Ok so my wife (who is relatively picky and hasn't been able to find "great" NY style pizza since moving here) said, "ok, best pizza in NC," after her first bite, and then, "ok maybe top five for best pizza - anywhere," before she was halfway through. I don't know that I'm that sold, but it is really solid if you're looking for NY style pizza - we'll likely be back soon. I'll say it's very balanced - not too cheesy, not too saucy, and the dough was near perfect. Yeah.. we'll be back soon. read more

Randy's Pizza - Huge pizza slices - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Rude and condescending lady on the cash register really made us feel unappreciated and unwelcome. I doubt we will be back. Too many pizza places to choose from without the bad vibes. read more

Always great pizza!! Never a bad choose!! They bake their pies fresh, and quick!!! They make sure you get what you want!!

Whenever we're craving pizza, I will always try to find a way to convince my husband to get Randy's (which is 30 minutes away) instead of Domino's (right down the road) and I won tonight. We ordered a medium lasagna pizza, and a small cheese pizza for our son. Our son who is three is a bit of a picky eater and usually just eats cheese pizza. Dominos is usually a hit or miss for him, but with Randy's he ate the entire small pizza over the course of three days. Our medium lasagna pizza was delicious and enough between my husband and myself. I did pick up, and my order was ready right on time. The lady ringing me up was super nice and polite, and I was in and out in just about 3-4 minutes. I knew I preferred the Miami Blvd location for Randy's but I'm glad this location exceeded any expectations I had. read more

Randy's Pizza - Medium lasagna pizza. Delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Really enjoy the convenience of Randy's - fast, friendly service though pizza can be variable in quality. Cheese pizza is the most consistently delicious, Sicilian pizza more of a miss. Salads are ok, but small for the price. Still, a solid 3 - 3.5 stars. Lunch deals here sound promising, so will aim for that next time. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Very good! I got the Cheese steak and it was really good.. I highly recommend Randy's!

We have gone to Randy's twice. The first time, I wasn't overly hungry by my better half was. I ordered the garlic knots, nothing to go crazy over but were good. We went back the other night and the Stromboli was HUGE and delicious! My other half got a veggie sub and said it was good. The only downfall is it took a while to get our food, but they were pretty busy so I'm sure that's why. Workers were super nice. We will definitely go back! read more

I ordered a 12" Sausage Pizza via grubhub, well the pizza arrived ice cold because it wasn't in an insulated container. Also, as the deliverer was walking into the building where I was located, I could see that the BOX containing the pizza was not sealed also the box was slightly opened. I didn't know if that deliverer may have opened it or what. Please Seal The Orders with a Security Seal of some sort. read more

Unfortunately I need to knock back Randy's at Lake Boone Trail a star due to service. Their pizza is still solid but have had to deal with some attitude when ordering the last two times I've been in for lunch. I rarely complain about service but in this case I feel it's not an exception or mistake. The pizza here is still some of the better za around but I'll just wait for my pizza at Randy's RTP. That location is 8x busier and still manages to do fine with customer service... read more

I love NY style pizza and this is first rate. Local places are almost always better, in my opinion, and this was one of those experiences. I had the pepperoni and sausage pizza. Thin crust, foldable and delicious. Service was fantastic and friendly. A great pizza and a great experience. Highly recommend. read more

Randy's Pizza - This was a whole pizza a minute ago... - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

I love the friendly vibe as I walk into the restaurant! Courteous, fast and friendly service! The cashier, Angela is absolutely the best! Randy's Pizza Lake Boone Trail location... read more

This pizza can be the best but the last several times it has clearly come from a dirty oven. The crust was so burnt underneath that is all you could taste. Pizza is a splurge for my eating habits and this is not worth it anymore. read more

Great pizza! NY style for sure no knives and forks allowed !! Sausage Pizza is awesome! read more

It's been a while since I've entered the doors at Randy's and I'm not sure why. They always serve up excellent food even if it is more fast food Italian & sammiches. The staff is always friendly and their fries (with extra seasoning salt ftw!) are awesome when fresh and burn-the-skin-off-of-your-fingers-and-mouth hot. It's not fine dining but it's tasty and it's flavorful. They also make a decent salad there but it's iceberg. Some people turn their noses up at that but I've always been a fan so it's coo. read more

Randy's is a Real Find. I'm from Florida and was Shopping next door and stopped in to get a bite for Lunch. Staff Very Helpful and Friendly. Their Pizza is very Good. read more

This is the best pizza place in the area! And angy the waiter is awesome! She deserves heaven! Beautiful soul! From "Jim"

First time trying this restaurant. I highly recommend choosing them when you desire a delicious pizza! They won't disappoint.

I have ordered delivery twice. Both times the 12 inch Supreme has been excellent. I especially like the crust --crispy edges yet pleasantly chewy inside the slice. Distribution of toppings was even. read more

This place is alright, the best part is the $3 GIANT slice of NY-style pizza. But the service is frustratingly bad. 1) If I call on a Friday or Saturday it's difficult to get through at all. It takes calling over and over again. They've put me on hold for 5+ minutes. And this past Saturday I called for an hour and kept getting the "User Busy" message. I called another location and got the same message, so I thought they had gone out of business. I called 20+ times. Staff an extra person during peak hours, for crying out loud. 2) if you order only pizza, they do a decent job. But if you order something else with it, like wings, they fall apart. I've never ordered wings and not had to wait 20+ additional minutes for my order. The last time, I showed up 30 minutes after ordering and waited an additional 30 minutes. The wings were hot, the pizza was cold. If they were a small "pizza by the slice" place with a working phone, I'd give a very nice rating. But they aren't. read more

I have seen the light!! I recently went back for pizza with my family to the Brier Creek location. We picked up two pies...one plain and one pepperoni. Wow. The cheese was perfect. The dough was crisp and perfect. Huuuge difference to my initial visit. Huge. This was pizza nirvana. I have had some 'za since moving here that made me seriously question my ability to ever have a decent pizza. The selection in my immediate area leaves much to be desired. No...really. Again....I tried Randys again as I believe everyone deserves a second chance. Boy am I glad I do! I could have missed out on perfection! read more

This place consistently has the BEST garlic knots and pizza. The sauce is flavorful, and the crust is thin and perfectly crispy. Plus, service is super-quick. This one is better than Randy's other locations, too. read more

food is great. delivery service is not. if you order for delivery be prepared to wait a long, long time, or for your food to not show up at all. read more

If you are unfortunate to have never had a good pizza or bagel or anything from NYC, then Randy's is going to be fine. It comes CLOSE. New York style pizza is only going to be found in New York... It's better than most... but. Not New York style, considering the water here is water here. Period. read more

The service is much better and I love the loyalty program. I enjoy that everybody knows your order. That for good better. I am the Friday woman, 1/2 baked and light sauce read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Looking for authentic New York style pizza in North Carolina? Then go to Randy's he will be disappointed trust me I know New York pizza like the back of my hand. The combos are pretty good deal and you can get garlic knots french fries with slices or sub. They also have calzones which is what I'm having today. Delicious a-yo-a-yo read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Welp, we tossed this pizza back faster than I could take a picture so I will just have to tell you the Margarita pizza was fresh to death. They used fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and basil, I am saying-it was good. We did this as a pickup. The girl who took the call was friendly and funny. We used a coupon from the GoPlaySave book (#saveadolladollabill) and ordered the Large Margarita 'za with a small cheese and both pizzas were very generous. IMO two people could eat the cheese and be happy. They also have great weekly specials with a specialty slice and drink for under $6. Ima saying...good food. That cheese pizza was flavorfilled which surprised me because I typically think cheese pizza is like vanilla ice cream (I typically crave more excitement in my life than vanilla.). My husband, the science teacher, was impressed with their box technology because the box is made to be folded to fit in your fridge when you have half a pizza left. Clearly everyone in our family had a win here lol. read more

Randy's Pizza - Catch the 1.50 coupon in the top left of the pizza box for a future order. - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all

Got pizza delivered for work party the other day. Ordering and delivery were perfect and $2 cost was amazing. Pizza was delicious. My fav was the vegetarian. It had so many vegetables cooked to perfection. Also loved the crust. On the thin side and not too bready. Very much like the NY pizza I grew up on. Great job Randy's read more

Randy's Pizza is my jam! I am a sucker for NY Style Pizza and Randy's is my favorite in the area! I go in for lunch and am usually in and out in five-ten minutes. I like that they have a bunch of lunch specials. My go to is the one topping slice, side salad, and drink for a little over $8 after tax. The slices are huge and are served to you piping hot. The service can be a little hit or miss, but overall since you just order at the counter and wait there isn't a whole lot of interaction. Parking is easy, although it can get a touch crowded during lunch since there are so many lunch spots over there. Next time I'm craving pizza I'll be headed on over to Randy's! read more

In town for work and popped in here. Staff was very friendly with everyone who came in. Great service and very accommodating. Ordered the Greek salad and meat lovers. Salad was way above expectations, good size, and they didn't skimp on cheese or olives (feel like most places do). Pizza was also very good with ample toppings. Good chance I'll repeat the visit next time I'm in town. read more

Delivery took almost 1 1/2 hours. The spinach pizza had no spinach, extra cheese was no cheese. Had to repeat order couple times. Pizza just ok. read more

First time ordering take out from Randy's and the last. The process for picking up food was chaotic -- had to line up to pay and then pick up the food. The cashier was taking phone orders, which held up the line. After paying, I had to wait for them to find my pizza. I ordered and paid for a veggie pizza with pepperoni added. When I got it home it was no longer hot. The veggie toppings were sparse and they left off the pepperoni entirely. Not happy! read more

If you're looking for a big ol' piece of pizza, this is your place. The slices are literally bigger than your head- it's basically the size of an entire pizza. You can purchase the delectable Italian pie by the slice or by the whole pizza. It's delicious, hot, greasy, cheesy, and everything you could imagine. If you're going to have Randy's Pizza I would highly recommend eating in the restaurant. Every time I've got mine to-go, it has become a mushy mess. Not a good pizza to save for later, but a great pie to eat right after it comes out of the brick oven. I would recommend this place for a quick lunch break from work or a dinner date with your husband or wife. Enjoy! read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

Literally my favorite pizza in raleigh so far. I'm from NYC, so I know what real pizza MY style pizza is. This. Is. The. BEST. Always delicious, hot, and fresh. Dangerous for me now that I moved & they deliver to me. Wings are pretty good too. Always great service!!! read more

Utilitarian slice joint with average slices. There is much better pizza to be found in the area, just do your homework. Employees are pretty brusque, which works in Queens, but probably not too well in NC. read more

We ordered two pizzas ...one large with pepperoni and thought we'd try the steak topping too. Eh... the steak was ok. A little like thin sliced spicy beef jerky... the crust was delicious and the pepperoni was delicious The second pizza was a small ....the ultimate and it had a little of everything topped on it and was very tasty. Crust also done perfectly! It took us a while to get home and sat for quite a while but still was NOT soggy ! I would definitely go back but not a lot because the two pizzas cost us over 55 bucks. read more

Randy's pizza on lake boone trail has some great options and fantastic wings. I was a bit hesitant at first to order wings from a pizza restaurant, but they definitely delivered. The team is very polite and welcoming! read more

Update... They have changed the cheese that they put on the pizza, it's dry, and salty. Customer service is not as friendly nor inviting. I walked in, my usual happy self, greeted the employees and got no response. So I payed for my order and left. I will not be back. read more

We were surprised with how great their pizza and salad was! Don't be surprised by how empty it may be. Their phone rang off the hook for to go orders! The pizza was fresh and authentic! The Greek salad was fantastic! Fresh ingredients. Our kids loved the Alfredo. read more

Randy's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

This is one of the best pizzas on Raleigh. A group of us got the 30 inch and it's was phenomenal.

Truly a hit or miss and quite frankly, I don't know if it's worth the gamble. I've been coming here religiously after discovering their super thin-crust/rich in flavor pizzas but I think that's everything I can rave about for this place. Service can be pretty pitiful when there is a crowd. Not so friendly workers and a 40 minute wait for 6 measly wings? Yeah we ordered everything at once and my pizza/garlic knot combo came out in a timely manner but not the rest of our order. We FINISHED our pizza and had to WAIT for the rest of our order. Thankfully, we shared the first combo or else it would've been real awkward- each of us taking turns to watch the other eat... Does it really take 40 minutes to cook 6 mini wings? This place is no fancy dine in- it's a quick fast food spot. So yeah, I was not happy eating wings that took forever and tasted like ones I could buy pre-cooked at a grocery store and warm up myself. Oh and the garlic knots were lukewarm on the outside and cold on the inside. Bonus, they were rocks..... At least their fries and pizza are consistently good. Also, whenever we asked the workers about the rest of our menu, they replied as if we were in the wrong. Overall, I have learned the hard way that they can't handle crowds. They can try but it'll result in grumpy workers and unbelievably long waits. read more

Randy's Pizza - Cheese pizza with bacon and garlic knots- the knots were cold on the inside and rock hard - Pizza Near Me - Raleigh, North Carolina

See all