This place is so worth it. The atmosphere, the food, the service were all exceptional. This would be a great place for a very romantic dinner or just a nice dinner with great friends. I was told that at the Christmas, they really go all out with the decorations. This is an absolute must if you are ever in Toledo, Ohio. read more

Mancy's Steaks - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

I ordered the steak and lobster special And the lobster came out and it was cold. The steak had no seasoning no sear and was overcooked. The baked potato was great. The lobster bisque got was cold and I had to send it back to get heated up. Service was slow and clunky the ambience as always was on point I'm not sure what's going on over there. I expected way better and I've had way better at Mancy's read more

This steakhouse has been here since the 1920's. It's in an old church and has a great vibe! Kind of dark for my liking. Service is good but don't be in any hurry when you're here. I ordered the 14 oz. aged New York Strip. It was a little bland but the cut of meat was very good. The loaded baked potato was good. I also had sautéed mushrooms. I wish they were sliced so I could top the steak with them. read more

Mancy's Steaks - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

Awesome place! Very intimate, fancy vibes, great food and service! Come for a special occasion or just because you want !! Christina our server was great! If you are looking for a really nice steak house in the Detroit/Toledo area... this is it! read more

See all

It has been a long time since we've eaten at Mancy's, it was my husband's choice to celebrate his birthday. We dined early on Saturday evening and it was steady. Our server Kelly was the best! I couldn't decide on a drink and without hesitation she recommended the pomegranate martini. It was amazing, frothy and smooth and I couldn't resist ordering a second one! It's one of the best that I've ever had! We ordered the nut crusted Brie for an appetizer which had berry compote on top. It was good but could've been hotter. I actually took the rest home and heated it up again the next day and it was so good as I warmed it up! My husband ordered the steak and shrimp Alexander with a 1lb baked potato! I ordered the petite filet with green beans. Everything was delicious, our steaks were cooked perfectly medium! We also added mushrooms as a topping for our steaks. The steak was seasoned well, no need to add anything to it and I could cut it with just my fork. We were seated in a booth in the area to the left beyond the entrance. I liked it because it was cozy, dimmed lighting, and we witnessed several couples celebrating their anniversaries! I also saw others order onion rings that looked delicious and will have to try next time! We also asked about ordering dinner at the bar sometime and it's totally acceptable. I'm happy that we had such a good night and a delicious birthday meal. I only wished that they would offer a complimentary dessert for your birthday, the cheesecake was yummy! read more

See all

The staff were very friendly. The interior is nice. It is definitely a classic steakhouse appearance. The lobster bisque was flavorful; they poured it tableside over lobster in the bowl. The steak was cooked great and flavorful. The creme brûlée was delicious! I would definitely come here again. read more

Mancy's Steaks - Lobster Bisque (Bowl) - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Normally this restaurant is superb and one of our favorites. This last time it was just meh. My husband and son got the Delmonico steaks but they didn't have that Mancy's touch to them. No seasoning or whatever the special thing Mancy's is known for . I got the kabob that was pretty dry. The Beirut's kabob meat is a lot better. The veal gravy really saved the kabob for me -- THAT is delicious! Green beans were undercooked (wirey) and plain, no seasoning or butter. How boring. The dinner salad was good and Mancy's has the best blue cheese dressing ever! read more

All the above. 4 lunch steaks. Mine was half the size if the other three. Thickness and length. Potatoes had black spots. So dark and depressing. Not nice ambience imo. I was in a dress. And there were 4 diners in our booth? Long awful booths. I'm 69 It's not very gracious or graceful trying to slide into a booth in a dress and being warm from outdoors. Try to leave gracefully that's out! I was embarrassed sliding out of seat. Do dark my sister in law and myself barely found the restrooms. I swear it hasn't been updated since last time I came there 30th ago. And my steak? Was overcooked. I won't be back. read more

Great steaks and maybe the best French onion soup I ever had. The place has been serving up high quality meals to folks for over 100 years. Needless to say they have learned a few things along the years. Don't pass up an opportunity to eat here. read more

Mancy's Steaks - French onion soup - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

First time I've ever been here and it was great. The server was awesome and the food was awesome. The building itself was really cool. We went during lunch. I got the ribeye it came with au jus and creamy horseradish. Loved it. My partner got the strip steak. It was aged and it was absolutely perfect. Got the stuffed mushrooms as an appetizer. Perfect. We got the cheesecake for dessert. It was on the small side but still really good. The restaurant says it's over 100 years old at that location. It was a really cool atmosphere walking into. Five out of five stars would eat here again. read more

Mancy's Steaks - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

We loved it! Everything was fantastic! Love the building. Steak melts in your mouth. No complaints.

This is a fabulous restaurant to celebrate special occasions. We have gone here twice for mu Birthday and have not had 1 disappointment. The servers and all other staff are great. The steaks are magnificent and the est of the menu is great also. Desserts are out of this world, and they have a good wine list. Again, looking for a special occasion place to celebrate, Mancy's is a great option. Dinner, you need to make reservations. 5 star read more

an incredible old world steakhouse that knows how to treat customers. Service is fast, friendly, and discreet. The barn service is exceptional, the wine list is curated and one of the better ones in the Midwest. I go to is the age ribeye and I would put it in the top three I've ever had. read more

5 stars but a little weird. We stopped in without a reservation, as we almost always do and we were told it would be about 45 minutes. We said we would wait. Then some seats opened at the bar and we told the girls up front that we would just sit there. They then told us that a new policy no longer allows dinner to be ordered at the bar. We then went to the bar and continued to wait for a table while having a drink. There were 5 other people at the bar and while we were waiting, they were all served dinner! I asked the bartender about it and she said of course we could order from the bar. We said we didn't initially because of the new policy about no food ordering at the bar. She said she was not aware of that as she pointed out everyone else eating. She wanted to know who told us that. Not wanting to throw anyone under the bus, we just said it was one of the girls up front. We were seated right after that conversation with the bartender. Our server was kind and helpful. The food, as always was excellent! The bussers hustle and keep everything g neat and clean. I'm just wondering if a change is coming.... read more

Wonderful anniversary dinner! My husband and I both had a NY strip steak with a salad and Yukon Gold potatoes; he also ordered a half order of scallops and French onion soup. I had the blue cheese crust on my steak. Everything was cooked perfectly and delicious. Our server was very attentive. The old-school steakhouse ambience only added to the experience. Highly recommend Mancy's for a special occasion splurge. read more

The original Mancy's ! You'll look for Frank Sinatra coming around the corner- excellent steak with the wonderful traditional sides paired with friendly service with a smile. You may never go back to the " copycat chain steak" restaurants- Please don't save it until a special occasion.....it's special because you deserve it! read more

Reservation was a breeze on a Saturday night, though they were packed. Promptly seated, server was very attentive and knowledgeable. We had bread for starters, lobster bisque and french onion soup. Of course we gotta try the steaks.. we ordered three 16 oz ribeye steaks cooked to medium rare perfection, well seasoned with onions and mushrooms on the side. NY strip steak was tender as well.. The Chilean Sea Bass was delish! The meals were satisfying and filling we didn't have room for crème brûlée.. perhaps next time. Happy tummy once again! read more

See all

I've been to many of the other Mancys and even the Mancys steak in Findlay. Right when you want into this place, just the building is magical. We were seated in the bar area. When we sat down I looked up at the ceiling and stained glass windows and was in complete awe. The cockatoo menu was very basic and we ordered h the r espresso martini since it's my sisters favorite. We had bread, salads and fantastic steaks. The food was hot, fresh and cooked to perfection. I'll be taking everyone here if they're wanting a nice steak! read more

See all

Our first trip to Mancy's. We met with great friends. Had a fabulous night. Food is delicious. The service is a definite 10!! Staff made us feel like regulars. read more

Great food and awesome service. You can see how they have thrived for 100 years. I have the Samon and my colleague had the NY Strip

We drove up from NC to do the hero hustle 5k on Saturday and we picked this place for dinner tonight. I am so glad we did. The ambiance was rustic and elegant all at the same time. The service was phenomenal. And this is the best steak I have ever ate. I would highly recommend coming here and I have to convince my husband to drive almost 9 hours so he can come try it! If I am ever back in the area I will be coming back here! read more

See all

Waiter and manager lied to us multiple times ....... I will never eat here again. The price I paid for this meal Everything should've been perfect. Me my wife and 2 of are friends went to dinner here last night and 3 of us ordered the loaded baked potato... 45 minutes after we order our waiter comes out and tells us they are out of baked potato. And that's fine. We went with the fries. The problem is 20 minutes later the table behind us had 8 baked potatoes delivered to their table when our waitress comes back, we questioned the waitress about that because she just told us they were out of baked potatoes and standing at the table next to us was the manager the waiter proceeded to tell us they are out now and the manager turns around and says the oven stopped working at the same time ......... so which is it ?????? Why lie about something like that why not just say we forgot to put that on the order or whatever might of happened.. and then the manager tells us we will get you baked potatoes out asap another 20 minutes go by the waiter comes back and says we're just gonna take the baked potato off your bill. We're out of baked potatoes lol like we haven't heard that light tonight already !!!!we get our bill and of course the baked potatoes is not taking off our bill because it's included in the meal !!!!! So multiple lies from the manager and waiter. we paid over $500 between the four of us we will never eat here again ..... This is by far the worst experience I've ever had in a restaurant. read more

Mancy's reputation for good steaks has taken a hit. Ate at Mancy's for years but last nights visit was off a little. Service was excellent but steaks were OK but not the usual excellent. read more

My husband and I had an exceptional experience. Our server was wonderful. The food was amazing. I was looking forward to trying this restaurant and I was not disappointed in the least. I have a new favorite! read more

Food was amazing. Flavorful and seasoned well. Service was top notch. Ambience was perfect for an Anniversary dinner read more

Mancy's Steaks - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Mancy's is okay. Doesn't hold my attention these days. A couple of our steaks were not cooked correctly. Salad was boring. French onion soup was good. Asparagus cooked just right. Crab chewy. Chocolate dessert bag is pretty good. Waitress was very nice. Some of the ambiance is nice. Many patrons are older and it's so dark in there. Odd clown at the entrance ... maybe it has some kind of history. Overall 3.5 ish. I expect to really enjoy my meal for this $$$. read more

Mancy's Steaks - Oscar Medallion's - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

Steaks are always solid. It's a shame they make you wait at the door if all of your party hasn't arrived - even when the place is empty. Honestly, let me order a drink at the table! read more

The Steakhouse to go to for generations in Toledo! The atmosphere you expect in a prime steakhouse experience, beautiful building! Well trained long term staff keeps this place very consistent! read more

Mancy's Steaks - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

Whenever i have a weekday off, i try to remember to go to Mancy's. The best kept fine dining secret on a budget. Classic cozy steakhouse vibes complete with a fireplace. The servers are always friendly and very attentive. On Wednesday you can get the chopped steak dinner with one side for $8! YES, you read that right ... $8! It's not your ordinary chopped steak either. It made from top quality cuts of meat from one of Toledo's best steakhouses. I encourage you to give it a try. read more

Mancy's Steaks - Chopped Sirloin Steak (12 oz.) - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

See all

We have been going to Mancy's Steak House since we were children, and it was always consistently good and a real treat. However dined there 2.6.26 and was very disappointed with the food and drink quality. The 10 oz. filets were awful. Tough, grisly and aren't nearly the top notch steaks they used to be. The drinks were mediocre at best. They need to get on board with serving craft cocktails. The Old Fashion was served over crushed ice, not a single cube that is recommended for bourbon, made with a maraschino cherry not luxardo cherry which is typical drink style served nowadays. Service was fantastic, very polite and friendly. Ambiance is fantastic. However with the decline in steak quality will not be returning ever again. read more

My wife and I came in for dinner recently. The food was amazing, just like always. She loves the oscar medallions and I went with the ribeye. Both were cooked perfectly and tasted the same. We were especially impressed with our server, Teresa. She was polite and attentive throughout our entire experience. The ambiance was quite nostalgic and nicely decorated for the holidays. Thank you for another great meal. read more

Old School Steakhouse with high quality and excellent service. Steaks seasoned perfectly and always served at perfect temperatures. The side salad is robust with the most delicious house made dressings. The original in the chain and still the BEST! read more

See all

My recent return to Mancy's steakhouse was significantly better than my last review. New menus with updated pricing and a diligent server all combined to make for a very enjoyable evening. The food is great, the service was excellent and the ambiance was what you would expect from a high end (price, food & service) establishment. Mancy's compares very favorably with many legendary steakhouses in the USA! read more

This is one of my favorite Italian/steak places. Excellent service and staff. Atmosphere is wonderful! Love the pork chops!

This place is beautiful. We walked in and it looks like a church. This is a great date night experience. The ny strip was fantastic. The baked potato was huge and the chili was delicious. I wasn't wowed with the sea scallops. I had the margarita with their specialty tequila and it was pretty good. My husband had an old fashioned that was smooth. Our waitress was nice and we waited an average time for foods and drink so we were happy. They definitely had a full house. I would come back here again. It was a great experience. read more

Perfect! Cozy and calm, good service, amazingly yummy food and drinks. Kid friendly. Have been coming here since I was a kid and now I bring my own. read more

I really enjoyed my dinner at Mancy's Steaks. I have been to the original Mancy's in Toledo and think I prefer this one over the original. The menu was good. Lots of steaks to choose from along with a nice selection of seafood. Service was excellent and the sides were great. The atmosphere is classic steakhouse motif. It was quiet and easy for conversation. Definitely the kind of place for a date or business dinner. read more

Delicious food and excellent service! We aren't local, but we will be back! The ambiance is great and the decor is very cool. Highly recommend for a date night. read more

See all

I've been here a number of times and drive from Michigan to eat here. In all the times I've been here, I don't think I've ever had a bad experience. The food is always fresh and delicious. I always get the filet and it's always tender, no fat. The baked potatoes are huge. The service is impeccable. We are always well taken care of by their resident longtime bar tender and by our server at the table. My husband loves the Shrimp Alexander and their Stoli Doli. I love the old school vibe of the restaurant. I've eaten my meal in probably every section and my favorite is the fireplace room just off to the left of the hostess stand. I thought the upstairs dining experience was fun too. 10/10 would recommend. 10/10 read more

Mancy's Steaks - My husband and me at Mancy's. - New American Near Me - Toledo, Ohio

One of the best steaks I have ever had. Got the 16 OZ USDA Prime , bone in, dry aged 32 days, NY STRIP Great service at the bar. I will definitely stop here every-time I am passing through or near Toledo. read more