I ordered the simplest thing possible, a PLAIN bagel from a BAGEL shop and they managed to get strawberry jam on it because they decided not to clean their utensils. There's just no reason to go here when a handful of other breakfast and bagel places are nearby. I would rather drive 20 mins out of my way to eat somewhere else. I had to wait approximately a thousand years for my order. They had to re-toast my bagel because they started doing 3 other more complicated orders for people who weren't even in the store. The bagel itself does not even taste like a Manhattan bagel. Not at all worth the price. read more

Manhattan Bagel - They got strawberry jam on my plain bagel, every bite tasted faintly of jam - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I wasn't sure if I would like Manhattan Bagel at first because it's a chain. Growing up in the area, there were/are a bunch of local bagel spots, but I'm glad that I tried MB out for the first time recently. I've stopped in a couple of times since and can say I'm a fan. I still support local bagel shops and prefer them, but I can also appreciate the convenience of a place like Manhattan Bagel. One of the pros is that you can order on the app and pick up. Great when you are strapped for time. I'm a fan of the farmhouse (grilled egg, bacon, ham, cheddar and country pepper cream cheese on a cheesy hash brown gourmet bagel - that's cheese on cheese!). I also think the lox on an everything with capers is pretty good here. The MB coffee is pretty good as well. read more

See all

I've been ordering two dozen multigrain bagels for a few years. They are my favorite and I feel as though I'm getting seeds and grains into my diet. I slice them and freeze them until ready to eat. read more

I was starving as usual and noticed the only place near by was McDonald's so I was making my way to McDonald's and then I saw this bagel spot and instantly changed my mind. I got the farm house bagel breakfast sandwich and a caramel chiller coffee. I don't eat pork so they substituted the ham for turkey and the bacon for turkey bacon. The bagel was warm and freshly made I ate half and was full. The coffee wasn't great but drinkable lol (mostly syrup no coffee) I did get a stomach ache after. Place was clean I think the owner or manager who ever he was kept wiping every table after each customer left, he checked that the inventory was fresh, vacuumed the floor,they wore gloves and face mask while preparing the food. I'd definitely come back for an egg sandwich with a hash brown in it. I paid $12 with my Apple Cash card so it was technically free. I was happy. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Farmhouse and Frozen Caramel Chiller - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

I cannot lie, I expected this to be just another bagel joint. However I was very very impressed, bacon was cooked to perfection. The cheese was melted perfectly and the bagel held up through it all. Perfect amount of chew to it. Reminded me of a NYC bagel from the ore covid days. The cold brew was strong too, the way I like it. I forgot to take a picture of the chocolate chip muffin. That too was good.!! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Large Ice Cold Brew Coffee 24.oz - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

Not the best bagel BUT they are very fast and get the job done when you are on the Run for breakfast. I much prefer a mom pop café or deli. I like my bagels BOILEDDDDDD first they don't boil them here read more

Manhattan Bagel - Yay - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

I absolutely love the bagels here. I am pretty surprised looking at the low rating and reviews. I particularly enjoy the jalapeño bagel and everything bagel here with the Jalapeño cream cheese. So good and super tasty ! read more

Above average bagel shop in a town filled with them. Not too huge (a good thing) but with a nice chew. Be very careful entering and exiting-how West Orange allowed this nasty strip of businesses so jammed together is beyond me. read more

Made a mistake coming here since I was starving and didn't have patience to find another spot. The bagels were bland and not the best. I got the veg out bagel and it didn't work. The cream cheese had no flavor and I think it was scallion. $10+ for a bagel sandwich and chips? Not good. Next time I would go to a local Mom and Pop bagel shop and I am sure there are a lot of them in the area. 2 stars. read more

Stopped in for a breakfast sandwich and café. Busy area on the weekends. Get packed in the parking lot but there is additional parking in the back. Fast service & staff is friendly. I forget the woman that helped me she had duck earrings she was helpful and friendly. Might be a local here after my walks around the lake. read more

See all

Ordered the dozen bagels + 2 tubs of cream cheese here for an early morning meeting. Bagels were decently fresh but slightly chewy. Decent selection. Looking forward to trying their sandwiches in the future. read more

I like manhattan bagel. This place is about 2 years old. The seating area is a bit small and it's by the door. They do have 3 tables outside when the weather is nice. I like the seating in roseland better but the staff is nice and friendly. Good place to meet a friend. Parking can get full- need to be careful backing up because it's busy. Convenient location. They have added a few new menu options with avocado which are good. I recommend the asparagus egg whites with mushroom on a thintastic and also the turkey bagel sandwich for lunch which has some cream cheese and also on a thintastic bagel. I come to both the west orange and roseland Manhattan bagels for brunch with girlfriends all the t read more

Fresh bagels with many options to choose from. The coffee was very good as well, the customer service was on point! read more

Manhattan Bagel - Asiago bagel with Frozen Caramel Chiller - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

Good bagels and sandwiches! A little pricier but I noticed the bagels are smaller than other local places. Ordered ahead to pick up and the customer service was great - social distancing protocols in place and very respectful staff. read more

See all

The bagels are freaking amazing. Service is always nice. It's a takeout spot but definitely worth it. Place looks nice.

I first had these bagels and pastries as they used to cater breakfasts at the apartment complex I was living in but since moving, I had a chance to wander in here willingly to be disappointed by my experience. Being the chain that it was, I almost feel like I should've known what I was getting myself into. The bagels weren't airy, dense, and lacked the chew you look for when enjoying a fresh NJ bagel. A few stars for having tons of variety in cream cheese flavors and bagel flavors. read more

Newer location (opened last year). Out of sesame bagels. Ok, well, let's go with plain. Lox cream cheese? Sure. Charge? I get charged for both plain & lox cream cheese -- yes, double-charged on cream cheese. Not a fan. Was the bagel with cream cheese good? Yes. But getting overcharged was not good. read more

A quick stop off the road to grab a bagel sandwich, toasted bagel; pretty much anything bagel. Gets pretty busy in the mornings with everyone grabbing their coffee and drinks for the day. Located right across from the ice skating rink and zoo it's always a convenient stop for food read more

I placed an order the other day for a salad and they don't wash their lettuce. Especially during COVID, who doesn't wash their lettuce? It was disgusting. I ended up throwing out my salad and I will never be back. read more

Manhattan Bagel - Dirt in the salad - Bagels Near Me - West Orange, New Jersey

See all

I've been twice, at the location across from zoo. Got it? You must wait in one line to order, then go to another line to pay. So annoying! Bagels are chewy and bagel sandwiches are very small. They ask if you want fruit or potato salad. I've never gotten what I ask for. They don't mark sandwiches so if you are with friends you won't know what sandwich is what. Sandwich to go served in a huge paper box and a plastic bag. So much for the environment. Amy L is an idiot. I know what location I was at. read more

See all

I was trying to decide whether to give 3 stars for the decent taste, or 2 stars for the lack of ingredients. So I decided to just be nice. This review is more for the owner..listen to your customers owners for more and better business. So I ordered online a bagel sandwich that was supposed to contain scrambled eggs , swiss cheese, and turkey bacon on a poppy bagel. Instead I received a "fried egg" and some processed looking yellow cheese. I don't eat a lot of yellow cheese. It has way more fat and calories than white cheeses. OK, so now we get to this part ... It tasted decent. The inside of the bagel just a little too mushy. HOWEVER.. Why are you charging $5.99 + tax for 1 bagel, with what appears to be 1 egg. I am not sure if it was a real egg. and 2 pieces of turkey bacon. I am not sure how much cheese because I could not tell where the egg ended and the cheese began. I CANNOT STAND a cheapskate sandwich..WHAT'S the point of that? I don't get it. A major part of the sandwich is WHAT is in it. That's why places like Katz Deli in NY, Coopers and Sandwiches Unlimited was in business for like 50 years. because they give you actual food inside of the bread. This would have been a pretty good sandwich (for that price too) if it actually had a customary amount of ingredients in it. And why do you advertise a particular sandwich and send something totally different. That's weird. I am going to be weird and rate everything 1-10. Delivery Time - 10 Freshness-10 Ingredients- 4 Accuracy- 1 Taste- 7 Value- 1 I have a feeling that they meant well somehow though. If I was in anxious raving bitch mode there would have been a return and problem. Have a great day. Add more eggs and meat to the sandwich and get the orders right. read more

Stopped here for a quick bite to eat with my wife while visiting family. We love getting bagels when in New Jersey because there are very few places near where I live in MA/RI. I had an egg sandwich with a spicy salsa and it was really good! I highly recommend it to those who le a little scalp sweat. read more

Do not go to Manhattan Bagel in West Orange, they overcharge. They charged me $4.40 for a green bagel with butter regular bagel with butter is $1.30. And $4.50 for a side of bacon. There were 4 slices. I will never go back there again. read more

I picked up a catering order here today. I'm familiar with this franchise from other location. But this location. I will not recommend. The service is horrible. I ordered for pick up to be in & out. But was approach by a rude employee. read more

Don't really see what the hype is. Bagels are ok, cream cheese selection is ok. Comparing to Dunkin Donuts, coffee and bagels are way better... but compared to non-chain bagel shops (who make them fresh in house)? No comparison. I live near here, so they sent a mailer with coupons to use for the weeks following their opening. The staff and manager at the time didn't seem to know how to ring me up (I asked for a flavored cream cheese instead of plain cream cheese per the offer), and the manager was kind of rude to his employee. He was overcharging me by 10¢ and his employee was trying to explain that to him- it was so awkward I just wanted to get out of there! So long story short- perfectly decent bagel and coffee. read more

Not worth it. It's good if you want a sandwich, but skip ordering a toasted bagel with cream cheese here. They have their toaster cranked up on high heat high speed, which I'm sure is because they're busy, but it leaves your bagel black and crispy on the inside but still ice cold. Not worth your money. Coffee's pretty good, I'll give them that. If you want a crappy chain bagel instead of the great bagels Jersey is know for, go to Dunkin 2 doors down instead. They know how to properly toast at least. read more

Meh. Nice selection, okay decor inside. Tables were dirty. Only two good places to sit. Only five tables of 4, so they were taken by single customers. I had the avocado, egg white, tomato & spinach on a thin bagel - but it was completely tasteless! Tomato and spinach were ice cold and really drippy. Coffee had that burnt smell, but with artificial flavoring. Nah. This was my first and last visit. read more

I tried to let discrepancies in my orders the past few months slide because of Covid. Now I'm not anymore. They honestly really know how to ruin a Friday. Every time I order something is missing or wrong. Don't have a special instruction area on DoorDash if you aren't going to even look at it. The worst part is, every special instruction was printed on the receipt but not reflected with the actual food. This is the last time I waste money there. I used to order 2-4 times a week. read more

Since this location recently opened at the end of June I think Sean W's review must be for another location. This review is for the Northfield location. I am familiar with Manhattan Bagels as they have a location in Media, PA where I visit often. The bagels there are terrific. They come close to being almost as good as those at Absolute Bagels (top rated) on the Upper West Side in NYC where I used to go before moving to W.Orange recently. Anyway, the bagels here are tasteless and the inside is too airy/bready; not the consistency of a good bagel. I was looking forward to Manhattan Bagels opening in W. Orange but after trying them all I got was disappointment. The shop itself is immaculate and the workers are all super nice BUT, since the bagels are sub-par, I will not be returning. read more

I absolutely love this place! The breakfast sandwiches are SO good! I normally order a bacon, egg & cheese on a croissant and it never disappoints. The coffee is self-serve which is great because I like adding my own sugar and cream. I've tried a few things off of the menu and I loved them all. I've never tried their bagels so I can't comment on them. The staff is very friendly and will go out of their way to make sure you're pleased with your experience there. You order in one line and pay at another one which is weird but things tend to run pretty smoothly. They normally get crowded during peak hours but they get you in and out. You can dine in if you want and they also offer outside seating! Woo hoo!! Got kids? No problem! They have highchairs and a very clean bathroom which is always a plus when you have kiddies. The parking lot in the front can be a challenge, but they do have parking in the back of the strip mall. MB is my new favorite go to spot for a quick breakfast/lunch! read more

See all

I live down the street from this location and I was apprehensive to go, because I did not enjoy a bagel I had at one other store. My daughter loves bagels, so I finally gave in. I ordered the cheesy BBQ chicken sandwich, a muffin, bagel with cream cheese and an iced coffee. The place was very modern and clean, including the restrooms. There was plenty of seating at 11:30 on a Thursday. The food was as expected. It wasn't amazing, but I consider this chain a step up from a dunkin donuts, so for that level of food it was satisfying. The only thing was the cold brew that I ordered was extremely thick and something about it was off. I asked the person behind the counter if that was a normal consistency and she agreed it wasnt, and upgraded to my drink to the next size up with a fresh cup. My first experience here was fairly satisfying and I will probably make a visit again in the near future! read more

Horrible customer service. The manager kept deliberately ignoring me while I was trying to ask about my order that was taking a long time to make. read more

I try not to leave negative reviews, but this one needed to be shared. I frequently visited this location over the last few months, but no more after yesterday. I ordered a bagel with cream cheese and a coffee. As I'm standing near the coffee station, I notice that of the 4 women behind the counter making orders, one of them was making orders WITHOUT ANY GLOVES ON. I'm looking at this woman's bare hands grab bagels from the toaster and rub the crumbs on her apron. Then she proceeds to spread cream cheese on the bagels still without gloves. I'm watching as the 3 other women are all talking around her. No one said a thing or cared at all. I watched the interaction for a bit hoping one of her coworkers would say something to her, but nothing. She just kept making orders with bare hands. I pointed out to the cashier the fact that she was making food without gloves on. It was only then the women started screaming "Nina, Nina no no". Then they started making the orders over again. I told the cashier I was disgusted and didn't want the bagel anymore. She seemed annoyed that I said that. Didn't offer me a refund, just a nasty glare. I was so uncomfortable and disgusted that i just left. Won't be returning. read more

Whenever I am unsure of what to eat, this is my go to place for fast food. The food is fresh and tasty. My co workers and I frequent this place on our lunch break and they rant and rave over their cold brew. I enjoy the tuna! It's amazing. Plenty to try here will always return read more

Yeah, no. Sorry but someone has to tell them, bagels are not supposed to collapse like a roll when you bite into them.

This place was the definitely of meh. It was clean and the food was OK - nothing wrong with it, but pretty bland. It tasted like a deli in a small airport in the middle of nowhere, not "Manhattan Deli" food located a few miles from New York City. The menu was surprisingly limited. I grew up in the area and there are countless small delis nearby that are much better - I wish I had gone to one. read more

I've eaten bagel with lox in many many places but this one is absolutely the best lox nova I have Ever had.nice and creamy and plenty of capers they even added scallions on my cream cheese.yum yum yummy I will Diffently be back. read more

I don't know what the fuss is about with previous posters. I've been twice and the service was great. It wasn't crowded so I paid where I ordered. They also asked if I wanted fruit or potato salad. I wish they had macaroni salad like their other restaurants. Food was great and very fresh. Could be because there were just a few people. Overall I'll be coming back. I did swing by over the weekend but it was crowded out the door so we passed. read more

I just went there today I had Nova Scotia salmon on a plain bagel which was on their breakfast menu very tasty the windows were very clean on the outside and a display cases for the food even though cold show with parfaits and fresh fruit and salads all look palatable. This is my first time coming here and I definitely will come back my sandwich even came with a small side of fruit for me to share with my son I love the 80s music playing inside and outside of the venue and the staff treated me very nicely definitely go again read more

I wish i could give 0 stars waited for 40 mins for 2 bagels and a breakfast burrito. Forgot to make my order. No apologies or service given. Food was mediocre at best read more