Great food, nice service . Recommendations would be that the bus staff doesn't clear plates while people are eating . Also water was never refilled . read more

See all

Best meal we had on the island! The food and service were excellent! Sand Dabs were some of the best I have eaten. Scallops with Pesto was amazing. Portions were large. Highly suggested! read more

See all

I would rate this place 10 stars if I could!!! I came for dinner last night and the food was absolutely phenomenal. Highly recommend the French onion soup. It was so good I had to come back for breakfast today. The ambiance is also amazing and I had great service!! read more

See all

In my humble opinion, this is the best restaurant on Catalina. Bolognese was money, as well as the Penne Primevera. Wife got the clams and they were solid. They were a bit unstaffed but all of the island is. read more

We had a wonderful dinner here last night on the island of Catalina in Avalon. Great ambience, excellent service by an entire staff who lives on the island. Started with a wonderful bottle of wine, a great kale salad that was bright and flavor not overdressed and had wonderful additions of cranberries and just the right amount of cheese. Also had Steamed Clams in a spicy broth that was excellent and then the big winner of the night was the pasta Primavera. The by far the best pasta Primavera we've ever had anywhere in the world. Clean full of flavor and healthy. Thank you for the wonderful experience. We would definitely recommend it and in fact, we have canceled our dinner reservations at another restaurant for the next night and will instead be coming back to M.. Daniel and the entire weight staff made the experience. Wonderful, we look forward to seeing you again tonight. read more

I had a really nice meal here. Service was excellent, fast, and friendly. Wine was great. Lobster linguini was very tasty. Food didn't take a super long time even though they were pretty busy. Reasonably priced (for Catalina). Great spot, would come here again. read more

M Restaurant - Lobster linguini - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

What a GREAT experience! Great drinks! Great service! Our server Joanna was impeccable! The restaurant was really nice and inviting. Not too close. Not too loud. Just right! Very inviting for tourists! Some of our food was on the cooler side but was great and had great taste! Thank you to the back crew of the kitchen. read more

See all

Fabulous restaurant on Catalina Island! Everything was excellent. The servers are locals, born and raised on Catalina. The food was outstanding. We enjoyed after dinner drinks and dessert at the old bar from a ship. 5-Star Date night read more

See all

Positive Experiences. Been a few times. Friendly staff, clean higher end ambiance, and quality food. We enjoy the cheesy garlic bread appetizer. It is light and tasty with a flavorful marinara sauce. The crispy ravioli is good too. The french onion soup was also very good. The Penne Arrabiatta was cooked perfectly with, I believe, the same flavorful Marinara. The Shrimp is large and succulent and Artic Char is really well made. The tiramisu was better than we expected for dessert. The only thing I could say is some dishes are cheese and cream heavy. M is our go to when visiting. read more

What an amazing experience, oh and the food we cleared our plates and had dessert! This little gem is located in the Metropole Market Place and huge and if you are walking by you can end up missing it but the smell will draw you back in! There was a huge party of 70 in the back. We were able to get reservations and choose to sit on the patio with a nice breeze around 7pm...however the employees made sure to quickly change out any empty propane Tanks whenever they were done. From the moment we stepped upstairs to the moment we left... our service was nothing but exceptional. Our waiter (name escapes me at the moment) Was nothing short of amazing. I have a specific food allergy and unfortunately every single dish had the one food that I'm allergic to. But that didn't stop the insistence of the chef and waiter who was able to cook up an exceptional off the menu halibut order while providing my SO With his chosen meal... the seafood plate. We started the meal off with calamari which was Cooked perfectly And must be one of the best calamari I have ever had. No tentacles here! We went with the suggested wine for our meal and was sure glad we did, the wine was very subtle but crisp and not too oaky as you get with most Chardonnays. This was my kind of server. I was pleasantly surprised when I was brought two desserts for my birthday surprise. One was a cappuccino moose which was exquisite, from the taste and texture all the way to the raspberry cheesecake. Very friendly atmosphere as everybody joined in to sing Happy Birthday. Yet I was not the only one to celebrate a birthday that night... I too enjoyed some Happy Birthday singing to another fellow birthday person. My halibut was cooked perfectly and it is too bad that it was not on the menu but so glad that they were able to make this exception for me. As for the seafood plate my SO would've licked the plate it was that good. We will definitely be back (even if it is just for wine & dessert) highly recommend. They do not offer tap water but like most places on the island have bottled water available. read more

See all

Came for breakfast on Saturday and the menu choices were varied and lots of healthy choices. My $4 fruit bowl was large! My friend had an omelette and really enjoyed it. Excellent service and outstanding views. read more

were sat at the window, with a beautiful immediately on thursday Aug 22nd. We were provided expedient, super friendly, helpful and professional service. The food was the best meal I've had in MONTHS, and I eat all over CA, including San Diego and the SF bay area. Pricing was more reasonable than you'd expect for a restaurant on the water on Catalina Island. I was provided with the most amazing capaccino mousse for my birthday. read more

See all

We came to M restaurant with a reservation in early September 2023 for our 10yr anniversary, with little to no expectations. When our table wasn't ready right away, we were a little wary at first, but it was ready within 5-10 minutes of our reservation time, and we were seated at a pretty little table near the front with a harbor view. After this snafu, everything else here was perfectly seamless. Our server was prompt and helpful. Food was absolutely EXCELLENT, even for my classically picky husband. We had the burrata and a Cobb salad for a starter (both fantastic), along with My Tuscan-style salmon (technically was called the arctic char) was some of the best fish I've had in years - my husband, while he loved his steak, agreed that my fish was really the highlight of the dinner. The Tuscan seasoning, the quality and portion of the fish; really one of the best fish dishes I've ever had. I had to fend off my husband as he kept trying to snake his fork over for bites. Really truly a superb preparation - soft and flakey, moist but not soggy, and a generous cut. Compliments to the chef and we highly recommend M Restaurant for a classy dinner or any special event. Looking forward to returning when we are back on the island! read more

Food was delicious! Seemed like everyone enjoyed why they ordered! There was 11 of us; almost all different entrees. Plus appetizers and "beverages" for the adults. "Service with a smile!" Greeted us correctly & tended to our requests. Nice place for a "fancy" dinner on the island. Would go there again! read more

M Restaurant - Calamari Piccata - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

Lovely staff and a highly skilled mixologist at the bar. Every app and entree was scrumptious. Large portions on everything on the menu. Wonderful view of the coast line. Make it your nightly dinner spot on the island read more

Order the cioppino and scallop pasta. Cioppino was very salty and scallop was very salty, the salt wasn't even melted. Pasta was ok. Asked for a new order of cioppino and got the same one that was heated up with added hot water. Didn't ask again how was it.... read more

M Restaurant - Cioppino was very salty and scallop was very salty, the salt wasn't even melted. Pasta was ok. - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

Great service, ambiance, and food! Jonathan was our waiter and he was very attentive and nice. All the food came out in a timely manner and everything was fresh and delicious. Their wine selection was on point. Our party of 10 really enjoyed this place. You should definitely try it out! read more

During our stay at Catalina Island, we had dinner here twice. The tables are arranged out in the front courtyard, allowing for ample spacing as per COVID restrictions. We had the Italian flatbread and the pasta bolognese both nights and enjoyed them. We tried the buffalo's milk but weren't fans of it. If you're looking for a nice, intimate dinner spot (especially during COVID times), this restaurant is perfect for that and the food is delicious. read more

M Restaurant - Italian Flatbread - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

Spontaneous drop in at this restaurant after zip lining and the food was very tasteful. My party ordered the pasta primavera and it was very fresh, baked lasagna was yummy and the serving size was a good portion, and the fettuccine Alfredo with chicken was delicious. The service was great. They made sure we were happy. read more

See all

I am at M right now and my server Joanna is the absolute best. My friends and I are tipsy and being annoying and she is an absolute delight. Give her a raise immediately. read more

Food wine ambience and service were spectacular. Reserve for dinner in the summer or you may wait extended periods.

Wonderful experience at the hands of our lovely server Lauren. This was a special wedding anniversary that exceeded all expectations.

1 star for the service and 1 star for the cute atmosphere. The food was absolutely horrendous. Pasta wasn't cooked well and there was a ridiculous amount of oil on everything. It was also expensive. Service was really nice, they seemed a bit understaffed. read more

We made a reservation and when we arrived there was a line to get in. We waited our turn then the hostess tells us "we don't have your table" and that she called our name, which was a lie because we were in line for 15 minutes! We were not offered any other options. She sat a number of groups without reservations before us and when we asked why, she again treated us rude. I come to the island every year and have never experienced such rude treatment . Horrible customer service! read more

My husband and I went there for our Anniversary and had a wonderful dinner. We shared the arugula salad, flatbread, and the scallop linguine with a pesto cream sauce. Everything was really good. The pasta was our favorite, but it was all very tasty. It's an open floor plan so I would think when the restaurant is full it could get a little loud but it was fine when we were there. read more

This place is TOPS! everything about it was just superb. The atmosphere is very romantic and understated. Just perfect for our anniversary dinner. We started with the calamari which was tender and delicious. My husband had lasagna, I had scallops and linguine with pesto. We got a bottle of Nero davolo. The price on the wine , which was great, was just around $30. But the food...eye rolling GOOD. the portions are enormous. I had to box about 2/3rds of mine and half my husband's, so come hungry. But aside from that, the care of preparing it, the flavors, the staff, all were just first rate. Highly recommend. read more

M Restaurant - Scallops and linguine with pesto - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

Food was very good. I ordered the calamari piccata and my husband ordered the shrimp scampi. Prices were in the normal range I also ordered an Aperol Spritz. Very refreshing. Where I struggled was the service. We were celebrating our 10 year wedding anniversary and wanted to "dine". We felt very rushed, they were prompt, but constantly clearing tables before people even left their seats. It was a little awkward as they would stand and watch for people to leave and swarm in from their staging area like flies to sugar. I've never seen anything like it. Although the staff was attentive and efficient, there was no warmth to the experience. Would I go again, maybe. I much preferred the more casual spot across the street. read more

See all

Hmmm where do I start.... Not the cleanest place, the coffee was cold and bland... yup bland So I asked to replace it and the guy waiter just heat it up same cup and all. When he brought it back he spilled it all over the table (my sode) and on my hat and backpack.... Said sorry and left! Without cleaning. Waitress came just rub the same napkins I issued to wiped table.... Food wasn't good either read more

Server was so rude. Lots of yellowjackets all over the place because they leave sweet condiments out. I asked server to put the condiments elsewhere away from our table due to the insects but she replied, "no I can't move them, that's just how it is here- you're near the water and there are going to be bees." Wow. The food wasn't great and was extremely overpriced. $18 for a veggie omelette is a total rip off. Then they added 20% gratuity at the end without even asking. read more

The place is nice although indoors is quite noisy so we sat in the patio and was very nice. They have heaters! The wine was very good I got a rose from France. Unfortunately the food needs much more attention. Fried zucchini very good they tasted fresh. Fried calamari not as fresh. Clams very rich in taste but overcooked or not so fresh. Vegetable flatbread VERY bad in fact my friend left it all. And they didn't even care to apologize or offer to replace or refund it. Too bad. I think this restaurant promises good but it's just a tourist place that you should stay away from if you are looking for decent quality. read more

Let's just be honest.. this place sucks. The food was poor to unremarkable and the service was even worse. The space is nice so it's not a total loss... not many choices on the island... the complacency shows. read more

Thoroughly enjoyed both breakfast and dinner. The wine selection could be a bit better, but that's my personal preference, I enjoy French wines. The service was pretty good. For a good ambiance, I suggest sitting outside. read more

M Restaurant - Avocado toast - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

If you are looking for a reason to go to Catalina Island, this restaurant is the only reason you need (although, to be fair, the entire island is an absolute gem). Service is fantastic. Quick response at the door, attentive wait staff, excellent mixologist at the bar, and the chef and staff - the pictures speak for themselves, but I will expound. Even though we were a party of 6, all food came out hot and together. All orders were made as ordered, with two having special requests. Portions were sized perfectly. I only wish I had been able to eat dessert as they sounded every bit as good as the entrees. I am looking forward to going back and revisiting this wonderful island find! read more

M Restaurant - Vegetable lasagna - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

I am super disappointed by this restaurant with such high reviews. I thought it would be better. Not only do you have to ask the server countless times for anything the actual service is awful. Not once did our server, with the long brown and blonde hair pony tail, ask how we were doing - bring anything we asked - and literally looked like she had to run off when the whole building was empty. The one thing that was great was the caesar salad. Everything else was a disappointment. read more

Great service and best food we had on the island. Drinks were okay, I would stick to wine or beer. Great for date night or celebration. Cheesy Garlic Bread is the best thing on the menu. read more

M Restaurant - Stuffed Manicotti - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

See all

I came here with a LARGE group for a company dinner and I was blown away with how friendly and helpful the staff was. Our orders were taken swiftly and every order was correct. 18 people got their meals altogether which is a huge feat by the kitchen, and my swordfish, rice, and veggies were delicious and perfectly cooked. Our server was an absolute champ keeping up with all our needs and I would definitely go back for their wine list and menu options. read more

My husband and I came to Catalina to celebrate our 34th anniversary. We ordered calamari to start which was served with a tartar sauce as opposed to the red sauce I was accustomed to having. It was delicious! The main event though was the pesto pasta with scallops for my husband and the octopus for me. Both dishes were cooked to perfection!! The pasta was aldente and the scallops melted in our mouths. The octopus was superb! Best I've ever had!! I would take a boat trip just to come for dinner and have the octopus again! If you've ever had octopus, you know how it's cooked matters! This was absolute perfection on a plate! It was paired with asparagus & mashed potatoes which were also scrumptious, but the octopus my friends was AMAZING!! If you've never tried octopus, then this is the place to try it! Our sever Maria was wonderful, prompt and attentive. The restaurant was clean and had a lovely ambiance as well. A good mix of casual & beachy vibes. A beautiful dining experience with a lovely view of the harbour We finished with the tiramisu which was delicious as well. Maria gave us the tiramisu on the house for our anniversary which was so thoughtful. Thank you M for a wonderful anniversary dinner! read more

The food here is delicious. So delicious that we dined here two nights in a row! The Bronzino was amazing and the Penne Primavera with added chicken was just as satisfying. Our server Javier was quite entertaining as well. We can't stop talking about our dining experience & plan to dine here again when next we visit the island. read more

M Restaurant - Penne Primavera w/chicken - Italian Near Me - Avalon, California

What a wonderful evening at M. Such a relaxing dining experience, great ambiance, delicious food and our server Lauren was the absolute best! You won't be disappointed, best meal we had while visiting the island! read more

The hostess aubree or Audrey in the morning was really nice and knowledgeable helped me out and is really pretty needs a raise