We order from Mark's regularly and have always been pleased with them. Delivery people are prompt and polite, the food is always hot and delicious! Love their thick crust and sauce on the pizza! read more

I'm in town for work. I ordered delivery. The pizza and wings arrived within an acceptable time and they were both still hot. The delivery driver was courteous and professional. I loved the pizza! Could have been a little thinner, but still great! read more

Mark's Pizzeria - Medium Cup 'N Char Pizza w/ hot peppers. - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

See all

I wish i read the reviews b4 I spent money here. I live 8min from this place, my kids and I waited almost an hour, the pizza came cold and with a little surprise that made us all not hungry anymore for pizza, two long hairs on top. Never again. Take these reviews into consideration if I were you. read more

I've been a customer for over 30 years but no more. Got pizza and 2 orders of wings last night (Webster). Paid over $50 and my toes are bigger than the wings we received. Called the store and got an apology from manager and a partial credit. Manager said they had just changed suppliers of wings this week and are returning to old supplier. What a shame, so long Marks! Never again! read more

Ordered a Large Pepperoni Pizza with extra sauce for the kids last night. Come home from work this morning to a Pizza that nobody ate. The kids said it arrived cold and one of the boys said they tried but the pizza was hard and seemed old. THATS exactly what it looks like. The manager at this location named "DANIELLA" is ridiculous and rude. Never offering to help but repeatedly suggesting I could have called last night. I explained ai ordered it for the kids as I was leaving for work. She then suggested the kids should have called last night. What a frickin COP OUT! She refused to do anything about this $32 pizza we ordered that arrived cold and HARD. Refused to give me their corporate number saying she didnt know it. RONT GIVE THESE PEOPLE YOUR HATD EARNED MONEY!!! They absolutely do not care about you!! This place is a disgusting rip-off. I font have time to deal with these kinds of establishments that overcharge for absolute garbage. But I couldn't let them get away with this crap. Hence why Im back here to let everyone else know to AVOID THIS PLACE, and avoid "DANIELLA" she can barely speak english too. SMDH. What a scam! read more

Garbage !!! Ordered 2 subs bread is burnt not even cut in half taste like poop. 38 dollars no way plus 5 dollar tip

They are the freaking rip off how the hell you gonna charge me $15 for fucking four chicken fingers without fries when I've ordered it before through you and when I try to talk to somebody, they were not even explained to me, but you know what it is what it is, and I will never ever order from them again and I will make sure people I know that are my friend here in the village of Webster. When I order from them they suck. Get the hell out of my face for $15. I could've bought a whole bunch of chicken fries and a bag of fries myself, fuck out of here read more

The product is good, the service is friendly and knowledgeable. The young people who I have encountered are hard working. read more

Ordered a pizza with pepperoni and ricotta. Ricotta didn't even melt, pepperoni looks like it was never even heated and the dough wasn't cooked through. read more

Mark's Pizzeria - Uncooked pizza - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

Pizza was ok, I bought a slice that was in the warmer case, guess they don't throw it in the oven to heat up.

Absolutely awful. Pizza used to be consistently good, last three times terrible, last night so bad went into the garbage. Never again! read more

Mark's Pizzeria - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

I go in and ask for two cheese slices and she starts to cash me out and this kid working just takes one of the last two slices which I was buying proceeds to take it and eat and I cannot even tell you how upset I am right now I haven't eaten all day and I got the second slice for my boyfriend and now we have to split a slice all because this boy couldn't wait like that is insane to me. I will be going to bay road from now on if I go to marks read more

Today I had the best pizza I've ever gotten from Mark's. It was made by the hands of my friend Angela Catalano, and it was utter perfection. Like seriously, maybe I was just hungry or something but the sauce, the doughiness, the amount of cheese. Utter perfection. Thank you Angela read more

The one on Ridge Rd, in Webster. Just horrible. Went for lunch, and asked the person behind the counter how long the pizza had been in the warmer. He said about 20 minutes, NOT. The slices we got were a warm, hot, mess. So much grease on top it took 5 napkins to get enough off to be able to try it. Crust was soggy. Should have taken a picture. read more

Here's the scoop, I ordered a pizza which was a tad subpar. This was a bit saddening ass I had good pizza there before. I saw one of the employees spit in my Pepsi but it was cool cuz she was kinda cute. read more

As always consistently the best pizza around. Service was also very good. If you looking for a good pizza for your family- this is it!

My husband and I eat at Mark's frequently, mostly their delicious pizza. We have never had any problems with their pizza. Tonight I ordered a grilled chicken ceaser salad. Absolutely horrible. Two pieces of chicken and waaaaay too many croutons. Also, the mushrooms were canned not fresh. Gave a very weird slime texture. Won't be ordering that again. read more

Mark's Pizzeria - a salad in a bowl - Pizza Near Me - Webster, New York

I've had multiple negative experiences with staff here recently, but the food has always been decent but I just ordered a pizza and it was missing a topping and had the wrong sauce. read more

Pizza is always cold and half wrong plus employees at the Webster village location are rude. Most other marks locations are much better. I recommend driving a little further for better service read more

Terrible. I use to eat at marks more often about 10+ years ago. It was only ever "convenience pizza" for us. It has become increasingly worse throughout the years at every location I've ever been at. The pizza is incredibly inconsistent. I feel awful for the younger generations in Monroe county at least around my age group that say "Mark's is the best pizza"; I don't know how to respond to that, but it's pretty sad. These chains are WAY over rated. read more

Screwed up order. Picked up a pizza (our fault for not checking it before we walked out of the store), opened it up at home and it was minus toppings we had ordered and paid for. When I called the store they told me they would need the entire wrong pizza back and they would make a correct one and bring it to us. However, I had hungry kids at my house who had already started eating. So now they say they will give me a credit for another pizza, but I'm not sure I will ever go back here. Looking for another pizza place in Webster now. Shame, since we really used to like Mark's when they were at their other location in the village, since they moved not so much, but I figured I would give them another try, shame shame on me! read more

I ordered 50 wings online in the early afternoon for our New Years eve party. I requested a 6:30 delivery time. I received an email at 6:50 that the order went out for delivery. When it was 7:15 and still no delivery, I called the store. I was placed on hold for 4 minutes, before they even knew why i was calling. When the person finally came back to the phone, i asked where my order was and was told it left at 6:50. I asked how a 6:30 delivery could be made by leaving at 6:50? i was told oh well we got really busy. i asked if that was really my problem, since i ordered in plenty of time. I asked for the manager and he came to the phone and said the delivery drivers were taking triple orders and they were got very busy. Again he said oh well we cant help it and there is nothing we can do about it. The order finally arrived around 7:30 and all the wings were cold and hard. They were disgusting. I would definitely not recommend this store, since they don't know how to treat their customers. Now i understand why 12 Marks stores are closing, and it wouldn't surprise me if this store was lucky number 13. My next orders will be from Salvatores. read more

We ordered a pizza tonight that was supposed to be free because of a screwed-up order. We arrived there to pick up the replacement Pizza only to find that they screwed it up again. This is not the first time. So if you're willing to accept screwed up orders go there. read more

I am very surprised to see poor reviews as I have ordered here for years and always had good food and excellent service. Not for nothing, they are busy all the time? I guess the reviews could be one offs or competitors. Either way, my fat ass knows pizza and Mark's is the best pizza in Webster by far... read more

Ordered a medium chicken bacon ranch pizza, to have it delivered. Delivery service was great but the pizza...meh! It was mostly bacon, hardly any chicken. Chicken is pretty much the cheapest meat you can buy. Why so skimpy? We were lucky to get 1 possibly 2 nuggets per slice. For over $20 for a medium pizza, I would have expected more. read more

As we sit here wishing we had Pizza and wings for our dinner, we wonder what is going on at Mark's Pizzeria in Webster. We like Mark's food, but tonight it never arrived. When we called the number that we placed the order with, the woman on the other end said she didn't have our order and that I likely called the West Webster store. Not sure how that is possible when I dialed the number I placed the order at. Does the gentleman that took my order at 7:47pm on 2/19/2019 think it is funny that he told us 45 minutes and then never placed the order? We received poor customer service when we placed the order and then poor customer service when we called an hour and 10 minutes later looking for our order. We are hoping this is not the direction Mark's is going in. Signed a disappointed Mark's customer. read more

I placed an online order with comments to call me when they delivered so I could help direct them once they reached my place of work. I never received a call and after 2 hours I called the store myself. After talking to the manager he said that the driver tried but I didn't have any record of the call on my cell phone! He then stated that he could offer me 15% off my next order. I prepaid online! I told him I wanted what I paid for and he finally agreed to have my food remade and sent to me (after a bit of back an forth). So after all that trouble I received my pizza and it was still raw. The dough was uncooked and the eggs ( breakfast pizza) were still extremely runny. read more

Worst pizza ever from this location! We are less than 8 minutes from this location yet our pizza took over 35 minutes to get here. It was rubbery and dry. The chicken wings were soggy and sitting in grease. Nothing was hot. I had called to find out what the problem was as an email had arrived informing us that the order was out for delivery. Was told the delivery person was lost??? He came racing down the road from the opposite direction he was reportedly lost. Delivery charge was $4.00 for this lousy service. Don't waste your time ordering from Mark's! read more

Tried Mark's once again since looks so good in their ads... Dough was great but very skimpy toppings... It was embarrassing as we had guests over and had ordered a sheet pizza. read more

We ordered large pizza with veg toppings, it was fresh, tasty and my family really liked it. Of course it's little overpriced.