First time there. The menu on the wall is beyond extensive but the cauliflower pizza with cup and char pepperoni is what caught my eye. I did try and order it online but didn't want to make a mistake so I drove there and waited while it was made. The inside is bet nice, clean with plenty of table space to sit and eat. The pizza was delicious by the way. Very tasty and the sauce was delicious. Probably one of the better pizza sauces I've had. Highly recommended Rhinos. read more

Absolutely one of the best subs and pizza in the region! The Beef Wellington sub is a fav. Definitely recomend! read more

Rhino's Pizza - Beef Wellington Sub Beef Wellington Sub - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Late on a quiet night I wound up here to get pizza for my kids and I. Almost pulled into another place but I kept going because this is the one I'd found on Yelp. I ordered what the kids wanted before I noticed that they push a dill pickle pizza and that it's "kind of a big dill" (see attached image). So glad I went back and ordered another (small) pie! The pizza was good with a fantastic crust. It was a bit more bread than I'd like, but it was so good that we ate it anyway. Never had a dill pickle pizza before, but it, too, was yummy. A bit out of the way, but I'd go back. read more

Rhino's Pizza - Dill decor - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Philly Cheesesteak was as good as I heard. Service was excellent, polite and speedy. Only did take out.

We ordered the Pickle Pizza! Pro tip is to add a ranch drizzle on the top. Man it was so good. Our entire family loved it.

Amazing food and incredibly friendly and hospitable service. Pickle pizza is out of this world. Will be back.

My favorite place for pickle pizza!!! I am obsessed with pickles plus great for my vegetarian friends. It is such good quality and dough is amazing. They are always super friendly here and are quick. You can online order or in store order. Wish this place was closer to me! read more

See all

This place all day and night! The employees are awesome, the food is absolutely amazing. The Dill Pickle pizza is incredible (get the ranch in the side which is contrary to another post), garlic knots are awesome. The crust is an amazing crispness outside and perfect amount of doughiness inside...just amazing! Cannot recommend enough! read more

We are in Webster for a swim meet and found Rhino's on Yelp and wanted a pizza dine in experience. This place did not disappoint! I wanted a pickle pizza which they are known for and my husband grudgingly said ok thinking he wouldn't like it. We both LOVED it. The flavor was incredible but the crust is amazing as well. We also ordered an antipasto salad and 15 mild, well done wings and we were very pleased. The salad was fresh and the wings were perfect--we can't wait to come back! read more

Tried this the other day. Not really what I would call '4 Star' flavor. I had to dump tons of seasoning on a slice to get past the bland sauce and crust flavor. Probably won't be ordering from here again. read more

We decided to give this place another try, after a bad experience a while back. We ordered online, which was ok until we were billed a convenience fee for doing so. We order A Donovan Pizza, which didn't (and never does) disappoint. Our second pie was a "cup and char" peperoni pizza, which we had to pay extra for the 'upgraded' pepperoni. I can say, the pepperoni was neither cupped, nor charred. This is a comparison easy to make as it is the same topping I order from places all over the area. Pepperoni was under cooked, had no color to it, and there was regular pepperoni mixed in on the pie after I had paid extra for the upgrade. We ordered chicken tenders 4 piece, and a side order of waffle fries. The fingers were good; however, the waffle fries appear to be nothing more than seasoned frozen fries from a bag. They were jammed into the same container as the tenders, and we could tell we received the bottom of the bag as it was all the potato ends and small crumb pieces from the bottom of some bag or container. When you pay NINE dollars for a side of fries, you should serve them in a separate container and ensure they are a full order not full of partial small pieces. Lastly, our order of garlic knots was also underwhelming. The container was filled with a pool of liquid, drenching the knots. They were small, stuck to the foil, and overall chewy. We have been ordering from this place for a long time, and this was over all out most disappointing experience. $75. spent for this visit. read more

In town for the week for training and I found rhinos not too far from my training facility and, my goodness, they make good pizza! I was particularly fond of the dill pickle pizza. I would highly recommend this place if you're in Rochester. On top of excellent pizza the service was stellar and everybody was so friendly to this out of towner. read more

Still outstanding . Had a great meat pizza the other day. Crust is the best , doughy yet crispy, yum. read more

See all

Yes, yes... I am one of the folks who felt the need to check out Rhino's Pizza again thanks to seeing the dill pickle pizza on social media. It's been a little bit since I ordered from Rhino's... but I was near Webster recently, so I ordered a small dill pickle pizza and another small pizza for takeout. If you've not been to Rhino's before, it can be a bit easy to miss. Down a side street, and sitting in a split building, Rhino's Pizza is now easiest to find thanks to the inflatable pickles in each window. The pizzas took 45 minutes. I arrived at Rhino's to pick up the pizzas an the place only had two folks in it... so I'm guessing there were plenty of delivery orders being placed. I thought I ordered two smalls... but the dill pickle pizza was substantially smaller than the other pizza, so maybe they ended up making the other pizza a large? I'm not quite sure. It was fine either way. About $30 for the two pizzas... one small and one "was supposed to be small, but pretty sure they made it a large". The people at Rhino's Pizza are always courteous and friendly, in my experience. I don't think I've ever had a bad customer service experience there. The main downside of this recent Rhino's Pizza experience was that my pickle pizza was, well, just lacking in pickles / pickle taste. There was a bit of pickle... a bit of the garlic from the sauce. I just expected much more pickle-y goodness and there just weren't that many on the pizza. Also? The pizzas, generally, are also fairly chewy... it's not a light dough, but one that's thicker, chewy, and is prone to bubbling while cooking. TL;DR Ultimately, the pizza was fine... but I'm reminded now why it takes something like the fad of the dill pickle pizza (though sadly lacking in pickles) to remind me of Rhino's. Their pizzas are just pretty average. read more

Rhino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

As many others have, saw the pickle pizza on social media and being a pickle fanatic, needed to stop in and try it. I ordered a small pickle pizza, thin crust over the phone and it was ready as promised in 30 minutes. Pizza itself was hot & fresh but crust wasn't that thin. The garlic oil sauce wasn't that flavorful, little skimpy on the cheese. The only topping other than cheese is thin sliced dill pickles and sprinkled dried dill weed. Honestly I really just tasted the pickles, but as a serious pickle fan - that was fine! The pizza automatically comes with a small side of ranch which is necessary because really overall the pizza comes off one note in flavor. I would probably overall rate the pizza 3/5 as at $12 for just pickles as a topping is quite expensive, in my opinion. Service was very nice, prompt and pizza was fresh, so if you're in the area I would recommend stopping in. If you're a dill pickle fan - you may be just as happy getting some Happy Pickles from the Public Market but the pizza is still worth a try. read more

Rhino's Pizza - Small Pickle Pizza $12, Worth a try. - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

I have read only good reviews about this place. 95% of the time we order from Salvatore's. I thought I would give this place a try to try something different. I ordered the pizza/ wing combo. I ordered the wings Buffalo mild. They were small, dry with no sauce on them. The pizza, was so bad I threw out half of it. Never again. I expected better for $37. read more

It was suggested to me that I come here to Rhino Pizza, a local pizza joint that apparently had some rave reviews. And they had a garbage plate, where my friend wanted to try. After traversing 26.2 miles on foot, you get a bit of an appetite. With that said, dinner in Rochester / Webster NY on my last night here in May 2019 comprised of basically pizza. And my friend decided to do the famed garbage plate that's eerily similar to what they call poutine in Canada. My friend and I stepped into the establishment around 6pm on a brisk Sunday evening. We dined here for about an hour before finishing up and headed back to the hotel. Rhino's Pizza can be thought of as your typical pizzeria. I can remember it being like Boston's Pizza in Honolulu, Hawaii. The set up is similar in nature and there was just a few tables for people to dine in and enjoy their food. The restaurant itself is quaint and small, but surprisingly full of character, which was somehow hidden on a Sunday evening. All of their menu offerings are on the board behind the counter and, if you weren't from the area, you'd have to take 5 minutes or more to decide on what's hoping to go into your stomach that night. And I ended up with a simple pizza. It worked for me. The overall experience here at Rhino's Pizza in Webster Ny can be categorized as simple, casual, interesting, and quite nice. It was a quiet Sunday evening meal that simply was cheap enough to be good. I did enjoy the ambience, which was definitely quiet on a Sunday. There was literally nobody there except for one other couple that was ordering behind us at the time. So it was a party there, just in separate tables. The service here was average and friendly, while being professional and low-key and laid-back. I did like the menu being swallowed up on the mantle behind the counter. It was almost like being at a bar with all the alcohol they had on tap. With that said, the restaurant itself was fairly small in a stand-alone building. It was clean and self-sustaining Rhinos pizza place is located at 85 Donovan Street in Webster New York. They accept major credit cards, which is always a awesome thing for us travelers and those who love being cashless. Yes they accept cash too. They have a private parking area, but be fair warrant that the neighborhood that this restaurant is it in is kind a ghetto. It lasts almost semi industrial by a small town like Webster. Not sure about public transportation options here in the town of Webster New York, but Uber and lift is always an option for y'all to consider if you don't have a private vehicle to get here. For most part though, that experience was interesting and enjoyable at the same time. It was a quiet meal with a friend who had traveled from Canada to be here in this part of New York to do the 26.2 miles on foot with me. I seem to have crazy friends, but that's OK. The pizza was quite good and decide to eat it all there at the restaurant because it was definitely good and delicious. My friend decide to order, as mentioned above, The garbage plate. It seemed appetizing at the time, but I decided not to taste it because It was my friends meal and I did not want to deprive him of such delicious endeavors. The trip here to Rhino's Pizza in Webster New York was well worth it. Pizza at your fingertips and I decide to get French fries on the side. I ended up taking it with me back to the hotel and eating it as a snack before going to bed I am packing my luggage before the flight Out of Rochester next morning. If you are in the area and craving pizza and other Italian delicious delights, consider coming to this pizzeria in the semi industrial area of Webster New York. I hate saying that this place is good for what it does, well not the best, it certainly was tasty endeavor and the pizza was good and spot on. I enjoyed it. And maybe you would too. 4.0 stars for the overall experience. 4.0 stars for the service. 4.0 stars for the food. 3.0 stars for the prices. Support local! B read more

645 on a Saturday and they already stopped delivering! Terrible!! There's sports on TV. Getting together with friends to watch the braves. Also the college world series. Zero stars for service. read more

Pickle pizza is life. It was absolutely a stop for us when we came back to visit. I flew with the leftovers home to my best friend in California and it survived the trip and was amazing still!! I love white sauce pizzas so this wasn't exactly a crazy experience, I think people imagine a much weirder flavor, it's so mellow and just good. My very picky kids love it read more

Rhino's Pizza - Pickle pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

The pizza is really quite good and they seem to be generous with the toppings. The wings...not so much. They must ration the sauce as almost all the medium wings are dry with just a drizzle of Buffalo sauce. This is not a one time thing. We have ordered from them 20+ times and it's the norm. I would recommend Rhinos for pizza. I would not recommend Rhinos for wings. read more

We really wanted to cave and try the dill pickle pizza just like most of the other reviewers here. We were having family over for dinner and figured ordering take out would be the best option for us. It did take a bit longer than anticipated for the food but it was a Saturday night so I'm not putting that on Rhino's. I can understand how a Saturday evening at a pizza join can go. We ordered a medium dill pickle pizza, a medium chicken fajita pizza and 20 wings. The food looked and tasted good. I don't really have any complaints about the taste. We all enjoyed the dill pickle pizza and the fajita was fine. It wasn't really anything to rave about. My biggest complaint was the size. It seemed like for a medium pizza, it was more like a personal pan. We had 5 people sharing the food and in hindsight I guess we should have ordered larges. The wings were great though, just how I like them which is super saucy. My husband prefers a crispier wing though so he wasn't exactly as thrilled about them as I was. For the price we paid, I'm not sure the food was worth it. I doubt we will order from there again. We've had other pizza's in the webster/penfield area that were just as good if not better for a better price. read more

See all

When in Rochester, do as the Rochesterians do. Normally that means a plate, but this venture was for the famed dill pickle pizza. Other places are selling them, but I braved the 40 minute round trip for Rhinos. The drive home was pure agony because of the incredible aromas that had me drooling. Wings were awesome, juicy inside and crispy on the outside. Garlic knots we're also great and swimming in flavor (herb oil). The star of the show was the pizza, which is a pickle-lovers dream. The base was a garlicy white sauce. Dipped in ranch/bleu is the way to go. read more

See all

$16 for a fish fry w/ a handful of fries and a thimble of mac salad. The fish was pretty good, but the portions of the two sides (which I'm sure aren't real expensive) were pretty disappointing. read more

I resisted the pickle pizza craze until now, but decided a couple of days ago I was finally going to see what all the hype was about. I placed my order online for some wings and one pizza, and confirmation suggested it would be ready in ~ 1 hour. This was fine since I had some work to finish up and then a half hour drive from work to Rhino's. I'll note, this was around 6pm, so pretty standard dinner time, so no surprise that they were busy. My order was not ready when I arrived and I waited probably 20-30 minutes extra once I arrived to pick up. This seemed to be the case for many of the people who were also there waiting for their orders. Again, it was dinner time and so they were probably busy, but then expectations should be set appropriately for the amount of time it will actually take to fill an order. As far as the pizza, I love pickles, so I liked it, but it wasn't mind blowing. I'd say an average pizza. I'm glad I tried it, but I probably wouldn't order it again. Boneless wings were nicely crispy and enjoyable. Loved those. I might return at a less busy time to try something else from the menu. read more

Decent subs, reasonable price and easy to get in and out. Didn't get any pizza. I would go back again for sure.

Last week I ordered a tuna wrap. I got a tuna on a roll and had to wait an hour more for dinner. This week I got the surf and turf wrap. I got all wrap, mayo and lettuce and very little tuna and what looks like the end of the bag of chips. Not a fan of enjoying my mayo and crumb dinner. Normally Rhinos is solid but I'm really irritated with my last two visits. read more

See all

Rhinos pizza is our go to spot. I really love their subs best. I'm not a huge pizza person (I know, it's weird). Their pizza is good though. I really want to try the pickle pizza they have become notorious for. *Pro tip I learned when I picked up my order last time, I mentioned the pickle pizza and if they sell it by the slice. The do not at dinner time. I told them I wanted to try it but was the only one in the house who was interested. They said if I want to try it I can order a white pizza and have half the pizza be pickle pizza. They're made with the same base. I know people in my house would have eaten the white pizza so I'm making sure I know that for next time, so I can try the pickle pizza! I LOVE their garlic sauce. It's the best. Don't forget to add an order of cheesy garlic knots! So yummy. read more

Rhino's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

My grandson and I grabbed some subs from here and were pretty pleased. He got a meatball sub with extra sauce and really liked it. I got eggplant which was good but needed more sauce. I will ask next time. We also got loaded waffle fries. They were generously covered with bacon, cheese and jalapeños. Very tasty and fast. We ordered by phone and the order was done in about 20-25 minutes. I will order from here again. read more

Great pizza!!! Slices available for lunch and great menu with subs and much more!! Wings too!!!

Went ahead and tried their famous dill pickle pizza and let me tell you it was delicious! I had also ordered another pizza and some sweet chili wings and I was not disappointed. Definitely will be returning and so happy it's so close to home. read more

Rhino's Pizza - Pepperoni, pineapple, mushrooms and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

Can't resist the dill pickle pizza. Their lead time is a little bit longer than most pizza places, but that is because everything is made to order. Super fresh. read more

This is the best pizza place in webster. The wings stand out. I'm from buffalo originally and these rival the best pizza place wings in buffalo. Make sure to ask for them well done. Salvatore's, Pontillos, and Marks are not even in the same league. The pizza is good. It's close to a thin crust. Better than the other local chains. It's also around the same price. I will probably never order pizza from another local place again. My parent love the subs. When they come into town, they always pick some up to take home. The "royal" is the best they have ever had. Well done wings take a while to cook. It can take a while for your order to be ready so prepare for that. On Mondays and Tuesdays they have buy one get one large pizzas. Amazing deal. The pickle pizza gets a lot of attention. It's fun and quirky but I wouldn't order just that for a meal. read more

Probably one of the best pizzas around the Webster area. Pepperoni PizzaPepperoni Pizza

The pizza is amazing here and I can't say enough about the customer service everything I've gotten here has been great and it's my go to pizza place in Webster! read more

I have been a fan of their pizza ever since they opened... Only had one not so great experience with the freshness of the pizza however the owner fixed the situation right away and was very accommodating read more

I was in town for a concert and VERY intrigued by a Facebook video I saw advertising THEIR DILL PICKLE PIZZA and being a pickle nut - just had to stop in and try it! It's a quaint little pizzeria inside of what looks like a reformed office building, parking off to the side and picnic style tables and small booths to sit at inside. After walking in and being hit in the face with a metaphorical cloud of flavors wafting into the dining room from the kitchen (it smelled delicious!), the ladies at the counter were VERY friendly and welcoming and made us feel at home! There was a BOGO special going on, so we got a cheese pizza as well as the newly infamous pickle pizza - both of which were delightful! They had a NY style crust and the sauce is on point! I honestly would have liked just a little more bite of pickle on the pickle pizza, but it was delightful! The garlic oil in lieu of sauce, sweet, creamy mozzarella, and pickles melded together PERFECTLY! Looking forward to another pie next time I'm out that way! read more

Feeling like a sub, but not the same ol routine? This is definitely the place to go! They have a huge selection of gourmet subs such as the Boldt - which comes with bacon, sausage and steak - all smothered in a country sweet style sauce they call Boldt sauce. Awesome! My mouth is watering just thinking about it. If you can't find anything that tickles your fancy on the board, the owner has been there every time I've been there and is willing to make you a sub to order. read more

Delicious pizza breadsticks and Amazing Customer Service! The inside location it's pretty clean well ambientes to look like an actual Pizzeria And the Window pick up it's great options to avoid a lot of contact nowadays that we're still under COVID-19 Delicious breadsticks and wing sauce!'n read more

Definitely a great mom's style of cooking a great hearty sub. The firecracker was just so fun and delicious to eat!! Inside has benches like a picnic. Note: Gotta Pay after you eat and drink. read more

Wings are really good!!! Had pizza too. Chicken Fajita. The toppings kept falling off and the chicken was a little dry. But I would definitely go back! read more