"Nightmare on Pep Street... and I Loved Every Bite"…read more Stopped in after a lab appointment, running on fumes and bad decisions, so I figured pizza was the cure. Loiee G's did not disappoint. I grabbed a Medium "Nightmare on Pep Street" -- garlic butter, red sauce, three types of pepperoni -- basically the holy trinity of flavor. I inhaled it like I was auditioning for a competitive eating show. While still chewing, I ordered an 18-inch Meat Pizza for the tribe back home (because sharing is caring, apparently). This is proper NY-style pizza: thin, crispy, and foldable -- the kind of slice that makes you feel like you should be yelling "Yo!" on a Brooklyn sidewalk. The topping ratio was chef's kiss -- not overloaded like most C-Bus pies that think they're competing in a topping-weight contest. Everyone at home gave the thumbs up, proving I can, in fact, make good life choices when hungry. Bonus points: the pinball collection is serious. My buddy (resident pinball nerd) told me to check out the Godzilla and John Wick machines -- because nothing pairs better with pizza than saving Tokyo or racking up a kill streak in neon lights. Verdict: Loiee G's is legit. Great crust, perfect ratios, and enough pinball nostalgia to make you forget your cholesterol results.

East coaster here, who has been craving NY/NJ style pizza since we moved here 7 years ago. Until…read moreLoiee G's opened, we considered the best pizza in the area to be Red Baron frozen - a sad statement. The pizza here is very close to east coast and it easily became our Friday go to after our first visit. This is a sit down place, which seems to be fairly rare here, you can actually buy by the slice and have a beer or wine to go with it. When you go here, plan on eating there as opposed to take home if you can. Take home is never as good as fresh out of the oven and you can play some pinball while waiting. Oh it's Friday now! We'll see them in a couple hours.

Great food, meatballs , pizza and sometimes ribs. All excellent with incredible service. It's a…read moremust stop in Delaware

This rating is purely based off their horrible service. We have tried multiple times to call in a…read morecarry-out order, and everytime the phone just rings and eventually goes to voicemail box that is full. Pizzas look amazing, but can't ever get a single person to answer the phone so we can order...

The place was nice and clean, very friendly service!!!! Menu has a lot on it!!!…read moreI had the spaghetti and meatballs, hubby had Italian Stromboli, friend had a Greek Sub. All the food was fantastic!!!! We will be going back soon !!!

I brought my dad here for his birthday, he has had a hard time finding good wings in the area and…read morethis place popped up as having "the best wings in Columbus" so I figured we would give it a shot. All the food coming out of the kitchen looked good, the wings were really good. I got the garlic parm and he got the teriyaki we ordered them crispy and they were perfect. There was only 1 girl working the dining room but she kept on top of it and we never had any issues with getting her attention if we needed anything. This is just a little dive bar, so nothing fancy but it had a cozy vibe and a family feel. There were a decent amount of families in there, and when we were finishing up there was a group of young soccer players with parents coming in. I don't live in the area but if I'm visiting my parents I would bring them back. Dad said he would be back to try other things on the menu.

We were in town for the weekend exploring all of what Delaware has to offer. The patio is what drew…read moreus in for a late lunch and cold drinks. We ordered the pesto bread and grilled appetizer platter. While it took quite a long time for our food to come, it was worth the wait. Both items were seasoned to absolute perfection. The honey almond beer we got was also a great choice. I don't know if the slow service is due to the lack of service staff or if it's the nature of the restaurant, but hopefully it's not something that they struggle with for long. Their patio really is a great space. It offers a great seat to take in downtown Delaware and to enjoy food and drinks. I look forward to stopping in next time I'm in town

Someone had recommended this to me because of the gluten free crust, which was surprisingly not the…read moreissue. I ordered the gluten free "pizza" and Caesar Salad. The salad came out with no detectable dressing. The server said: "Oh yea we do it traditional without Caesar Dressing...Just olive oil and vinegar." No Caesar dressing on a Caesar salad? Odd. But I ate it. I was starving. I waited thirty-five minutes for my pizza to arrive. It had almost no cheese on it. Server said: "We use fresh cheese so it's not going to cover your pizza..." Newsflash: I use fresh cheese all the time and never have that issue. She offered to remake it. Which would take another 20-30 minutes, with the same amount of cheese as before... "If you want more cheese to cover it, you'll have to pay extra.." "Can you bring me cheese to put on top of this?" "No. It won't be melty." As I was leaving, she said: "Our pizzas are dry. Our salads are dry..." What a way to be remembered! 34 bucks for dry Romaine lettuce and pizza with almost no cheese that took forever to make... Today's lesson: Make sure you bring your own cheese and dressing, cause Amatos isn't providing it...The whole meal felt like she was making excuses for why they were clearly cutting corners on everything and for why they couldn't provide you a decent pizza covered in cheese or a salad covered in dressing in under an hour. ( And under 40 bucks of course). Its lackluster at best and they aren't really willing to work with you to fix the problem. Sure, they'll remake it with the same amount of cheese and toppings as before and it take more of your time but if really want coverage on the pizza that you ordered. you'll pay extra. (Even though fresh cheese doesn't really melt enough to cover it...) This particular server was way more interested in lecturing me on why it's more traditional to put a drop of oil and vinegar on a Caesar salad than Caesar dressing! The picture below shows the way pizza came: Little to no topping, almost no cheese and almost burnt on the edges...With plenty of excuses and customer blaming to go around... In my defense, I left half of it on the table. This review should suffice anyone thinking of going there on any given night and to the owners. Go elsewhere!

Gabby's calzones are the most popular item served. The service is always friendly, the bartenders…read morebust it!! Thursday through Saturday, expect to wait a bit, but it is always worth the wait

Got home & our pizza was so burned it was not edible. Tried to call to discuss via phone was put on…read morehold & no one ever came back. Sadly we won't be going back.

The pizza is outstanding. Couple that with fast, friendly service at fair prices and you have a…read moreSunbury area jewel

Staff members are awesome- great tavern pizza - get the charred pepperoni pizza. Nice outdoor…read morepatio, restaurant is clean and organized.

They cook a quality fresh tasting good pizza staffs friendly helpful atmosphere is good and…read moreambiance is casual services are good they are good for a community

Recently discovered this place. We get a pizza from there once every week or two. It's always been…read moredelicious! I think it's the best pizza I've ever had. And I've had a lot of pizza LOL

Not my first time here, but tonight was not a good night. I will say, the actual food was good and…read moredid not have any problem with it. Our problem was speed. There were 4 of us. Our food was ordered at 5:45 PM. We had a sandwich, 2 calzones, 6 honey BBQ wings and cheese garlic bread. Wings and bread requested as a meal, not app. 35 minutes later the sandwich is delivered along with the bread. Nothing else. We asked twice about our food and were told sorry and that the kitchen is backed up. Another 20 minutes and watching others get served at the bar that appeared to be friends with the bartender and order well after us, the calzones come. The wings came right after but were wrong. Not to mention the first beer was brought out and rudely slammed on the table and it was wrong. The bartender seemed to have an attitude when told this and asked for a glass. Never an apology for anyone in authority. No offers to make it right after telling the order taker twice. Sorry to say this sold your fate, doubt we will be back. The whole experience took well over an hour. Too long. Willing to allow anyone to have a bad night but admit it and try to make it right. $65 spent at the table.

Stopped in after running a few errands, and left questioning every other pizza I've ever eaten…read more Four Points looks like your typical small pizza joint with a bar--but don't be fooled. The pies here come fully loaded, like they were built by an overachieving Italian grandma who refuses to accept "light toppings" as a concept. I grabbed a Supreme and a Carnivore, because balance is important--veggies for the soul, meats for the heart (and cholesterol). Both were cooked perfectly: crisp crust, cheesy layers of happiness, and toppings stacked so high they needed their own building permit. Had a couple of local microbrews while I waited--because what's pizza without beer? The bartender was friendly and clearly knew their stuff. Bonus points for serving up brews that didn't taste like they were filtered through regret. Took the pies home and--no surprise--they were a hit. Everyone's inner food critic went quiet after the first bite. Verdict: Four Points Pizza is the kind of place that makes "errands" sound like code for "pizza mission." Come hungry

I tried the Italian subs and they were AMAZING, like I was very hungry and this hit the spot. Not…read moretoo far from home either, it's a win-win situation, and they even have their own seating and drinks in the fridges. Pretty much a gas station and a restaurant mixed! Pretty much anything you can think of (food wise) is there.

Been wanting to try CM's pizza for some time...finally remembered while out running errands…read moretonight. Originally planned to takeout but found that CM has a dining area with about ten tables so we ate in. Pie was ready when we arrived (told 25 mins, arrived 5 early). Soft crust, sweet sauce and plenty of cheese (even on the side without extra cheese) and flavorful pepperonis that curled up and were crunchy on the edge. Server attentive and dining area clean with several tv's. And being part of a market, a wider range of drinks to choose from. And no bate anywhere near the pie or dining area!

I really enjoy the wings. They're very good although a little small for my liking. That doesn't…read morechange my opinion about how good they are. I would recommend and they have very good delivery service.

Being perfectly honest, the pictures on yelp make this look pretty unappealing to me. I moved to…read morethe area not quite two years ago and have considered ordering for a while, but I couldn't get over how the food looks in pictures. I've also been severely disappointed by small town pizza in the past, so I'd always drive to Delaware or Marysville if I wanted a pizza. Tonight I was feeling extra lazy, didn't want to cook, didn't want to drive and refuse to use food delivery....so I decided to give Leb's a try, since it's just three minutes from home. The place itself isn't much to look at, which is fine by me, but there was also a weird smell (alcohol?) in the air that was a little off-putting to me. I was a little worried but ordered anyway. When I got the pizza, I figured out why the pictures look "bad" to me....the cheese is mostly on top of the other toppings. I could tell, though, this wasn't a pizza made for its social media posts....this was just a good old fashioned, well made pizza. And holy crap, was it GOOD. I ate half of an extra large, admittedly a good bit more than I meant to eat tonight, and I really want more as I'm typing this out. Seriously, every part of this pizza was just good...the crust and sauce especially stood out to me. I don't order pizza often, but I'm definitely going back and not just because I'm lazy and it's close.