All Star Pizza

Nothing to complain about here. My wife and I tried it for lunch one day last week. The pizza is…read moredeep dish, Detroit style, you can buy whole pies, but they have several for sale by the slice. They had a garlic confit pizza, which was absolutely outstanding. We also split a Greek salad Which was large and fresh, and we couldn't finish. I will definitely eat here again. They also a pretty significant takeout business.

The service was wonderful. Our food was brought out to us and they even offered to pick up our…read moreplates when we finished eating. The dining area was comfy and had various seating options. The food was pretty good but for the price of the subs I wish they were a little bit bigger. The ciabatta bread was soft and fresh; but it wasn't big enough for the meat portion and you were left with a lot of saucy bread at the end. For the price I wish they gave you an additional cutlet on the sandwich. I really enjoyed the flavor of the sauce. Definitely a place to try again, but I do wish they gave you more in terms of portion size.

4.2 mi•North Winton Village

001

See all

Nino's Pizzeria

4.4(105 reviews)

Great pizza and a really great prices. Lots of options are many, many overwhelming. Wings were…read moregood. A bit salty but solid. Hole in the wall place

I grew up in the 60s on Rosewood Terrace, close to where Nino's is on Culver Rd. I remember getting…read morepizza there in the 70s when Nino was running the place. I moved to Texas in '82 and only got back to Rochester a few years ago. I didn't realize Nino's was still in business till just recently. I stopped in there tonight and ordered an extra large Sicilian pie. Nino's son Jimmy is running it now. The place is a liite different inside but the pizza is as good as I remember...that marinara sauce is still the same, flavorful and slightly sweet, loaded with mozzarella and a very generous amount of fresh toppings, all at a very reasonable price. I've traveled the world since I've been gone, even to Italy, and I don't remember pizza better than this. I'm glad they are still around. If you're looking for a great Sicilian pie, look no farther then Nino's... Molto bene!

Table

Small pepperoni and mushroom pizza.

See all

Ardor Park Artisanal Pizza

4.6(77 reviews)

5.1 mi•Park Avenue

Visiting family in Rochester and looking for a good pizza place. When I saw the pizza photos on…read moreYelp and especially the way the crust looked, I knew this would be a good place. But it turned out to be a fabulous place! Absolutely excellent pizza, well crafted, authentic crust and creative ingredients. Their latin spin on the Hawaiian pizza, La Pina Loca, is masterful and the black garlic & funghi was outstanding. My brother and his wife, locals, were astounded that I'd found such an amazing place on their hometown. We'll be back!

Honest Review The…read morepizza was SO GOOD! Honestly, the food itself was delicious and I would've happily given this place a great review... BUT I specifically ordered the pizza without hot honey, and it was also supposed to have pineapple on it. When I got home , I realized the pineapple was missing and the pizza had hot honey on it anyway. I immediately called THREE times to try to get it sorted out. Every single time, I got an automated message saying they were going to transfer me to someone, and then... no one ever answered. ‍ That's incredibly frustrating, especially when you're calling right after you discover there's a problem with your order. The pizza itself was seriously delicious, but the customer service was disappointing. I really hope they improve their phone service because I'd actually like to order from here again!

Pizza Oven

Tommy V Pizza

See all

Stuffed Garlic Bread - comes out hot and bubbling! Very good.

Pizza Wizard

4.6(159 reviews)

5.4 mi•South Wedge

Pizza Wizard.... I can't quit you. PW definitely knows pizza fellow Foodies…read more A must try when in ROC. The staff is very friendly and helpful in selecting a pizza of your desire. So let it be written...So let it be EATEN!!

The atmosphere here is great! I always loved the Swillburg/South Wedge and miss living in the area…read more This place captures the essence of the area perfectly. And the food??? Amazing! We got a WGR and Big Dodge Ram for pizza, and an order of 8 mild wings (extra crispy with a side of the wicked sauce since I love spicy food). The pizza was perfect. Great, crispy crust, flavorful sauce and toppings. And the wings?? Spectacular. Fried perfectly and both sauces were great. Mild Buffalo had a really good flavor, unlike some of the mild that are bland and boring. And the wicked had a great spice but good flavor, too. Service was super friendly and helpful for these newbies. We'll be back for sure. We definitely had leftovers so plan accordingly.

See all

Vern's

4.4(282 reviews)

4.3 mi•Park Avenue

•$$$

Vern's is definitely one of those spots that's worth a visit! They don't take reservations, and…read morewhen we arrived around 7:30pm on a Sunday evening, it was packed. We were quoted about a 40-minute wait for a table, but told bar seating might open up sooner (around 30 minutes). They took my number and we stepped outside to take a walk around the block while we waited. We ended up getting a text about the bar seat availability in about 15 minutes. Once we got seated at the bar, things turned around quickly. The space has a really cozy, intimate vibe with dim lighting, warm atmosphere and overall it feels thoughtfully put together. We ordered hot toddies to drink, which were perfect for the weather, and for food we got the Japanese sweet potatoes and the cavolo nero pesto. Both dishes were incredibly delicious - flavorful and well-balanced. Just be prepared for a wait (and maybe stay nearby instead of wandering off), but once you're in, it's a great experience!

We tried out Vern's for the first time on a Thursday evening! We made it there by about 5:00 PM and…read moreit was easy enough to get a table for 2 with only indoor seating available. It's a small space inside but it's designed well enough to manage a flow of traffic for customers and staff. We sat in the back greenhouse area. I think the least enjoyable part of our experience was how loud it was in the restaurant. Definitely not a good spot if you're trying to catch up with someone and your voice doesn't carry. I couldn't actually hear the specials the server was telling us. I want to try out Vern's again, so I may wait until there's an outdoor table or ask to sit in the second level to see if that's quieter. We tried one of their spring menu appetizer items, the Japanese sweet potatoes with kimchi ranch and dill. One bite and I was addicted, these were so so good. We then moved on to the classics for entrees -- bee sting pizza and the ragu-- and we were amazed at how good everything was! The only note we had was about the pizza, it was very soggy in the middle but still edible if you rolled it over in itself. We also had a few cocktails, and while they were somewhat small, you could tell they weren't watered down in any way. Two drinks was more than enough for me. Overall it was a great experience and we want to try it again. If you're someone who struggles to enjoy a meal out where you can't hear much, maybe wait for outdoor tables.

Seating area

Lost Meatball Ragu | Instagram: @telephonesmoothie

See all

Gin fizz

GG's Pizza

4.6(23 reviews)

1.4 mi

This place has such good vibes with very affordable food and amazing flavor!! Will be back.read more

Solid pizza and wings. Met the wife here after work after seeing some of their Tik Tok videos and…read moreit did not disappoint. First off the two girls working the counter were super nice and hustling, it was busy. The cup and char pepperoni was perfect. Good sausage on the pizza as well, and crust had a good chew, and some crispy bits on the edges. The wings could have been a little crispier but the buffalo sauce was in point, just the right amount of heat. Good blue cheese. Surprise hit were the fried onion petals. Not a lot of seating inside but clean tables and most people were picking up to go orders. Will definitely come back.

See all

Strangebird

4.4(227 reviews)

5.6 mi•Wadsworth Sqaure

Great for lagers and pilsners I didn't get food but the bar…read moreservice was great and beer was exceptional Plenty of seating Lots of beer options

Met up here on a Monday evening and was excited to try it since I had never been. I got the fries…read morewith preserved lemon aioli - these magical bites somehow stayed hot and crispy through the whole meal. I tried (& loved) their Belgian triple since it had just won a silver medal at the NYS Craft Brewers awards. It was well-deserving of the honor it received! Staff was friendly and attentive, and it was easy enough to get a bartender's attention for a refill. Seating area was bright and spacious with great atmosphere. Parking situation is kinda hairy - extra tight spaces in a small lot, but it was manageable for a Monday, and there's street parking if you don't happen to get a space in the lot. Cheers!

Bar area

Brownie ice cream sando

See all

Outside parking lot area

Purple Monster Pizza

4.4(18 reviews)

12.6 mi

We recently moved to the area and this has quickly become our go-to pizza spot. We've eaten here…read moreseveral times now, and the quality is consistently excellent. The pizza is always solid, but the wings are truly amazing--perfectly crispy and packed with flavor every single time. I also really appreciate that they offer gluten-free dough that actually tastes good (which is rare!). And don't skip the dessert dough--it's a favorite in our house. Reliable, delicious, and clearly made with care. We're so glad to have found this place and will definitely keep coming back

Purple Monster Pizza in Greece, NY is the kind of mom-and-pop spot every neighborhood needs. It's…read morecozy, casual, and absolutely clutch when pizza cravings hit--especially during Sunday night football. The crust is crisp yet chewy, the cheese perfectly melty, and the toppings generously loaded. Whether you're grabbing a quick pie for the family or hosting a game-day hangout, this place delivers quality and comfort every time. There's something charmingly local about the vibe, and you can tell the owners put heart into every order. If you're in the area, Purple Monster is a must-try slice of Greece.

Outside

Grease

See all

Purple monster

Peels on Wheels

4.7(94 reviews)

4.2 mi•Beechwood

I needed a quick bite before my flight and found Peels on Wheels on Yelp. From the friendly…read morecustomer service to the delicious food, everything was definitely five-stars. Louis was very helpful, explaining the menu and specials since it was my first visit. I decided to try the Detroit-style white top with Mike's honey drizzle and a pineapple Jarritos. While waiting, I sat on a few chairs outside in front of the garage. It took about 15 minutes, and my pizza was piping hot. My ricotta melted due to the steam, but it was still very good! The portion was generous, I could only finish one slice and took the rest to go. It's not a sit-down restaurant, it's perfect to take to-go; however, there is a table that you could stand and eat at, if you needed to. The decor was also nice and bright, with a unique twist with decor. Louis also mentioned they source most ingredients locally, which is noticeable in the freshness of every bite. He was kind enough to offer me a New York-style cheese slice, which was also delicious! While a little pricey, the quality justifies the price. I can't wait to return! If you're in the area, definitely check them out!

I know it's pricey but the pizza is amazing. The sauce is great, they use that amazing Italian…read moreflour, and the ordering process is easy. The only thing I wish they did was a vegetable pizza.

Interior

Cuban sandwich

See all

The Pizza Stop

4.2(138 reviews)

6.3 mi•Center City

While here on a visit we stopped here for their NY thin crust pizza. We were not disappointed…read more Pizza is ordered by the slice. Many varieties. We got slices of pepperoni, mushroom and broccoli, bacon pizza and plain cheese plus a cobb salad with chicken. Everything delicious. Great thin crust and great mozzarella cheese. Salad was good too. Prices good, friendly service at the counter. Comfortable atmosphere. One of best pizza we had in a long time!

This pizza is AWESOME. Walked 3 blocks for this perfectly cooked, thin pizza. Oh man. Every choice…read moreis DELICIOUS. I tried the garlic cheese white pizza. The slices are HUGE. $8 for a slice and a drink. The staff are quick, polite and knowledgable. I loved the subway murals on the wall. Very fun to look at.

Inside seating view

Pepperoni pizza

See all

Assorted pizza slices on a rack

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

8 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Barb L.

0

1

0

8 years ago

I have been coming to Allstar for a long time now (around 2 years) Everything has been amazing up until yesterday at around 4pm. I walked in to Allstar and all you could hear was profanity rap music with obscene amount of cuss words. The two guys who waited on me where very unprofessional and had the biggest attitude. It is not the normal staff that is normally there. It was like walking into a pizza shop into the ghetto. Until new staff comes in I will not be back. read more

Tim V.

0

7

0

13 years ago

Best pizza joint in Rochester! Thanks to the recommendation of my IMS broker, I was able to enjoy the best thin crust carryout and have it on trade too! read more

Anthony M.

0

2

0

8 years ago

Great pizza, friendly staff! It's always a great experience and their delivery staff was super nice!

Sam R.

0

1

0

9 months ago

Holy smokes, this place is ass (I need 85 characters so I'm writing this extra bit of text)

Carl L.

0

1

0

7 years ago

The pizza is amazing, I love the thin crust and the wings are incredible

Kyle R.

0

4

0

8 years ago

Great food and amazing people! Cant wait to order from there again!

Trish L.

32

16

6

10 years ago

just not worth it, in my opinion.

Lainie E.

27

8

0

10 years ago

Delicious. The pizza is amazing.

All Star Pizza - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Rochester, New York Restaurants near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Coffee near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Breakfast near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Dinner near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Things to Do near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Desserts near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Parking near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Burgers near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Shopping near All Star Pizza

BEST of Rochester, New York Movie Theatre near All Star Pizza

Best of Rochester

Things to do in Rochester

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed All Star Pizza also viewed

Pizza Stop, Greece

3.9

(73 reviews)

Stopped in for a quick pizza and garlic knots. They were so delicious. The garlic and butter and…read morethe garlic knots made me want to dip my pizza crust in it! We will be back soon.

The downtown location will always be a classic... but there's a lot to be said for the convenience…read moreof a small strip mall storefront with lots of parking (no city parking meters here.) The store is small with only a few tables for dine in and very clean and neat. The staff is absolutely too notch! Very friendly, chatting with customers and generally smiling. It's welcoming. Just like the original in State Street location there is a large selection of slices, both NY thin crust and thicker Sicilian. Something for everyone and very high (but not quite at the top) on my list of go-to pizza joints. Definitely worth a stop if you're in the area.

Brandani's Pizza

3.9

(78 reviews)

Great pizza! You will get your moneys worth (per slice)…read more Fast service Efficient Would recommend

I might as well gotten Dominos. Box dough, bag sauce with corn syrup, taste like fake vegan…read morecheese, Ok it was freshly cooked

The Pizza Stop

4.2

(138 reviews)

While here on a visit we stopped here for their NY thin crust pizza. We were not disappointed…read more Pizza is ordered by the slice. Many varieties. We got slices of pepperoni, mushroom and broccoli, bacon pizza and plain cheese plus a cobb salad with chicken. Everything delicious. Great thin crust and great mozzarella cheese. Salad was good too. Prices good, friendly service at the counter. Comfortable atmosphere. One of best pizza we had in a long time!

This pizza is AWESOME. Walked 3 blocks for this perfectly cooked, thin pizza. Oh man. Every choice…read moreis DELICIOUS. I tried the garlic cheese white pizza. The slices are HUGE. $8 for a slice and a drink. The staff are quick, polite and knowledgable. I loved the subway murals on the wall. Very fun to look at.

Guida's Pizza

3.0

(83 reviews)

I hadn't had Guida's since they closed down in Penfield... and I have come home to the promised…read moreland. I took a new job in the west side and my coworkers typically order from Guida's in Gates. Having tried their delicious pIzza in the office, I ventured over to Elmwood to check them out for myself... and it is fantastic! A large selection of lunchtime slices including thin crust wood fired, white pizza, Detroit thick crust and Grandma's pizza. All have generous toppings and are baked to perfection. The dining area is very nice and always tidy. Above average for a busy storefront pizza joint and I love the staff. Always a smile and a kind greeting. Watch the steady stream of huge slices and happy customers heading out the door at lunch time and you will know you're at the right place. My favorite in the west side.

Good food and great service time! Had our food quick and it was piping hot. Always a great…read moreexperience.

Trotto's Pizzeria

4.0

(26 reviews)

I know pizza is personal and there are many options. I'm going to tell you about a pizza shop that…read morehas been around forever. There is a reason for this, the owner Jeremy, even in times of rising food prices, has held the price and Quality of his pies. The pizza can be ordered thin, thick, or regular. You have a large selection of toppings and the crust and sauce is a match in heaven. You can pickup or have it delivered. The times given are very accurate and the drivers are very personable. Wings, mushrooms and mozzarella sticks are also available. The next time you're in the mood for pizza, give Trottos a chance to be your favorite! You won't be disappointed!

Creating a great sheet pizza and crispy wings isn't easy, but you'll find that at Trotto's. While…read morein search of a good meal, while watching a ball game, Trotto's came up as the top rated option and they were right! Highly recommend the sheet pizza - medium crust cooked all the way through, just enough sauce and fresh veggies on top. The wings were even better - Buffalo style and garlic Parmesan, juicy on the inside and crispy outside. Sounds trivial for western NY where pizza and wings are done correctly, but when visiting from out of state, one appreciates when it's done we'll.

Nino's Pizzeria

4.4

(105 reviews)

Great pizza and a really great prices. Lots of options are many, many overwhelming. Wings were…read moregood. A bit salty but solid. Hole in the wall place

I grew up in the 60s on Rosewood Terrace, close to where Nino's is on Culver Rd. I remember getting…read morepizza there in the 70s when Nino was running the place. I moved to Texas in '82 and only got back to Rochester a few years ago. I didn't realize Nino's was still in business till just recently. I stopped in there tonight and ordered an extra large Sicilian pie. Nino's son Jimmy is running it now. The place is a liite different inside but the pizza is as good as I remember...that marinara sauce is still the same, flavorful and slightly sweet, loaded with mozzarella and a very generous amount of fresh toppings, all at a very reasonable price. I've traveled the world since I've been gone, even to Italy, and I don't remember pizza better than this. I'm glad they are still around. If you're looking for a great Sicilian pie, look no farther then Nino's... Molto bene!

Good Guys Pizza

3.6

(47 reviews)

The steak bomber is still good. I had mine with mozzarella, onions, and mushrooms. The quantity of…read morefillings seems to be less than in the past, not much meat and not extending to the edge of the roll. It's all chopped, so maybe they don't want it overflowing on to the grill, but makes for a skimpy sub. Still very tasty.

changed their sauce - not happy - new owners - also got two burned pizza's when we got home .read more

Pizza D's Mendon

4.3

(37 reviews)