Another Sunday another day of eating Good Guys pizza at my childhood home! My parents have been ordering Good Guys every week for say...15 years? Growing up it used to be our Friday dinner go-to! As a family of 6 who treated pizza Fridays like a religion, Good Guys has been consistently excellent since they opened in 2002. There's nothing that really comes close in Chili. We love their cup n char pepperoni and white garlic pizzas. They have a soft crust, perfectly balanced sauce, and don't skimp on the cheese or toppings. The staff is always super kind and they have an amazing large pizza special on Monday and Tuesday. The location is central (in the same plaza as McDonalds, Chili Fitness Center, etc) and, if picking up, you're usually in and out within a matter of minutes. I know we'll continue to order as a fam for as long as we're still gathering in Chili! Thanks Good Guys! read more

The steak bomber is still good. I had mine with mozzarella, onions, and mushrooms. The quantity of fillings seems to be less than in the past, not much meat and not extending to the edge of the roll. It's all chopped, so maybe they don't want it overflowing on to the grill, but makes for a skimpy sub. Still very tasty. read more

Bland pizza, crust has a good consistency is really the only positive. Otherwise entirely unremarkable.

changed their sauce - not happy - new owners - also got two burned pizza's when we got home .

The sheet pizza is pretty good & delivery came quick. Wings were FANTASTIC. Would order again.

Food- 1st time ordering from here and the cheese pizza and was Really good!! Fried mushrooms were good but a small portion for the price. Service- delivery took over an hr but glad to have a pizza place deliver! read more

I have to give some serious kudos to Good Guys Pizza in Chili! They did me a solid with their service it was pick up but it was also done on time and hot and definitely tasted good and hit the spot . They were very pleasant, knew their stuff. They made a mistake in the order of toppings however they made another pizza with the correct order of toppings but that's not the best part, it is that they gave me the one that they made a mistake on for free. So to me that is awesome thing as well as great customer service. But it wasn't just because I got a free pizza out of the deal but because they wanted to get the order right and told me about it upfront. I do highly recommend this business and I will continue to patronize this establishment. read more

I haven't had good guys pizza in quite a while so I wanted to give them a shot again. We ordered a medium pizza with extra cheese and a few sides of bleu cheese which was ready in 20 mins on a Thursday night. The pizza itself was pretty good, I liked the flavor of the sauce and the crust was nicely cooked. I thought $20 for our order seemed pretty high though and maybe thats because I know of other places nearby that charge $27 for a sheet pizza... we felt a little ripped off for what it was. Also the bleu cheese was not good. It tasted really off and we ended up not even eating it. I will say the pizza was good enough not to need it though. All and all pizza was good but prices were too high so we probably wouldn't come back. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Medium pizza with extra cheese, pretty good but a little pricey - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

We order from Good Guys almost every week, and I must say that on the average most weeks our pizza is delicious and our wings too however, sometimes the regular wings with the bone are undercooked or the packaging that it comes in leaks all over. We usually have our pizza and wings delivered and I must say that the delivery people are prompt, kind courteous and efficient. We never have a complaint. Another thing that I like about Good Guys is that they will take my credit card over the phone. They are usually able to pull up what we usually order and have that on hand. read more

The pizza was pretty good. The service was good. It was just one person when we went. The time for the order was overestimated. We got there 10 minutes early, and it had already been done. We got take-out so can't speak for atmosphere. read more

My new go to pizza place. Tried the pizza on the special night were you get a large for $11 and the pizza was great. The sauce is tasty and the pizza was cooked perfect. Staff is very friendly. I ordered the pizza and it was ready on time and waiting when I got there. There are coupons offered too. read more

I ordered pizza and wings. I asked for both, well done! The wings were undercooked, the pizza was doughy, and the delivery driver had wings on top of the pizza, so it was also pushed into the pizza, and all the toppings were on the cardboard! 3rd time ordering and 3re time messing up but keep raising your prices! read more

We ordered a cheese and pepperoni pizza and 1 dozen wings. This was our first time at Good Guys in Chili. It was ok. Definitely not great, we probably will not go back. The pizza had barely any cheese and you were lucky to get 2 pepperonis per slice. The wings were soggy but the wing sauce tasted good. It was edible but that was about it. read more

No complaints, but nothing exceptional. Have only ordered a couple times on their $10 Monday specials. It's good pizza, especially for the $10. read more

Love this pizza so much! Crust is thin, unique taste. Good cheese. Just yum! My favorite in Rochester

We have been longtime regulars at Good Guys but the last 4 or so orders have shown a decrease in quality overall but increased prices. We called in a pick up order of 3 large steak subs (lightly toasted) and 2 orders of loaded fries. We were told 45min so we showed up at that time but they hadn't even started the fries yet. We ended up waiting over an hour. The order was $72 which is crazy for 3 subs and 2 sides at a takeout pizza joint. Got our order home to find burnt sub bread, the burnt taste made the whole thing taste burnt even after tearing off the really brown pieces. The sandwiches themselves had very little meat in them, more burnt bread than anything. Looks like we'll be on the lookout for a new joint! read more

Good Guys Pizza - Burnt Steak bomber - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Picked up a large pepperoni pizza with pineapple topping. My friend takes a few bites and then starts screaming. He found a stapler pin stuck on his gum. When he pulled it out it was covered in cheese. I called them up and they wanted me to bring it back to issue a refund. I was annoyed by the fact that I had to bring it back and decided never to order from them again. Terrible experience, definitely not worth an intestinal perforation! read more

Good Guys Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Updating my review from months ago....total UPGRADE!! My new GO TO pizza place!! I can't get enough of you GOOD GUYS!! I'm not sure what happened, but your pizzas have been consistently delish! Love the sauce- spicy, flavorful and you don't skimp OR over do it. You load up the toppings and cook the crust perfectly. I go for your standard large cheese and pepperoni (not a huge fan of NY Style so try the regular crust one) mostly but I do love me some onions from time to time. I have been ordering once a week and you nail it every time. Great price too! read more

Pretty average "Mom & Pop" shop pizza. Nothing overly memorable. Pros: Better than chain pizza, $9 Large pizza on Monday & Tuesday Cons: Crust is kinda tough, Cheese is low to average quality (greasy) Atmosphere: Takeout only, Kinda dirty inside read more

Good Guys Pizza - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

We ordered the large pizza with meatballs and green peppers...free boneless wings came with it. Pizza was delicious. Meatballs were so good. Thanks for making dinner tonight. read more

Good Guys Pizza - Large meatball with green pepers at Good Guys pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Next to carbines, best pizza in the greater Rochester area. And its a different style. High quality ingredients and toppings. Carbones is more of a rochester style. Good guys is more of a ny style. I have been on a best of ny style mission this past year, and good guys is the best. Wish they were out on the east side or in the city tho. read more

Ordered pizza for brother and sisters going through Dad's house cleaning it up to prepare for sale. Pizza was ordered the night before and it was delivered on time and looked great and tasted great also. The salads were excellent and very fresh and tasty. We were very pleased with quality of food and the delivery service was excellent. read more

Our go to place for pizza, searched for years to find pizza as good as Buffalo's - this place has it! Subs and calzones are awesome too. Exceptional delivery and staff. read more

Stopped in tonight for 2 regular sized subs. 1 a ham & swiss and 1 a turkey & swiss. Very disappointed when I got home to find the meat extremely skimped on, with barely 2-3 pieces on each, almost unable to be seen under the pile of lettuce on stale sub rolls that crumbled as we ate them. It was essentially more like an overpriced lettuce & cheese sandwich. At $8.99 a piece one would expect at least a couple handfuls of meat per sub, on fresh bread. Good Guys is mediocre at best. Very unsatisfying & a poor value for my money. read more

Good Guys Pizza is pretty good. It's definitely not top tier, but it's better than the chains (including Salvatores). Their wings are also very good. See my pictures for the full menu as of 12/31/2016. read more

See all

Woah, I think I found my new favorite pizza spot on the west side! I heard about this place from a friend, stating they offer the hexagon Mexican pizzas from high school years in the cafeteria. I had to go and see for myself. It's true, they have them - and taste just as good as I remember. I ordered 3 this past weekend, and while sitting down to wait for my order to be ready I noticed all of these newspaper articles and clipping showing all of these awards and recognition for best pizza. I figured they had to be good to have this kind of attention, so I went back to the register and ordered myself a slice of regular pizza. Woah, thank God I didn't leave without that slice - it was soooo good! I don't think I have devoured a slice of pizza so quick in my life. Now the size people, we're talking HUGE. And yes, I devoured it plus a Mexican fiestata. I was in pizza heaven. I can't wait to order from them again! read more

Good Guys Pizza - Huge slice of cheese pizza. One of the best slices I've had - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

This is our go to pizza place and has been for years. If we pick it up or have it delivered, always great pizza. Great customer service and we have never had an issue with an order. I do agree with other reviewers that it is a little pricey for pizza. They do offer coupons all the time, I just forget them. read more

Good Guys has very good pizza, wings, subs, and sides. They're my favorite pizza shop in Chili and I order often. The prices are reasonable and similar to other pizza shops in the area. My most-ordered item is their chicken cordon bleu sub, with honey mustard added. The chicken fingers, ham, etc. always taste great, but what makes the sub is the bread. The bread is crispy on the outside, slightly chewy on the inside, and absolutely delicious. (Updated my review from 4 to 5 stars, due to great food and even better consistency... It's just always delicious!) read more

The pizza is delicious highly recommend, with a coupon we got a free medium pizza! Exxellent customer service as well.

I ordered a fish fry on Friday at 3:45 pm yesterday. Very disappointed in the food that I was served. It seemed the fish and potatoes were cooked in old oil. The fried potatoes were not edible. Bad day at the fryer. read more

This place is a contender for one of the best pizza/wing places in Rochester. Every time I have order pizza and wings from here I've been very happy with their product. The wings are cooked crispy and delicious and not over sauced. Their blue cheese is fresh and tasty. Their pizza's are cooked well and the again..not over sauced or over cheesy. Way better than any of the chain places around. read more

Ordered the New York style (I forgot its official name and can't find the menu online). Tasted acceptable but the crust was tough and very chewy. My jaw was sore after eating here, it really hindered enjoying the pizza. Went once and I don't plan on going back. read more

Today these guys forgot how to add. The original total charged to my card was wrong by just a buck and when I called to let them know they became upset after they realized that they charged the incorrect amount. Somehow it is wrong to expect to be charged the correct amount of money. They started getting rude so I decided to cancel my order and the manager refused to refund my money...which was still more than the original price should have been. It should have been no big deal to fix it but they would not. The manager told me that I was "talking shi*" to him and hung up. Nice. So we didn't get any food but they still want to keep my money that wasn't even for the correct amount in the first place? Too bad they can't live up to their name. I suppose the fact they are located in a dilapidated building in a crumbling plaza should have given us a clue of the pride they take in their business. They probably need that extra cash more than me anyways. What comment can the owner even make to justify not providing goods but keeping the funds? They are welcome to add their two cents to explain and if they did it would show that they at least care about their reputation which is not apparent from their actions today, you know with the owner refusing to talk to me and all. Perhaps they'll be more talkative in this forum and hopefully they can use other vocabulary than the vulgar words that the management is fond of using with customers. I hope you have a great day guys!!! read more

This is probably the best pizza place in town. Pizza sauce is delish as is crust. Love,love their pizza.

Never been disappointed with good guys until now. Hadn't ordered for a while and was realky craving a pizza. Called several times between 9:20 and 9:30 to order and no one would pick up the phone. I decided to drive over and order amd got there at 9:34 (live down the street). I walked in and asked if I could order and the guy looked around at everyone and the clock amd then decided they were closed. I will have to find another place I guess. Just very dissapointed. Posted at 10:02 which gave me time to come back home, login and write this read more

Best Pizza in Rochester. Has great wings and subs as well.

Only place I'll go for buffalo chicken subs (and I've had A LOT of buffalo chicken subs..). Consistent, delicious and staff is always friendly. Been ordering here for years and Good Guys never disappoints!! read more

We order delivery from here every now and then and the food is pretty good and prices about average, plus they have a few specials. What I really appreciate about these guys is that they almost always make sure they get the order right and the one or two times they have messed something up they went out of their way to fix it. read more

Best wings in town! Their garlic parm wings are not to be missed, Instead of just garlic and oil, they use ACTUAL wing sauce! Great flavor. Pizza is great and the toppings always taste fresh. Love that they have Fiestata's as well. read more

Chili's best!!! Consistent every time u order extra cheese means extra with them! Crust is flavorful and tender unlike p----till next door! Sorry Steve! Don't change a thin. This is a recent review I just ordered a steak sub and this review is for the owners of Good Guys if you are paying attention to your business and yelp since you were on it I would appreciate an answer I have to give you three stars because the quality of your pizza and sandwiches has lessened I ordered east Philly steak with peppers onions mushrooms the peppers were cut in small squares half raw no mushrooms that I could see Chappys hots down the road has the best cheesesteak sandwich in the area you might want to try their's to try to do yours better my name is George Morone I would appreciate your comments this is to the owners of good guys normally your place is excellent and a frequent it and will continue to in hopes that it gets back to what it was the best pizza place in chili thanks !! read more