rude and seemed like she did not want to be there. The pricing on the menu screen is very different from the actual pricing and she was very rude clearing up the confusion. Pizza was a solid 6/10 but the service brought that down to a 3. read more

I ordered three 16 inch pizzas. When I paid, they gave me two 16 inch and one smaller, maybe 14. I pointed out that they had given me the wrong pizza. The guy doubles down and argues that it's the correct pizza, just the wrong box. We open the box and the crust doesn't even touch the edges. Eventually he grabs another pizza from on top of the oven. I don't expect to be back. read more

Always really good food!!!! Ive always gotten delivery. Strombolis are amazing!! Love love love

First time visit to Raleigh, had to find the best local pizza joint. Randys did not disappoint! Great, prompt service, and food is AMAZING! Highly highly recommend! read more

Really excellent pizza. Had a side of wings and salad and it was delicious. Very quick and professional. Definitely recommend

Ordered a pizza at 8pm and they called me at 8:50pm to say that they don't deliver because my address is 20 min away. They had my address for 50 min yet waited to call and inform me that won't deliver. I have a feeling they are just lazy because they close at 9pm and didn't want to make the effort. Now my family is hungry and could have ordered different food during that time but alas these inconsiderate fools wasted our time. Absolutely unacceptable. I'd give them zero stars if I could. read more

We came in here on Friday evening, I was looking for something inexpensive and close by. This is conveniently located in a plaza with a Food Lion. Long story short, I'd say the 4 star rating is totally accurate. Having been a New Yorker for most of my life, I'm picky about pizza, but I lived in California for a while and had some of the most vile slices ever out there. So my standards aren't ridiculously high anymore. I have a bit of an aversion to eating reheated pizza slices when I'm trying a new place for the first time, so we did order a whole pie. We went for the next size up from the small and it was HUGE, probably ideal for two adults and two kids. We were happy to have leftovers for breakfast the next day though. We paid a total of $21 for two pints of beer and our huge pizza. This is a solid, proper NY style pizza. The crust is what it should be, has a lighter amount of toppings, but it still tasty. There isn't a WOW this is the best pizza ever factor to it, but it's pretty darn good for the south. We will definitely be back and I recommend coming here if you are longing for a NY style pie. read more

See all

I have visited Randy's in the past, but 1st time at this Wycliff Rd location. I ordered a cheese slice for dine in and then noticed not even 1 of the 10 available tables were clean. After waiting almost 15 minutes for my plain cheese slice, it is finally served to me looking undesirable and dryer than a cracker. I was soo heartbroken because I was looking forward to the Randy's quality slices that I had grown to love from other locations not this stale leftover pizza from hours and hours ago. If you're looking for fresh tasty slices this IS NOT the location. I do not recommend. read more

This pizza has gone down hill. Ordered 3 pizzas this last time and all were basically under cooked, soggy crust - 1 worse than the others. One had chicken, which was not good at all, couldn't finish. Other lacked seasoning...reheated in oven to cook more and added salt, pepper and oregano for flavor, which made it better. But overall disappointing and wouldn't recommend. Online ordering is easy and convenient. read more

very good buy pizza is always great, and not over priced like most places are now days.

Randys pizza is just what I needed being so far away from home. New Yorkers know that when someone says NYC style pizza it's a hit or miss. Honestly, we ate it when we were here last time and I totally forgot the name of it. So, I was in Durham and trying to figure out what the name of this pizza shop but I was only getting pizza shops in Durham. That didn't help because I needed it to be more location specific so I could find it AnyWho we're back in Raleigh. Guess what I found it. It was a Friday night and I was just running to grab something to drink, and I happened to be in the same shopping center that it was in. Meanwhile, I had called earlier only to be on hold for a very long time to find out that the wait time would be 50 minutes for takeout. I couldn't consent to that timeframe because I knew my husband was hungry. So, I called him, and when I walked out of the store, I saw that Randy's pizzeria was right there. Talk about serendipity! so I go in and I order inside because they told me that it was going to be only 15 minutes to get my order yippee so if ever you want to get some thing a lot faster go in to get it from takeout don't call it in and yeah that's the difference between 15 and 50, 35, yeah. The young lady at the counter was personable and professional. The restaurant is more of a takeout type of place even though there is limited seating. I enjoy the pizza so I will be back. Thank you Randy whoever you are. We went with the Supreme and the reason I held a star is it didn't have any mushrooms. read more

Solid pizza. Thin crust with good flavor. No overkill on the cheese or sauce. Also, great white pizza. Definitely ordering from them again

Some of the best wings in Raleigh and the best pizza in a 2-3 mile radius. Great to-go, friendly service.

I've had two recent bad experiences with Randy's Pizza at Lake Boone. Their pizza had been good, though pricey, but this place is on the decline. I'll never order from them again. In November 2023 I ordered a pizza to be delivered to my home (I live less than 2 miles from their Lake Boone store). The pizza never arrived. Repeated calls to the store yielded no results, except to get a credit. I ended up going to HarrisTeeter and buying a pizza from them (for 1/2 the cost). On 3/21/2024 I decided to give them another chance. I ordered a pizza from Randy's at Lake Boone. I ordered ahead, for a 6 pm pickup. I picked it up at 6:05 pm. The pizza was cold and dry. It was supposed to have basil on it. There was one piece. I gave them written feedback, but have not heard from them. Two days later, I ordered a pizza from Mellow Mushroom on Peace Street in Raleigh. A better pizza for less money. read more

LAKE BOONE TRAIL. Our first pizza with Randy's was great and had no complaints. Our second we ordered online at 5:00 PM pickup was 6:20. I showed up 6:30 finally left 7:30 with pizza. I asked about 4 times where pizza was in the process. Each time he told me was oven so I eventually inquired HOW LONG to cook he refused to respond. Later I found out was never in oven he lied to me. I asked him again how long he refused to tell me stating others were ahead of me- mine was now 1 full hour later than pickup time of 6:20. Look I don't give a shit if people are honest and just say I am sorry will be another 40 minutes but don't f'in lie to me OK? Finally quality pizza was VERY different VERY poor versus first time. We ain't goin back!!! I hate liars. Oh I asked him repeatedly to just give me ANY 18" pizza stacked under the heat lamp even with no toppings and he refused. If he had half a brain he would have known I was the angry customer he should satisfy versus others who hadn't come by yet. read more

They are very slow when you eating in don't get nothing to take out or delivery unless you want it cold. read more

They say the best food in thee Carolinas is the BBQ, but WOW when I come back the first place I'll eat is Randy's Pizza. For $7 you can get two slices bigger than your head, plus a drink. Not that hungry? Substitute a couple of garlic knots for one of those slices and still pay only $7. The crust is fabulous, and the combination of toppings, cheese, and sauce is on point. If you're a pizza fan, trying Randy's is a MUST. Top 3 pizza joint I've ever eaten at! read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Ok so my wife (who is relatively picky and hasn't been able to find "great" NY style pizza since moving here) said, "ok, best pizza in NC," after her first bite, and then, "ok maybe top five for best pizza - anywhere," before she was halfway through. I don't know that I'm that sold, but it is really solid if you're looking for NY style pizza - we'll likely be back soon. I'll say it's very balanced - not too cheesy, not too saucy, and the dough was near perfect. Yeah.. we'll be back soon. read more

Randy's Pizza - Huge pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Great food, good music, and nice staff!! Stromboli, pizza, and garlic knots were amazing!! read more