Mark&#x27;s Pizzeria

Absolutely one of the best subs and pizza in the region! The Beef Wellington sub is a fav…read more Definitely recomend!

First time there. The menu on the wall is beyond extensive but the cauliflower pizza with cup and…read morechar pepperoni is what caught my eye. I did try and order it online but didn't want to make a mistake so I drove there and waited while it was made. The inside is bet nice, clean with plenty of table space to sit and eat. The pizza was delicious by the way. Very tasty and the sauce was delicious. Probably one of the better pizza sauces I've had. Highly recommended Rhinos.

Dill Pickle Pizza Rhino's

Pepperoni and sausage pizza

See all

Guida's Pizzeria

3.1(48 reviews)

0.1 mi

Always great, love the calzones and the slices there , True…read moreNY style slices, always cooked to perfection and crispy , their sweet red sauce is the greatest thing on planet earth

Our go to.... For Pizza. Thick crust is amazing. Try the breaded sweet/sour wings.. YUM!!! We…read moredrive 45 min. To pick up. It's so worth it!!! Peggy and Dave

Garlic knots

Calzone - kinda burned and not good

See all

Delicious

Pub 235

4.0(264 reviews)

0.7 mi

We came here for dinner and had a nice time. I had never heard of Chicken French before and learned…read moreit's a local dish that a lot of people enjoy, which meant I naturally had to order it for my entree -- it was very tasty, kind of like a chicken piccata with a lemony butter sauce. The caesar salad that accompanied it was also yummy, the croutons were crispy and the veggies were fresh. They have a nice wine list too. Just a note, you probably don't want to come here for conversation or if people in your party have hearing issues -- we sat in the patio room and it was so incredibly loud, we couldn't hear a thing. The front room/bar area was also very noisy.

We love the Pub menu and rarely have a bad meal there. We're…read moreregulars ! Last week I had one of the best dinners ever : the special - 2 grilled pork chops with a humongous baked sweet potato. I've never had such tender, tasty pork chops. Kudos to the chef. Our server, Samantha, was also top notch. Another fav is the Aegean salad . Huge . Fresh . Wonderful.. I gave 4 stars instead of 5 because my Virgin Mary, usually one of the best around town, was off-base and the bartender would not re-make it . I was offered a different drink but wanted my usual great VM.

French dip

See all

Cheddar Beer and Bacon Burger with Garlic Parm Fries!

Proietti's Italian Restaurant & Catering

4.1(164 reviews)

1.0 mi

Catered a recent pickleball tournament. They were incredibly friendly and accommodating by making…read moremy son a gluten free pizza as they were serving wings and regular pizza. I'll definitely visit them another time because they were so accommodating. Very nice of them to do this as part of the tournament.

I made reservations for 4:15. The restaurant opens at 4. I got there right around 4:10 tonight and…read moreit was packed. I chose to wait for my friend in the lobby. Right before my friend got there an older lady, a manager or maybe the owner told me I could only have my table for an hour. What? She showed me her reservation list. So?? It's not my fault that the restaurant was overbooked. I thought this was incredibly rude. My friend and I discussed going to another place and we were told that they would just make the other reservation wait until 6. My friend and I both worked in the food service industry for DECADES. I have never been told or told anyone they only had an hour to eat. We said we didn't want to feel rushed. I'm from out of town we were catching up. We were not planning on camping but an hour was simply not enough time. We are not rude so we ordered as fast as we could. We didn't ask for more time. We got garlic bread as an appetizer. They brought over some complimentary zucchini marinara or something. We both ordered chicken French and our food didn't arrive to our table until nearly 5pm. At some point the lady came to tell us that we didn't have to rush some other ladies were willing to get up. Thank you for letting us know, but it was incredibly tacky to tell us multiple times how long we could stay and what their plans were. And yet they still kept looking at our table making it very uncomfortable. We really only sat there for 15 minutes after our bill was paid. We were gone by 6. The original time we were told we could stay until. The garlic bread was okay. It was just their dinner rolls sliced in half and grilled/toasted. The Italian wedding soup was mostly vegetables (huge vegetable chunks). A few meatballs, some stringy chicken and a very few noodles. The broth was good. The chicken French was excellent for the most part. The spaghetti noodles were short. Almost as if they broken and impossible to twirl on fork to get a bite. It was messy, slurping noodles was so embarrassing. I ended up having to leave most of my noodles on the plate because I had to give up. It was a nearly $29.00 dish. I had specifically asked our server to put the garlic bread on my check since we were paying separately. She ended up splitting it between our checks. I wasn't happy with that. I wanted to pay for it myself. We tipped very generously each over 30% for apparently the huge inconvenience we caused. Giving this place a 4 is also generous. I'm not sure I would come back here again. For it being both of our first times coming here-the experience left a bad taste in my mouth. The ambiance is nice, the lighting is good but the whole debacle with being told how long we could stay and then "not realizing we had a reservation she thought we were walk ins. " The food presentation (huge obvious towel swipe on my dish-hope that was a clean towel and there wasn't any cross contamination), the soup may as well been called Italian vegetable soup and the short noodles making it impossible to enjoy a pricey dish... the dessert menu is also lacking. Maybe giving it a 4 is misleading.

The entrance area.

Side of spaghetti

Proietti's Italian Restaurant & Catering

See all

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

2.9(49 reviews)

0.6 mi

We usually get a sheet pizza with a couple of toppings. Always cooked perfect. Great crust and and…read moretoppings go from edge to edge. The breaded wings are plump and meaty and by far the best we've had. No skimping on the sauces either.

We order here at least 3 times a week because of how close our job is never again called to order 2…read morepizzas man on the phone was absolutely ignorant I won't be giving them my business ever again

See all

Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

3.6(14 reviews)

3.4 mi

Always order online for pickup- orders are ready on time and done perfectly! Staff is friendly…read moreand courteous. Highly recommend! Great pizza!

I ordered the salvie plate for delivery and the food was phenomenal and service was outstanding. I…read morewould rate this meal a 10 out of 10. Yes the delivery was also outstanding.

Tuscan Wood Fired Pizza Catering

3.9(32 reviews)

0.5 mi

I was so happy to see this food truck at the Lilac festival. However, the service has gone down…read moretremendously. Pops had a serious attitude about splitting the pizza in separate bags. Also, Ive ordered a marg pizza plenty of times at many different pizza shops but what they served at the lilac festival was horrible. $16 and I got bread and what taste like a can of tomatoes. The cheese was non existent. I get it alot of people come past at these events to order food but the quality of the food shouldn't suffer to save cost. $16 for a margherita pizza ... that half pizza picture doesnt live up to that price at all. So much better the first time in a smaller setting.

Tried the pizza on food truck before and was curious how the actual restaurant would stack up --…read moreand wow, it did not disappoint! I stopped in for a quick bite before my movie and they totally delivered. The soup hit the spot, and the bistecca panini was absolutely outstanding. I'll definitely be back for round two! Also the owner is very friendly and received great service!

Antipasto tray

Caprese plater

See all

New on the menu as of 5/11/16

Coach Sports Bar

3.3(40 reviews)

0.4 mi

Great food. Great vibes. Definitely check out. You will not be dissapointed. The service is…read moreawesome and the food is great.

Basically the same bar before the remodel. If you're not a regular forget about good service. Our…read morebartender had to be flagged down every time we wanted a refill and she practically threw our paper plates at us . Served us our food but had to ask for utensils, pepper, ect and you could see it was annoying HER. I will say the pizza was very good. The service stunk

Medium wings - 75cent wings on Tuesday nights!

Fish fry

See all

Buffalo Wings. Blue Cheese was weak 7/10.

jojo Bistro & Wine Bar - Webster

3.7(69 reviews)

0.5 mi

Decent place to stop in for a quick bite and a glass of wine, but nothing to write home about…read more Never had a bad experience here, but also never had a showstopping one either.

Food was cooked perfectly, flavorful and juicy would definitely recommend and will be back!!!!read more

Steak Frites

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Jaren C.

6 months ago

Just because you had one minor problem one time doesnt mean you should leave a one star review. I wouldnt say it's 5 star worthy but im putting 5 just to compensate for all the bad reviews. read more

Susan A.

15 years ago

I really like their pizza but not their delivery service. The pizza arrived cold and/or wrong items. Now I pickup the order to make sure the pizza is hot and correct items ordered. read more

Meg D.

13 years ago

Very overpriced. Pizza is inconsistent.

Mark's Pizzeria - pizza - Updated October 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Webster, New York Restaurants near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Coffee near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Desserts near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Parking near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Things to Do near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Dinner near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Breakfast near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Burgers near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Shopping near Mark's Pizzeria

BEST of Webster, New York Smoke Shop near Mark's Pizzeria

Best of Webster

Things to do in Webster

Browse Brands

Mark's Pizzeria

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Mark's Pizzeria also viewed

Joe's Brooklyn Pizza

3.4

(252 reviews)

I only tried 2 kinds of pizza but they were both great. I had the grandma's Sicilian. This was a…read morethick slice with tons of flavor. Sauce was nice, crust was great, and cheese was on point. I also tried a regular thin plain slice. Nice crunch, good sauce and just a quality slice. Old school vibe inside here and friendly counter service. Would 100% go back.

Meh, they couldn't get a cheese pizza right! The tomato sauce didn't taste quite right. Won't…read morerecommend going here.

Papa Johns

3.7

(3 reviews)

Papa has returned to the Rochester area. Their pizza was as good as the commercial says. They were…read morecelebrating their grand opening with WDKX blasting in the parking lot and the parking lot full, the pizza on the app was ready as promised. We had onion and Italian sausage on original crust and both toppings were notably high quality. Service was prompt and friendly. A good addition to the area, especially since there are no Huts nearby.

I ordered a large pizza and a side of garlic knots. I recieved i large pizza and a brownie cake…read more When I called to try and make it right, I was told basically to bad, unless I come and pick it up. I wasnt looking for anything more than maybe a credit on my next order. I will never be ordering from here again.

Tony Pepperoni

4.0

(97 reviews)

Delivery was fast. Pizza was tasty . I have ordered a large…read morepizza with onions and pepperoni. The slices were decent size

We ordered a medium pizza rather than just slices from the counter because we wanted it fresh and…read morehot. The pizza was tasty, but the size of the pizza was supposed to be medium and we got what is actually a small pizza anywhere else. Can't help but feel ripped off by this place.

Lucci's Pizza And Grill

3.2

(11 reviews)

This morning 1 of my co-workers and I stopped by here for a coffee to go in between runs to a…read moreconstruction site. I remember the original place, things are different now. The place was clean, I must say that, both inside and out. But there was only 1 other customer and 1 employee running the show. Something was missing from the original days as I remember. Usually there were always a few customers running around. More action so to speak! My co-worker and I both got a coffee to go, I got a small, $1.31 cents, he got a bit more in a drivers cup and it was I think $1.40 and change. My co-worker commented on it. The coffee bar had only a few creamers in the bin. The employee just kind of stood there, basically to take the money. I guess I'm saying things have changed, no spark as there use to be. I;m saying this from my own observation as well as other reviews.

Best breakfast garbage plates in town! My friend and I come here at least once a month and we…read morealways leave full and satisfied. The only thing that could improve is the consistency but despite slight differences, its always good. Friendly owners as well!

Pizza Stop, Greece

3.9

(73 reviews)

Stopped in for a quick pizza and garlic knots. They were so delicious. The garlic and butter and…read morethe garlic knots made me want to dip my pizza crust in it! We will be back soon.

The downtown location will always be a classic... but there's a lot to be said for the convenience…read moreof a small strip mall storefront with lots of parking (no city parking meters here.) The store is small with only a few tables for dine in and very clean and neat. The staff is absolutely too notch! Very friendly, chatting with customers and generally smiling. It's welcoming. Just like the original in State Street location there is a large selection of slices, both NY thin crust and thicker Sicilian. Something for everyone and very high (but not quite at the top) on my list of go-to pizza joints. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area.

The Pizza Stop

4.2

(138 reviews)

While here on a visit we stopped here for their NY thin crust pizza. We were not disappointed…read more Pizza is ordered by the slice. Many varieties. We got slices of pepperoni, mushroom and broccoli, bacon pizza and plain cheese plus a cobb salad with chicken. Everything delicious. Great thin crust and great mozzarella cheese. Salad was good too. Prices good, friendly service at the counter. Comfortable atmosphere. One of best pizza we had in a long time!

This pizza is AWESOME. Walked 3 blocks for this perfectly cooked, thin pizza. Oh man. Every choice…read moreis DELICIOUS. I tried the garlic cheese white pizza. The slices are HUGE. $8 for a slice and a drink. The staff are quick, polite and knowledgable. I loved the subway murals on the wall. Very fun to look at.

Pizza Shack

3.1

(16 reviews)

Usually great food!, but the girl who answeres the phone sometimes is extremely rude don't feel…read morelike ordering when she answers to take my order:(

I was camping at Hamlin Beach SP and ran into Hamlin for supplies. I saw this place on the way to…read moreTops so I figured I'll just order up some grub and called in an order. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and a large Italian sub. The order was ready by the time we left Tops. I went inside to pick up the order and instantly regretted it. Talk about a dive. It just felt dated and cheaply thrown together. Anyways, I grabbed our order and headed back to our campsite. The pizza - bland, cardboard crust. Canned sauce, boring. Cheese and pepperoni fair. In high school, I would get cafeteria pizza that had more soul than this. I was tempted to give what wasn't eaten to the racoons, but I didn't want to give them gut rot. The sub - It was a fairly impressive looking sub, lots of meat and stuff. Well, heck. The sub roll was good. That is it. The meat (stacked high) was cheap, cheap, cheap, and lacked any flavor. I honestly don't know how you can have 3 types of meat that have no flavor. I asked for oil dressing, and I'm pretty sure I just got vegetable oil, and not some sort of sub dressing as normal. Oh and the creepy gun sign in the window is a turn off too. I carry, but geez, chill out.

Pizza Shack 1

3.6

(29 reviews)

This was a pleasant surprise! I grew up on the east side of Rochester where I feel some of the best…read morepizza was when I was a kid in the 90s. Places like the original Amicos Pizza on waring road. Pizza that tasted like the recipes used, came straight from Italy. Many of the old skool places in western NY have this in common. Pizza shack is no doubt that old skool pizza with a taste that is like stepping in a time machine back to when you could go to almost any pizza parlor and get a fantastic pizza, before the oversaturation of pizza restaurants.

Love this place and the owner is so nice! The food is great, thin crust pizza with a perfect amount…read moreof toppings and the single slices are HUGE.

Carbone's Pizzeria

3.8

(65 reviews)