We did not enjoy the pizza or rest of our meal. It took a very long time to get our food. Just sadly not a pleasurable experience

Their pizza kind of reminds me of a less greasy pan pizza that had huts all over the place. The sauce was tasty, service quick and staff friendly. It's a large space with a portion closed off, waaaaay past covid. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Sausage n pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

The food was excellent for the price would highly recommend also would recommend calling 30 minutes before pick up

Pizza was great! Crust could of been just a tad bit more crispy but my family and I loved it! Ingredients were fresh and lots of toppings! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Meat lovers pizza was on point!!! Ingredients were delicious! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

Nothing like warm pizza with great crust. Not greasy and love the vegetarian option. Yummy! Nice people work here too. 2 pizzas and a drink for less than $10. Soooo worth it! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - two slices of pizza on paper plates - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

The ownership likes to project their political views when instead they should be focused on a clean establishment and better tasting food. Completely underwhelmed by their pizza and their POV. read more

Always stop at Pudgies when we are in Rochester. Or we order a pizza, freeze and carry back to Maryland

Love this pizza. Always great and no problems with my order. Wish I could eat it five times a week!!!! Nice team working here.

Food, service and atmosphere very nice and inviting. This was our first trip to Pudgies. I highly recommend their Stromboli bread. So delicious. Crust was cooked perfectly. Nice crunch and airy at the same time. Filling was also delicious. Counter and sitting area was spotless. Bright and inviting. Just like in Italy. Will definitely be back to try some of their other menu items. I give this restaurant an A+. read more

I actually love it here. The location isn't the best, and I wouldn't sit and eat inside, but to get some garlic sticks and a slice to go, it's great! The service is strange. It's usually a rude person at the register, and they sometimes have this strange policy where you need to show your ID to use a credit card, but if you get past that, the food is good. I've had a few things from here. I got a sub at least once, a veggie slice once or twice, but my go to is a slice of cheese and 3 garlic sticks. The garlic sticks are basically white pizza cut in strips. They're super good! And if you ask, you can swap out the marinara that usually comes on the side and get ranch instead. If you're eating pizza, you've gotta have some ranch. :) There's always slices and stuff in the case ready to go, so you don't need to call ahead unless you need a full pizza or a sub or something like that. I'm not a thin crust person, and they have a good thick crust. I think it's one of the better pizzas in the area. read more

I had ordered a steaksub last week and apparently they charge you extra for certain toppings/ingredients.. they charged me for grilled onions mushrooms and peppers while also charging me for boss sauce and cheese. I thought that's what comes with a steaksub .. it was good just way overpriced in my opinion. There's better subs around the city read more

I haven't been here in like 7 years or so since I moved out of state. Yesterday I needed a break and went for a drive. (Oh I'm in Rochester temporarily! I should mention that....although it would have been worth the 30+ hr drive! Well, that's a bit extreme maybe...). This was on my list of restaurants I should visit while I'm here. Dang it, I forgot how good it was. I ordered two slices of pepperoni and I forgot they had breadsticks too, so I was forced to buy two of those, if you look at them you'll understand how I was forced...some strange universe phenomenon. The counter person said if I buy three I get free sauce, geesh now I have to buy three??? Well, okay. The crust on the pizza is the best around. It's like soft and buttery and tastes mildly of beer (yeast) and it's not overdone and doesn't have cornmeal (which I hate the texture of which so many pizza places use on the bottom of their crusts!) it's a good sized slice. The breadsticks...if you look at my photos of them...well I can't be responsible for what happens to you. All I can tell you is I'm awake at 4am thinking about them. They don't allow dine in. They are really good at social distancing and they only six people at a time in the lobby part. I got there about I think 1:30 and it was not overly crowded but definitely was doing good business. I was so full after eating the three breadsticks and the first slice of pizza but it was so good I powered through and ate the second slice. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Two slices of pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

See all

If you eat at Pudgie's too much, you get Pudgy. Simple concept really, but I guess the people in these parts really, really love their pizza. What to get: Slice What else: Starlight is so cute This popular bright-orange pizza spot (not to be confused with THE Pizza Spot downtown which is the best Pizza place in the 585) is on a major intersection in a low-income area. You'd think that, considering the fact that it is in an under-privileged area, it would have competitive prices. It does not. It was almost *six dollars* for my slice of f***ing pizza. Granted, I got a specialty slice with a crust on the top and the bottom of it (more like a pie). But this thing wasn't insanely enormous, it also wasn't very hot and it wasn't very moist. In fact it was a little congealed, the cheese and such, and didn't have generous portions of meat and sauce and cheese and toppings inside, either. It was mainly just bread, and it was a little over-done in places despite not being hot. Now, I'll give you this: it did taste pretty good. But it wasn't amazing, nor was it generous with toppings, nor was it hot nor well prepared, and worst of all, it cost literally twice what I think it should have cost. On the other hand, the selection here is good, the decor is shiny and eye-catching, the location is great, and the girl who served me was absolutely lovely to me. I thought we were going to exchange phone numbers or something. Then she realized I was with someone (my kitten Starlight) and that was the end of that. But yes - super cute. If it smelled of garlic in here it'd be Pungent Pizza. If it was a boat-rental agency for rowing down the stream it'd be Punting Pizza. And if you got free kisses with your slice, it'd be Pucker Pizza. Actually I think I almost did get a free kiss. But at nearly $6 for an underheated slice that had been sitting out forever, I don't think I'll be going back to have a second bite at the proverbial cherry. Or pizza slice, in this case. read more

See all

I'm 45 now and I've been coming here since 1991. It's a long time. There's simply not better pizza in Rochester, NY. And if there is no one ever pointed our to me....and I've tried many shops in town. Yeah, it's in a tough part of town but...the pizza is worth your life!!! read more

I was in Rochester for work and stumbled across Pudgie's. The name caught my eye and I crossed my fingers that they took credit cards. Thank you Yelp for the confirmation! I was kindly greeted by a nice lady and ordered my small meatball sub ($4.39). 4 generous meatballs covered in mozza on a toasty roll. Just do it. There was a lot going on...on the menu (pizza, hot & cold sandwiches, fried chicken, ice cream, etc). Not only was the service quick and friendly but the decor was spot on. I took a pic so check out the album! This place has history and flare. I'd go back. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Does it work? Go to Pudgie's and find out. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Every year I come to our church convention from Florida. I make sure I stop by and eat here. Never disappointed the pizza and wings are excellent. We ordered the family special 20 wings, 32 pieces pizza with half pepperoni and other half cheese, and a 2 liter drink They never let us down. The customer service was amazing. Thank you for making us feel welcome. read more

two med steak subs meat dry placed order at 7:26 ready at 8:20 they new that was old and dry $25 they used to be so great

I used to go to Pudgies every week after my son's baseball games-Pudgies was a sponser of the team. I had a hankering for pizza and thought I would give it a try for old times sake. I was not disappointed. The staff was friendly, greeting me when I walked in. They showed the pizza to me before I paid and asked if everything looked ok. It was yummy like I had remember and the large had about 12 large slices. Overall I was pleased and will go back again. I should have tried the pumpkin spice latte ice cream as it sounded Devine! Maybe my next trip! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Large cheese pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms and onions-yummy! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

The most outstanding pizza experience in Rochester, NY is here at Pudgies. All natural ingredients, delicious cheese, sweet sauce, great wings....Oh to die for. read more

Lowered my rating because food quality was lowered. Slices usually good. They looked dried out. Asked if newer one coming up. They brought up another that looked better but was dried out as well. read more

See all

The pizza is very good! They are always on time with making your order. They can look you up with your phone number and see your order history. Creates efficiency. Variety of pizza here is very yummy, we love the steak pizza! read more

Absolute best wings i have ever had, I have tried them all over the city and for sure they are the best from Pudgies! read more

Pudgie's Pizza - AMAZING WINGS! and Huge! - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

Homemade taste. Freshly prepared ingredients. Comfortable dining room booths. * I recommend this place! * It will be worth your money. It will be worth the drive to 1753 Goodman St N, Rochester, NY 14609: Questions? Call them @ 585.266.6605 read more

Great Pizza and awesome wings so I guess it was worth it but 10.84$ for a slice and 5 wings with no drink is terrible ‍ prices are the only bad thing about this place service was pretty good and the food was good! read more

Best pizza joint in the city of Rochester hands down. Great customer service. Want to enjoy a good pizza, can't go wrong with Pudgie's Pizza. The cookies here are delicious. read more

Pudgie's Pizza - Cheese pizza with some spices and snickerdoodle cookies. Both items are very delicious. - Pizza Near Me - Rochester, New York

They are ok. The last time I ate from then was a couple of years ago & they didn't taste too bad. Everything was fresh & the cheese pizza was very cheesy & the crust & bread was very good just like how it should be. read more

Probably the best pizza in Rochester, I have been going here for years and the service and commitment to quality is some of the best I have seen in the industry. What makes it even better, is that when available, the topping ingredients come from the local farmers market. The subs feature bread from a local bakery, and premium meats and toppings. read more

Not bad pizza, tasted like the love child of domino's and papa johns. I probably won't order it again for the cost. Honestly Wegmans is the best pizza deal around. read more

Excellent pizza. Sinatra playing in the background jn a joint that has decor that hails from that time. Comfortable casual time. I will be back for sure. read more

The pizza was awesome!! I had the Veggie Pizza. Everything looked good and the place was highly recommended by a local. I recommend as well. Not the healthiest but worth the splurge. read more

WOW! The pizza tastes awesome! The wings are perfect, The customer service is great and the prices aren't that bad either! I highly recommend this restaurant! The food here really hits the spot and they even have a couple of old school arcade systems here! read more

Been coming here for decades and today after my daughter's dentist appointment and hearing such a good review from her teacher I decided we would grab a quick bite so we decided on pizza and my daughter picked Pudgies. Soon as we walk in the pepperoni pizza is coming out of the oven so of course we grab slices. Great pizza, great service, great prices. Love this place read more

Felt like eating a good pizza with some friends called pudgies talked to jack i told him what I was looking for he said he personally would make the pie and I have to say it was the best pizza I've had in a while . Keep the good work and the great taste up . read more

I've been going to this place for years!! I love it. The price has gone up a lot, and the taste has changed some, but it's not bad. I'd love to see them remodel or do something unique to bring in new costumers. The reason I gave it 3 stars is only because of the price. Big chain franchises are killing them with there special deals. read more

This has been a local fave since I was a kid. The pizza is singularly delish and the bread they use for their subs is so good; steak subs are my favorite. They have a great selection, and the place is super clean. Service is always wonderful, great neighborhood dive. You have to have the fried dough! read more

By far the best tasting pizza in Rochester. The hard part is that sometimes they can't deliver due to shortage in drivers, and the restaurant itself isn't very clean. But the food is delicious. Keeps you wanting more! read more

Excellent service and the food is delicious.. Decor is a bit outdated however its nostalgic.. It's been 20 years since the shops closed in my hometown. When I realized they had a location in my current city I had to stop by. It was like going back to highschool. Good to see a business that hasn't cut cost on cheaper processed ingredients. read more

Went there for pick up , it was just overly crowded , they take cards but you must have an id , place looks dirty and if you ever been here before don't waste your time over my expensive for Pizza Hut tasting pizza read more