We finally managed to try Pizza Nota after weeks of attempting to place an order -- and once we…read moreactually got the food, it was excellent. But getting there was a journey.
CAESAR SALAD (Family Style)
Chopped romaine, caesar, shaved parmesan, red onion, garlicky breadcrumbs
This was a standout. Fresh, craveable, and honestly one of the best Caesars we've had in a while. The garlicky breadcrumbs were perfect, and serving it in a funky pizza box was a fun touch. We couldn't stop eating it.
THE UPSIDE DOWN (Trenton Style)
Mozz first, pecorino, parmesan, Bianco DiNapoli tomato, basil, EVOO
Fantastic pie. Great crust, bright sauce, balanced cheese -- the whole family loved it. Not a crumb left, and there may have been some light negotiating over the last slice.
QUATTRO E PEPE
Mozzarella, provolone, ricotta, pecorino, black pepper, lemon zest, basil, parsley, EVOO
This one sounded amazing on paper but didn't quite land for us. By the time we got it home, the cheese had tightened up and the whole thing leaned salty and a bit dense. Not bad, just not something we'd reorder when the Upside Down exists.
The real issue:
Our rating isn't lower because of the one miss -- it's because actually ordering from this place is an ordeal. Pizza Nota requires the Slice app, and multiple times we built an order only to be told at checkout that ordering was closed. This happened repeatedly over the course of a month. We finally succeeded by placing an order at 3:30 PM. Whether it's the app or the restaurant's setup, something is clearly off, and it's frustrating enough that it will definitely affect other customers too.
Bottom line:
The food is genuinely great, and we'd happily come back -- if the ordering experience becomes more reliable. Fix that, and this is easily a five‑star spot.