Great pizza. That crust. It's delicious and stays crispy. Beats the shit out of those chain places like blaze or whatever. We all loved our toppings, from the cup-and-char to the buffalo sauce to the shredded chicken, just all delicious. Service, phenomenal. Like they really care you enjoy your pizza. Can't believe I used to go to fucking Blaze. read more

We have ordered here a few times from grubhub (I know, I know I'm lazy and hate trying to park) but whenever the pizzas/ calzones arrived they were ALWAYS amazing. My partner is vegan leaning and we appreciate the non-dairy options. I make a point to order the vegan blue cheese ( a couple for later) it's soooooo good. I hate blue cheese but this is magic in a little dixie cup. The only downside is sometimes it doesn't arrive ( not this business's fault at all) read more

My dad has been here a lot of times while in Rochester and brought us there to try it this past weekend. The owners are super friendly and take great care in making their pizzas. They are so reasonably priced and they have fresh ingredients and great sauce! We enjoyed creating our own pizzas and they tasted great! We will be back again soon! read more

See all

Wonderful service It's quick and they pay attention is what you want Nice place casual and clean. The pizza are very inventive and you build your own. Generous toppings and the crust is just the way I like it. Definitely going to keep on filling my craving for pizza from here read more

The build your own pizza concept is awesome! You have the opportunity to watch them build it, and place it into their brick oven. The pizzas are DELICIOUS! My husband and I traveled down to Rochester for a comedy show, and tried Create A Pizza and it hit all the right spots! Thin crust, and delicious! My husband insisted that we couldn't leave, to travel back home for our 5hr travels - until Create A Pizza opened at 12pm, to grab a few pizzas for the road. The owners work the pizzeria, with such pride and joy and you can feel it. Family photos to show you the people behind the business, and it was the sweetest. 10/10 for Create A Pizza! Thank you guys for the BEST pizza ever read more

See all

Saw great reviews for this place, and decided to take my daughter recently. Walking in, this is a great little spot! We were immediately greeted by a man making pizzas, and despite being busy, he was immediately asking questions and explaining the process. We decided to share a half cheese, half cup and char with garlic butter sauce. I added some balsamic glaze and parm at the end - what he referred to as "finishers." I was super impressed with the politeness and the speediness of the process. The pizza was done in about 5 minutes. My daughter loved the skittles machine that spit out skittles at a rapid fire pace. They spilled everywhere. A lady working there gave her another quarter to get more. The food - this isn't one of those thick, doughy pizzas you usually get. It was very thin and packed very full of flavor. I loved it despite it not being super filling. I also ordered garlic bread because I'm a sucker for it. This would've hit 5 stars if the garlic bread wasn't nearly tasteless. This place overall is incredible, but the garlic bread could use some improving! I will definitely be back! There is a large selection of different toppings and sauces to get. read more

Create A Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The service was amazing. The ambiance is very Lis back and chilled. The food was good.

You should try this friendly, affordable pizzeria-calzoneria on Rochester's up-and-coming Monroe Ave.! The food is delicious. A companion and I ordered two "regular" calzones: they were HUGE and totally FRESH. I can guarantee the latter, as I saw our pizzaiola put them in the oven as I walked through the door to pick them up. We had a nice chat as I waited for our order. They're also open late: something I'm shocked other pizzerias in the area (like Park Ave.'s [in]famous Chester Cab) should get on if they want to compete with "Create"! I look forward to return to try one of their signature pies. read more

I came across this place while looking for somewhere to order a vegan calzone. They have three choices of vegan cheese, Follow Your Heart, ricotta and mozzarella. They also have a choice of vegan blue cheese or ranch for a dipping sauce. The vegetable ass ins are extensive. And the have vegan sausage, meatballs and pepperoni. You can create a calzone for any craving you may be having. The prices are reasonable and the food is good. A solid choice overall. read more

Food was delicious. Great service as well. Highly highly recommend!! If you are looking for a great place to get some excellent pizza, this is the place. read more

Delivery was fast, and I appreciated the size of the pizza for the price especially compared to other places. I ordered the Buffalo Chicken pizza with extra shredded chicken. It tasted okay but the reason I gave it 4 stars and not 5 is because it was very oily. Maybe I shouldn't be surprised about that because, well, it's pizza. I don't know if there would've been less oil if I hadn't added the extra shredded chicken. I had leftovers the next day but couldn't finish it because of how much oil seeped through the crust on the bottom. read more

I'm a big fan of pizza, good pizza and as much as Rochester is known for all of its pizza locations, Create A Pizza is one of the best. Great pizza, excellent prices, if you enjoy pizza, give this place a try. read more

I'm new to the area, and just ate at Create a Pizza. Loved it! You can choose a personal sze, 12", or calzone, and load it up with as many sauces and toppings as you'd like. They make it for you as you watch, similar to how Subway does it. The service was wonderful-friendly staff with just the right amount of conversation as my pizza was being made. I wouldnt say it has the best ambiance for dining in, as it was pretty warm in there because of oven. There are only a few tables to sit, so it isn't geared toward a sit-in type of restaurant. The pizza was delicious and the ingredients were fresh. They also had cauliflower crust, which is gluten free, and lots of vegetarian and vegan options. If you're craving a pizza, give this place a try. So good and inexpensive! read more

Really good pizza's! Got the Gluten free Mediterranean, Gluten free BBQ Hawaiian and the Gluten Free Veggie Delight. All three were amazing. Perfect and super fresh with great taste!! Totally worth the drive and stop! If you are in the area, you should stop and eat here for sure! read more

See all

Stopped in after finding online deal and had a great dinner. They have traditional crust in personal size and 12in as well as a 10in Cauliflower crust/Gluten free option. They have some suggested flavor combos and create you own options with no charge for unlimited veggies. We were quickly greeted with very friendly and helpful staff. They have some specials which this week included dill pickle pizza with pieces of dill pickle and garlic butter sauce which was tempting as I love pickles, but I went another route. I got a cauliflower/GF crust which was thin, may have been perfect if a little crispier on the bottom which I probably could've requested. I had hearty tomato sauce which had a nice flavor with fresh mozzarella, mushroom, caramelized onion, red onion, pineapple, jalapenos, fresh bazil and a bbq sauce drizzle. Veggies were fresh and sauces flavorful. Nice restaurant concept, fresh options, decent pricing and very pleasant staff - would give them a try if in the area. read more

See all

Ordered delivery on Grubhub and got an awesome gluten free and regular crust custom pizza! The signature fresh mozzarella and balsamic drizzle is a must! Pizza arrived still hot and crispy! Would definitely recommend. read more

Create A Pizza - Custom Pizza with Unlimited Toppings GF & Regular Crust - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! My family and I came here while on vacation and holy crap, it was some of the best pizza I've ever had!! Service was amazing and the owner was so personable and friendly. The guy helping us made us feel super welcome and made us all laugh. Best pizza ever and you are missing out if you pass on this awesome local place! read more

Create A Pizza - Custom Personal Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Great service and great pizza! It has become our default pizza location. Highly recommend

I love entrepreneurs who take a good idea and make it a reality. Create A Pizza is a new pizza place with a focus on exceptional customer service, quality ingredients, and tasty final product. We fed our family of four for $28 (with a Groupon) including four pizzas and four 20-ounce drinks. For my pizza, I did 3/4 veggie and 1/4 Hawaiian on a 12" crust. Because there was no limit on the toppings, I loaded up the veggies including carrots, roasted red peppers, spinach, olives, onions, and green peppers on top of the hearty tomato sauce and provolone/mozzarella cheese mix. I tried the fresh mozzarella on the Hawaiian portion of the pizza and it was really good too. Each member of my family chose a different sauce and toppings for their personalized pizzas. Since I have once child who is fixated on pepperoni pizza only, it was nice that he could have his pepperoni while the rest of us explored other palate pleasers. We were vacationing in Rochester so I don't know if we will ever get to return to Create A Pizza. But if I was a local, I would be a regular. read more

See all

I love Create A Pizza. It's located at the edge of the hustle and bustle of Monroe ave. Everything is unique here from the pizza slice logo to the new and comfortable feel of the decor. Just like the name says, you pick your preferences and they create a fresh brick oven pizza for you. This is the freshest and most tasty pizza I have had in Rochester. Why have pizza that's been sitting around all afternoon. Lazy pizza lol They have toppings galore and you can complete your pie with drizzles, grated cheese, pepper flakes and more. Btw the drizzles are amazing. There's a fantastic lunch special that doesn't hold punches in value. You get a personal pizza and a drink for about $6!!! Wow For the healthy, they offer cauliflower crust, gluten free and vegetarian options. Support local business, come in and say hi and get yourself a pizza pie! read more

Create A Pizza - Meat lovers lunch special! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

This is an amazing pizza joint! we tried it with a Groupon and the quality and experience were great! Everyone gets to make their own pizza and it is cooked so quickly! Love all of the healthy options and our family loves visiting! read more

See all

Had pizza here last night after 10 pm...we were looking for a solid snack after laughing for almost a full two hours (and thus working up our appetites) over at Comedy at the Carlson watching Mike Young and Bob Saget. And Create A Pizza was a great choice! We picked it over other late-night-snack competition after reading an article in The City Newspaper. I was interested in the gluten free, veggie-heavy pizza, but my hubby wanted to try a traditional pizza with savory (aka MEAT) toppings. And since it was late and we had never eaten here before, we decided to just get one, so I acquiesced and we got their single 12 inch 'Meat Eater' pie with cup-and-char pepperoni (they have 2 kinds of pepperoni but cup-and-char is the stuff of childhood memories, and the only way to go), meatballs, sausage, cheese and the hearty tomato sauce base. It was perfection. From order to service was approximately 5 min - they were in the process of making several take away/pick up orders when we got there, but were able to make ours as soon as we settled on what to get. And it took maybe 2 min to cook. I was seriously surprised that it took longer to decide on which one we wanted than it did for them to assemble and cook the pie. The traditional crust is thin and flavorful - not cooked to a crunchy/stiff consistency, which means that the more toppings you pile on the better the chances that your slice will droop as you pick it up - but folding in half is still an effective way to eat. The 'Meat Eater' was one of their 'house creations' (of which there are a handful to try), but they have a huge variety of toppings for you to make your own. Including meat alternatives, the longest list of veggie options I have seen at a pizza joint (including roasted zucchini! broccoli! artichokes! among others), 6 or more different kinds of cheese, multiple sauce bases and additional toppings to put on top and/or drizzle (fresh basil! balsamic! etc). They do have a gluten-free cauliflower-based crust, but it is made with egg and cheese, so is not vegan; as yet no gluten free AND vegan crust options but the General Manager assured us they are working on it. That said, they only have one assembly area and one oven, so this is not a gluten-free shop - meaning there's a chance of cross contamination, which also probably means those with celiacs can't eat here. BUT the GM says she wants to be able to meet all the dietary requests thrown her way, so expect more to come from this great new addition to the Upper Monroe neighborhood. For now, we were impressed and we will be back. Next time I'll be getting that gluten free crust with garlic and oil base, parmesan cheese, zucchini, olives and artichokes...already dreaming about it!! read more

This place has been open since January and deserves to be around for a very long time. I only heard about it from a Living Social coupon I bought, and the only disappointment I had was that I didn't discover it sooner. Clean, and bright, something for everyone (even gluten free and vegans), with a trendy/hip vibe. The pizza was outstanding and super affordable. Outstanding value...Two of us barely finished one 12" pie. The owner and her 17 month old daughter Olivia was the finishing touch on the personal experience at Create A Pizza. A must try! read more

See all

We always come here when we're in Rochester. Husband and daughter order the pizza and I order the calzone! I grew up having fried calzones and no one does that anymore. I had the calzone here and it is out of this world!! Pizza really good here too!! Also love the couple running the place.... read more

My partner and I wanted pizza while exploring the Rochester area for my potential move. We found this place based on other reviews on yelp and Google. It was absolutely amazing! It is a family owned and operated business which adds a welcoming charm of the establishment. Each person that came in seemed as though they were long life friends of the the owners. And each time someone left the owners said "Take it easy!" which to me, was very wholesome. I have a gluten sensitivity, so when I ordered the cauliflower crust, one of the owners asked if I had an allergy or sensitivity. She then told me that the meatballs on the supremes pizza have breadcrumbs in it and asked if I wanted a different meat or to simply forgo them. I appreciated the extra mile she went to ask me those questions to ensure I enjoyed the pizza. The pizza was absolutely delicious!! I ate my entire pizza and could have had half of another! I look forward to visiting this local pizza shop in the future and will recommend it to everyone I know visiting the area. read more

Came here with the expectation that it would be like a pi craft or a blaze pizza. The positives is that the service was quick, there were great topping options, vegan friendly choices, and that they offered both regular pepperoni and cup and char pepperoni. The negatives was that the pizza wasn't cut well and also so thin that it was almost impossible to pick up. I could eat the whole twelve inch pizza and still be hungry afterwards on an empty stomach. That was really disappointing. I was with someone who's pizza was definitely thicker than mine, so it could have just been a rare mess up, but definitely a factor to make me consider going elsewhere next time. read more

Create A Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

I absolutely love this place I go here whenever I can! Definitely my top favorite places to eat. The vegan options are amazing. The staff is so friendly. For me the crust is exactly how I love it! read more

See all

Easily the best gluten-free pizza in Roc. Friendly, down-to-Earth, mindful staff who always inquire about the severity of my gluten intolerance/allergy. The owners are frequently sourcing higher quality, better tasting ingredients (peeped the new vegan cheese options) and on top of all that it's woman/family-owned. I frequently recommend the to all who are looking for vegan, gluten-free friendly pizza options! read more

Just stopped into this new pizza place on Monroe Ave... Talked with a friendly pizza artist named Katelyn and she went right to work whipping up some awesome pizzas for us quickly. Toppings, construction and flavor were great and overall quality was high. My only complaint was that the top of the crust was nice and crispy, but the bottom was left soft and chewy. No big deal ... just for me personally I'll ask to crisp the bottom more on my next visit. They just Celebrated their one year anniversary and am happy to say we will return for a future meal. Keep up the good work Katelyn & company read more

See all

This is our favorite pizza place in area. I have celiac disease and their care and attention to the needs of the GF community and the risks of cross-contamination make them a trusted local business. My husband, who is not GF, loves their regular crust as well. The people who work here are also so lovely and they really remember and keep up with their regulars. 10/10 read more

Best make your own style pizza in the city of Rochester! The owner and employees are very kind and attentive. Never ever had a bad experience at this location. Not to mention, the quality of the pizza and calzones are top notch, definitely made with love and care. Support small business if you're able!! read more

Create A Pizza - Oh and vegetarian and vegan options galore!!! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

For me it's hard to find a good pizza. This one checks all the boxes. I got a 10 inch with pesto, fresh moz, spinach, artichoke, red peppers and shredded chicken. It was amazing. The knots were sitting there shiny and fragrant so I got some of those too! The toppings were fresh, the pizza was baked just how I like it and the service was great. The woman waiting on me was very polite and attentive. I will definitely be back for more. read more

Create A Pizza - Custom Pizza with Unlimited Toppings - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Excellent flavor and quality ingredients. I'm so happy for the vegan options! If you're looking for a low-key City spot for fresh pizza, Create A Pizza will fulfill your need. We ordered two vegan pizzas and the dessert pizza. Everything was hot and delicious. We live in Brighton and it's a quick skip away. read more

Great spot. Seem covid conscious. Love the pizza options: multiple gluten free/ dairy free options. It's the only place I have found in Roc that has these kinds of options on a pizza read more

I've been eyeing this place for a little while now, as it's virtually next door to one of our favorite restaurants in town. Finally went in, and now I'm kicking myself for waiting so long. We stopped by outside of peak hours, so with the exception of someone who was just leaving, it was only us and the people working there (one of whom might have been the owner, but I'm not positive). Whoever they were, they were both extremely friendly and we had a nice chat while they cooked up the tastiest personal sized pie I've had so far. There are a couple of national franchises in the surrounding area that do the whole "custom pizza" business model, but having eaten at both those joints and this one, I'd put this local spot ahead of the chains. And I'm pretty sure these guys are actually less expensive, too. What's not to love about a better product, at a lower price, from a locally owned and operated restaurant? The woman I spoke with said they'd been there just over two years. I hope they've got many, many more ahead of them. I'll be back. A lot. read more

Hey everyone , Okay so I'm not gonna go on and on but I just want to say that this place is a scam. I say this because you can go to the grocery store and buy pizza dough and make it and home to your likely just the same as this place is offering to you expect at an expense price. So I don't recommend this unless you are going to go there to waste money on something is is done just as good as if you do it at home. Even the staff look incredibly annoyed when customers walk in and order food because there standing around time was interrupted. Only nice thing about this place is that they offer variety on what you can put on your tiny pizza. read more

Pizza is lyfeee!! My first time here I created my own pizza with any toppings I like. Some things cost extra but it's all worth it! It cooked super fast in like 3 mins and was popping hot just how I like it!!!! I def recommend this place!! Nothing like this in the Rochester area. Heard they deliver too so I'm keeping that in mind read more

Create A Pizza - Best pizza ever! With sweet buffalo sauce! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The pizza was delicious and the staff nice. It was my first time in, so I ordered quick in person then came back to pick it up. If you like thin crust, with a bunch of toppings, this place is your jam. I got a Groupon deal, but even without it the prices are reasonable, especially considering the quality of the food!! Sometimes pizza doesn't taste as good the second day.., the (very few) leftovers we had were just as good!! Can't wIt to go back!! read more

I got a personal pizza from here about a week ago and it was delicious! Not to mention, a lot cheaper than most "create your own" pizza type places. Everything was really fresh and the size was also perfect, just enough to be full but not have leftovers. I also noticed they have full size pizzas on their menu which would be a great option if you love their pizza and don't want just the personal size. I'm looking forward to creating more pizzas here! read more

I went in earlier this afternoon for the first time! I was a bit indecisive about what I wanted; but the young man who took my order was so patient,polite and helpful with recommendations! Excellent customer service! The pizzas I ordered were delicious! The crust and ingredients tasted fresh! I will def go again! read more