Clean, great food, great service and plenty of parking available. The menu offers plenty of great food options and don't pass on the family olive oil that is available for purchase, it's all I use now that I've tried it. read more

Well like all good things it must come to an end. I went to this place recently and the way I was treated as a customer vs DoorDash was two totally different things. When I walked in could see in the face of the person I was not who they wanted to serve (not sure if it was race (I rarely play race so don't at me) or just an ignorant person); however, I could tell I was not desired. I thought even if customer service is bad the food might make up for it, but not so unfortunately. I got the Corned beef sandwich and it tasted like it was dipped in toilet water. I never got through the first bite before spitting it out and throwing it in the trash. Sadly I will never return. read more

Excellent food huge menu can't wait to go back. Staff was very friendly and the service was great.

Always good. Certainly the best Rueben sandwich around. The potato salad pairs perfectly with it. A bit pricey, but worth it.

This used to be our go to comfort place. Always good food and quick service. The past two times, service has been bad and the food not the quality we had come to expect. Tonight it was horrible, took for ever to have a server come to our table. We ordered right away and got hummus, it was thin and tasteless, I watched our order sit under heat lights for over 10 minutes. When it finally was brought to our table mine was under cooked and I sent it back. It was something I had ordered many times in the past and it looked like a kid made it. The service was bad and food had horrible. This makes me so sad, I don't see them staying open if something doesn't change. I heard other tables having issues with their orders as well. Just not what it used to be. read more

Ok so after 100 years this place was sold about a year ago? to Alesci's. Food seems the same. If I hadn't been told there was new ownership I might not have known. It was a few years since I was last there. Nothing seems to have changed at all. Frozen in time. So many things come and go. Fond memories. This is one of them. Where else can you get fresh matzoh ball soup - Reuben - etc etc etc - The service was excellent - the food just as good - the price was ok. read more

Omg!! This was everything!!! Wish this place was close to home. I need the unicorn. The perfect Ruben. love Rubens if the meat is thin cut tender and lean .. and not messy. I know ...im picky but when its right im making happy sounds as i eat. This was all that. Theres a regular and thin Ruben..this was thin but still tender. Got the soup and 1/2 sandwich combo . Chicken noodle on a cold winter day .... perfect. They brought me a whole sandwich... i questioned it because my husband ordered a whole sandwich. But she said that was the half ..maybe 1/2 the thickness because his was taller. I have small mouth, so wouldn't want tall anyway. I ate all but 3 bites of sandwich. Soooo delicious. The desserts looked very good but we were too full to consider. Fiona was our server and she was also perfect. Very fast friendly...efficient and checked on us without being intrusive. Kept drinks filled. Great experience. Highly recommend. read more

Manhattan Deli - dill pickles - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Such a good classic diner. Our waitress has worked there for over thirty years and was great. They keep plates of pickles coming which was a real perk for me! I had the corn beef sandwich and if was everything you could want. read more

First time visiting here looking for a good corned beef sandwich! This is a hidden gem in the corner of the shopping center; and it wasn't busy on a Saturday afternoon. We both had their regular and lean corned beef sandwiches; and they are delicious! 8oz of meat so arrive hungry! Nice ambiance and excellent friendly staff. Would definitely return. Highly recommend read more

Food was ok. Most of the place is outdated but don't mind getting a sandwich to go. Worth the price

Almost everthing had2 breakfast and both were the worst we ever had. Eggs weren't cooked and coast was burnt will never go back again

This Manhattan style deli is a delicious little gem in Lake County, Ohio nestled in the corner of a small plaza in Mentor. They serve breakfast lunch and dinner along with offering a catering service. First, the breakfast is one thing we travel 30 minutes to enjoy. Whatever brand of coffee they serve, my husband and I think it's the best! Always tastes freshly made. The latkas (potato pancake) are the best! Every time I go, I say I'm going to get something else, but I rarely do. They always have latkas on special! Second, the homefries they serve are unique because they use redskin potatoes and slice them and then fry them. This makes them soft and crispy. They are so good. My favorite way to cook them! The waitresses always walk around with 2 pots of coffee (decaf and regular) your coffee never gets cold! Keep up the good work! read more

See all

Favorite deli in the Cleveland area. Matzo soup, New Yorker sandwich w corned beef, cole slaw on rye bread, whole pickle on the side. Others I. My party had similar orders, west side Reuben, chicken Caesar salad, Manhattan burgers and more matzo soup. All were good and filling. Be careful, two restaurants near each other, Mentor and Willoughby Hills. read more

Food is fresh, a lot is homemade and obviously not store bought. We try something new each time and it's all so good, from breakfast to lunch. Staff is always friendly and attentive. read more

I've been working in the area and have visited Manhattan deli half a dozen times. Usually have had no issue food has been decent. This time I asked for green beans they brought me cauliflower and broccoli Cauliflower makes me ill. When I came in and sat down I was asked four times if someone got my drink order yet and I had already. That was even with my plate on the other side of the table they didn't want to ask me if my food was all right Even after I started eating after scraping all the vegetables onto my salad plate no one asked me if my food is all right. You also cannot pay the bill at the front counter and they still didn't ask me how many food was. Maybe it's Friday and just disappointed. read more

Food is good and they have the best fries around. Always forget they are there because of their location though tucked back in the corner of that strip mall. read more

I feel like I was totally ripped off!! I know times are hard & that inflation is bad . . . But they had the GALL to charge me $17.99 for a teeny, tiny Reuben that should only be $6 - $7 NOT $18! Places that charge that for a Rueben put 4 times the meat on it! Also, the menu states that it has "Russian" dressing - they sent a packet of THOUSAND ISLAND!! Not the same! I HATE thousand island!! Lastly, they charged $8.95 for their soup, that amounted to a lousy HALF a Cup - with rock-hard carrots & 1 pathetic, mini matzo ball. You SUCK, Manhattan Deli! read more

Manhattan Deli - Midwest Reuben - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

See all

Delicious food! Ordered on Uber eats because I was craving a bagel and bacon. Ordered an everything bagel with their garden veggie cream cheese added lettuce and tomato with a side of bacon. Food traveled well to Mayfield Heights! Cream cheese was on point, fluffy delicious bagel and bacon was amazing ! I can't wait to eat here again read more

Been going here since I was born. The food has always been perfect, & service has never been an issue. Their dill pickles are absolutely immaculate. I also really like the Italian Wedding Soup. These people know how to do food! read more

We were in willoughby today decided to try it! It was loud at 1pm on a Thursday. The waitresses are older and ours did a fantastic job ! Husband had cod and fries, ( best place for Cod I'd a deli in Aurora). I had the Italian wedding soup their version it was good. My sandwich was the Cleveland Philly, very greasy to much cheese and the bottom bun disappeared. We will try another place next time . Bill total was 43.00 and I had water . ! read more

Wish we had a Manhattan Grill near us! Our server was helpful and very pleasant. The restaurant is very clean. And the food...!!! Fantastic experience with a delicious bowl of Matzo Ball soup and a huge chopped salad with homemade dressing. Wish I had had room for latkes or blintzes -- they looked so good at a neighboring table! So many yummy-looking choices! We'll be back when we pass this way again. read more

You will not be getting a traditional Jewish deli corned beef sandwich like you would have at Corky and Lenny's or at Jack's Deli.

Maybe listing the things that we love would be easiest - free pickle spear appetizer, mushroom swiss burger, Cuban, steak fries, all you can eat fish on Friday, cheesecake, and so much more. The staff are on their game. See my pics for the specials each night. On Thursday, I got a free slice of cheesecake. Go! It's so worth it! read more

See all

Good was great!! Loved the variety to choose from , the service was very quick too!!!

Ordered delivery tonight, not worth the money. The soup was $8 and it was a tiny container. Onion rings were $7 for 4. The Reuben is now $18.50 and they forgot the side and the sauce. Way overpriced for what you get, mediocre food and not enough of it. read more

Having a tire repaired down the street and this place was recommended. I had their Famous French Toast. It was absolutely delicious. My server Tiffany was awesome. Great service!! read more

Manhattan Deli - Famous French Toast - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Came for a quick bite dinner. For lunch and dinner, it's your typical deli. Prices were right and the quality of the meats they order in are good. The inside is a bit dated. The service was as expected. I ordered the potato pancakes stuffed with corned beef with a side of sour cream and applesauce. The potato pancakes were good. While the corned beef was lean, it was thin sliced deli meat, just a sandwich on the pancakes. It lacked the flavor I was expecting. I think this would be a great place for breakfast. The dessert counter looked tasty and I'd come back for a cup of joe and a piece of cake! Looks like they'd put together a good catering deli tray as well. I'd recommend for those types of needs. Enjoy! read more

See all

This place was great. Very authentic NY deli...even the personality of the staff! They were very attentive but didn't have the southern charm I'm used to in Atlanta. But this added to the experience and is not a complaint at all. read more

Manhattan Deli - Julienne salad - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Holy moly prices have gone up and portions down. I have to say though the reuben sandwich was delicious. Had to wait 30 minutes for take out. I guess we gotta get use to this. ‍ read more

Good little deli with good food. Some days they are quite busy but fortunately not always. Not the easiest location to find. read more

Great food and greater service. The people here are very friendly and the food is always delicious. Shannon the waitress was very knowledgeable about the menu and very personable. Would come here a thousand times. read more

I remember being a little girl walking into Manhattan Deli with my Mom and thinking, "I wish I could live here." As an adult, I drive 40 minutes to come enjoy the best deli around and still consider bringing a cot with me. Just noshing on pickles, matzo ball soup made from scratch and some damn good corned beef on rye. It's joy in om-nom-nom form. Now, you need to trust me on this one. I've been coming here, eating like a horse and leaving happy since I was just a wee-mini-Cara. This is what a deli is supposed to be. A huge menu full of cold-cut favorites, sandwiches galore, middle-eastern tasties and homemade soups. And if you really want to know what wins my heart, they give you free pickles instead of bread before your meal. Love at first "crunch". My wait staff experience at Manhattan Deli usually consists of two options: A mildly crabby older woman or a super friendly older guy--either way, I'm usually the youngest one around. Regardless, you'll always get great service and atmosphere at a low cost. The prices are great, perfect lunch selections for any palette and the best deli fare around. Any way you slice it, Manhattan Deli is deli-licious! read more

Manhattan Deli - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Not great for take out!! Dining in you'll get your money's worth. Best corned beef and the matzo ball soup is inconsistent.

As my sister and I were driving around, ravaging to find a place to eat, with nothing looking/sounding good, she suggested Manhattan Deli...which was fine by me as it gives me another place to review. :) My mom has been here on several occasions and has raved about it so we figured why not. Our stomachs had control at this point and honestly, soup on a cold day sounded very appealing. And it's not often you see both owners walking around the place asking you how everything is and if you could use anything. Really nice people who worked there. Our waitress was killer awesome. She took our order by memory and we both ordered the corn beef hash that came with a bread roll, salad and two eggs for $7. Cool. When the food came out my eyes got as big as my stomach felt empty. The portions were HUGE! My sister and I could've definitely split one. The bread was made by hand I'm 99% sure and was delightful. I ended up with a salad (which was also huge for a side salad...nothing fancy but fresh and homemade dressing) whereas the sis subbed in some clam chowder soup and insisted I try it. I don't like clams...well...not of that particular nature anyway. ;) It was really delicious and had great flavor and consistency. Not watered down or anything that would remotely resemble an instant soup. My sister and I easily ended up getting containers for our food as there was no way we could eat it all. On the way out, I couldn't help but admire the cheesecake that called my name before me. It was their chocolate one (cannot remember the name of it as I was so mesmerized) and looked super rich but divine. I had to have it. So I got two. No, that wasn't my inner fat-kid talking...I bought one for my parents to split ya weirdos. The lady at the counter was super nice and boxed up the slices in a safe-transport container...which my car appreciated. Definitely will be back to try other things. Really enjoyed it and their coffee kicks ass too. Very good, even black, with hints of chocolate in that too. Loved it! GO! Do it now! :D read more

Manhattan Deli - Delicious corn beef hash! Yum! - Delis Near Me - Mentor, Ohio

Great local place, super friendly staff! The menu and the quality is consistent. So much better than some chain place! Kudos to the owners!

Been coming here for over 20 years for the great servers and that Matzo ball soup. Mmmmm. You can't find it better any where. Great place for breakfast lunch or dinner!! The Ruben is to die for and I highly recommend it! Fatoosh salad is great for the vegetarians. read more

Cold, stale Falafel? Check Soggy pita bread? Check Dry salad? Check The only saving grace was the coleslaw I am usually not the one to leave reviews, and this is my first Yelp review ever! Too bad it had to be a bad review Manhattan Deli. read more

Enjoyed a great Father and Daughter dinner tonight. The matzo ball soup and corned beef was great and Emily had a really good salad. Have yet to have a bad meal here. read more

Manhattan Deli Mentor Oh. How can you not love a place that gives you a plate of house made pickles when you sit down. Yumm. We have herd about the Manhattan Deli from numerous friends that live in Mentor, so when we were at Roma's last hair appointment, we thought we'd drop in since it is right down the street form L&G. When you first walk in, you see the classic deli counter with meats and prepared foods for purchase to take home. Corn beef, pastrami, Latka, ext. along with baked good and pastries. Our waitress, Rhonda was a very pleasant and polite mature woman who was very informative and insightful of the menu and specials. She also came to the table with the plate of delicious pickles, so in my book she's awesome! Since this was our first time, naturally I had a little tasting of many things to truly give an accurate depiction of our dining experience. For starters, we ordered a hummus plate, zucchini sticks, and a huge Greek salad. The hummus was almost inedible, I don't know if it was the tahini or the citrus, but it did not taste anything like hummus, and it came with pre-packaged squares of pita that were so dry they were almost rubbery. The zucchini stick were thick spears coated in a crunchy thin breading, these were probably some of the best I had ever had. I could eat these all day. Roma and I shared the Greek salad; small baby olives, oil and vinegar, cucumbers, red onions, and a pile of feta. Pretty tasty! For the main course we ordered Beef Shawarma, Falafel, and Latka. The beef was thin strips, over cooked with old seasoning caked on each strip. Even with all the seasoning, they had very little if no flavor at all. Sitting on a pile of chopped iceberg lettuce with pickled beets and a side of tahini, Yikes that's alotta salad! I was so looking forward to having the falafel, but man what a disappointment. Again, they were so dry, I almost had to dip them in my water just to ensure I could digest them. No flavor what so ever. Then there was the Latka, another disappointment. Yes it was cooked fresh, and yes it looked delicious. But they were bitter and almost sour tasting. Even with some apples sauce, I couldn't eat them. The saving grace for this experience was the desert. Roma had the lemon cheesecake, and I had the carrot cake. Both were absolutely delicious, but wouldn't you know, they weren't even made by the restaurant, they buy them from a local bakery. Surprise! I guess this is all do to my willingness to be daring, and seeking some true ethnic cuisine. Everyone that suggested this place recommended the brisket, or the pastrami. I wish we would have stuck with that. I am not writing this place off yet. I will be going back and trying some of the more popular dishes. When I do I will hopefully be able to rewrite this review. read more

See all

I wish I lived in Willoughby, OH. I'm from Illinois. I was having tests done at Cleveland Clinic and decided to try Manhattan Deli. I ordered a Reuben, onion rings and a virgin strawberry daiquiri. My meal was wonderful. The Reuben was piled high with pastrami, kraut, Swiss, and Russian dressing. The onion rings were huge, crispy and everything was delicious. The daiquiri was refreshing. When I get back to Willoughby, I'll be back at Manhattan Deli. read more