The website was easy to use, and at checkout, they offered $2 cinnamon toes to add onto my order, which I couldn't pass up. At the store, I asked for a cup of marinara because the website didn't let me select marinara and they gave me a cup for free, on top of the sauce I had selected instead! The food was delicious! I had a stomach ache prior to eating, and after eating the cinnamon toes, I began feeling so much better! Hahaha. I can't wait to order again next week! Check out their specials! read more

I know pizza is a personal preference, but I don't know why Mr. Shoes Pizza isn't in the 4-5 rating zone. I've tried so many pizza places around Rochester looking for a good thin crust pizza and Mr Shoes wins hands down. You have to ask for the thin crust. And after the first pie, you might ask the next time to go a little lighter/heavier on the sauce or cheese. They know what you mean and can make it exactly as you like. Give them a try, if you haven't already. read more

For a quick grab and go it's not bad- it's nearby and easy to get to- I just prefer a thinner "crispier" crust.

Love Mr Shoes. Their Pizza wings are fantastic. I love their blue cheese. Usually my go to is Pepperoni but they have alot of choices. It's delicious! read more

Not sure why this place doesn't get more love. It's got a hole in the wall vibe inside, but we got a large cheese for just $15 and it was money. It's definitely a New York style pie, but the bottom of the crust is just a little fried like a pan pizza. Next time we'll get the buffalo chicken pie, which sounded amazing. read more

Great pizza Great service. I've never had a bad item from Mr. Shoes. I highly recommend this place for pizza

Just got off the phone with a manager named OCTAVIA and this girl obviously doesn't know what 1+1 is. Where did you find her? So, I received a delivery for a pizza that was beyond messaged up and a male young manager gave me a credit for a free pizza. Somehow he put it in the system as a free topping which is obviously wrong. You don't get a delivery for a messed up pizza and get a free topping, you can a free pizza. Common sense right? Not with OCTAVIA, she said since the manager only put a free topping that was all she was giving me. Tried to explain the issue and she wasn't hearing it. She said she is the manager on and she makes the rules on her shift. She proceeded to keep an attitude which gave me one and hung up on me when I asked her if she knew what one plus one is since it's an obvious mistake by the other manager. Is good help that hard to find? They sent me a funny but ignorant message on Facebook then blocked me. I attached a pic. read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Best pizza around go see for yourself awesome customer service love there daily specials

Once again, Mr. Shoes has outrun themselves! LOL! I have been ordering from them for years, and this is by far the very best (and GIANT!) Calzone I have ever had. The Shoemaker Calzone with Garlic Parm inside + extra cheese, made by Timmy. Yes, it was so good that I actually called them to give them a shout out and asked who made it. In my opinion, you will always win the race! Pro tip, don't sleep on the toes, get them every single time! read more

See all

The meat lovers pizza was delicious, and the fried dough was mind blowing! Great price! And the people are super duper helpful and friendly! read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - Cinnamon Toes (Fried Dough Bites) - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The barbecue chicken pizza was incredible! So flavorful and the breaded chicken had great texture and fit well with the sauce :) Also love the buffalo chicken hot sub, especially on a cold day I've also ordered the giant boxes for parties and it's a great price for the volume, and so Mr. Shoes is our go to place to order! read more

See all

The people behind the counter are always friendly. The blue cheese is remarkable. The crust is tender. The wings are crispy. It's reasonably priced. It is the best pizza in Rochester. read more

Fast service, great quality food, our favorite take out pizza ever! it is dangerous that we live so close.

Despite the name I didn't order pizza! They have many offerings and my company covered lunch one Friday with an Uber eats coupon. I selected steak bomber sub and a PB pie. My sub was huge, perhaps too big. It felt a bit wasteful but it was delicious when it dried out as steak subs sometimes are. The pie was a bit dry but still yummy and it took me several days to eat it because it was so rich. Everything was packaged well and the sub arrived warm. A great way to end the work week. read more

Stopped in to get a slice because as a kid I remember my family ordering this pizza all the time. Now Mr shoes only has this single location, and where the pizza is still very good. It wasn't as incredible as I remember as a child. Still a great place to grab a slice or order a pie with many options for toppings. Worth trying if in the area, you won't be disappointed. read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - Buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

My family is Very picky when we order pizza we all have our favorite, Mr Shoes is now the new family favorite that's right we finally agreed on something. Always fresh ingredients and plenty of toppings Dough is tender an crispy sauce just right oh don't forget the breaded wings WOW AND A OUT OF THIS WORLD STEAK SUB WITH THOSE SAUCES ON THEM. Be nice to your family and give them a try. You won't be sorry oh by the way it seems no matter what time we stop in the owner is always there. Nice to see that commitment these days read more

Kudos and special thanks to Nick, Jeff and team for taking our order so quickly this afternoon and providing the volunteers working to serve our community with a hearty lunch. Our JOIN volunteers and neighborhood residents greatly appreciated the sheet pizza and wings special we ordered. Project J.O.I.N. is a summer collaborative community outreach initiative happening every Tuesday and Wednesday from 10am to 2pm at the corner of Jefferson and Frost Avenue in the southwest quadrant of the city of Rochester during the months of July and August; bringing human support services straight to the street, rebuilding trust and relationships, connecting neighborhood agencies and training residents to be navigators of the human service systems. Project JOIN salutes Mr Shoes Pizza on South Avenue for providing quality food, great customer service and supporting our community outreach efforts. read more

Great Buffalo Sandwich. Pizzas are just ok, but they're ok enough that I eat them fairly often.

One happy and safe customer at Mr. Shoes!! Best pizza spot in town, we always come here for a slice! Stop by for the best food :) read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Mr shoes is an amazing pizza restaurant with so much more to offer than pizza! I ordered a meat loves calzone and was not disappointed. The calzone was large and stuffed with ham, pepperoni, Italian sausage and mozzarella cheese. The calzone had a nice thin crust with and nice buttery finish. read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

I ordered a pizza and a sub from Mr. Shoes Pizza, and it was the most average food I've ever eaten. There's was nothing special about the pizza dough, sauce or cheese but it wasn't bad either. Even the thickness of the pizza dough was middle of the road. The sub bread was bland, and the amount of meat in the sandwich was thin. There are far better alternatives in the Rochester area. read more

I ordered online as a gift for a friend, they had to call me due to me messing up the address, but they sent them exactly what I asked, and followed my instructions wonderfully. The friend I ordered from said the pizza was great. read more

Well this was disappointing..., it was during lunch hour and a slice of pepperoni that appeared very dry and now reminded me of that impression "like cardboard". Guess back to Costco I will go. read more

Mr. Shows loves going to Broadway to watch Phantom and such. Whereas Mr. Sheers loves to wear women's stockings (but who doesn't). Mr. Shea's often goes to Buffalo to see shows downtown in that old Main St Theatre. And Mr. Shahs is a former Iranian dictator. Thankfully none of those people own this place (except maybe the stockings guy but that's everyone isn't it? No? Just me?). I liken this place to Country Sweet, in that they make sweet pizza and extremely sweet, hot, syrupy "Rochester style" wings. You cannot get wings like this anywhere else in the world, except maybe on this road. Country Sweet charges more, but honestly I like them more. They're bigger, they're saucier, and the spice will blow your head off while also making you scowl from sweetness. Don't get me wrong though. These wings are really good. I don't give out 4 stars lightly. Okay, I do, but in this case, the wings are actually good. The pizza tastes a little weird, so I recommend sticking to the wings, true Rochester wings. Try them here, try them down the road at Country Sweet, and see which ones you like better. read more

I had company so I thought it would be nice to order from Mr. Shoes and have the food delivered (using UberEats). After waiting almost 2 hours, I received a message that my order was cancelled and I wouldn't be charged. That's it - no apology, no explanation. I will never, ever order from Mr. Shoes again. Why bother - I wouldn't get my food anyway. read more

The service was okay. The wings my brother loved. He definitely recommends going there just for wings. The pizza was pretty bad. Who puts broccoli on a pizza? Stick to the wings and you will be safe. read more

See all

Stopped yesterday on my way home from work as it was too hot to cook. Location is easy to get to, in and out, with plenty of parking. Printed an online coupon, which was large pizza w/1 topping, 10 wings, and 2 liter soda for $25.00 + tax. Guy who answered phone was helpful and prompt, food was ready 30 minutes later when I picked it up, nice and hot! Have to say although pizza never impresses me, or wings, this place did. Pizza was delicious, and wings (sweet and sour) were totally awesome. Plus I have lunch for several days this week as I have leftovers. If in the mood for pizza and wings, give this place a try, very good. Also when I got home and looked at the menu, they have subs, burgers, etc quite extensive, so will definitely be back to try something else. read more

Interior and staff aren't necessarily the most welcoming, but the food has been a hit so far. I've gotten thr Cajun Black n Blue Steak Bomber and the Shoe Be Do Be Do Steak, gf got a chicken finger sub and fish and chips. All the subs were great. The fish and chips was pretty lacking, like little janky frozen fish filets. But overall we're enjoying them so far. Typical pricing. read more

Mr. SUCKS - that should be the name of this pizza shop. You cannot count on Mr. Shoes to get orders right. IF you order anything other than the food, for example napkins, FORGET IT. Why offer to provide something if the delivery person just f#cks things up? The pizza is just average and not worth the trouble. I don't need to order from a business that doesn't go all the way to make a customer happy. read more

I will never buy pizza from Mr. Shoes again! The pizza looked like it had been made earlier that day, reheated to prevent waste and pepperonis were just thrown on afterwards. The crushed was totally black (burnt) on one side of the pizza and the bottom was burnt as well, only the inside pieces were edible. The dog didn't even want to eat the crust. I called Mr. Shoes and they only offered basically to pay for the tax of my next pizza ordered, which I feel is unacceptable for the order that was place for a number of things. This isn't the only time I've ordered from them and the food was not up to standard, now it's time for me to express how I feel about the inconvenience of it all. read more

Mr. Shoes Pizza - TRASH! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

We ordered hot wings and the country ranch chicken and bacon pizza for delivery. The food arrived at exactly the time they had predicted and it was hot and delicious. The delivery guy was friendly. What more can you ask for when you've been on the road all day and are just ready to eat and relax? read more

Lately (past 2 years) the staff has been continually rude. As the service has declined so to has the pizza. I loved the 10$ pick up large but I've just had enough crappy experiences with staff and dry, chewy pizza without enough cheese that I finally decided to look at the other places around town. Bye bye! Hope you can turn it around cause i was always a fan! read more

Absolutely love Mr. Shoes pizza! Quality is always good. Great selection! I see a lot of negative reviews here. ALWAYS give a vendor a second chance. A though about the burned pizza review. It looks like she brought it home, put it in the oven to warm it up but forgot about it. She may have gotten distracted and forgot it was in there until she smelled it burning. read more

Walked over from the childrens hospital at 7 to get my sister some food, been a rough week, get there and they're closed, pretty bad out with snow too, nothing online saying they are closed, stay away, pizza is pretty bad, had it before, my sister wanted a thing of onion rings and a burger, probably a good thing though, might have got food poisoning read more

I had Pizza from here yesterday for the very first time. A co-worker bought it which was very nice. The Pizza was amazing, not greasy and tasted great! Will definitely be back. read more

2 for 3 on good wings and even though last order wasn't fried hard. Cash refund was given . Nice small place for quick food. Really should be a 3.5 read more

I've been going to Mr. Shoes now for almost ten years and have consistently received amazing customer service and the best pizza in town! You really can't beat the pick up special ( large cheese for 9.99) or the awesome pizza and wing deals. I also love to stop by on week days for a huge pizza slice for lunch! Give Mr. Shoes a try and I promise you won't regret it! read more

Pros: They have a vegan option -- specifically, white pizza (garlic & olive oil) with assorted veggie toppings. Ask them to hold the cheese. Cons: The pizza isn't very good. I ordered from Mr. Shoe's only once, so take my review with a grain of salt. The white pizza was allegedly made with garlic and olive oil, but I couldn't detect any garlic taste in it at all. The pizza was bland and uninteresting. I had to put garlic powder and Veganaise on it to make it taste better. read more

Recently gave Mr. Shoes a shot because Grub Hub is running a $5 off $10 orders promo, and chubby guys love free food! So I ordered the "Big Daddy Jay's" Cajun Black 'n' Blue Steak Bomber and a side of fries. Came to like $7.00 after the $5 off. The fries were ok, kinda soggy by the time I got home due to condensation but not too bad. The problem was, they were little. They were like shoe string thin and like 2 -3 inches long, kind of hard to eat them that way. I probably just got unlucky and ended up getting the bottom of the bag =(. As for the sandwich... It's described as such " Our world famous steak topped with sauteed onions and mushrooms, bacon, bleu cheese dressing, and mozzarella." Only problem? They forgot the blue cheese dressing.... Kind of one of the corner stones of the sandwich. I wouldn't get food from these guys again, there are just better choices with better food and cooks who don't forget main ingredients. read more

MR Shoes Pizza is the best. When ever my wife and I go to Rochester its all I want to eat. Their Pizza, subs, salads are great! The wings are excellent. read more