Just what we needed for some girlfriend time after going to the coffee shop needed a cocktail and some good lunch. Thank you Michelle. I don't know how you do it. It was a room full of people and you handled us all. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Fried - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Friday was our first time there. We were seated right away for some drinks and a late lunch. Service was outstanding and I enjoyed was the atmosphere at the bar. Many seemed to know one another and it reminded me of a modern Cheers type feel. We ordered the turkey wrap with waffle fries and the Korean Good For Your Soeul Burger and tater tots. Everything was absolutely delicious and enough for two meals. I would highly recommend the Old Stone Tavern. That extra crisp on my tater tots and melt in your mouth flavor on the burger was on point! read more

See all

Kinda disappointing I've been there twice now before I decided to write a review. 1st time I got their 'Kevin Bacon' burger and I ordered it 'medium' with the mac salad for a side. The taste was good but overcooked and dry and it had no bacon. I waited 45 minutes to get my food on a workday and being in a rush with 15 minutes left to eat and return to work, I didn't bring this to anyone's attention. Went back last night, ordered a fish fry with Mac salad and another Kevin Bacon burger for my wife along with their Flight of Wings. The burger was cooked medium this time. The fish is frozen, not fresh. The wings were frozen as well. I ordered Buffalo hot sauce and it was mild...no kick whatsoever. The mac salad this time had way too much mayonnaise. The food here is 'average' and based on my experience, it is also inconsistent. The owner/servers are friendly. This is an average " bite to eat" place, not a food experience place. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Wing Flight - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

I have been here twice, both for quick meetups with a friend and we wanted to have a drink together, but also something to eat. Both times the atmosphere was wonderful! Staff were very welcoming and helpful, The food was equally wonderful and the cocktails and beer selections were great. A wonderful casual spot! read more

placed order at 530 in the evening. then at 815, order canceled without explanation. completely unacceptable. never again

The menu here is so fun! We've tried a lot of different things - the smash burgers, garbage plate tacos, crab Rangoon pizza (my favorite), mozzarella sticks, mac and cheese, and more! This is a typically busy and loud restaurant/bar. The food is generally fantastic but I find it more pleasant to order take out from here. Both times I've eaten in restaurant I had the same experience of waiting for ages by the door to be seated. One time it was busy, one time is was not. Once we were seated, service was okay, but the first time we waited it was for an unacceptable amount of time without acknowledgement. It is also extremely loud inside when it's busy and you will find yourself yelling across the table to talk with your friends. I would rate them 5/5 based on the food alone, but because of my restaurant experiences, I'm going with 3. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Smash burgers, garbage plate tacos, crab Rangoon pizza, mozzarella sticks, mac and cheese - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Decent little bar with some lovely buffalo cauliflower. Not going to reinvent the gastropub or anything here, but a solid local option.

Of all the bar-style restaurants in Rochester, The Old Stone Tavern is by far my favorite. Water is served iced in a big pitcher, which was exactly what we needed after taking a long walk in the summer heat. The menu is extensive, and everything we've had there has been well-made, hearty, and absolutely delicious. Old Stone's chef puts effort into raising the bar for bar food (ha!). I don't have a picture of the fried cauliflower bites because we simply dove in and started munching, but trust that they're the best I've ever had. Everything is well-constructed and thoroughly thought out as a menu item. The grilled teriyaki chicken tacos were great (if a little more coleslaw than my personal taste), and my dad raved about his Big Plate (Old Stone's version of the famous garbage plate) and called it "the best he's ever had." My mom has ordered the same thing every time she's come--the honey butter chicken and biscuits--and has always taken home half of it to eat for breakfast the next day. The chicken is AMAZINGLY crunchy! It's fried with the same technique as their chicken strips and all the chicken in their sandwiches, and is the real showstopper. I'm still waiting to get together a big group of friends to come here for trivia on a Wednesday, but The Old Stone Tavern's cozy atmosphere and delicious food is absolutely worth your time. read more

See all

The fish fry is excellent. The place was full but the service was still very good. Prices are decent. A little loud in there but we were given a table by the wall which helped our little group of friends get caught up. read more

Stumbled upon this place! The vibe is okay but the food is great! I was struggling to tackle this sandwich and left half of it. Bread was a little soggy so it didn't feel like "burger" but overall I would eat here again! read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Spicy honey chicken sandwich - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Was very good, had a hard time choosing what I wanted so many different things to choose from. definitely will be back again

Great salad! I love the grilled Romaine lettuce. Good service, fast and efficient. Good smash burger too!

I went here for dinner with my friends when I was visiting Rochester from out of town. I'm gluten free so we were looking for gluten free options in the city. Old Stone Tavern popped up in our search and we decided to go there since it had good reviews. However, upon arrival we found that they didn't have as many gluten free options as it was led to believe online. The service also wasn't great. We waited a while for our food to come out when we ordered and saw the waitress a total of 2-3 times even though we were one of the 3 tables in the restaurant. She was abrupt and rude when we were ordering and rolled her eyes multiple times during the interactions we had with her. Towards the end of our dinner, our waitress completely disappeared and the bartender just dropped off the bill without a word and left. The food itself was pretty good and we did enjoy the meal. However, the atmosphere and the rude staff was a reason we probably won't return. read more

While we were visiting upstate NY we knew we had to drive over to Rochester and get ourselves a garbage plate. Never had specifically a garbage plate before, as it is a local thing, but with a cheeseburger, chili, mustard, onions, and mac and cheese over a bed of fries, you can't go wrong (unless you're describing this to your cardiologist)! All of the elements mixed together in one satisfying bite is so delicious and perfect comfort/drunk food. As for this tavern, the place was clean with nice ambiance and the staff were so friendly. One of the staff took extra time to chat with us even after we had already paid the bill. That shows genuine care when a conversation is had after the transaction has been completed. They also have a rather expansive menu of burgers, fried fish, and other pub fare. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Garbage plate - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Really great food and service! We will definitely be back. I can't say enough about how nice the waitress was. She made recommendations of places for us to go. My son had the buffalo boneless chicken bites and they melted in your mouth. read more

See all

Always a great time with amazing food, but the best part is the crew! Super cool, friendly, and fun. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Sunday Brunch - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Big garbage plate with macaroni and impossible meat along with the tater tots was my choice this restaurant

This was our second visit! Great atmosphere. Super friendly staff. Always a great selection of drinks, and I can never decide what to order. We both went for their version of the garbage plates today. Way too much food and way too delicious. The fries are incredible and so is the mac salad! read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Dog & Supersmash Burger Plate - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Wasn't too busy as it was a weeknight. Bartender was also server so we sat at the bar. She was great. Attentive, funny and helpful. Wife had the Honey Chipotle chicken tacos. Stuffed full of fresh ingredients. Chicken was juicy and beautifully seasoned. The chicken Sammie was amazing. The picture shows 2 pieces of pounded, buttermilk brined crispy juicy goodness. Why can't everyone make chicken like this! And adding the Japanese flavors is genius ! We will be back!! read more

See all

Food is delicious. The choices are inventive, delicious and plentiful. The service left a lot to be desired, however it seemed they were seriously short staffed for a Saturday night. I ordered the Good for my Seoul burger and it did not disappoint. I also got a side of onion rings which were also delicious. We also got loaded tots for the table. They were crispy bits of goodness. Could have had a bit more toppings throughout instead of the small pile on top but still super yummy. read more

See all

Stopped by for a late lunch in Rochester on our way back to Syracuse from Niagara Falls. This pub-style restaurant was the perfect place to satisfy our cravings. We were greeted with a friendly smile and served immediately. We ordered an onion smash burger, a garlic butter burger and a veggie burger with fries and tater tots on the side, respectively. My blueberry peach cider hit the spot. Food--5/5 seasoned fries and tater tots perfectly crispy, burgers well seasoned and savory. Condiments at every table. Ambience--4/5 I prefer restaurants without tv sets but at least the volume was off. 80s music playing medium loud. Clean and fresh smelling bathrooms which gave an extra point! Street parking, lots of seating, attentive staff. read more

See all

The Old Stone Tavern has great food, reasonable prices, friendly staff!!! We will definitely be back!

What a nice surprise. Came based on local recommendation and now have eaten there 3 days in a row. Vast menu with allot of unique flavors.The wing KISS sauce is really good. Portions are huge. read more

A great variety of pub food in a bar/restaurant atmosphere. Everything was great, except the one waiter called my 5 year old a "diva" because I asked if his slice of pizza was coming out... weird vibes, but great food and service from other staff during a Friday lunch. read more

Had the Animal Smash burger with side onion rings. Holy hell, this thing was massive, juicy as hell, and delicious. Half pound burger was perfectly cooked and so juicy with those carmelized onions and secret sauce perfectly complementing the burger and toppings. Bun was smaller than the meat so burger in every bite. Outstanding. read more

We stopped in for a Friday night fish fry before heading over to the Amerks game - and boy were we impressed. For me, it was all about the fish and they did it right - a great crunchy batter that was cooked right. So often a fish fry is soggy and greasy - not at all with this one. Steaming hot when it hit the table - and the slaw was cool and creamy on the side. Service was quick and friendly - we were in and out and over to the War Memorial well before the first face off. The place was clean and inviting - with plenty of on-site parking. Did I mention how good the fish fry was ? One of the best we've had in quite some time. The OST is definitely worth the trip downtown !! read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Yuengling Beer Battered Fish Fry - Haddock - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

The animal style Smashburger is an absolute must! Season so well and the fries whether you get regular or sweet potato always satisfying. Highly recommend. read more

Food was good, really busy so service was a bit slow. Good spot if you're at U of R and need some place to go. Good selection of beer and lots of tvs with games (on Saturday) read more

This was a fun find on our visit to Rochester. The food was fantastic, pub style but tons of options. The bathrooms were clean & well maintained. Our server was fantastic. She was tending bar and all the tables, but you wouldn't expect she was alone. Good sports coverage. read more

Well, the wife and I decided to visit the Old Stone Tavern on South ave, Rochester NY.. We walked in to order drinks and have wings for super. Not super busy, got seated quickly. Waiter by the name of Todd asked if we wanted drinks and we said no but ready to order our food. Todd replied with well you're going to wait if not ordering drinks. So we waited 15 mins, Todd comes back to take our order. Wife orders wings as planned and I did the same. When I asked about a new sauce they had on menu, wanted to see if I could try the sauce before putting in all on my wings. My friend Todd the waiter replied with, "we're not Apple Bees" so I said never mind bring me the regular sauce. Todd from the time we walked in was rude!!!!!! Todd could've ask me if I wanted the new sauce on the side to try. Todd continued to be rude afterwards with his comments that he didn't care that we no longer wanted to eat at Old Stone Tavern. We decided to NOT have our drinks and paid for them anyway. He killed the vibe! I'm lost for words on why this waiter was Rude. I don't recommend this place because you don't matter as a customer. Wowwwwwww! So disappointing! On a positive note, we decided to go to Dinosaur BBQ for wings which they have the best wings in town!!!!! That's right !!! read more

Terrible food, terrible service. Despite the claim on their menu, WORST PIZZA IN ROCHESTER! Somehow they managed to both burn the pizza and undercook it, which is ironic since they buy a premade product other restaurants in the area use. The service was extremely slow and not at all attentive. The space and location isn't that bad. It's an open room and there's a bar, nothing too special. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - Gluten free pizza - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Awesome place for a hearty meal. Make their own sauces the maple chipotle is to die for on the chicken taco's or as a side to another dish. Bang Bang Shrimp tacos were incredible. Make sure to stop by and check this gem out. read more

The Old Stone Tavern - people sitting at the bar - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

Quality pub food - I tried their attempt at an 'animal-style' In-n-Out Smash burger - not quite there but tasty nonetheless. They had a trivia night during our visit that was fun. The house was packed and clearly this is a neighborhood gathering spot in the Wedge. read more

Still a solid place for large portions and tasty treats. Just do yourself a favor if you want to have a conversation with your friends DONT come here when a game is on. The tv is turned up loud and patrons are coming it and it gets busy. Our server was pleasant enough but it just seemed to take a bit longer for our food? Also considering our world at the present moment staff was at a minimum and they were hustling. We had a few gaffs but nothing to complain about. They do brunch, on tap beer offerings are slim but not bad they do have bottles. If you want wine it's Barefoot.. just NO and 19 Crimes, Cocktails are tasty. Parking is on the street. read more

See all

Service was great. Server was very attentive. Food was subpar. Maybe it's what I ordered. I'll give it a try again and see...all in all not too bad read more

Nice local tavern. Staff is super friendly. It's a casual place, reminds me of "Cheers". We got wings. Cooked hot and yummy. They seem to have a large menu that I look forward to sampling. read more

We ate here as a group while at a hockey tournament in Rochester. Our group had a great lunch and enjoyed our meal. The location is very convenient, and there is adequate parking on the street and out back. There is plenty of seating if you push the hightop tables together, like we did. The service was excellent, and everyone was very friendly. The menu is pretty simple, mostly bar food, but everything was homemade and tasted great. I had a burger, and while a bit greasy, it tasted great. My wife had a gluten free pizza and it was tasty as well. The bottom line here is that Old Stone is a great place for a group looking for a reliable meal with a good selection of beers. We would eat here again read more

Really good food! Service was good. And it's pretty big inside. Not super loud for a sports bar.

Do not pay with your credit card. Pay with cash the manager Todd said " what do you want me to do about it " the bartender Natasha who will charge your card for a tip 24-48 hours after you have visit this restaurant. Make sure you check your bank statements if you have visit this place . read more

The Old Stone Tavern - American Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I had the best burger of my life here today. It was the onion smashburger and I'm dreaming of when I can have it again. So much flavor, perfectly cooked, and quality ingredients. The tots had a seasoning on them that put them over the top. Plus they were perfectly cooked. My grandfather had the steak sandwich and said it was amazing too. I highly recommend and will be back! read more