don't like to exaggerate, but the garlic parm wings at Mac's may be the greatest culinary achievement of the modern era. I went in planning to order pizza like a normal person. Then I made the life-altering decision to get the garlic parm wings. Big mistake. Now every other wing I eat will forever live in their shadow. Crispy, absurdly garlicky, and covered in enough parmesan to make an Italian grandmother proud. I would confidently recommend them to friends, strangers, and anyone walking within a 50-foot radius. 5 stars. Honestly considering writing my congressman about them. read more

The challenge I have when I go to an establishment and spend my hard earned money is how so many of them today, just don't care about that. Time is just as valuable as Money as well. I went to Mac's and made an order. The girl at the register read it back to me. 30 mins later I got something that was NOT what I ordered. They offered a refund, and to remake it, but they missed the point. My time is valuable and they showed they didn't care about that. They kept my money and I hope they enjoy it for the nothing I got. read more

We've only ever gotten pizza to go here, so I can't speak for the service other than our pizza is always hot and fresh when we get it. The Pizza is pretty good and this is one of our go to places. The inside looks very relaxed...tables and a little area with arcade games. read more

I absolutely love this pizza. It's a cross between NYC pizza and one local brand I loved from my childhood. Family friendly atmosphere, fantastic service. An employee saw that we already walked up to the counter 5 times to order for our family and brought our order out to us saying they saw our many trips up there. Always hot! read more

See all

Excellent pizza and they delivered to our hotel. Wish I lived here just for this place. I woud totally recommend this place.

Friendly, live music on the patio and really tasty food! A little confusing when you first walk in on how it works. Go up and order food and they'll give you a pager when it's ready, then if you want drinks go to the other side and place your order! Fun summer spot. read more

See all

This is some old-school NY pizza! Very good, though this was my first visit, based on feedback from a co-worker. I will follow-up after I have been here a few times. I ordered a Mac Daddy with light sauce, pepperoni and extra cheese. I didn't really notice the extra cheese though. It seemed like a normal amount. There was some charring on the crust, but not enough to negatively affect the taste. This is why I will have to go here a few more times. read more

Mac's Pizza Shack - Mac Daddy (18") with Pepperoni and extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Macedon, New York

Got a pizza to go with onions and mushroom. The sauce was very flavorful. This is a thicker doughy crust which I like. The dough was good but not as flavorful as some. I picked up and was only 10 minutes away and by the time I got home it was cold. Not sure why, but was easy to reheat Worth a try, a good pie Wow that rhymes. Lol read more

My daughters and I stopped in for a quick slice of pizza. It was excellent: low cost and high quality. It looks like it's an entertainment venue with a diverse calendar of events, too, but we didn't have time to really investigate. read more

Excellent service & staff. Nice live music, friendly atmosphere & delicious pizza. Can't wait to return! read more

Mac's Pizza Shack - Yummy - Pizza Near Me - Macedon, New York

While the pizza had decent flavor, the pizza was unfortunately very tough and chewy, making it difficult to eat.

I ordered pick up on a busy Friday night. The wait time was a speedy 25 minutes. A specialty chicken and pickle pizza topped with zesty ranch dressing, Mac Daddy size 18 inch cost $31. The pie was delicious with tons of toppings thick and toasty crust. The chicken fingers were also a large portion served with 2 sauces, blue cheese and buffalo. I will order from Mac's again! read more

Ordered for delivery. Told half hour to forty five minutes Called after an hour and a half. Told it was on the way. Called after two hours to cancel. Told driver left with the food. Two and a half hours laters. No show read more

First time ordering from here. We did delivery because we didn't want to miss any of the football game. Their website was a little confusing on ordering. It also did not give details to how many slices came in each pizza size. We opted for the thick crust & let me tell you this is what you need to do!! The crust was perfectly cooked. The toppings were plentiful & spread out perfectly. We ordered for delivery at 12:41, yes I know a strange time but each time that was available had a 1 at the end (12:41, 12:51, etc). I would have liked to be able to type in the time I was requesting it for. I was able to order the day before which was great & the delivery driver offered me a copy of the receipt & was super friendly. The pizzas came 20 minutes early which you think would be great but it was not in this case because we did not have guests coming until 12:45 so the pizza could have been a little warmer when our guests arrived. That is why we requested the time we did. But on that note I would rather have food come early then late since I don't want people to be waiting around for food. All the toppings were great, fresh & absolutely amazing. Quality was top notch. We normally have our go to pizza place but this one is now added to the rotation. I look forward to trying more of their menu. read more

See all

Our favorite pizza in the area! Great atmosphere if you eat in. TV's so you don't miss the game!

Mac's is conveniently located at what was once called "The Station" in Gananda. Serving pizza, wings, subs, etc.. While the pizza is OK, it is nothing to write "home about" or "YELP" praise about. The few times I have stopped in to get a quick slice for lunch I've found the pizza to be poorly made and just a messy pile of thick, hard dough with lots of can tasting sauce and minimal cheese. I've been told that the owners are generous to the community and always there to donate pizza and help out which is wonderful! It has the potential to be a great pizza place if they took the time to care about what they were making and serving their customers. Pretty disappointing... read more

Macs pizza shack may be the only decent place to eat on the entire Gananda parkway. Not a whole lot of competition but they provide the best pizza in the Macedon area by far (place across the way serves marks under a heat lamp for hours, yuck) and the staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. If you're down to drink some beers there's a brewery attached as well. Definitely a cool & clean place to grab some comfort food anytime of the week. read more

Great pizzas and calzones. Their GF crust is also excellent! It's worth the wait (45 - 60 minutes) on a Friday evening.

Not good...ordered a sheet pizza for out of town friends. The delivery girl was the best part of our Macs experience. The pizza was horrible. It was burnt to a crisp on one side, and dried out on the other side. I might as well have just taken 40.00 out of my wallet and thrown it in the fire pit out back. Seriously guys??? It's pizza. It's not that complicated. read more

I refuse to pay $15.00 for a garbage plate that's only worth ten bucks maximum. Getting tired of getting ripped off by restaurants.

I enjoy exploring their menu! Pizza, calzones, desserts, etc ... I've liked it all. They are careful to prepare my order with my specific requests, which I greatly appreciate! I live a bit away from their restaurant, and they still deliver to me. The delivery staff are always kind and early (my food is ALWAYS hot when it gets to me!) I like supporting local business ... especially when they try as hard as Mac's team does! read more

Great food, especially their well known wings! Staff is nice. Environment is fantastic to hang out inside and out on deck

I really love how they decorated the restaurant over all a lovely atmosphere. The owner is amazing and almost always their. The food is very good! though sometimes they mess up my orders. read more

Pizza is okay and a little pricey. Mac salad is weird so I don't like their garbage plates.

Love their pizza!!! And if you're interested in a beer with your pizza drop across the aisle and stop at Dispatch Beer!! 2 great businesses in 1 building!!! They have a common area to enjoy your beer and pizza with your family!! read more

I ordered a sheet pizza with pe and sausage got a pizza with pepperoni and anchovies . ordered 30 wings and wing sauce spilled all over the bag and onto my daughter's brand new sweat.. I am a big fan but not today at all.... read more

Macs will be our new go to place for pizza and how lucky are we that we live around the corner from them. I have been there twice since moving here in July and we really Love the pizza and the friendly service, we will continue to go here from now on because we tried all the rest and this is the best. read more

Wonderful owners, great people amazing food choices and one of my go to places for all things food!

Coming back from a tournament at the local sports complex, this pizza place not only was the closest but had the best reviews. A nice medium thick crust was crisp, just like my favorite "Buffalo" pizza. The pizza came out quick and we dined in. A nice sweet sauce and the large was a perfect size. The wings weren't as crispy and saucy as I like, but being from Buffalo we are a bit snobby. I'd go back! read more

I haven't got a lot to say about Mac's, other than the delivery has always been on time and pizzas ready at the pickup time. Oh, and they also have my favorite pizza *ever*. Their buffalo chicken pizza is to die for, in my opinion. It's the only buffalo chicken pizza where the chicken pieces aren't flimsy slices of chicken. It's like, whole chunks of chicken tender. It's seriously to die for, and my favorite pizza of any I've ever tried. If this place ever closes down, it'll be a full on mourning period for me. Wings here are alright. A few times they came a little undercooked but nothing major. For the most part they are good, if on the smaller side. The few times I've picked up single slices, they were good too. A solid business and chill people all around. read more

Great service! Quick and delicious pizza and subs! Slices available too. We love macs pizza shack!

service is terrible! cashier Daniel (?) made fun of me to one of my friends who was ordering the food. but it's not like i'm the one who was tryna have a 2man w 2 other people& his sister..... yikes! read more

The family decided to order from mac's and have it delivered the calzones were so big that just one would've been good enough great pizza

Convenient and quick, however the white pizza needs work otherwise I'd give 5 stars. Friendly staff!

horrible customer service. received two raw pizzas and was told it was too late for a refund when i had requested it that day. i was offered a compensation equal to the amount payed for the two pizzas towards my next purchase. i then called to place an order and the worker was beyond rude and denied our previous deal. will not be ordering again and i do not advise giving this business service. read more

Really good pizza, used to get their lunch specials all the time when i worked right around the corner. Miss be able to grab a slice for Lunch but still pick up a pizza for dinner every once and a while. read more

Nice new location. Great landscaping. Order was ready when they said it would be. Wings were delightful and the Fried dough was spot on!!!! read more

We tried this place for the first time last night. So happy with the pizza and wings we ordered. Customer service was great and since I work in retail, I appreciate this! The pizza was perfectly done ,as ordered. I always order my wings extra crispy and they nailed it. Sauce was yummy also! This will be our new place to order from. Delivery was also on time. Can't wait to try more items from their menu!! read more

How come the only time there's food here in the morning is when the lady with glasses is working? Whenever it's the guy with the backwards hat and gauges there's guaranteed to be two slices of old gross breakfast pizza and "I had like ten but someone JUST bought all the breakfast sandwiches a couple minutes ago" every single time with that excuse. Yet, he magically decides to never make more when that happens? Very inconsistent service. read more

Excellent food at an affordable price. Super speedy delivery, though the menu is small what they do, do, they do well. They have been the slayers of all other local pizza joints for me and my family. read more