Love the pizza, have been picking up pizzas here for years. Fast, good and decently priced and sized.

We had a catered lunch for work today from this restaurant. Unfortunately the delivery was late, but everyone seemed to enjoy the food. I found the chicken French dry and lacking seasoning. The salad was fun with chickpeas added, I thought a good option for protein if anyone didn't eat meat! I was surprised that garlic bread or knots weren't included with such a large order, but maybe that's just a local thing in Syracuse. read more

Ordered 2 pizzas. Did a combo which was great to see regular wings as an option not just boneless. Pizza was great. Wings were great. Happy to have this as a staple in town. read more

The calzone was delicious! I will say I only came here to play the pinball machine, but I was quite surprised by how good the food was. The owner was very kind and happy to supply as many quarters as needed. read more

If you want a traditional calzone don't order from here. Their food is good but this is not a traditional calzone. It's like a very thin stuffed pizza with not much filling in it. It tasted ok but my tastebuds were expecting a traditional calzone. I put a pen in the picture so you can see the sizing of it. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - Calzone - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Came here with a friend and our kids after a day at the zoo. We had a short wait and we're able to catch up while the employee brought over hot and fresh French Fries. They were out of this world and we're crispy while not being overly greasy. The pizza was really good. Crust was perfect sauce to cheese ratio was on point. Place was fairly busy but still running smoothly. read more

5/10 pizza. If you like thin and crispy pizza, this would be totally up your ally. I prefer doughier pizza and cup char pepperoni. Better pizza joints in Rochester in my opinion. read more

This pizza place is just down the road from House of Guitars on Titus Ave. I love this place. Not the cheapest pizza but they are one of the best! They are never stingy on pizza toppings and have many items to choose from. Delish! I also like the sweet tart sauce for my wings and to dip the outside pizza crust in. The wings are also good. I like extra crispy and they are really good. I will be happy to move closer to this place! read more

See all

Order was 2 hours late, ended up canceling and refunding, don't get my time back. Should know better than to use Grubhub, its a crappy delivery service. The manager even admitted on the phone that they do this all the time. read more

It's dirty inside. The dining room looks like it hasn't been cleaned in months. The slices are out in the open on a shelf with papers & stuff above it. It smells & the owner is rude. I completed my purchase of one slice & tossed it. If their dining room is that dirty, I can imagine the kitchen. What I could see of it was not good at all. CLEAN YOUR RESTAURANT & WASH YOUR WORK SHIRT.... Geesh read more

There is simply no better pizza in Rochester NY! We drive from Webster as we love it so much! Their sauce is to die for, I wish I had the recipe for my pasta. Their toppings are generous and the crust is delicious and not greasy like other pizza places! read more

I can't say enough about how DELICIOUS everything here is. The pizza, doughy and amazing. The wings, you have the option to pick drums or flats (drums are gross ((personal opinion lol)) ) No where let's you pick drums or flats except here. More wing sauce options than anywhere. And they have Uncle Ralph sauces (RIP) which coming from someone who worked with him and love his sauces, it's so nice to see his legacy living on and his sauces still being used by local businesses. So we get 2 ton Tony's for every party. We live in Webster so if it's a small order or we don't feel like driving we get Mark's. But after ordering things we don't normally, like GARLIC KNOTS. I'm taking the 20 min trip from now on. The BEST garlic KNOTS I have ever had. I could eat them every day for the rest of my life. Didn't even need marinara. The pizza is always perfect. Sauce is amazing. Cheese isn't skimped on. I always order extra cheese from any other pizza place.. not necessary here. They don't skimp on ingredients or flavor. The pickup today was super easy. I called when I was outside and they put it in my trunk for me. Everyone there is super nice. I highly recommend!!!!!! read more

Absolutely spectacular food and amazingly attentive service. One of the best pizzas ever, definitely recommend read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - Spectacular - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Food is usually good but service is not. I emailed them 3 times about missing items and wanting a refund and never heard back. Wont order from them again. read more

This is my go to on grub hub in Irondequoit. I really enjoy their pizza its ways hot and delicious. And they deliver theirselves, it never takes as long as grub hub states. I think their prices are very affordable and in close range to other pizza joints in the area. Another thing I like about 2 ton Tony's is that they do take part in fundraisers in the Irondequoit community and I think that's important in business. I also order wings from here frequently extra extra crispy, and they are perfect. The calzones are huge and my husband loves them. Only place that could use improvement is their garbage plates, but they are a pizza joint, get the pizza... Definitely a place to check out if you haven't. read more

Great pizza. Closest to NYC pizza. Full of flavor... great location place looks ok.. but again it's a pizza shop read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - Yummy - best pizza in Rochester - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

One of the better takeout pizzas I have had. Great topping selection, nice crust. Buffalo wings were excellent, crisp and sauced perfectly. If I lived closer, this would probably be my go to place! read more

Great place for a slice, a HUGE slice. It covered three paper plates. They have a wide variety of wing sauces to dip in. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - big slices - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Their chicken wings (bone-in & boneless) are absolutely wonderful! Both are tender & cooked absolutely perfectly! Definitely worth the cost!! read more

I'm sorry "Tony P." but your comment is incorrect. You never made good on anything. I find it amusing and quite humorous that you would make the claims and report that you made this right when I know for a FACT you didn't and that you also would have zero way of remembering me or my specific situation. This is pathetic. read more

Pizza is very good, lots of flavor and fresh ingredients. Sent pizza to a medical facility as a thank you. Super good definitely would recommend. Thank you!!! read more

The slice was giant and actually had great crisp after it was heated up for me. The taste was probably 4 stars for Rochester pizza but as I ate my slice alone in the dining area, I heard the workers, possibly the owner talking poorly about other customers. I may return for a slice but if I hear this talk again, it will be my last time. read more

Arrived in town yesterday! Looking for some NY pizza! This is a hole in the wall place with tasty, flavorful pepperoni pie! Slices are huge! One is enough and satisfying unless you want to weigh two tons!! Friendly and hard working owner! Give it a try! Heads and shoulders over place we tried yesterday in what is a snooty area around these parts! See other review. read more

Best tasting pizza sauce in town. They don't seem to skimp when it comes to quality ingredients and spices. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - Slice with pepperoni and bacon. The slice was partially cut through so I could share ( Yeah, like that's going to happen!! Get'cher own!!). - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Ordered from Tony's tonight for the first time. A delicious pizza with loaded toppings...impressive! They are definitely a favorite now'

Best breakfast pizza in Rochester , ordered three for Thanksgiving and everyone enjoyed them immensely

Best pizza in Rochester! Love the fresh ingredients used. No one else uses the cheese they use it is amazing. Check the website for deals.

Great pizza! My favorite is with pepperoni and bacon. Their pizzas have a good mixture of toppings, cheese, and sauce. They also have really good fried ravioli. In my opinion, this is one of the best pizza places in Rochester. read more

Wow a hidden gem. Dam good pizza a pleasant surprise. If you've been around a while and remember Proietti's on Goodman Street back in the day, well this place is using the same family recipes. They have three types of pepperoni, regular, beef and cup-n-char. Now that's my kind of place I wish more places would offer choices and pepperoni, our favorite is cup-n-char. Tried a white clam pie, outstanding.............. read more

Ordered delivery while in Rochester, NY for field work. I had been traveling all day from KY on flights and finally got to the hotel and needed food fast. Was hANGRY, and 2 Ton Tony's hit the spot. I ordered cheese bread, boneless wings with the Golden Ragin' Cajun sauce (mix of Cajun and Garlic/Parmesan sauce), and a house salad. The cheese bread was HUGE! No complaints here, just didn't realize how much I was ordering, have leftovers in the fridge. It was good, and very bad for me, which was what I was going for. The wings and sauce were great. The sauce was not spicy, just flavorful, I really liked it. The salad, just okay, I will say the ranch dressing was very good. Yes, it is possible to do ranch badly, or even choose ranch dressing badly (if bought in), either way, well made OR well bought ranch. I would recommend 2 Ton Tony's. I think if I lived here, it would be a go-to pizza night destination. Wish I would have tried the pizza, though, had just had pizza before leaving KY, so I needed to change it up. Maybe next time! read more

We love the food from Two Ton Tony's! We mainly go with pizza and wings. Wings, crispy with the Tropical sauce...can't be beat!

Huge slices and delicious! I would always make sure to grab a slice for lunch when I would fill in at our spencerport property. 2 ton Tony's probably offers the biggest slices around Rochester. I love that they do not lack in toppings and when I say topping I generally mean cheese and sauce. Nothing is worse than a dry crusty pizza. A must try for sure. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - So big, I needed it sliced it half - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

When we moved to Irondequoit we ordered from here the first night. We got delivery it came quickly and the food was so good. Nothing else compares. This is our go to place for pizza, wings, and all their other menu items too. Also a perfect place to stop for a slice. The staff is also super friendly. Does not disappoint. read more

This place is awesome 4 the taste of pizza. The business is owned by the family who run the Italian restaurant in webster called proitties. Please check this place out plus the 1 in webster. They continue 2 amaze Rochester with great quality Italian cooking. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - 2 Ton Tony"s Pizza - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I work nearby and 2 Ton Tony's has hit the spot for lunch on more than one occasion. I have only tried the slice of spinach, artichoke and ricotta pizza. The crust is thin, which normally I don't love. I think that they they reheat/crisp the slice before serving definitely helps. The portions are HUGE and I've only eaten the whole thing once. Definitely a good amount of pizza for the price (a slice and a 20oz of Coke come to less than $8). I feel like the Titus Mall isn't the most glamorous and smelled rather like a gross bathroom last time I was in. read more

2 Ton Tony's Pizza - Size of the lunch slices (both are included), which a coke for size comparison. - Chicken Wings Near Me - Rochester, New York

Super fun atmosphere inside. Ordered pizza to go was ready on time and friendly and personable staff added to the overall experience. Have had before at parties but this was the first time ordering. Slices are cut into squares which I was expecting . Look forward to trying other menu items. Breakfast pizza is always a great choice read more

This pizza came highly recommended and I have to say after trying it twice we were really disappointed both times. Ordered just with extra cheese. Both times there was almost no cheese on it, and a ton of sauce. We also had the wings (mild and garlic Parmesan). Both were dry and lacking flavor. Won't be going back. read more

My fiance and I were invited to dinner at her mom's place, where she was serving pizza from another establishment (silly woman), so I thought we would compliment the dinner with some wings. I've never had 2 Ton Tony's wings before, but the place is right on the way to mom's house so I placed an order online and prepaid. I also requested a specific pick-up time a couple hours later. I ordered 2 15-count orders, one mild and one sweet. I arrive at the pizzeria exactly at my requested time and Boom!, my wings were in the process of being put in the trays and bagged. After ordering several hours earlier my order was delivered hot out of the fryer. OK, that's point #1. I take my order to the car and the first thing I said to my fiance was the young lady at the counter was the friendliest, sweetest gal ever! I came into contact with a couple other employees who were also very friendly. But I'll say it again, the young lady at the counter was exceptional! That's point #2. We take our wings to supper and they are an unqualified hit! Everyone loved them. None of us are particularly fond of extreme hot sauce so the mild was perfect for our crowd. But I gotta tell ya the sweet sauce was so freaking good, like nothing I have ever tasted before (and I'm 60+; I've been eating wings a very long time). That's point #3! Three for three, that's what they call batting a thousand. And that means I'll be back again and again. Thank you 2 Ton Tony's! Great job! See ya soon. read more

Our family always orders from 2 ton Tony's. When we first moved to our neighborhood 5 years ago they sent us a voucher for a free pizza so that we could try them out. Such a great way to earn loyal customers and get your product out there. What I like about the pizza is the amount of toppings they put on! I hate when toppings are sparse. The crust is not thin or thick. Just right. The sauce has a lot of flavor. The wings are the best I've had when delivered. They somehow still remain crispy. I also like the variety of sauce choices they have. The service has always been pleasant and I love that you can order online! Vegy convenient. read more

Best pizza in irondequoit. Previous reviews about amount of cheese on pizza and dry wings are accurate to an extent. I always try to order my wings with the note "extra saucy" and if the people working always delivered on that I would be ecstatic, but sometimes they ignore me. It's too bad, because the sauce is delicious and makes them into excellent wings. Pizza sauce is well spiced and cheese just enough to cover- it might be a little 'juicy hot out of the oven, but the pizza makes superior leftovers. they are always fast, owner is always super nice. I'll turn this review to five stars the day i can order extra wing sauce on grubhub or that "extra saucy" is always honored. read more